Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being told my toddler "rules the roost"

119 replies

hasitreallybeenthatlong · 24/12/2022 04:36

Recently separated from Ex and living back with parents who are very old school and my DS2. It's incredible awful time of year to be doing this and I'm dealing with a break up but last night after DS went to bed my parents decided to talk to me about parenting and how my son rules the roost, how I need to be more in control and not give in, examples used are when I feed him I'm giving him too big a portion ( fussy eater but aren't they all at 2) and I need to stick it out so if he doesn't eat dinner he doesn't get a yoghurt and how I need to be the leader and not let DS dominate and how he is a handful. I'm just trying so hard I'm in a situation I don't want to be in ( living back with parents and financially not able to leave any time soon) I just said right now I'm just trying to keep my head above water with being ok, looking after my son and making sure he is as happy as can be after this big change. It just made me feel shit! On top of a failed relationship I have huge mum guilt and now this!

OP posts:
qpmz · 24/12/2022 09:28

Christmaslover2022 · 24/12/2022 05:53

I never said you force feed them. If you put crap on their plate they will eat it. Kids that only eat chicken nuggets were given them by their parents! If they are hungry, they will eat the healthy food. No drama, just healthy stuff there at every meal. Interesting you seem to assume I condone force feeding a child??

Who said anything about nuggets or other junk food? If you put a plate of fruit and veg in front on a 2 year old, they may or may not touch a thing!

museumum · 24/12/2022 09:27

Your parents have likely forgotten what two year olds are like.

But please don’t think that letting him break boundaries will in some way compensate for the situation with his dad. The kindest thing to do now for him is to keep boundaries and routine. Even if he pushes back, it’s kindest in the long run to firmly but kindly maintain boundaries.

good luck.

qpmz · 24/12/2022 09:25

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 24/12/2022 05:48

In our house fruit and veg is not a choice the child is 2, short of ramming food down their throats how do you make a 2yr old eat what you give them?

That's what I thought!

HowSadSteps · 24/12/2022 09:20

No one here can say whether your child’s behaviour is in fact difficult.

It is however highly probable that your parents are:

a) finding the new living arrangements difficult
b) can’t remember what living with a two year old is like, and
c)are old school parents.

Whilst you are living with them, for the sake of domestic harmony can you listen to (but not necessarily act upon) their concerns?

Longer term it would be best to move out when you can afford it. Can you put your name on a housing list, seek financial support from your ex, apply for any relevant benefit?

Beseen22 · 24/12/2022 09:20

My parents have completely unrealistic behaviour ideals for children. They constantly say how well behaved my youngest is, he's not well behaved...he's severely speech delayed and therefore quiet. They constantly say how terrible a friends kids are when they are at church...which 2 yo would cope sitting silently for 3 hours at church??!

SmileWithADimple · 24/12/2022 09:18

I agree with @Dolphinnoises

"I think parents who were very strict find it extremely challenging to witness it being done another way by their own children." I think this may be the root of the problem.

Hang in there OP. Sounds like you're doing fine.

JennyForeigner · 24/12/2022 09:11

We have a 3 year old and two coming up to two. Surviving the day is impressive, the rate they can pincer food off a tray and onto the floor is painful, the bossiness is extreme. It has to be! This is how they learn their boundaries right?

It's not helpful to sit you down for a come to Jesus OP, and if you'd burst into tears and said 'I'm doing my best' I bet your parents would have been horrified. Just keep on keeping on, get out as quickly as you can, don't get comfortable and build up resentment for the future. You need to reset into your own life when you can.

Theluggage15 · 24/12/2022 09:06

You say you won’t be moving out any time soon due to financial reasons, this is a huge upheaval for your parents as well as you. The PPs saying they should mind their own business, your child, your way, ignore their comments, are being ridiculous.
It’s their house and their lives so they have every right to say something. It sounds like they said it calmly so you need to carry on the discussion in the same vein.

Dibbydoos · 24/12/2022 09:05

Do you think they're right? That's the most important thing here. If you do, then take heed, if not them ask them politely to leave you to manage your child.
All 2yo are hard fulls, I would ignore that comment. There is a school of thought that allowing kids to do what they like gives them independence early and they make better choices because of it.

Cuppasoupmonster · 24/12/2022 08:55

Suggest they take DS for a day or two and model the parenting they want you to do. No doubt they will return him a delightful, compliant and well behaved toddler 😉

Newmum0322 · 24/12/2022 08:47

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/12/2022 06:31

Can't see any mention of chicken nuggets in the OP. Not sure your response is very helpful seeing as it's based on a load of made up details.

Also you are completely wrong about what constitutes a healthy diet for a 2 year old. Fruit and veg is fine in moderation but they need carbs, protein and fat primarily.

I was literally thinking exactly the same!

Gingernan · 24/12/2022 08:45

2 of my kids have 'returned' one with partner and baby for 2 years.
Lots of give and take, hard for them and for me as I was a single parent and did feel a bit taken over. However it was magic having a baby in the house. I never once felt I needed to challenge feeding etc. I was a nursery nurse but a laid back ( occasionally hopeless) parent myself. We all get there, and parenting changes. 9 years on, my granddaughter now has a brother who is more challenging and I'm glad they are well settled in their own home.

MilkyYay · 24/12/2022 08:45

They probably haven't picked the best time to raise it but they likely mean well, its much easier to instil a few boundaries at this age than it is to correct their behaviour later on.

Its really tricky given the circumstances, but is it possible you are pandering to him a little trying to compensate for the upset of the separation/circumstances? It can feel like the kind option but probably isn't, kids need boundaries/consistency.

Dutchesss · 24/12/2022 08:43

Good or bad toddler behaviour can be very subjective.

I think it's great that your parents have sat down and had an open chat with you. It will help stop any resentment building and give you all a chance to hear each other.

Please try not to see it as criticism. If you are able to keep these open conversations with your parents, regardless of whether your opinions differ, then it will make for a much smoother living situation for you all. You get to choose what you might want to compromise on and they get an honest answer of why you do some things differently. There's no right or wrong.

1Wanda1 · 24/12/2022 08:40

Grandparents just do this. They genuinely can't remember what it was like with their own children. I know that's true because I have a 15 year gap between my second and third children and even I can't remember the detail of my older kids' meltdowns/fussiness etc.

My mum is always saying things like "you were much stricter with the other 2 than you are with DD, she gets away with anything." Er, no I wasn't and no she doesn't!

In my parents' mind they merely had to give me and DB "the look" and we'd fall into line. Pretty sure it wasn't like that. I just let the comments wash over me now. It's like that Baz Luhrmann song: "Accept certain inalienable truths
Prices will rise, politicians will philander, you too, will get old
And when you do, you'll fantasize that when you were young
Prices were reasonable, politicians were noble
And children respected their elders"

NCNCNCYEP · 24/12/2022 08:40

WandaWonder · 24/12/2022 04:45

Food, toys, the way he plays, choices over TV, lots of other things I think they could stay out of

'Being a handful' to me you need to address that, kids do not need to play up 'to express themselves' or otherwise I have heard parents try and justify bad behaviour.

If they are not coping you need to fix that

Kids don’t “play up” - he is 2. He is developing. Tantrums, pushing boundaries, being inquisitive are all completely natural for his age. Rather than going for the jugular and instantly punishing, we should really look at the “why”.

OP - I know it’s hard but please don’t fall into this old-school parenting style trap. Children don’t need to be punished or shamed for feeling and acting totally normal for their age. It’s bizarre that people are still pushing this narrative that children need to be controlled. They just need to be guided. He’s going through a big life transition (as are you) so expect some confusion and dysregulated behaviour. It’s not up to you or your parents to punish him for this, it’s not his fault, just simply look at “why” he is being like this and help him work through those feelings. Of course discipline should play a part, but in a “teaching, guidance and support” way.

People wonder why there’s a mental health crisis. It’s because we weren’t emotionally supported adequately growing up. Instead we were shamed for showing (entirely) normal feelings and basically told/shown from an early age “I don’t support you for feeling anything other than happiness or compliance” and so we learned to internalise. Your parents are proof that for generations kids have been there to control rather than guide and support.

babyva · 24/12/2022 08:39

Christmaslover2022 · 24/12/2022 05:45

Maybe the portions are too big, and if he's fussy then you give a yoghurt then it's not great imo. In our house fruit and veg is not a choice.

And you may not want to hear this but its unlikely they are happy about you moving in with a possiblr unruly toddler either, they have their life and to have you move back in is a big thing. Of course they are going to say things. Sorry OP but I think they are probably right, you probably do have a toddler that's a bit out of hand. Not an ideal situation but you'll have to try your best to get on with them because they are doing you a favour. Are you on the housing list? Can you private rent with some help from government?

There's a special place in hell for people like you, who kick others while they're down.

Don't worry. Karma will get you.

Kizzy192 · 24/12/2022 08:37

Poor boy is only 2 and going through a big upheaval himself. Plus, there's no such thing as bad behaviour at 2. They can't reason, they are slaves to their sugar levels and are busy learning about the world. You might have to grin and bear the comments I'm afraid, as you're in their house, but maybe show them a few articles/videos on child development and behaviour. Also be totally honest with them, tell them how much you are struggling and need/are thankful for their support. Honesty is always the best way.

WhatInFreshHell · 24/12/2022 08:36

@Holly60 Well said!

Newmumatlast · 24/12/2022 08:34

Christmaslover2022 · 24/12/2022 05:53

I never said you force feed them. If you put crap on their plate they will eat it. Kids that only eat chicken nuggets were given them by their parents! If they are hungry, they will eat the healthy food. No drama, just healthy stuff there at every meal. Interesting you seem to assume I condone force feeding a child??

That's not always true actually. Even if hungry, if someone genuinely doesn't like something they won't eat it unless they feel coerced then perhaps they might but the experience will be negative and may give them food related issues when older.

I agree with not letting kids take the mick with food in terms of only eating crap when they could eat better however I also don't agree with making people eat things that they genuinely do not like

Roundlampshade · 24/12/2022 08:31

I used to get this all the time from the older generation. It’s a stock phrase. That and “Here comes Trouble” (referring to DD) which I find offensive, actually. Label a child and that’s what they become, and all that.

I’d ignore it. If you can. Or agree with them and then carry on doing what you’re doing.

thelobsterquadrille · 24/12/2022 08:31

How long are you staying with your parents? Is it only for a few weeks or will it have to be a bit more permanent while you sort finances out?

I have to say, I would really struggle to move back home now and I don't even have children. This is a massive adjustment for all of you - so while you feel their criticism is unfair, try and remember that it's not just your life that's been turned upside down by all this.

Dolphinnoises · 24/12/2022 08:29

I think parents who were very strict find it extremely challenging to witness it being done another way by their own children. It seems like criticism to them. Plus when they were parents, your grandparents were telling them this stuff, and they are unconsciously replicating that role.

On the portions - have a Google and see if they have a point. On the behaviour - have your own boundaries shifted? I know when I’m on the bones of my area with work, or emotionally, I hold the line on eg screen time far less than I should. Inwardly I think “oh sod it, just have the bloody iPad, I’m too tired to argue”. Is there an element of that?

If not and it really is that they expect you to parent in a way which makes you uncomfortable, you need to politely make that clear. Why is it not your ex living at his parents?

Holly60 · 24/12/2022 08:28

Christmaslover2022 · 24/12/2022 06:01

So because I don't agree with the OP, I'm not supportive? So basically you want an echo chamber not another opinion?

No you are being deliberately obtuse. You are not helping because frankly what you suggest is not realistic. You either had extraordinarily compliant children or you are lying. Most 2 year olds (and I've worked with a fair few) will not placidly sit and eat what they don't want. Most non- abusive parents will not let their children go hungry. So if a 2 year old is refusing to eat what is provided the natural parental instinct is to find something they will eat.

At no point has OP mentioned plates full of chicken nuggets. She mentioned a yoghurt.

You keep trying small bits of different food until they get used to it and eventually they become good eaters but you don't withhold food as a punishment for expressing a preference.

grievinggirlneedsadvice · 24/12/2022 08:24

I absolutely despise the word 'handful' for a child. Does anyone really think a child has to be convenient and compliant all the time?
Yes it's a difficult situation all round, but the people who should take the brunt of it here are adults. Any help, discipline (in the proper way as in guiding a child to live the best life they can not instilling fear and pain into them) should be given to the child to improve the child's life, not ours. It's the adults responsibility to help the child make the child's life better not the child's responsibility to make the adults life easier.
I think having a chat with your parents about how they can help you help your child and their grandchild through this might help them have some empathy for a child who's world's been turned upside down without any choice.
This must be so difficult for you too, is it going to be much longer?