Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect dp to get a vacestomy in 20s.

542 replies

Justmegan · 25/12/2022 23:40

Just that really. Me and dp already have 1dc. Dp 27 I'm 25. Thing is I had a traumatic birth. Me and dps compatability means that we have quite large children together, dc got stuck heart rate dropped... you get the picture. I've been told if I get pregnant to expect that again.

Needless to say we have been crapping ourselves about me getting pregnant Again. Not only because of the birth but the pregnancy was horrible on my body and I really suffered being under 5 ft! I can't and won't take any hormonal contraception as the side effects don't agree with my polosystic ovaries. Dp and me both don't like condoms and I can't feel anything and neither can he. Call it childish but with any feeling there ( we have tried different condom types) it's like humping a wall. I can't tell he isn't in to it and it kills the mood. So we have been avoiding sex.

My thing is that we are engaged and dp says he wants to be married to me. We live together and are a happy family. So it's it unreasonable to expect him to get a (if needs be reversible) vasectomy. He keeps saying he doesn't want to inflict more trauma or a hard pregnancy on me but does nothing about it. He also seems quite happy in our abstinence which is weird to me giving how young we are. I understand because we are so young things can change but at the moment I feel like just letting our sex life turn into non existent for 2 years isn't the answer either. So aibu to ask this?

OP posts:
Bluebellysmell · 28/12/2022 21:55

Have you tried a diaphragm OP?

It's none hormonal, and means neither of you need to have surgery.

DifferenceEngines · 28/12/2022 21:44

Lavender14 · 27/12/2022 23:01

@CJsGoldfish "of course there is a contraception available, you just refuse to be bothered"

I think this is a bit unfair- this isn't true for all women. Last time I went to the gp they ruled out all hormonal contraception for me due to side effects I'd previously experienced having tried a variety of options. They recommended mirena coil because it was supposed to be localised. I know lots of people find it really great but for me it was god awful and I had constant chronic pain while I had it (gave it 2 years to settle because I didnt know what else to do.) Condoms and the natural method feel a bit unreliable to me in terms of margin for error so I would prefer to be on something else as condoms as I can't get pregnant again this soon after a section? Since I can't use copper coil/pill/bar/implant/injection what would you recommend me that my gp can't? Genuinely would love a solution.

There's a big difference between what you have been through and OP's reluctance to even discuss or consider other options. Perhaps she has actually explored different types of hormonal contraception, but she certainly doesn't give that impression. She also dismisses the mirena on the basis of a scare story that does not make sense, anatomically. She just seems stuck on this one course of action.

MintyFreshOne · 28/12/2022 21:15

Men run the world and it doesn't favour them to make these solutions. There's a really interesting book that outlines how the world is built for men, including how only male dummies were used for car crash tests, leading women to be more likely to suffer severe injuries in car accidents

This ain’t it. It literally is about numbers.

Besides, imagine if they had developed male HBC before female. Would you really place that much trust in another person (a man) when the consequences affect you way more? You’d be a complete fool.

MistyIsland · 28/12/2022 20:55

I doubt you’d find someone to do one on someone under 30. Even privately. In some areas they don’t even offer them on the nhs anymore. There can also be a lot of side effects for men.

Dh and I were questioned quite heavily, this was 10 years ago and dh was 40 and we had finished our family.

I did have a wobble about 5 years ago and we looked into a reversal and they are very expensive and don’t have a high success rate also the longer you leave it the less chance they have of working, last chance before I had an ablation to stop my heavy bleeding chances of pregnancy were slim to none before looking into it

I do believe contraception should be a joint decision but neither can be forced to have an operation they don’t want. However the op seems to want it their way and not making a joint decision with their partner

Lavender14 · 28/12/2022 20:48

NinjaWarriorCooker · 28/12/2022 20:42

So you think it’s a great idea to hand contraceptive responsibility to men….

I would rather be on charge of my own contraceptive responsibilities thanks.

I would still like to be in control of my own contraception don't get me wrong, but I think men should be held equally responsible since they would be equally responsible for any ensuing pregnancy. I think that just saying they aren't reliable enough or whatever to be responsible for themselves actually allows them to have a cop out while women are being called "lazy" for struggling to find a suitable solution themselves. I think it also in term perpetuates that concept of 'trapping' men or like the woman should be left dealing with the pregnancy since it was their responsibility in the first place. These attitudes don't help further women in the slightest. I know a suitable solution doesn't exist right now, but I do question how much investment has been put into it.

Rewis · 28/12/2022 20:46

Of course a couple can talk about family planning and birth control options. Vasectomy being one option.

NinjaWarriorCooker · 28/12/2022 20:42

Miajk · 28/12/2022 19:31

Actually I don't think it's an issue of it's harder.

Men run the world and it doesn't favour them to make these solutions. There's a really interesting book that outlines how the world is built for men, including how only male dummies were used for car crash tests, leading women to be more likely to suffer severe injuries in car accidents.

There were many more examples but yeah.. this thread shows exactly why. Nothing is ever expected of men. God forbid they experience discomfort, responsibility, anything.

So you think it’s a great idea to hand contraceptive responsibility to men….

I would rather be on charge of my own contraceptive responsibilities thanks.

Lavender14 · 28/12/2022 20:42

lifeinthehills · 28/12/2022 06:53

The copper coil isn't hormonal at all. Why can't you use that?

I already have pretty horrendous periods so gp advised against the copper coil because it can make them worse.

GelPens1 · 28/12/2022 20:25

Miajk · 28/12/2022 19:29

Actually copper coil does have side effects for lots of women, just different to hormonal contraception.

Heavier & more painful periods are a key one that many women experience.

So now OP will be doing the pregnancy, birthing, contraception side effects, and her partner will be doing what exactly? Nothing? Sounds about right. The bar is on the floor isn't it.

OP doesn’t want to be pregnant again so she can use condoms (try different types and brands) or have her tubes tied. OP’s boyfriend doesn’t want a vasectomy and probably hopes for more dc in the future. OP shouldn’t take his choice away.

Miajk · 28/12/2022 19:31

MintyFreshOne · 28/12/2022 07:52

My point is really just that as women we're always expected to accept contraception regardless of the side effect and it can sometimes feel like we need to take the least offensive option while men rarely need to think about it

We are the ones that get pregnant, it affects us more intimately and the consequences fall more heavily on us.

Besides, from a pharma POV, it’s easier to stop one egg than 100 million swimmers …

Actually I don't think it's an issue of it's harder.

Men run the world and it doesn't favour them to make these solutions. There's a really interesting book that outlines how the world is built for men, including how only male dummies were used for car crash tests, leading women to be more likely to suffer severe injuries in car accidents.

There were many more examples but yeah.. this thread shows exactly why. Nothing is ever expected of men. God forbid they experience discomfort, responsibility, anything.

Miajk · 28/12/2022 19:29

GelPens1 · 26/12/2022 09:58

You’ve ignored loads of women saying that the copper coil is non-hormonal and, for the majority of women, there aren’t any issues. It is absolutely disgusting to make a young man go through an irreversible procedure to make him infertile.

If you don’t want to fall pregnant and don’t want to use condoms or the copper coil, then you either have your tubes tied or you let the man go and find someone else.

Also, if you want another baby and it’s big again, then opt for a Caesarian. You have loads of choices regarding contraception.

Actually copper coil does have side effects for lots of women, just different to hormonal contraception.

Heavier & more painful periods are a key one that many women experience.

So now OP will be doing the pregnancy, birthing, contraception side effects, and her partner will be doing what exactly? Nothing? Sounds about right. The bar is on the floor isn't it.

Algor1thm · 28/12/2022 08:22

MintyFreshOne · 28/12/2022 07:52

My point is really just that as women we're always expected to accept contraception regardless of the side effect and it can sometimes feel like we need to take the least offensive option while men rarely need to think about it

We are the ones that get pregnant, it affects us more intimately and the consequences fall more heavily on us.

Besides, from a pharma POV, it’s easier to stop one egg than 100 million swimmers …

This. It isn't a sexist thing. It's much, much easier to create a reliable contraceptive method that focuses on the egg and not the sperm. They've been working on a male pill for a long time and just can't make it reliable enough.

Algor1thm · 28/12/2022 08:20

Lavender14 · 27/12/2022 23:01

@CJsGoldfish "of course there is a contraception available, you just refuse to be bothered"

I think this is a bit unfair- this isn't true for all women. Last time I went to the gp they ruled out all hormonal contraception for me due to side effects I'd previously experienced having tried a variety of options. They recommended mirena coil because it was supposed to be localised. I know lots of people find it really great but for me it was god awful and I had constant chronic pain while I had it (gave it 2 years to settle because I didnt know what else to do.) Condoms and the natural method feel a bit unreliable to me in terms of margin for error so I would prefer to be on something else as condoms as I can't get pregnant again this soon after a section? Since I can't use copper coil/pill/bar/implant/injection what would you recommend me that my gp can't? Genuinely would love a solution.

But OP hasn't tried the copper coil... could be the perfect solution for her and much less drastic than a vasectomy and yet she's unwilling to try.

I'm also in your position however and I use a combination of Natural Cycles and condoms. I never have sex during the most fertile 3-4 days of the month, even with a condom on, just in case. Seems to have done the trick for me for about 5 or 6 years, and my husband and I are highly fertile (conceived first month both times we've tried).

MintyFreshOne · 28/12/2022 07:52

My point is really just that as women we're always expected to accept contraception regardless of the side effect and it can sometimes feel like we need to take the least offensive option while men rarely need to think about it

We are the ones that get pregnant, it affects us more intimately and the consequences fall more heavily on us.

Besides, from a pharma POV, it’s easier to stop one egg than 100 million swimmers …

lifeinthehills · 28/12/2022 06:53

Lavender14 · 27/12/2022 23:01

@CJsGoldfish "of course there is a contraception available, you just refuse to be bothered"

I think this is a bit unfair- this isn't true for all women. Last time I went to the gp they ruled out all hormonal contraception for me due to side effects I'd previously experienced having tried a variety of options. They recommended mirena coil because it was supposed to be localised. I know lots of people find it really great but for me it was god awful and I had constant chronic pain while I had it (gave it 2 years to settle because I didnt know what else to do.) Condoms and the natural method feel a bit unreliable to me in terms of margin for error so I would prefer to be on something else as condoms as I can't get pregnant again this soon after a section? Since I can't use copper coil/pill/bar/implant/injection what would you recommend me that my gp can't? Genuinely would love a solution.

The copper coil isn't hormonal at all. Why can't you use that?

BadNomad · 28/12/2022 01:13

The reason it falls on women is because it is women who take all the risk of pregnancy. Would you seriously trust a man to take the contraceptive pill if it was available? I wouldn't trust a man as far as I could throw one. Because, at the end of the day, men will never be the ones at risk of pregnancy so they will never care as much about the risks. You have to look after yourself. And if you think a diaphragm plus condoms is still too much of a risk, then you shouldn't have sex at all because no form of contraception is 100% reliable and sex can cause infections and UTIs etc. Not even male sterilisation is 100% guaranteed to prevent pregnancy. So that's pointless too if you want 0% risk.

Lavender14 · 28/12/2022 00:52

BadNomad · 27/12/2022 23:44

Along with condoms, it is very affective. She asked what she can use. She can use a diaphragm. He can use condoms.

It's a pretty low effectiveness rate considering that's the rate when used effectively. Given that if I got pregnant again I'd risk rupturing my section wound, no I wouldn't really want to risk it with such a big margin for error but I will speak to the gp about it, I don't know anyone who uses a diaphragm so I hadn't considered it. There's still possibility of side effects with that such as uti, bladder infection and reaction to spermicide and doesn't suit all women's cervix shape. My point is really just that as women we're always expected to accept contraception regardless of the side effect and it can sometimes feel like we need to take the least offensive option while men rarely need to think about it. I don't think anyone should be "expecting" their partner to do anything to their bodies that affects their fertility but it does seem unfair that the ball mainly falls in the female court while male contraception is widely underdeveloped and under researched. I don't think we should be calling other women lazy for recognising that it can be really hard to find a good fit.

BadNomad · 27/12/2022 23:44

NalaNana · 27/12/2022 23:37

If @Lavender14 isn't confident in the effectiveness of condoms I doubt she'd be happy with a diaphragm either at 92% - 96% effective when used correctly! (I had to Google it as I'd never heard of this type of contraception - not an expert!).

Along with condoms, it is very affective. She asked what she can use. She can use a diaphragm. He can use condoms.

NalaNana · 27/12/2022 23:37

If @Lavender14 isn't confident in the effectiveness of condoms I doubt she'd be happy with a diaphragm either at 92% - 96% effective when used correctly! (I had to Google it as I'd never heard of this type of contraception - not an expert!).

BadNomad · 27/12/2022 23:14

Lavender14 · 27/12/2022 23:01

@CJsGoldfish "of course there is a contraception available, you just refuse to be bothered"

I think this is a bit unfair- this isn't true for all women. Last time I went to the gp they ruled out all hormonal contraception for me due to side effects I'd previously experienced having tried a variety of options. They recommended mirena coil because it was supposed to be localised. I know lots of people find it really great but for me it was god awful and I had constant chronic pain while I had it (gave it 2 years to settle because I didnt know what else to do.) Condoms and the natural method feel a bit unreliable to me in terms of margin for error so I would prefer to be on something else as condoms as I can't get pregnant again this soon after a section? Since I can't use copper coil/pill/bar/implant/injection what would you recommend me that my gp can't? Genuinely would love a solution.

A diaphragm. Non-permanent. Non-hormonal.

Lavender14 · 27/12/2022 23:01

@CJsGoldfish "of course there is a contraception available, you just refuse to be bothered"

I think this is a bit unfair- this isn't true for all women. Last time I went to the gp they ruled out all hormonal contraception for me due to side effects I'd previously experienced having tried a variety of options. They recommended mirena coil because it was supposed to be localised. I know lots of people find it really great but for me it was god awful and I had constant chronic pain while I had it (gave it 2 years to settle because I didnt know what else to do.) Condoms and the natural method feel a bit unreliable to me in terms of margin for error so I would prefer to be on something else as condoms as I can't get pregnant again this soon after a section? Since I can't use copper coil/pill/bar/implant/injection what would you recommend me that my gp can't? Genuinely would love a solution.

CJsGoldfish · 27/12/2022 22:38

my body doesn't take to hormonal contraception then there aren't many options left. It's not all up to me
If YOU are the one that doesn't want another child then , yes, it IS up to you. You've given different reasons for not wanting to take responsibility for your own contraception but it seems to be...
a) laziness (of course there is a contraception available, you just refuse to be bothered) and..
b) punishment for all you went through in having the baby you wanted to have and didn't prevent.
c) Some weird and controlling "well, if you loved me.." play

You asked if YABU, the answer was yes and yet you are adamant you aren't. You are 🙄

What a nightmare you seem to be, your relationship isn't sustainable whether he leaves now or later 🤷‍♀️

America12 · 27/12/2022 21:55

Justmegan · 26/12/2022 16:22

@MintyFreshOne pull out is what we was doing. Got pregnant twice from it. So obviously he isn't very good.

It's not that he's not very good , it's because that method isn't reliable. You can get pregnant from one sperm which is released before he ejaculates.

Sammmmmy1512 · 27/12/2022 21:05

I dont think your unreasonable to ask the question but u have to respect his reply. I think u need to do some research into it tho, it cost us just over 4k to get my hubbys reversed 6 years ago so i imagine its alot more now. You mentioned about being abstinent for 2 years? Does that mean u do want more children and if so then its not something u should even consider doing now! Also its totally normal for sex to decrease after having a baby so please dont worry about that :)

Sometimeswinning · 27/12/2022 20:58

Gemmanorthdevon · 27/12/2022 15:40

Christ what a horrible thread.

A PP has already hit the nail on the head. The only body you try to change is your own! If you don't want to risk getting pregnant again, and you are refusing every form of contraception due to reasons that affect you, then you get bloody sterilised! And if that's to scary and invasive, then how dare you suggest somebody else goes through it so you don't have to?

I really hopes he chucks you a tiara and tells you to jog on at such a selfish request for such selfish reasons.

I don't agree with the op at all. I find her completely unreasonable with throwing all these obstacles in the way when anyone suggests she has options.

However, of course she can ask. He can say no! Women are asked everyday to prevent and abort pregnancy. I'm sure he can handle a question!