Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel upset my inheritance is reduced

812 replies

MoMuM7 · 26/12/2022 11:18

I have very generous parents who worked extremely hard to ensure their kids were looked after. When we came of age (21) they told us how much each of us would inherit when we're turned 40. My sister asked for them to give a her a lump sum equal to her share so she could buy a house and they did that. When my brother turned 25, her asked for half of his share ao her could put down a deposit for a house and have enough cash to cover a 3 year sabbatical which they did. I haven't asked for anything as I was happy to wait till I turned 40. I started working when I was 16 so I have always been more financially secure than my siblings but im a freelancer which makes work difficult to come by and i also have 2 under 2. I'd planned to take 6 months maternity then go back to work in January but I'm shattered. My body, soul are exhausted from back to back pregnancies. I turn 40 in Feb so I was hoping to use my inheritance to take another year off, get therapy and sort my self out without financial pressure. DH works hard but his income alone won't cover us if I'm not earning.

Anyway, yesterday (Christmas!) my parents asked if they could reduce my inheritance sum as my brother 'needs it more'. He's just gone through a divorce (he cheated) and his ex-wife took him to the cleaners. His business went under during Covid and he hasn't worked in 2 years although he could get a job if he chose to. He claims he can't go back to working for someone else after having been his own boss for 10 years.

I'm devasted. My parents insist I don't have to say yes but I don't feel like i have much of a choice. I haven't stopped crying since.

OP posts:
Allsnotwell · 26/12/2022 20:10

OPs parents are alive.

Yep. Fully aware of that - have read the thread.

Parents promised the money. Up to OP to take it and then decide if she helps or not.

Notonthestairs · 26/12/2022 20:08

Yes its entirely reasonable that the Ops brother has a) already spent 50% of his gift, b) wants to retain the rest of his share (so he will have benefitted 100% plus a portion of the Ops share, c) refuses to work and d) nobody has suggested the third child hand back a penny to support poor profligate brother.

musingsinmidlife · 26/12/2022 20:07

LaLuz7 · 26/12/2022 20:04

No one is arguing that OP has a legal claim on thar money. She doesn't.

We are arguing on the morality of the situation, not on legal technicalities.

It’s not illegal to be an asshole and her parents are acting like ones.

The post I responded to was telling her to talk to a solicitor to legally try to ring fence her share of the savings now so that there won't be less of an inheritance when her parents die. You can't keep your parents from spending their own money when alive (even if it is on things or people you don't agree with) so that your inheritance isn't reduced when they die.

Spottypaperbag · 26/12/2022 20:06

Hope the conversation went well OP.

LaLuz7 · 26/12/2022 20:04

musingsinmidlife · 26/12/2022 19:58

OPs parents are alive. This isn't actually inheritance money. It is just the parents current savings. She has no legal entitlement to their savings accounts or assets and you can't take legal action to force your parents to pay you an equal amount from their savings as they spent on your siblings. Adults can decide how to spend their money while alive. OP is banking on a conversation from when she was a teen / young adult where they said they would give her some money at forty. Now they are asking her if she needs the money because if not they will spend their money differently to help out another of their children who they feel needs it.

You may wish parents dead so you can get your hands on their cash and assets but the reality is that while alive, they have control of their own funds and can spend it as they wish.

No one is arguing that OP has a legal claim on thar money. She doesn't.

We are arguing on the morality of the situation, not on legal technicalities.

It’s not illegal to be an asshole and her parents are acting like ones.

BellePeppa · 26/12/2022 20:02

You shouldn’t have to pay the price (literally) for his cheating and consequent divorce. Stand up for yourself and say No!

musingsinmidlife · 26/12/2022 19:58

Allsnotwell · 26/12/2022 19:50

To add I would also ask for all your share and say if you choose to help your brother that will be a conversation to be had with him.

If this is a huge sue you could then approach a solicitor to ring fence your investment - plus interest if you invest in a property. Solicitor could advise.

He could then pay you rent or a % of the property based on different conditions - like the children become in adults/ he can can buy shares back when working etc

There are more ways to deal with this that all or nothing.

OPs parents are alive. This isn't actually inheritance money. It is just the parents current savings. She has no legal entitlement to their savings accounts or assets and you can't take legal action to force your parents to pay you an equal amount from their savings as they spent on your siblings. Adults can decide how to spend their money while alive. OP is banking on a conversation from when she was a teen / young adult where they said they would give her some money at forty. Now they are asking her if she needs the money because if not they will spend their money differently to help out another of their children who they feel needs it.

You may wish parents dead so you can get your hands on their cash and assets but the reality is that while alive, they have control of their own funds and can spend it as they wish.

Allsnotwell · 26/12/2022 19:50

To add I would also ask for all your share and say if you choose to help your brother that will be a conversation to be had with him.

If this is a huge sue you could then approach a solicitor to ring fence your investment - plus interest if you invest in a property. Solicitor could advise.

He could then pay you rent or a % of the property based on different conditions - like the children become in adults/ he can can buy shares back when working etc

There are more ways to deal with this that all or nothing.

Allsnotwell · 26/12/2022 19:47

I agree the only thing your brother had learnt is to rely on the bank of mum and dad - I also wonder if her is aware of the situation?

Currently he can choose to use his share and work - it’s not one or the other! He has skills and there’s a skills shortage.

Notonthestairs · 26/12/2022 19:47

I bet the brother wouldn't use his gifted money to bail out the Op.

I bet he wouldn't even be asked to.

LimeCheesecake · 26/12/2022 19:47

If they had given you the money at 30 instead of 40, and you hadn’t spent it, would it be reasonable for them to ask you to give some to your brother to fund him not working?

ultimately if they decide they don’t want to give you the amount they originally promised for your 40th and to use the difference to help your brother, that’s their choice, by asking you they’ve acknowledged as far as they and the rest of the family are concerned, the money belongs to you, so have asked if you would be happy to give some of your money to your brother.

id go with saying that if it’s your choice then no, you wouldn’t give some of your money to your brother, but if they do want to give money to him and then decide to give you less than both siblings, that will be their choice.

GreenSunfish · 26/12/2022 19:46

If you don’t stand up for yourself now and your brother takes your share it will lead to family bust ups down the line.

grumpycow1 · 26/12/2022 19:45

Tell them no, you need the money for your mental health and your brother can’t keep being bailed out, he needs to own up to his mess and work his way out. If there’s always a safety net what will he learn??

dontputitthere · 26/12/2022 19:41

@musingsinmidlife that's not what I'm saying. I don't expect money. Or even the same amount of money.

But giving money to two kids. Then asking the third to give theirs to their cheating lazy brother. Well that's shitty

Course they can do what they want. But the relationships fucked.

Canthave2manycats · 26/12/2022 19:40

Blossomtoes · 26/12/2022 19:08

OP isn’t pregnant @Canthave2manycats. She’s on mat leave with her second child.

You're quite correct - I mixed the OP up with another post I just read. Still she's mentally and physically exhausted from having 2 babies in a short space of time.

@musingsinmidlife what a ridiculous comment!! Obviously parents spend money on their children according to their individual needs. You have a musical child, who takes lessons on various instruments - but another has no interest, and doesn't have an equivalent hobby - clearly there's a degree of inequity. You can't treat all of your kids exactly the same all the time.

One child lived away from home for uni and was supported; other two lived at home with no expenses and therefore were supported in that way.

This situation is different though. The OP's parents made a commitment to all of their three children and it's only fair that they honour that. I actually don't understand why they say aged 40, and then handed out to 2 of them. All 3 should have got it at the same time.

musingsinmidlife · 26/12/2022 19:36

dontputitthere · 26/12/2022 19:28

You again

It's not about money though is it. It's about favouritism. Just fairness and equality for all of their children

They've also been shits by putting it all on the op so it's her decision or she's the one condemning her brother to a life of misery (I mean he could get a job but that's obviously too easy a solution)

Not all families exist under a every child gets exactly the same amount. My parents have helped out my adult brother and his kids because they need it. I would pout and complain and be mad that I didn't get the same amount but I don't have that mentality. I don't expect my parents to financially support me nor do I think as adults I am entitled to an exact equal share of all their savings and assets and that they have no right to spend their own money as they wish.

Jackandjamie · 26/12/2022 19:32

I think if it was something like a medical condition or something they he had no control over then it would be different but if it’s because of a cheat induced divorce it’s very unfair. It’s essentially you giving your brother the money which is unfair. I actually think it’s extremely unfair to even put you in that position

Tigger7654 · 26/12/2022 19:31

Half!

Tigger7654 · 26/12/2022 19:31

Your DB made his own choices and they shouldn't impact on you so you need to tell your parents no, they can't take from you to give to him. If they want to help him out he can have his remaining share can't he, didn't you say he only took held his initially?

dontputitthere · 26/12/2022 19:28

musingsinmidlife · 26/12/2022 19:25

This is their money and they can spend it as they wish. They aren't dead and this isn't an inheritance being split as per a will or estate.

No one is entitled to their parents money. In this case your parents have asked you and so you can tell them you also need money. They may have no idea how much you are struggling and that you need their money too to get by. Money isn't always spent equally. Sometimes one child has a special need and needs equipment to therapies that cost more, sometimes one is in a competitive sport that is expensive etc. Many families spend based on need and not on every child gets the exact same amount, regardless of need. Your parents see they have one child in need and one child not in need so they are directing their resources as they see fit. If you are also in need, then you need to tell them so they can financially support you too.

You again

It's not about money though is it. It's about favouritism. Just fairness and equality for all of their children

They've also been shits by putting it all on the op so it's her decision or she's the one condemning her brother to a life of misery (I mean he could get a job but that's obviously too easy a solution)

EasterIsland · 26/12/2022 19:28

Good luck, and please try to find a way to tell your parents how you feel. That it’s not about the money per se. It’s about the symbolism of helping your siblings but not you. Symbolically, what does that indicate about the way they think about you?

Ask your parents that. Ask them if they really think less of you than your brother and sister.

LongTermSwinger · 26/12/2022 19:27

Sometimes one child has a special need and needs equipment to therapies that cost more

Comparing parents spending on a child with special needs to the OPs parenting prioritising her brother because he cheated on his wife is pretty much scraping the barrel in the “sometimes needs are different” stakes

Atethehalloweenchocs · 26/12/2022 19:26

OP, any updates? I hope you got to speak to your parents. It is not right that they give your share to your brother - I hope you got to explain that to them.

musingsinmidlife · 26/12/2022 19:25

This is their money and they can spend it as they wish. They aren't dead and this isn't an inheritance being split as per a will or estate.

No one is entitled to their parents money. In this case your parents have asked you and so you can tell them you also need money. They may have no idea how much you are struggling and that you need their money too to get by. Money isn't always spent equally. Sometimes one child has a special need and needs equipment to therapies that cost more, sometimes one is in a competitive sport that is expensive etc. Many families spend based on need and not on every child gets the exact same amount, regardless of need. Your parents see they have one child in need and one child not in need so they are directing their resources as they see fit. If you are also in need, then you need to tell them so they can financially support you too.

LongTermSwinger · 26/12/2022 19:25

Good luck with talking to them.

Its ridiculous that the solution to your brother fucking up is you losing out. Especially when he still has half of “his” money left.

I’m guessing the fact your sister doesn’t talk to him is linked to his golden child status?

Swipe left for the next trending thread