Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset my inheritance is reduced

812 replies

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 11:18

I have very generous parents who worked extremely hard to ensure their kids were looked after. When we came of age (21) they told us how much each of us would inherit when we're turned 40. My sister asked for them to give a her a lump sum equal to her share so she could buy a house and they did that. When my brother turned 25, her asked for half of his share ao her could put down a deposit for a house and have enough cash to cover a 3 year sabbatical which they did. I haven't asked for anything as I was happy to wait till I turned 40. I started working when I was 16 so I have always been more financially secure than my siblings but im a freelancer which makes work difficult to come by and i also have 2 under 2. I'd planned to take 6 months maternity then go back to work in January but I'm shattered. My body, soul are exhausted from back to back pregnancies. I turn 40 in Feb so I was hoping to use my inheritance to take another year off, get therapy and sort my self out without financial pressure. DH works hard but his income alone won't cover us if I'm not earning.

Anyway, yesterday (Christmas!) my parents asked if they could reduce my inheritance sum as my brother 'needs it more'. He's just gone through a divorce (he cheated) and his ex-wife took him to the cleaners. His business went under during Covid and he hasn't worked in 2 years although he could get a job if he chose to. He claims he can't go back to working for someone else after having been his own boss for 10 years.

I'm devasted. My parents insist I don't have to say yes but I don't feel like i have much of a choice. I haven't stopped crying since.

OP posts:
Winter2020 · 26/12/2022 16:16

I voted YABU simply because you said you feel you don't have a choice but to help. You have been asked - say no!

The idea that your brother would have your money so he can save his own (half that is left) is crackers.

It is only fair you get what you were promised - an equal share. You speak of a well earning husband, potential to earn well yourself and savings but none of us know what the future holds. If you or your husband became unwell and unable to work for example you could really need that money in time. If you don't need it you could save it for your kids uni/house deposit etc.

While having this conversation I would just ask for your money sooner rather than later so it's done. What if your parents became unwell or died - would you ever see your share?

uhOhOP · 26/12/2022 16:13

PetraBP · 26/12/2022 15:15

Wow.

First world problems.

Based on the information you have provided, I’ve calculated the exact amount that your parents owe you.

It’s £0.

You people who say "first world problems"...! Is a problem only a problem if the person with the problem is also starving and homeless in the middle of a war and at risk of genocide?

Blowthemandown · 26/12/2022 16:11

@MoMuM7 your brother is not your problem to solve and if they give him this money he will be back for more later.

So, say you want to take your equal share as previously planned. If they want to advance him more money that’s up to them but not out of your share. They can take it out of the charity money.

Don’t be bullied OP.

Eleganz · 26/12/2022 16:11

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 16:02

I’ll fix this for you. It isn’t true In your opinion, I’ve hired people into senior positions in organisations, who have been consultants and self-employed contractors, and it is never ever worked out. I wouldn’t make the same mistake again, and I would advise any of my clients to avoid them.

Of course it is my opinion, just as it was your opinion but you were the one making sweeping statements...

The fact is lots of people do it, despite your experience and advice. I've hired people too (lots) who have previously been self-employed. I've worked alongside people who been self-employed previously. I've worked for a director who was previously self-employed. I've worked and hired across private, public and higher ed sectors. You don't have a monopoly on experience. It is not "virtually impossible" to move from self-employment to employment despite what your opinion of that is.

Some work out and others don't, same with people who have never been self-employed really.

SirMingeALot · 26/12/2022 16:10

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 12:43

My parents have enough to last them into old age. I can't help but feel that they want to stop bailing my brother out and they are passing on their responsibility to me. If really wanted to help him without touching my pot, they could. They want to 'help out family'. My needs apparently don't matter because DH has a good job and we have savings.

I feel like an idiot for having expected their money and made plans for it. I'd promised myself id never depend on them. I feel even worse to be upset that I'm not receiving a gift. I was never entitled to it anyway.

The idea of being made responsible for him would bother me more than the immediate money issue.

Weepachu · 26/12/2022 16:10

Blimey, this is the parable of the prodigal son brought to life. Tell your parents you really need what you had been promised and golden balls can pull his finger out and get a job. What a cheek he has!

stopthebarking · 26/12/2022 16:08

Good for you for planning to stand up for yourself. Your brother is a grown man and a father. He'll just have to suck it up and take whatever job he can get, even if it means working for someone else again until he can possibly find his feet and start a new business of his own. (Poor baby! 🙄)

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 16:02

Eleganz · 26/12/2022 16:00

This isn't true, plenty of people switch between self-employment and employment. The idea that self-employed people have some magical knowledge that makes them dangerous on the workplace for senior management or owners of large businesses is laughable. I'm sorry but running a lone trader or similar operation is not at all the same as running a larger organisation. Even then I know plenty of people who are self-employed who are so dreadful at the business-side of their operations I don't know how they keep things running.

There really is no excuse for OP's brother not to be employed.

I’ll fix this for you. It isn’t true In your opinion, I’ve hired people into senior positions in organisations, who have been consultants and self-employed contractors, and it is never ever worked out. I wouldn’t make the same mistake again, and I would advise any of my clients to avoid them.

Eleganz · 26/12/2022 16:00

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 15:40

And actually, with regards to the comments about self-employment and going to work for other people, once you’ve been self employed for a certain amount of time, it’s actually virtually impossible to convince somebody else to employ you. They are well aware that you know how business works you’ve seen under the Bonnet. You know how most employees are getting absolutely shafted on a daily basis. Most business owners and corporate’s do not want those people in the business.

This isn't true, plenty of people switch between self-employment and employment. The idea that self-employed people have some magical knowledge that makes them dangerous on the workplace for senior management or owners of large businesses is laughable. I'm sorry but running a lone trader or similar operation is not at all the same as running a larger organisation. Even then I know plenty of people who are self-employed who are so dreadful at the business-side of their operations I don't know how they keep things running.

There really is no excuse for OP's brother not to be employed.

autastic · 26/12/2022 15:59

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 12:31

It honestly didn't feel like i have a choice because he either uses my share of the 'inheritance' or uses the rest of his or gets a job. My parents reason that he'll need the rest of his share for himself and his children. I agree with them on that.

If I don't agree to sharing with him, I'll most likely be seen to be unwilling to chip in to help a family member in distress which is awful, you see, especially since I should be so grateful to be getting any money at all. Besides if I were to go back to work, I'd make so much money so quickly since I'm the little hard worker. Mum had 3 kids back to back and she managed!

We're fucked up.

Kp you are being pathetic now, throwing your hands up and woe is me.
You do have a choice you already said your other sister can't bare to be in the same room as him, so you are not going to be seen as failing to help a family member.
You have already said he has half his money to come but he wants yours instead because he will spend it. This way be can't spend it.
And as for your parents... they have said this in the hope you will fall into place and make their lives easier and they can blame you when they say no, thus side stepping the fall out and will take all the glory of you do. They have shown you what they think of you. The only choices you have are to realise the only person to blame if you don't get your money at this point is you... you can say no and deal with the fall out of your resentment and your sister is going to be pissed she got less than your brother as well.
If they then try guilt tripping you leave, walk away cut yourself off and then report your siblings to the tax office as I imagine these gifts are well over the tax threshold!
Sorry to be so blunt but you are in a drama triangle and you have labeled yourself victim.
40 is a great age to grow up and out of the allotted role your parents gave you and free yourself of this....remember you are already getting less than you siblings because of inflation and on that note your sister was the smartest taking it all at 21.

user1497207191 · 26/12/2022 15:59

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 15:40

And actually, with regards to the comments about self-employment and going to work for other people, once you’ve been self employed for a certain amount of time, it’s actually virtually impossible to convince somebody else to employ you. They are well aware that you know how business works you’ve seen under the Bonnet. You know how most employees are getting absolutely shafted on a daily basis. Most business owners and corporate’s do not want those people in the business.

Bollocks. Lots of self employed people go back to employment. Some people can't hack working for themselves. Sometimes circumstances change. Sometimes, markets/industries change. Just look at the expansion of IR35 over the past few years - tens (if not hundreds of thousands) of people previously operating as personal service companies are now back on their "employers" payroll as staff. During covid, I lost a huge number of my small business clients - many had to give up their small businesses and get jobs, any job, mostly in supermarkets and doing deliveries.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 26/12/2022 15:58

Don’t let them make your brother’s problems yours - i.e. don’t start talking about what he should do.
I would just state the following:

  1. it was his choice to screw up his marriage, so morally you don’t want to give him money to make up for what he lost in the divorce
  2. you have to be employed to earn money, so you don’t want to subsidize him so he doesn’t have to do the same
  3. your sister is (rightly so) not expected to give him any of her share
  4. you were counting on the money that they promised you
Hoplesscynic · 26/12/2022 15:58

OP, you keep saying that your brother "needs help" and yet, he still has 50% of his own inheritance and the choice to get a job to cover his Bills. Giving him your money will not help him, it would just enable him to continue on the same destructive/selfish/lazy path. Chances are, once he spends your inheritance he will still be in the same position "asking for help".
Don't feel awkward saying No, my god if I was your brother I would be incredibly embarrassed to even raise such a suggestion! Your brother sounds selfish and spoiled, I bet he's used to your parents bailing him out lots throughout life. He's a grown adult who chooses not to sort his own problems, but take away from other people instead. That would be a firm No from me.

mrsbyers · 26/12/2022 15:58

Another consideration is that even if you’d received the same they have already had an advantage as factoring inflation in your share is worth less

WeepingSomnambulist · 26/12/2022 15:57

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 15:40

And actually, with regards to the comments about self-employment and going to work for other people, once you’ve been self employed for a certain amount of time, it’s actually virtually impossible to convince somebody else to employ you. They are well aware that you know how business works you’ve seen under the Bonnet. You know how most employees are getting absolutely shafted on a daily basis. Most business owners and corporate’s do not want those people in the business.

This feels like it was written by someone with no experience of running anything or hiring.
It just isnt true, not in my experience of being a business owner and dealing with freelancers who very often go off to work for large companies after doing great work.

kdramaqueen · 26/12/2022 15:56

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 15:40

And actually, with regards to the comments about self-employment and going to work for other people, once you’ve been self employed for a certain amount of time, it’s actually virtually impossible to convince somebody else to employ you. They are well aware that you know how business works you’ve seen under the Bonnet. You know how most employees are getting absolutely shafted on a daily basis. Most business owners and corporate’s do not want those people in the business.

Sorry, but I don't necessarily agree with you on this, as it might depend on the industry.

My df had his own retail business and when he got older decided he wanted less stress so became an employee. Ds had a Ltd company but is now an employee after the market changed. No problems getting hired and now in line for a big promotion. His ownership experience helps.

Wakk · 26/12/2022 15:55

Your plan sounds good. Just be honest, you've made plans for your part and don't wish to change those as they are so necessary for your family.

WeepingSomnambulist · 26/12/2022 15:55

Dont kid yourself about their will. That is going to be changed so whatever is left will go to your brother.

Tell them how you feel but make sure you leave that conversation with them understanding that your answer is no, and now that you're 40, they can transfer the same amount your sister got to your account. Tell them that if he needs money then he can ask for the other half of his but you're not subsidising his lifestyle. Also make it clear that you've noticed that they have not approached your sister and asked for some of her money back, so they expect you to be the only one who misses out.

Honestly, make sure they full understand what they've done here.

RudeElfTheRainDear · 26/12/2022 15:52

The more I read on here about inheritances the more I appreciated the fact that I have no expectation or hope of one.

I have, instead, been able to spend my entire life loving my parents simply based on the kind of people they are and not what £ they are worth.

It's a freedom.

Ayeaken · 26/12/2022 15:51

Your parents shouldn't even have asked you to forego your share, any of it. It's put you in an impossible position.

Your brother is in the situation he's his nt hus own doing (ruining his relationship my being unfaithful and refusing to get a job). That's his problem not yours. I'm all for helping my siblings but that's if they 'need' it, not if they can't be arsed to work and earn their own keep.

I'd tell your parents that it's their money and ultimately their decision how they spend it (put the decision back onto them) but tell them you'd be really hurt if they decided not to treat you all the same. It's the truth.

BabyFour2023 · 26/12/2022 15:50

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 12:43

My parents have enough to last them into old age. I can't help but feel that they want to stop bailing my brother out and they are passing on their responsibility to me. If really wanted to help him without touching my pot, they could. They want to 'help out family'. My needs apparently don't matter because DH has a good job and we have savings.

I feel like an idiot for having expected their money and made plans for it. I'd promised myself id never depend on them. I feel even worse to be upset that I'm not receiving a gift. I was never entitled to it anyway.

So why aren’t you using your own savings to find your maternity leave?

dontputitthere · 26/12/2022 15:49

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 15:40

And actually, with regards to the comments about self-employment and going to work for other people, once you’ve been self employed for a certain amount of time, it’s actually virtually impossible to convince somebody else to employ you. They are well aware that you know how business works you’ve seen under the Bonnet. You know how most employees are getting absolutely shafted on a daily basis. Most business owners and corporate’s do not want those people in the business.

I mean... that's one hell of a sweeping statement.

I've got about a dozen stories of friends that say the opposite.

I was freelance for years and got asked by one of my companies to come and work for them full time and have been an employee ever since.

So I think that should be taken with a pinch of salt. Obviously don't know the brothers line of work.

TheGirlWhoTamedTheDragon · 26/12/2022 15:48

Doesn't sound like he's doing much to find ways to generate self-employment income, either. 🎻

LadyEloise1 · 26/12/2022 15:46

@Angeldelight81 - that's a very good perspective well articulated.

Angeldelight81 · 26/12/2022 15:40

And actually, with regards to the comments about self-employment and going to work for other people, once you’ve been self employed for a certain amount of time, it’s actually virtually impossible to convince somebody else to employ you. They are well aware that you know how business works you’ve seen under the Bonnet. You know how most employees are getting absolutely shafted on a daily basis. Most business owners and corporate’s do not want those people in the business.