Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To donate my sperm or not?

113 replies

Ineedlegalhelp · 24/12/2022 19:04

My female friend, in her mid 40s, is asking me to help her conceive by sleeping with her without protection

i am 40 years old. Single. Unmarried. And without a child. All my choice
She is also single, unmarried, and without a child but desperately needs/wants one

Is there any way I can do this for my friend, and still protect myself from compulsorily having to pay child support?

I worry that I may be pursued for child support in the future. Although she is promising she won’t do that, I want to be sure, legally speaking, that I can protect myself and my finances

Any advice please

OP posts:
2bazookas · 24/12/2022 22:23

She can never make that promise because her circumstances (or the child's) might change. What if she dies or is disabled in a car accident?What if the child is needs 24-hour care for life ? What if the child , grown up, seeks your support at university; or claims inheritance rights from your estate .

The only reason she wants to be directly impregnated by you; is because at some very deep level she counts on your personal relationship, being able to trace and contact you, as the ultimate fail-safe backup for her and the child.

If she wanted absolute privacy, independence and no-strings uninvolvement, she'd go to a donor service .

ThisTimeNext · 24/12/2022 21:40

Another woman here saying don't do it. And of course she will ask you for money - she will, as others say, put her child first. If she's struggling, nursery fees take most of her money and she sees you enjoying holidays, a new car, a nice place to live she will become resentful, (quite rightly).

If you meet up for lunch or drinks or coffee as you presumably do now from time to time - and she says she can't afford the rent or a new coat or Christmas - or "your son" needs private speech therapy or a new car seat...- and you say "Sorry - that's not the deal".

And if you fall in love at forty five with someone younger, (as so many men do), and suddenly want a child of your own with her you'll have to explain. New GF may be uncomfortable with that. And if your friend sees that you do have a new baby who has everything her child doesn't - how's that going to play out?

And really could you see your child go without? And could you tell that child when he's ten or fifteen or twenty one that no, you didn't ever want to have anything to do with him, or her?

You don't need arguments you just need to say no. (Suggest a sperm bank if you think it would help)

whumpthereitis · 24/12/2022 21:15

Aside from all the other obvious issues, even if she promises now not to pursue child support, she could change her mind at any point.

don’t be a fool. Hard no.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 24/12/2022 21:07

Of course she can pursue you for child support, unless you both go to a solicitor and draw up a no obligation contract but the solicitor may well not contemplate it.

Just don't do it. The ramifications,particularly for the child would be enormous.

Tell her to get artificially inseminated at a clinic if she's that desperate.

Oh, and £2000 a month might sound ok to a single person but she'll struggle to afford childcare, so she'll be contacting you via CMS.

No! No! No!

whatwasIgoingtosay · 24/12/2022 20:53

Take the top ten good reasons from these posts and write them out as bullet points, then send the list to her, headed, 'here's why I can't/won't donate my sperm to you'

purpledalmation · 24/12/2022 20:53

You will be liable for child support, no matter what. All it takes is a change of mind and a dna test. Tell her get AID from a clinic

AngelinaFibres · 24/12/2022 20:46

SirVixofVixHall · 24/12/2022 20:37

The risks are higher for some chromosomal abnormalities, yes, but it is not “very likely that the child will have issues”. I had my children in my forties, as did several of my friends, and none of us have children with any congenital problems. My consultant at the time told me that problems were uncommon.
Until the advent of the pill many women had a last baby in their forties, and it certainly was not the case that most of those children had health problems problems. My great grandfather, his uncles, his great aunts, all were born to women well over forty.

But anyway OP. Of course this is a bad idea, unless you also want a baby and will co-parent.

You are correct but this child will not be born to 2x parents who are committed,as a team, to enjoy the absence of issues or to support if there are issues. The Op will serve his purpose, then expect to leave. His friend has no idea what is coming and older father's have a higher risk of having autistic children.

AngelinaFibres · 24/12/2022 20:42

It's very easy, when you don't have children, and never saw yourself having any, to think that it's just a baby. You did your bit and that's it. But it's not. That child will look like you ,have characteristics that come from you, have health issues that come from your side of the family. That child will want to know, as they grow, where they came from, why they look like they do, why they have hair that's not like their mother, eyes that are different. Who was my dad, why don't I see my dad, where are my grandparents etc etc. Once that child is on its way you are tied forever whether you like it or not.

SirVixofVixHall · 24/12/2022 20:37

AngelinaFibres · 24/12/2022 19:51

This. In the unlikely event that this actually works your advanced ages make it very likely that the child will have issues. There are so many women on here who work PT or not at a because their child has significant problems. What is she going to live on if that is the case.

The risks are higher for some chromosomal abnormalities, yes, but it is not “very likely that the child will have issues”. I had my children in my forties, as did several of my friends, and none of us have children with any congenital problems. My consultant at the time told me that problems were uncommon.
Until the advent of the pill many women had a last baby in their forties, and it certainly was not the case that most of those children had health problems problems. My great grandfather, his uncles, his great aunts, all were born to women well over forty.

But anyway OP. Of course this is a bad idea, unless you also want a baby and will co-parent.

vodkaredbullgirl · 24/12/2022 20:35
Hmm
Lemontree23 · 24/12/2022 20:26

notsorich · 24/12/2022 20:13

I don't think you can be sure there is no financial come back.

She's not planning on asking you for anything right now. She's on good money right now. But, as has been pointed out, there's no guarantee she'll have a straightforward pregnancy or birth, and her child may require so much care that she decides to jack in work.

Once she has her baby, she'll always put her baby first - and that includes ahead of any promises she's made to you. It's not personal. If she has a vastly reduced income and is struggling, of course she'll pursue you for child support. She'll do what's best for her child and that means acquiring funds in any legal way possible.

If you remain in her life, it's going to get complicated being mummy's friend, but not daddy. If you don't stay in her life, it's going to be weird getting your head around knowing about a child with your genes and not being in that child's life.

Let's face it, if you wanted to help someone make a baby, you'd have donated to a sperm bank ages ago, and all parties involved would have had clear boundaries emotionally and financially. You wouldn't have considered this had your friend not asked.

The only reason to not use a sperm bank is cost, and if she's struggling with money now, she'll struggle even more when she has a baby. Which circles back to coming after you for support.

It's a bad, bad idea. Be there for her on her fertility journey, but don't sleep with her or donate your sperm in any other way.

This. Come on op it's a no brainer really

AngelinaFibres · 24/12/2022 20:24

My son has just had a son. The child is the absolute spitting image of him. How are you going to feel when you see your child and they look just like you. Do you have parents ? I would feel very sad knowing that a child who was my grandchild, my flesh and blood, was out and about in the world and I either hadn't known about it or knew but wasn't allowed anything to do with that child. How would your friend feel if members of your family wanted a relationship.

notsorich · 24/12/2022 20:13

I don't think you can be sure there is no financial come back.

She's not planning on asking you for anything right now. She's on good money right now. But, as has been pointed out, there's no guarantee she'll have a straightforward pregnancy or birth, and her child may require so much care that she decides to jack in work.

Once she has her baby, she'll always put her baby first - and that includes ahead of any promises she's made to you. It's not personal. If she has a vastly reduced income and is struggling, of course she'll pursue you for child support. She'll do what's best for her child and that means acquiring funds in any legal way possible.

If you remain in her life, it's going to get complicated being mummy's friend, but not daddy. If you don't stay in her life, it's going to be weird getting your head around knowing about a child with your genes and not being in that child's life.

Let's face it, if you wanted to help someone make a baby, you'd have donated to a sperm bank ages ago, and all parties involved would have had clear boundaries emotionally and financially. You wouldn't have considered this had your friend not asked.

The only reason to not use a sperm bank is cost, and if she's struggling with money now, she'll struggle even more when she has a baby. Which circles back to coming after you for support.

It's a bad, bad idea. Be there for her on her fertility journey, but don't sleep with her or donate your sperm in any other way.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 24/12/2022 20:12

What happens if she suddenly dies or gets ill, you could raising achild you never wanted?

It's a ridiculous idea.

Wanderingoff · 24/12/2022 20:11

You literally don’t need any good points to make to justify not wanting to impregnate someone!!!!!

just say no. And you’re not open to discussing it any more

Ineedlegalhelp · 24/12/2022 20:08

magicofthefae · 24/12/2022 20:04

It's so ridiculous it sounds made up to me.

But if it's not.....
OP think critically....if all she wanted was your sperm...and genuinely nothing more than that....why not go to a sperm bank, or find a regular f buddy guy (whose genetics/background she knows a tiny little bit), and use f buddy for their sperm without them knowing she's not on the pill and then ghost f buddy when she's pregnant and has no use of f buddy anymore?

I don't think she's being open and honest about how much she wants from you. If it genuinely was just your sperm...she can easily find that from fertility clinics/sperm banks. If she was concerned about using a random sperm diner whose genetics she doesn't know, she could find a f buddy, get to know them a little bit and use them.

I think she wants more...for you to pay or co-parent, even if she says she won't. When she's paying sky high nursery fees, is sleep deprived and knackered....she'll be begging for help, and that's assuming she has a non disability child.

You will 100% regret this in every way possible of you go ahead.

Also, no child deserves to grow up in an environment where they were conceived intentionally, fully knowing the child would be fatherless; the child feeling unwanted and unloved by their biological father. It's truly selfish of your friend.

Encourage her to find romance, if she does, then she can go down routes of IVF, egg doner, adoption or fostering...if she 'NEEDS' a child. There are plenty of existing children requiring loving homes.

Thanks a lot for your advice. It really means a lot. I have said similar to her, and she basically tried to emotionally blackmail me. To guilt trip me. I stood my ground though, while being as empathic as I could be. I have picked some good points here that I will use next time we speak

OP posts:
OneTC · 24/12/2022 20:07

The thing is your worried about someone cursing their commitment and coming after you BUT that you even consider it a possibility says you don't know this person well enough to enter into this kind of arrangement.*

*No-one does btw, cos it's stupid. You're not donating your sperm you are fucking someone with the intention of making a baby. They couldn't be more different

Ijuststoodonlego · 24/12/2022 20:04

AngelinaFibres · 24/12/2022 19:45

Ruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuun.

Sprint more like it 😂

magicofthefae · 24/12/2022 20:04

It's so ridiculous it sounds made up to me.

But if it's not.....
OP think critically....if all she wanted was your sperm...and genuinely nothing more than that....why not go to a sperm bank, or find a regular f buddy guy (whose genetics/background she knows a tiny little bit), and use f buddy for their sperm without them knowing she's not on the pill and then ghost f buddy when she's pregnant and has no use of f buddy anymore?

I don't think she's being open and honest about how much she wants from you. If it genuinely was just your sperm...she can easily find that from fertility clinics/sperm banks. If she was concerned about using a random sperm diner whose genetics she doesn't know, she could find a f buddy, get to know them a little bit and use them.

I think she wants more...for you to pay or co-parent, even if she says she won't. When she's paying sky high nursery fees, is sleep deprived and knackered....she'll be begging for help, and that's assuming she has a non disability child.

You will 100% regret this in every way possible of you go ahead.

Also, no child deserves to grow up in an environment where they were conceived intentionally, fully knowing the child would be fatherless; the child feeling unwanted and unloved by their biological father. It's truly selfish of your friend.

Encourage her to find romance, if she does, then she can go down routes of IVF, egg doner, adoption or fostering...if she 'NEEDS' a child. There are plenty of existing children requiring loving homes.

BoreOfWhabylon · 24/12/2022 19:57

Were you planning to continue seeing her as a friend? If so, you would be having contact with the child. All sorts of potential complications for all concerned. Not least the child.

girlmom21 · 24/12/2022 19:56

It's a crazy idea, OP. Don't do it.

Ineedlegalhelp · 24/12/2022 19:54

AngelinaFibres · 24/12/2022 19:51

This. In the unlikely event that this actually works your advanced ages make it very likely that the child will have issues. There are so many women on here who work PT or not at a because their child has significant problems. What is she going to live on if that is the case.

Thanks

OP posts:
Bargoed · 24/12/2022 19:54

Honestly I wouldn't her IQ canny be that great to pick someone who is as clueless you by 40.

AngelinaFibres · 24/12/2022 19:51

bakewellbride · 24/12/2022 19:05

Don't do it. Mid-forties is probably too late anyway and full of health risks.

This. In the unlikely event that this actually works your advanced ages make it very likely that the child will have issues. There are so many women on here who work PT or not at a because their child has significant problems. What is she going to live on if that is the case.

Survey99 · 24/12/2022 19:46

Ineedlegalhelp · 24/12/2022 19:36

She earns ok. She earns about 2k a month. Her finances for now are ok. The issue is not her finances. Even very rich women often, I believe, demand financial support from the father of their kids. And when the child is small, her finances will surely suffer.

Her current financial situation is not my problem. My problem is can she, legally speaking, force me to pay child support

To keep earning £2k a month it is likely she'll need to pay say £1k in childcare. Or maybe change her job to one that pays less to care for the child you created.

Again, who do you suggest helps support the child you created?