Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my 7 year old just being honest or is she ungrateful? Maybe it’s me maybe I’m really shit at choosing presents?

265 replies

MarrymeKeanu · 25/12/2022 11:23

My 7 year old DD had the following on her Santa list...

A cuddly koala that talks
Gym equipment so she can do gymnastics at home (obvs can’t have a rope hanging from the ceiling)
Lol stuff
Barbie aeroplane
A history book
Lego set
A see through umbrella
A computer
Photo frames
Surprises
Clay

And few other bits that I couldn’t make make out (sneaky look at letter before it went to Santa because she didn’t want me to see it)

This morning she opened from her list
Cuddly koala that talks
Barbie aeroplane
History book
Lego set
Surprises which were...
Playdoh set
Arts and crafts set (new pens, ribbons etc)
A lovely fluffy lockable box to put her special things in
Barbie doll for the aeroplane
Polly pocket set
Sink n sand game (she’d said she wanted this)
Puzzle
Couple of new clothes

She’s just told me she doesn’t like most of her presents and this year isn’t as good as last year.

Shes told me she isn’t that keen on the Barbie aeroplane now, Santa got the wrong history book (it’s an age appropriate lift the flaps Usbourne book), she never wanted polly pockets (already has some and asked for more about a month ago), doesn’t like the crafts set....

Aibu for thinking I’m shit at choosing presents or do I have an ungrateful child? I need perspective.

OP posts:
bookworm14 · 25/12/2022 22:13

Also, all I want for Christmas next year is for the only child = spoilt slur to die in a ditch. 🙄

This. Sick of the lazy stereotyping.

Prettybutdumb · 25/12/2022 21:59

That’s why we completely stopped doing lists 2-3 years ago. They prefer surprises and there’s no hunting for stuff they might not like anymore by the time it’s Christmas morning. I gradually get things I know they’ll like or need, they get a surprise in every single box and squeal with delight.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 25/12/2022 21:56

I was, by all accounts, a wonderfully grateful child at 7. That's because I knew my presents came from my family. My kids are the same.

If I'd thought a magical being did it all, I would have been very disappointed that the magical being didn't always get things right, and I wouldn't have had any tolerance for weird substitutions. I'd have taken it very personally if Father Christmas hadn't got me exactly what I asked for, but he had got all my friends what they asked for.

For the love of all the fairy lights in the street, stop overdoing it with the Santa pretence. Santa only fills stockings, and wrapped gifts bought by you should have a label saying so.

lifeinthehills · 25/12/2022 21:54

I think 7 year olds do know better than to be ungrateful and that would be ungrateful. But here you have a 7 year old who believes in Santa. She thinks she can pass comments about her Christmas gifts without offense, because the gift giver isn't there.

Fleabigg · 25/12/2022 21:48

Yes she’s been ungrateful and I’d be upset by it too. I can see how it can happen though. I know I need to start redressing the balance in time for next year myself because my DD has got in her head that she could ask Father Christmas for a huge list of stuff and all she wanted from me was a scarf. Definitely need to reign it back to FC just bringing one gift or the stocking and the rest are from us.

Also, all I want for Christmas next year is for the only child = spoilt slur to die in a ditch. 🙄

Rainbowsparkles29 · 25/12/2022 21:33

I’d limit the requests to Santa to one gift in future. Having a whole wish list is a bit crass, and then getting it all and complaining IS being spoilt. Limit expectations!

The problem is though that tbf to the kid she didn't get most of what was on her list if you really look at it. The things that I would've assumed were most important she didn't get. I think if you really can't get it you need to prepare the child for this and basically let them know that they won't be getting it. This is why as I said earlier in the post that I only let my dd pick 3 things that she really really wants. If we hype kids up towards Christmas being all about gifts then we have to accept that it is going to be disappointing for them if we don't meet those expectations

Puppers · 25/12/2022 20:54

Shitfather · 25/12/2022 14:54

And I agree with @Mariposista - give her gifts to a children’s charity so she learns the value of things. I don’t buy the “she’s only 7” and “overwhelmed” comments.

Well that's OK. You don't need to "buy it" 🤷‍♀️ It's patently clear that you're no expert on child development and that you are extremely mean spirited so it's really neither here nor there.

The kind of adult who carries out a character assassination on a 7 year old, to her parent, on Christmas day is certainly in no position to be making moral judgements on anybody else.

holidayelbow · 25/12/2022 20:19

Maybe too late but you can get tbr at home balance beams from Amazon- they go right on the floor and fold away. My 6yr old got one from Santa.

Yousee · 25/12/2022 20:14

Thing that jumped out at me was that some of the surprises weren't so much surprises as substitutions and we all know how annoying they can be when doing the online shop.
A lockable box when she just wanted a couple of photo frames. Playdoh instead of clay. Polly Pocket instead of LOL.
That said, at 7 you should be able to expect a bit of social awareness but it's clearly shot to hell when kids think a magical being brought the presents rather than them costing Mum blood, sweat and tears to sort out.

Goldpaw · 25/12/2022 20:03

MarrymeKeanu · 25/12/2022 14:43

I need to catch up but just when I thought all was going well grandparents have arrived with sack-loads of great presents, MIL is a HUGE shopper and has spent lots on each child! DD has just announced that nanny and grandad have given her better presents than Santa this year. 🙄

Santa needs to buy less and mummy and daddy more. She probably wouldn't be so fullsome with her opinion of Santa's choices if he was there in the room.😉

anotherscroller · 25/12/2022 19:52

Endlesslaundry123 · 25/12/2022 12:24

Please please don't shame her for this. She trusts you enough to be honest with you. If you make her feel guilty for being honest, she'll stop telling you hard truths and that will be a very bad thing in her teenage years when she'll likely face lots of hard / shameful things. Thank her for her honesty and tell her "nobody's perfect, not even Santa. Sorry you're disappointed" (everyone has a right to feel disappointed).

This

Busybody2022 · 25/12/2022 19:16

@MilkyYay Usbourne lift the flap books are absolutely ideal for 7 year olds. They aren't babyish.

MilkyYay · 25/12/2022 19:06

She is ungrateful. But i would say

a) a lift the flap book for a 7 year old? Aren't those for little ones who can't read? My 7 year old niece has had a proper thick children's encyclopedia.

b) I'd be discouraging writing a huge long lists of wants to FC. Its not about demanding loads of stuff!! My kids only put one thing on their list each and they have their expectations that its a suggestion to FC, and he can't always give everyone exactly what they ask.

nutbrownhare15 · 25/12/2022 18:59

Does she think it's all from Santa so isn't worried about offending him? My personal opinion is that that is too long a list. She shouldn't be expecting all that stuff. My 7 year old got to ask for 2 things from Santa and two things from parents. Less scope for disappointment that way. We got her about 4 smaller things and she got things from relatives too. Does she get pocket money so she can save up for things herself. And I would suggest you practice gratitude as a family by regularly talking about what you are grateful for during family meals.

SomethingOriginal2 · 25/12/2022 18:52

Miss03852 · 25/12/2022 18:51

You have a very accurate username.

🤣🤣

SomethingOriginal2 · 25/12/2022 18:51

I think it depends on how she's saying it, is she stomping her feet and complaining. Or is she telling you about the feelings that she's struggling to process because you're her safe space and she needs your help to process it.

It's OK to feel disappointed . Both for you and her. Christmas expectations are always high. Next year try yo manage both or your expectations in the run up.

Miss03852 · 25/12/2022 18:51

Shitfather · 25/12/2022 14:54

And I agree with @Mariposista - give her gifts to a children’s charity so she learns the value of things. I don’t buy the “she’s only 7” and “overwhelmed” comments.

You have a very accurate username.

BeardyButton · 25/12/2022 18:46

Shitfather · 25/12/2022 14:54

And I agree with @Mariposista - give her gifts to a children’s charity so she learns the value of things. I don’t buy the “she’s only 7” and “overwhelmed” comments.

And we wonder why so many kids grow into emotionally damaged adults who go no contact with parents. There are so many threads on here about horrific childhoods. Giving a kids presents away like this would not teach gratitude. It would teach fear. It would teach distrust. It would teach that adults do hideous things and they get away with it because they are adults.

Burgoo · 25/12/2022 16:51

My partner is all about the presents. I am really not. I didn't get huge amounts of stuff as a child and I don't see the need for it for my child. You can get a few nice things without going overboard. That said, she has a very different background and I "get" it.

I love the gratitude comment by @TwoProngedFork . This needs to be built into everyday life. I often make my child stop, pause, notice what is lovely around her and to appreciate things she gets (be it food, presents, clothes etc). If it's a few times a year exercise it won't stick.

Burgoo · 25/12/2022 16:48

@bellac11 "This is what comes of teaching children a blanket 'be honest about your feelings' because they don't understand that actually its quite rude to just blurt out things like that."

^THIS!^

Firstly yes we want children and teenagers to express their feelings and at the same time I think we may need to rein it in a bit because expressing ALL feelings without a filter can get us all in a pickle!

@MarrymeKeanu

You could just tell her that if she isn't happy with them that you can take them back (or if she is still into Santa, that he can come collect them). Of course if she says "okay" then you have to follow through, no empty threats. But give her the chance to say "actually I do like them a bit". You want to make it aversive so she doesn't say this stuff again.

Alternatively you could ask how it may feel if she gave someone a thoughtful gift and they said they didn't like it. In that you teach children to mentalise (make sense of what they do and how others may interpret and respond internally).

Just a note: never let someone else make you feel like a failure. Especially your children. If you are doing your best then don't stoop to martyr syndrome, "oh woe is me, I am a failure". It isn't helpful.

My sister went well into her teenage years before she stopped saying "that's crap, why did you get me that?" So guess what? I stopped buying presents for her. We have a very good relationship nowadays and she is actually much more thoughtful when buying mine and taking hers from me too.

katepilar · 25/12/2022 16:37

YOu are not shit at choosing present, nor is she an ungrateful child.
You need to look into why she said those things. Sounds like something is bothering her about her life and she is just acting it out or perhaps mirroring your feelings. Thats what small children do.

OooScotland · 25/12/2022 16:32

@TwoProngedFork Thank you - I’m glad it came across as it was meant, and a Happpy Christmas to you too x

OooScotland · 25/12/2022 16:30

@TooManyPlatesInMotion Thank You x

autienotnaughty · 25/12/2022 16:29

I don't think she's ungrateful. She doesn't understand that you lovingly choose and pay for the gifts she thinks the all magical Santa does.

TwoProngedFork · 25/12/2022 16:26

OooScotland · 25/12/2022 15:01

No advice, just a random story from a Christmas past;

When I was that age in 1978 I got one present for Christmas (plus a few books from visiting relatives), so it was a big deal. I wanted the Fisher Price tree house. They were all the rage and my parents couldn’t get one so they got the Fisher Price doll house instead. I remember being very, very disappointed so I know I was quite sulky about it. It was a very large outlay for a working class family at the time of three day weeks and rolling blackouts so my Mum yelled her head off at me and went off to cry in the kitchen.

At 7 you’re just learning everything so it took me quite a few years to realise that my mum was upset because I had been ungrateful and that you don’t act like a brat to people who love you and buy you gifts.

What I remember about that day now that I’m 51 is once we’d all calmed down my Dad got down on the floor and played with that house with me until I loved it. It was my most treasured possession until I was far too old for it and it fell apart. My dad became ill the next year and died when I was 15 and I’m glad I have this memory of a wrong present, a lesson learned, and a demonstration of love. Merry Christmas OP.

What a moving post. Thank you for sharing this. Teaching/learning not to sweat the small stuff is so tough.

Have a lovely Christmas.