Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset my inheritance is reduced

812 replies

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 11:18

I have very generous parents who worked extremely hard to ensure their kids were looked after. When we came of age (21) they told us how much each of us would inherit when we're turned 40. My sister asked for them to give a her a lump sum equal to her share so she could buy a house and they did that. When my brother turned 25, her asked for half of his share ao her could put down a deposit for a house and have enough cash to cover a 3 year sabbatical which they did. I haven't asked for anything as I was happy to wait till I turned 40. I started working when I was 16 so I have always been more financially secure than my siblings but im a freelancer which makes work difficult to come by and i also have 2 under 2. I'd planned to take 6 months maternity then go back to work in January but I'm shattered. My body, soul are exhausted from back to back pregnancies. I turn 40 in Feb so I was hoping to use my inheritance to take another year off, get therapy and sort my self out without financial pressure. DH works hard but his income alone won't cover us if I'm not earning.

Anyway, yesterday (Christmas!) my parents asked if they could reduce my inheritance sum as my brother 'needs it more'. He's just gone through a divorce (he cheated) and his ex-wife took him to the cleaners. His business went under during Covid and he hasn't worked in 2 years although he could get a job if he chose to. He claims he can't go back to working for someone else after having been his own boss for 10 years.

I'm devasted. My parents insist I don't have to say yes but I don't feel like i have much of a choice. I haven't stopped crying since.

OP posts:
EasterIsland · 26/12/2022 19:25

@MoMuM7 you E had the predictable MN response, but please ignore those posts.

The basics of the situation are that your parents are treating you with less respect and love than your brother. (Whose troubles might be said to have been self-inflicted).

YANBU to be deeply upset. Very deeply upset.

And it’s not about the money(although that is part of it). It’s the unequal treatment and the sense that your parents care less about you than your brother or sister.

As you’re finding out, sometimes there is a penalty for being the sensible, self- reliant child. Your family often assumes you need less care.

I hate the Biblical parable of the prodigal son. I always feel for the sensible elder son who does what he should do.

LavenderfortheBees · 26/12/2022 19:14

Good luck this evening.

Marchitectmummy · 26/12/2022 19:14

Why can't they give you the money you were promised and extra to the brother from the care money they put to one side and if they need more they can still sell the house as is their fall back now?

StolenCookie · 26/12/2022 19:09

Oh and please pay no attention to the bitter posters who think you’re entitled to nothing. I don’t believe for a second that anyone in your position wouldn’t feel hurt.

Gingerbreadhouseofhorror · 26/12/2022 19:08

Late to the party but just echoing what many others have said - you need to be honest about this OP - say no and explain why, and tell them what your plans are with the money. Why should you bail your brother out of a situation of his making? He should get a job! Stop being a people pleaser, and claim what is rightfully yours!

Blossomtoes · 26/12/2022 19:08

OP isn’t pregnant @Canthave2manycats. She’s on mat leave with her second child.

StolenCookie · 26/12/2022 19:07

Canthave2manycats · 26/12/2022 19:02

That's a horrible thing to say! Not only is the OP pregnant, but this conversation happened on Christmas Day FFS - and it's not the money per se - it's that the parents would even ask this of their daughter! She's the only one of the three who has waited patiently for her share, and because of that, her parents think it's ok to disadvantage her to accommodate her feckless brother? Really???

@MoMuM7 absolutely say no. Your twat of a brother should get 'rewarded' for shagging another woman and breaking up his family? If he was my son, I'd be ashamed of him. He already got money to buy a house - nothing to do with you that he fucked that up. Am I right in thinking that he still has half of his share? Let him use it. He made his bed etc. If he doesn't want to get a job, tough, he can live on benefits. Might make him feel more grateful for all the advantages he's had in life.

I disagree with PPs who say you're not "entitled" to anything - I think that you are, because your parents made this plan, communicated it and executed it for your siblings who asked for it early. You're just as worthy of receiving your equal share - if you don't ask for it for yourself, do it for your children.

Best wishes x

Totally agree with this. Your brother has half of his remaining share!! And he doesn’t want to work? Ok? He can suit himself but for OP to lose out on her inheritance because of what frankly sounds like utter selfishness would be outrageous!

Canthave2manycats · 26/12/2022 19:06

PetraBP · 26/12/2022 15:15

Wow.

First world problems.

Based on the information you have provided, I’ve calculated the exact amount that your parents owe you.

It’s £0.

You're a honey aren't you!!!

StolenCookie · 26/12/2022 19:02

Gosh, I really feel for you OP. There are some very complicated family dynamics at play here. I think it’s shocking for your parents to ask that you give up part of your inheritance. It is NOT your job to rescue your brother. I don’t think privilege comes into this - your parents promised you all something and you accepted their offer (in your mind) in good faith, so of course you’ve made plans for that money and assumed it will come to you at the promised time. I really hope your family don’t succeed in guilting you out of your inheritance!

Canthave2manycats · 26/12/2022 19:02

SofiaSoFar · 26/12/2022 11:47

Tell them no. Why would you not do that?

The "..haven't stopped crying since" is pathetic though, to be quite frank.

That's a horrible thing to say! Not only is the OP pregnant, but this conversation happened on Christmas Day FFS - and it's not the money per se - it's that the parents would even ask this of their daughter! She's the only one of the three who has waited patiently for her share, and because of that, her parents think it's ok to disadvantage her to accommodate her feckless brother? Really???

@MoMuM7 absolutely say no. Your twat of a brother should get 'rewarded' for shagging another woman and breaking up his family? If he was my son, I'd be ashamed of him. He already got money to buy a house - nothing to do with you that he fucked that up. Am I right in thinking that he still has half of his share? Let him use it. He made his bed etc. If he doesn't want to get a job, tough, he can live on benefits. Might make him feel more grateful for all the advantages he's had in life.

I disagree with PPs who say you're not "entitled" to anything - I think that you are, because your parents made this plan, communicated it and executed it for your siblings who asked for it early. You're just as worthy of receiving your equal share - if you don't ask for it for yourself, do it for your children.

Best wishes x

Blossomtoes · 26/12/2022 18:57

DepressingTimes · 26/12/2022 18:52

There are tax implications as well, assume your parents know all about that. Usually inheritance is given when someone dies and there are rules now about handing out lump sums before death.

It’s not a problem if you live for seven years. I just have to hang on for another 30 months for my estate to be free and clear!

DepressingTimes · 26/12/2022 18:52

There are tax implications as well, assume your parents know all about that. Usually inheritance is given when someone dies and there are rules now about handing out lump sums before death.

Eleganz · 26/12/2022 18:51

Mari9999 · 26/12/2022 18:35

Angeldelight81,
At this time you are providing assistance to your children based upon their needs. You have no idea what the future may hold for any of these children. It is quite possible that the one not going to university may never experience any financial need. It is possible that they may all have ongoing financial need. One may have great need in the future, or God willing they may all be very successful and never need any assistance.

Wise people let circumstances and situations determine their behavior, and not some platitude about fairness. Caring parents want to see the needs of all of their children and grandchildren met. They would shift heaven and earth ( to the extent possible) not to have family members doing without needs .

Adults nurturing you like him or her more than me, may nerd therapy more than money. If I had no financial need and my brother's life seemed on a downward spiral for whatever reason, I would not blame or question my parents stepping in no matter what the cost was to those of us in better situations.

Do you think that the day will come when you think some commitment to an arbitrary notion of fairness will be more important than helping any of your children that you believe to be in significant need? Do you believe that any of your children have the right to dictate how you allocate your income and resources?

It seems though that this school of thought would not be the one that would make long term promises of equitable financial assistance to all children and then partially deliver on those promises early for some siblings but not others.

This is not OP's fault, this is her parents fault in creating such an expectation and allowing it to become so emotionally loaded both in the past and now by presenting one sibling with an apparent choice (so that the parents don't have to make it) to determine whether their needs are more than the needs of a sibling who has, by all accounts, got themselves into this situation and does not appear to be taking all opportunities to help themselves (i.e. quite debatable from their perspective).

This is the parents' mess and, if they genuinely feel that one child is more needy and deserving at this time they should be brave enough to make that decision by themselves and live with the consequences of not meeting the expectations they themselves have created and encouraged.

Annabella91 · 26/12/2022 18:51

No he should get up of his ass and get a job there's plenty out there.

ScroogeMcDuckling · 26/12/2022 18:49

A lot of people have said it on her.

Say what you truly feel and think.

if that’s a struggle actually saying it write a letter to your parents expressing your views.

I cannot talk from personal experience at all about receiving inheritance and probably never will be able to, but I do know if one sibling gets a better Christmas present than the other sibling, it does grate a little.

Good luck

Pumperthepumper · 26/12/2022 18:44

Eleganz · 26/12/2022 18:41

Why not? Things do indeed change. You can't look into the future and decide you'll never need that money, and neither can they. So why make a long term promise and set an emotionally charged expectation like that and then follow it up by delivering on that promise early for some siblings and not others?

But it’s only emotionally charged if you really need the money. And OP doesn’t.

Lost123454 · 26/12/2022 18:44

Say No

You're brother is a cheating freeloader who wants more handouts to allow his bum lifestyle

He isn't your problem

Like you say, he could get a job if he wanted. He chooses not to

Look after Number One

Hoplesscynic · 26/12/2022 18:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Eleganz · 26/12/2022 18:41

Pumperthepumper · 26/12/2022 18:19

Why? Things change. You can’t look into the future and decide you’ll never need that money, and neither can they.

Why not? Things do indeed change. You can't look into the future and decide you'll never need that money, and neither can they. So why make a long term promise and set an emotionally charged expectation like that and then follow it up by delivering on that promise early for some siblings and not others?

Lilavanblue · 26/12/2022 18:39

ReneBumsWombats · 26/12/2022 17:26

Oh stop being so obtuse. You know damn well what's wrong when parents set money aside for each child and then try to withhold one child's share or give it to one of the others.

You aren't clever or morally superior with this disingenuous rubbish and you aren't fooling anyone.

Agree with this.
Parents not being able/ willing to give their adult children money is one thing, parents saying they will give their children equal amounts and than changing their mind in favour of one child is another.
In my case, I won’t be inheriting much from my parents (if anything at all), but I love them no matter what. If they‘d behaved like OPs parents I would be annoyed though.
It‘s not about money, it’s about fairness.

Mari9999 · 26/12/2022 18:35

Angeldelight81,
At this time you are providing assistance to your children based upon their needs. You have no idea what the future may hold for any of these children. It is quite possible that the one not going to university may never experience any financial need. It is possible that they may all have ongoing financial need. One may have great need in the future, or God willing they may all be very successful and never need any assistance.

Wise people let circumstances and situations determine their behavior, and not some platitude about fairness. Caring parents want to see the needs of all of their children and grandchildren met. They would shift heaven and earth ( to the extent possible) not to have family members doing without needs .

Adults nurturing you like him or her more than me, may nerd therapy more than money. If I had no financial need and my brother's life seemed on a downward spiral for whatever reason, I would not blame or question my parents stepping in no matter what the cost was to those of us in better situations.

Do you think that the day will come when you think some commitment to an arbitrary notion of fairness will be more important than helping any of your children that you believe to be in significant need? Do you believe that any of your children have the right to dictate how you allocate your income and resources?

DahliaBlue · 26/12/2022 18:27

Just say no. It is not fair and not what was promised. In the future you may find yourself in a position where you need the money. In fact you were planning to use it now for additional maternity leave. You have to put your DC before your DB and anway ex-wife will take at least half of anything given to DB. If they go ahead and reduce your share anyway, let that responsibility lie directly with them. Do not pave the way for them and allow them to say later "We asked you and you were in agreement"

Pumperthepumper · 26/12/2022 18:19

Eleganz · 26/12/2022 18:17

Yes it is. If one child has planne don having the money I promised them - I could see that it is easy to be hurt as a child by a parent appearing to favour another sibling over you when I don't think they are more deserving.

Your move...

Why? Things change. You can’t look into the future and decide you’ll never need that money, and neither can they.

Eleganz · 26/12/2022 18:17

Pumperthepumper · 26/12/2022 18:12

No, it isn’t. If one child needs the money - for whatever reason - I could see that it would be tempting to give them more, especially when the other child is financially secure.

Yes it is. If one child has planne don having the money I promised them - I could see that it is easy to be hurt as a child by a parent appearing to favour another sibling over you when I don't think they are more deserving.

Your move...

a1poshpaws · 26/12/2022 18:16

Explain to them that you were really looking forward to the money for the reasons you've listed.

Add that for them to give your brother further financial support would not only be really unfair since he & your sister have received X amount already, it would also be colluding with his incredibly infantile, utterly selfish and completely egotistical stance on working for an employer.

They TOLD you that you don't have to agree. So putting your hard No to them in these terms is unlikely to upset them, as it's logical and fair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread