Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To dump a friend - and how?

117 replies

Mrcpy · 24/12/2022 08:16

I have a friend who lives locally. We met 7-8 years ago at baby groups while I was on mat leave. I didn’t have much in my life at the time as OH had a busy job and I was looking after 3 kids so we liked chatting about family stuff.

Gradually my life has changed. I went back to a job which I’m obsessed with. Paradoxically OH got less busy, so we spend more time together. Kids are older. I started exercising, lost weight, enjoy a few hobbies, and work quite hard. Life is interesting and it’s hard to fit in everything I want to do.

This friend is still a SAHM and when we meet we just chat about husbands and kids. When I bring up other topics (generic things like news, music, tv) she just smiles and says “oh wow, you do so much” and doesn’t seem too interested. I find our meet-ups quite boring and I’d rather play tennis than sit in a cafe tbh.

I’ve tried to gently drop the friendship, but she still texts me regularly asking to meet up. I’ve pleaded being busy with work. Don’t feel sorry for her - she’s much more sociable than me. Rather I think she feels sorry for me - she thinks I’m an introvert (true) and desperately lonely (false).

She wanted to meet and exchange Christmas presents last week. I replied that I’m feeling run down and haven’t been organised with presents so please don’t give me anything. I didn’t say she could come round. But she came round and gave me a present anyway. I was mortified. Today I’ll need to go and buy a present for her. We haven’t seen each other for months so I didn’t think we’d do presents this year.

Anyway, I know I’m not a very nice person but I’d appreciate pointers on how to go forward.

YABU: stop being so selfish. Make time for your friend.

YANBU: break it off definitively (how?)

OP posts:
Ireolu · 24/12/2022 10:24

Mean post OP. Your friend sounds like a nice person who clearly still values you. I don't have a single friend that goes out of their way to give me a Christmas or birthday present. I dont do it either so its not a problem.

Let's hope you are not on the receiving end of being actively dumped by a friend anytime soon. Don't go back looking to be friends if Life for ukh gets boring again!

thelobsterquadrille · 24/12/2022 10:23

thewinterwitch · 24/12/2022 10:11

So... You're allowed to dump a bloke you've dated after you realise you have little in common and he bores you, but you're not allowed to realise your life situation has changed and you no longer have anything in common with a casual friend who bores you, yet pities you because you are an introvert?

Of course you can move on the friendship.

But you can do so without being unpleasant about it and looking down on the person 🤷🏻‍♀️

thelobsterquadrille · 24/12/2022 10:21

@Thepeopleversuswork - yes, as I've said multiple times, of course friendships end and I don't think OP should feel obligated to this woman by any means.

But the way she wrote the OP - it just seemed so sneery and like she felt the friendship was beneath her now. It's just not necessary to be like that about someone who actually hasn't done anything wrong.

I would probably be quite hurt if I thought my old friends felt like that about me. Yes, we're not close anymore but at least they have the decency to be respectful and don't look down on me because we no longer share the same interests 🤷🏻‍♀️

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/12/2022 10:17

@thelobsterquadrille

OP was quite happy to be friends with this lady when it suited, but now can't be arsed as she's decided she has better things to do with her free time than sit and have a coffee occasionally.

But that’s life, no?

This happens all the time. People are “friends” because they work together or because they share a hobby or their partners are friends. When the factors that link them dissolve the friendship also breaks down.

I don’t see why anyone should feel obligated to remain friends with someone out of duty when the friendship is no longer life enhancing. It sounds as if this woman has no interest whatsoever in the world beyond her immediate horizon. Frankly people like this are quite soul destroying and I wouldn’t want to prioritise this sort of friendship over something much more life affirming like exercising or something which expands your horizons.

I don’t think the OP should be cruel to her but I think it’s entirely reasonable for her to decide this isn’t where her time is best invested.

I also can’t help noticing it’s usually women who are expected to devote their time to “dead” friendships out of a sense of duty because no one thinks their spiritual or intellectual fulfilment or increasing their happiness is important. When did you last hear of a man taken to task for avoiding someone he hung out with out of expediency and now considers dull.

Women are constantly expected to play nice and tolerate dull people because that’s what women do. It’s bullshit.

2bazookas · 24/12/2022 10:15

DO NOT buy her a present.

Stop being a pushover.

IncessantNameChanger · 24/12/2022 10:12

If you only met once this year I'm not sure why she still sees you as a friend. I don't like being phased out or ghosted. I think it's cruel. Just either tell her ( preferable) or ignore her completely so she gets the picture. One of my friends did this to me, phased me out. Then years later her husband died. I keep wondering how she is but have to sit on my hands and remind myself she very likely can't stand me.

thewinterwitch · 24/12/2022 10:11

So... You're allowed to dump a bloke you've dated after you realise you have little in common and he bores you, but you're not allowed to realise your life situation has changed and you no longer have anything in common with a casual friend who bores you, yet pities you because you are an introvert?

thelobsterquadrille · 24/12/2022 10:05

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/12/2022 10:00

This lady was good enough to spend time with when OP's partner was busy and she was a SAHM - but now she has a job and her partner is around more, she's dumping her because can't be arsed to spend a few hours having coffee occasionally.

But let’s be honest here… loads of “mum friendships” are like this. A lot of them are friendships of expediency not real bonds.

The OP sounds much more driven and dynamic than the other woman who sounds as if she has not really experienced any kind of growth as a person since having children. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with knowing what someone’s limitations are and accepting that there are parts of your life they will never fulfill. A friendship is not a marriage.

I don’t see that it’s necessary to “dump” this person. I think it’s a slow fade (which the OP has done already). But I don’t see why wanting to choose friends who align with where you are in your life makes you “vile”.

Like I said - there's nothing wrong with not wanting to continue a friendship, but there's no need to look down upon the other person when they've actually done nothing wrong.

OP was quite happy to be friends with this lady when it suited, but now can't be arsed as she's decided she has better things to do with her free time than sit and have a coffee occasionally.

Yes, lots of friendships are circumstantial but that doesn't mean you have to be so disparaging about a person you clearly liked and cared about at some point - especially when there hasn't actually been a fight or a disagreement.

dustofneptune · 24/12/2022 10:04

Personally I just think friendships ebb and flow, and I feel like they're usually contextual. All friendships revolve around an anchor point - working together, Thursday night after-work drinks, kid/dog playdates, shared hobby, etc. I don't think you're a bad person at all. I also don't think you're a user!

You were in similar circumstances when you became friends, and circumstances have changed, which leaves you with much less in common. You also get this sense that your friend sees you as this kind of stressy, work-obsessed introvert who needs a social life, so she takes pity on you. That feeling doesn't come from nowhere. I can actually relate, because I've had friends like this - they'll make comments like "when do I get to drag you out?" / "Are you dead?" etc.

I just think you're incompatible as friends now, from the sound of it. So the only way forward, if you don't want to continue the friendship, is to explain to her gently that you feel you're on different pages now, or to do the slow fade - never meet up, and take weeks to reply to texts. It's up to you which one you choose to go with.

03X · 24/12/2022 10:03

Friendships come and go in my experience, normal in life. I am a bit of a crap friend though! But I’ve fizzled out a few and had a few fizzle me out. No hard feelings, it’s life!

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/12/2022 10:00

This lady was good enough to spend time with when OP's partner was busy and she was a SAHM - but now she has a job and her partner is around more, she's dumping her because can't be arsed to spend a few hours having coffee occasionally.

But let’s be honest here… loads of “mum friendships” are like this. A lot of them are friendships of expediency not real bonds.

The OP sounds much more driven and dynamic than the other woman who sounds as if she has not really experienced any kind of growth as a person since having children. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with knowing what someone’s limitations are and accepting that there are parts of your life they will never fulfill. A friendship is not a marriage.

I don’t see that it’s necessary to “dump” this person. I think it’s a slow fade (which the OP has done already). But I don’t see why wanting to choose friends who align with where you are in your life makes you “vile”.

MyBooksAndMyCats · 24/12/2022 09:52

Ahhh so when you was bored you basically used her but now your busy and happy in life you don't want to be friends?

You sound awesome. Hmm

insufferableknowitall · 24/12/2022 09:50

Ah so you used her when your life was boring and you had nothing much else to do… you sound lovely.

LadyKenya · 24/12/2022 09:49

Holly60 · 24/12/2022 08:36

You do seem to view this friendship through the lens of how it suits you only.

Is there not value in it simply because she seems to value it?

You say she is a lovely person and she likes you. That to me is immensely valuable.

But if you really don't value the friendship then yes don't string her along - she sounds too nice for that. Be blunt - I'm too busy to meet up at the moment. And repeat.

I hope there doesn't come a time in your future where you wish you still had her support though

Good post. Decent people are not that easy to find imo. There are lots of takers out there.

thewinterwitch · 24/12/2022 09:48

Mrcpy · 24/12/2022 09:44

Well this has been a reality check

I'd say disregard the insane nastiness and listen to the more moderate and sensitive responses only. The only reality check I'd take from this thread would be not to post this sort of thing in AIBU.

Mrcpy · 24/12/2022 09:44

Well this has been a reality check

OP posts:
Ursuladevine · 24/12/2022 09:40

PonyPatter44 · 24/12/2022 09:38

Possibly outing myself as an exercise-swerver, but who plays tennis in December?

Loads of people

I went for a run this morning and loads out

it’s 11 degrees and beautiful

PonyPatter44 · 24/12/2022 09:38

Possibly outing myself as an exercise-swerver, but who plays tennis in December?

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 09:30

@Mrcpy

On a side note, I am really interested how the topic is all about you OP. At no point did you consider how this may impact her. You may be one of the few people she sees, she may have limited contact with other people and you seeing her even once or twice a year may be the only non-family time she gets.

You also don't consider that if you are having this wonderfully exciting life that she may not be interested - why would someone who has to look after the kids all day want to talk about your life and things you are doing? I suspect that would feel miserable for her.

Why haven't you asked her to do something a bit more interesting than just a coffee shop? You could go to the cinema, a zoo, a museum, shopping, any number of things that would allow you to just be with her. I think this is your problem. You can't just be with her, you have to have something to do or talk about. Maybe working on being with and appreciating someone's company may be a better use of your time.

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 09:25

Ease your way out of the situation.

If it doesn't work just tell her that you feel you have different interests now and don't feel that you enjoy the time with her as you used to. Tell her why you feel this way and give her a chance to change her behaviour (e.g. bring up interesting topics, not bang on about the kids and husband etc). If she continues then just say you'd prefer to have some space.

I'm not a fan of fragilising people. If you don't like or want to be around someone, I'd just tell them. All this "you are mean" is so schoolyard, if you respect her enough you will just tell her. I'd want someone to tell me!

zen1 · 24/12/2022 09:25

You want to end a friendship with someone you’ve seen once this year? Was seeing her the once too much? She is nice and not annoying (by your own admission), so how is seeing her once a year difficult? It’s not like she is really demanding of your time or anything. From your OP, it sounds as though you feel she is now beneath you and not worthy of your friendship as you lead a more interesting life.

Stressedmum2017 · 24/12/2022 09:24

Omg yes dump her for her sake and also try and get over yourself. You sound like you think you are the absolute shit compared to her 😂 honestly the tennis bit was super cringe.

Elsanore · 24/12/2022 09:21

I've broken off three friendships over the course of my life and it was not pleasant to have to do and upsetting each time. I'll briefly summarise what I learned and maybe you can do better than me.

Friend 1. Seriously let me down during a time when I was in a lot of distress, having been a very selfish friend all along. She fell out with me due to a perceived slight, and I chose not to make up and rekindle. This was the easiest.

Friend 2. Became closer than I wanted when we lived in same city after being peripheral acquaintances at uni. Briefly housemates at one point as we were both skint and needed to survive at the time. I was always uneasy with her, she was something of a bully and a user. Later when no longer housemates she didn't turn up to an occasion very important to me due to a last min better offer and I decided to cut my losses, and did what would now be called ghosting. Very awkward. She contacted me to ask if I was dead.

Friend 3. Became close quickly due to being thrown together in a life situation. She was horrifyingly bitchy and said the most awful things about all her other friends to me, it was so obvious I was getting the same treatment behind my back. Also I felt I was being mined for info to be later discussed with others. I attempted to fade out, its become a bit of a challenge to her and she's trying to not allow me to fade. Very very awkward.

Billslills · 24/12/2022 09:18

Ursuladevine · 24/12/2022 09:14

To start a thread about someone you met ONCE I. 2022

my mind boggles

**On Christmas Eve too.

Dibbydoos · 24/12/2022 09:18

I personally like coffee catch ups...Sad you don't find her conversation interesting anymore, but equally she doesn't find yours interesting either!Why not invite her to one of your other social things. She might like tennis - you never know.

Swipe left for the next trending thread