Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When did it become so hard to give things away ?

131 replies

BethJ62 · 24/12/2022 11:39

Having a clear out including lots of baby stuff that DGC have outgrown and DD doesn’t want . Moses basket , clothes , toys.
As money is tight for many people I decided to give it away using a local Facebook site .
Simple ? No.
Despite me asking people to collect , every person who has shown interest has asked me to deliver . A couple of people have become a bit stroppy when I said collect only . Reminder - this is good quality free stuff.
Yesterday I waited in all day for someone who didn’t appear . Today someone who said she was desperate said she would be here at 10. I told her we are going out at 12 so she has to be here before then . 10 minutes ago she messaged and said she would be here at 2 !!! I reminded her the arrangement and she said she thinks I could be a bit more understanding!
Has anyone else experienced similar ? I don’t think I am unreasonable but maybe I am ??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fleura · 26/12/2022 17:24

We moved house recently and got rid of lots of old furniture - used but in good condition. I was really keen to try and pass them on so found a company online that collect items and give them to families in need. They had excellent reviews and are regularly contacted by charities such as Crisis and Shelter to supply furniture.

Got in touch, was asked to supply photos of all the items, did so apologising in the process as it had taken me a week or so to get everything together. Lots of friendly emails back and forth with the office and then complete silence once the photos had gone over.

Needless to say, after chasing them up, they offered to pick up only a couple of things - no problem, the rest either wasn’t in the condition they wanted or didn’t have the relevant fire certificate/instructions etc, very frustrating but not their fault. Then they told me they were fully booked for the next few weeks and could either pick up first thing the following morning - bearing in mind they were emailing late afternoon - or it would be a few weeks after our move date 🤷‍♀️. I’d specifically told them in my first email when we were moving and the days they could collect aswell as stressing to let me know if the dates didn’t work as I didn’t want to waste my time or theirs. It was incredibly frustrating.

In the end, the whole lot got taken by a house clearance firm to the dump as I just didn’t have the time to go through the process again with someone else or try and sell it privately.

Hamster1111 · 26/12/2022 17:03

Facebook marketplace is notoriously full of time wasters. Take it to the charity shop in the new year. At least you can be rid of it at a time that suits you!

DrNo007 · 26/12/2022 17:03

I use freecycle and while I used to get the odd time waster who didn’t turn up, I haven’t experienced that problem since moving to the southeast a few years back.

Doris86 · 26/12/2022 17:00

123woop · 25/12/2022 06:52

Yes. My friend had a load of baby stuff which she put on marketplace in covid times and said she'd like it to go for free to a family who was struggling etc (it was all very very nice expensive stuff). A woman messaged with all of this "oh I would love this, my life has been so tough, I don't know where to turn now I'm pregnant etc etc". Her and a man turned up in a hire van and took the lot and within 24 hours it was all on Facebook marketplace again but being sold for many many ££££. She's since kept an eye on them and their business is collecting free stuff from places and then selling it on!

That is why you should never use FB to give away stuff of any value. There will always be someone lurking ready to pick it up and resell at full value.

Always sell at full value, or if you want it go to a good cause give it to a charity shop or baby bank etc.

ghostofadog · 26/12/2022 11:27

I agree OP, it seems so odd when everyone is apparently struggling so much financially and yet you can't give perfectly good stuff away for free. Charity shops often won't take stuff because they're full. But when you go in and look at the stuff they're asking £5 for some old bobbly top from Primark so of course they're not going to sell that. Why don't they sell stuff for 50p or a pound then they would help people that needed it and have a really fast turnover, and probably make more money.

SalYPimienta · 26/12/2022 10:14

This is why I no longer give things anyway. The sense of entitlement is just beyond belief. The last straw for me was when someone I had told needed to collect before 12 texted at 12 to tell me she was still an hour away and was travelling from the south coast - i had put the item on a local group precisely to avoid that kind of shit. She then had the audacity to get abusive and angry with me for not cancelling my plans to stay in and wait for her so I could give her a free 40 inch television.

I honestly find it depressing how entitled so many people are. It's grim.

WGACA · 26/12/2022 10:07

Baby banks are best to donate good quality baby stuff, especially the bigger items. Olio is good too.

BatFaceGirl · 26/12/2022 10:03

MorrisZapp · 24/12/2022 14:56

How do you find this information? I wouldn't know where my local womens refuge was.

Just Google women’s refuge and your area. You’ll probably get an email contact, a PO Box address, and possibly a phone number. There might not be a phone number though, and there definitely won’t be a street address due to confidentiality/safety.

The one I contacted was really happy to come collect the stuff but might not be the case everywhere - and I had a lot of stuff!

123woop · 25/12/2022 06:52

Yes. My friend had a load of baby stuff which she put on marketplace in covid times and said she'd like it to go for free to a family who was struggling etc (it was all very very nice expensive stuff). A woman messaged with all of this "oh I would love this, my life has been so tough, I don't know where to turn now I'm pregnant etc etc". Her and a man turned up in a hire van and took the lot and within 24 hours it was all on Facebook marketplace again but being sold for many many ££££. She's since kept an eye on them and their business is collecting free stuff from places and then selling it on!

Literaturemakeslifebetter · 25/12/2022 05:59

Just to counter balance this I sold a bunch of my daughter's American Girl Dolls and accessories for 250 quid to a lady off FB yesterday- met her, she was on time, she turned up in her porsche at my local library, older lady cash in hand, I was so sure she would be a no show when she texted, I am the grandma in the porshe, I thought yeah right.Such a good experience via FB marketplace. I agree charge a low price, people respect a deal more than a freebie somehow.

candlesinthesnow · 25/12/2022 04:05

willstarttomorrow · 24/12/2022 23:20

@candlesinthesnow ours is desperate for donations. I live in a big northern city, lots of wealth and also lots of poverty. I am also a Social Worker and we cannot get any section 17 money approved without looking to charities etc first as the council budget has been decimated.

So interesting! I’m in the south and it’s the opposite, it’s very hard to donate smaller things like toys and clothes. Buggies, stair gates etc are a bit easier, but only in perfect condition and still with instructions.

They seem to prefer monetary donations overall which is understandable as I guess that is more efficient. Last time I tried to donate clothes I didn’t get anywhere with baby banks (or charity shops) so I ended up selling them on Vinted instead and donating the profits!

willstarttomorrow · 24/12/2022 23:20

@candlesinthesnow ours is desperate for donations. I live in a big northern city, lots of wealth and also lots of poverty. I am also a Social Worker and we cannot get any section 17 money approved without looking to charities etc first as the council budget has been decimated.

BethJ62 · 24/12/2022 20:07

Thanks for further suggestions however I updated to say the stuff had been collected and I have since had a complaint that one of the toys needs a battery !
I was telling some friends about it today and one reminded me about her experience with free stuff . She is a keen reader and usually donates books afterwards to charity shops . During lockdown they were closed so she got a box , placed loads of books inside with a sign saying help yourself and left it on her garden wall .
A woman appeared at her door clutching about 6 books , not to say thank you but to ask if she had any Ian Rankin . When told no , she was very disappointed and asked her to check again !

OP posts:
candlesinthesnow · 24/12/2022 19:42

willstarttomorrow · 24/12/2022 19:09

Do you have a local baby bank? They would be happy to have it but not sure if they collect.

I think this is area dependant as it’s difficult to donate to the baby banks in our area, they seem to get too much stuff. Especially clothes.

willstarttomorrow · 24/12/2022 19:09

Do you have a local baby bank? They would be happy to have it but not sure if they collect.

poefaced · 24/12/2022 19:02

Same, had over a 100 messages about the free TV I was giving away. Took several attempts before it was collected.

Would be easier to take it all to my local dump, which is clean and well organised, but I hate throwing stuff away.

Boating123 · 24/12/2022 18:45

People on Freecycle seem far better than people on Facebook.
If it is something lots of people want I either go for the second person who asks or the one with a bit of a story.
The first person, may be the fastest, but is often more likely to mess me around so I tend to avoid the first person.

Figgypudding123 · 24/12/2022 18:41

FB marketplace is a nightmare. I don't touch it with a ten foot pole after trying to sell an almost new washing machine for £40. 5 people didn't show up and 1 person offered me a fiver. Cheeky fucker! Told him to do one and gave it to Emmaus for free. (Rather give stuff away to good causes for free than be taken for a mug by some twat who was clearly going to resell on EBay the moment he got it home.)

candlesinthesnow · 24/12/2022 17:29

lynthesearesexpeople · 24/12/2022 15:06

I did have one memorable occasion where I was giving away some Barbie stuff midway though December, a big item so I said collection only.

Someone messaged me that it would make their dds Christmas as they had no money. They then asked where I lived. She then said it was too far and could I deliver - 70 miles away. No. Then they asked if I would pay for a courier. Also no.

I was then bombarded with messages saying her daughter was distraught, I had ruined a little girls Christmas. I woke up to about 50 in a row getting more and more angry and abusive. I blocked her and the admins got involved when she said she was seeing someone to come and “sort me out” (couldn’t she have sent them to pick up the Barbie House then?!)

It was absolutely mental.

My god this is awful! Did she have your exact address??

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 24/12/2022 17:17

Sally Army are my go to for donations of baby stuff/clothes. Had tons when we moved. I went to the Sally Army shop to see if they wanted them as they didn't seem to have much in the shop..Yes please they said. We tend to give them directly to families that need them rather than sell them.

Winterfellismyhome · 24/12/2022 17:12

Olio all the way. You get banned if you mess people about

closingscore · 24/12/2022 17:00

Switch to the olio app, you get a better standard of recycler!

BethJ62 · 24/12/2022 16:53

My listing clearly stated collection only . I really don’t think that’s unreasonable.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 24/12/2022 16:37

Notconfident · 24/12/2022 16:25

I'm on the fence with it purely because I can't collect or deliver as I can't drive for health reasons. So I know how frustrating it is when you're asked to deliver, but also know how frustrating it is to miss out on quite a bit (generally things I genuinely need as well as I'm still furnishing my home) because I can't collect or have someone collect for me.

That's fair enough, but a lot of people ask if you deliver when the listing clearly says "collection only".

Also, fair enough for people who actually live in the centre of town or locally to the seller, where it's likely people will be passing and "could" drop off smaller items, but we've had it where people have expected us to drive for miles to drop something off for a fiver (literally miles, as in an hour away where the petrol alone would cost more than they were paying, not to mention half a day lost of our time!).

Notconfident · 24/12/2022 16:25

I'm on the fence with it purely because I can't collect or deliver as I can't drive for health reasons. So I know how frustrating it is when you're asked to deliver, but also know how frustrating it is to miss out on quite a bit (generally things I genuinely need as well as I'm still furnishing my home) because I can't collect or have someone collect for me.