Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Son has come home with a girl

164 replies

sonotprepared · 24/12/2022 03:55

He's 18, and knows this girl. Has just brought her home saying she's locked out. Tells me she was upset earlier (with good reason).

She seems to be staying here tonight and I'm uncomfortable about it.

He's been at a club, so a bit tipsy. Asked if he's sleeping on the couch if she's staying and he says no. Obviously intends on sharing his bed with her.

WWYD? This is new to me!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Zedcarz · 25/12/2022 13:38

Bit late now but if this was My house and scenario, (they're 18 and adults)
'Here's the sofa/ spare room, got spare duvet etc, x can sleep on the sofa, you have his bed'
If she insists on sharing his room / seems keen maybe remind them ts a big day tomorrow, you're a sensitive sleeper and have lost your earplugs 🤯
Unless you're religious I don't see an issue with it, you wouldn't make your 18+ couple friends sleep separately?
I met a locked out teenage girl one night. She was in a right state, I'd have let her sleep at mine but everyone I was with said she'd Rob or kill me etc so I worked really hard with her to find someone via her phone to come and get her, she contacted me the next day to thank me profusely and i frequently lost my bag, keys etc back ij my wilder days, so it does happen and is not necessarily a ruse.

Furries · 25/12/2022 03:19

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 20:44

@toomuchlaundry "if they are drunk they might not be consenting!"

If my gran had wheels she'd be a bike!

Care to elaborate on this? I’m not getting your comparison with consent vs being a bike.

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 20:44

@toomuchlaundry "if they are drunk they might not be consenting!"

If my gran had wheels she'd be a bike!

BaublesandBangles · 24/12/2022 18:15

Only on MN would parents kick their 18 year olds out for doing normal 18 year old things.

Murdoch1949 · 24/12/2022 17:57

Your son is out of order. It is your house, she is a stranger to you. You need to put your foot down, if he doesn't accept the sofa offer, he can leave too. Imagine if her parents turn up saying is my 15 year old daughter here.

Flyinggeesei234 · 24/12/2022 13:38

gogohmm · 24/12/2022 08:35

Youngsters today are a lot more liberal sharing with the opposite sex isn't taboo - dd often shares a tent with a lad who isn't her boyfriend (she has a serious boyfriend) it's no big deal

Agree with this.

billy1966 · 24/12/2022 12:15

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 24/12/2022 06:02

Well your son clearly doesn't respect you, he's paid board once, regardless it's still your home. You are perfectly entitled to not have random women in your home. I wouldn't. If he wants to sleep with random women, he can pay for a hotel.

This.

Who does he think he is?

I have children this age and if either of my boys took that tone with me he would be finding digs.

Bringing her back is ok.

She would be on the sofa in this house or they could find a hotel.

No way would we accept that.

toomuchlaundry · 24/12/2022 12:11

@Frabbits if they are drunk they might not be consenting!

Frabbits · 24/12/2022 12:10

They are both consenting adults. Making one of them sleep on the couch is ridiculous.

StephanieSuperpowers · 24/12/2022 12:03

KimberleyClark · 24/12/2022 09:28

I agree with this. When he’s living in his own place/flatshare/house share as a fully independent self funding adult he can do what he likes. Until then he needs to abide by and respect your rules.

Yeah, I can't get on board with the idea that if it's legal you can't insist you don't want it in your house. Lots of things are legal but people have a rule against it in their won home.

What's the point in having your own house if anything, so long as it's legal, goes, regardless of your feelings?

CarrotCake84 · 24/12/2022 11:31

Asking Mumsnet won’t give you balanced enough opinions, many Mumsnetters seem prudish when it comes to sex, like it’s something that shouldn’t happen, it’s a normal act between two people. They will shame your son for having a healthy and natural curiosity about sex and the Mumsnetters who say their teens didn’t bring anyone home, it’s probably because they were shagging in a field instead, or they was at uni taking partners back to their student accommodation. As long as it’s consensual and they’re using protection, there really is no harm in what they’re doing.

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 11:12

If they wanna bang each other then they do. They are adults, it isn't your job to police his bedroom.

Do you not trust him not to rape someone? Cos that is how it is sounding. Surely he knows about consent?

Are they even interested in each other like that? I mean I assume so given how insistent your son is re: bed sharing arrangements.

It sounds that OP is more put out by the fact her little boy isn't her little boy anymore. Yes he is going to have sex, it is on teenage boys minds much of the the time. This is a normal, healthy expression of sexuality. It is also better in your house than under a bridge or in an alleyway somewhere. I'd want to know if he has protection rather than stand fighting about where this girl is sleeping (and assuming that they are even interested in each other).

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/12/2022 11:05

Westernesse · 24/12/2022 07:00

Mind your own business and go to bed.

@Westernesse

its her house so it is her business

OneDayFri · 24/12/2022 10:39

pictoosh · 24/12/2022 05:40

He's 18...what's the problem?

The problem is it's not his house, he's a child being housed by his parents and should know to ask for permission before taking a girl to share his bed for the night. It's about common decency and respect for one's parents.

U2HasTheEdge · 24/12/2022 10:36

StarlightLady · 24/12/2022 09:37

I’d ask if she would like tea or coffee in the morning!

Parents should not police who adult offspring sleep with or invite home unless they are interfering with their (the parents) own lives.

For the record, l was bringing boys home at his age (40s now, so no lectures please) and sex didn’t take place when parents were in.

I do get to police who can stay in my house. Especially as I have other children who live here, who also wouldn't be comfortable with a stranger in their home.

My younger children would hate to bump into a stranger in their home when they wake up. They would find it uncomfortable, and so would I.

I don't want people in my house who I don't know.

Mammyloveswine · 24/12/2022 10:03

I used to sneak loads of lads back when I lived at home!

My parents have never mentioned it but I do wonder if they knew! I'm sure they must have heard!

They never said anything though!

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/12/2022 10:02

InFiveMins · 24/12/2022 06:46

They are both adults for gods sake. Let them get on with it. You have completely overreacted here Confused

@InFiveMins

nah

it’s her house! she doesn’t have to let them get on with it if she doesn’t want to

AccountDetail · 24/12/2022 10:02

lurkinglittleladybug · 24/12/2022 04:08

Yes he could be taking advantage of her if she’s in a vulnerable situation, I would insist one of them stay on the couch especially if she’s been drinking and is upset, is she in the right state of mind to consent to sex?

My thougut too. I was all ready to say they are adults but DS sounds like a bit of a predator.
She is vulnerable and he is taking advantage of that. I would tell him that, and that it won't be happening under my roof. I would certainly see him in a new light.

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/12/2022 09:59

It’s not his house

it’s his mum’s house

she doesn’t want him bringing people back and cos it’s her house it’s her rules

when he has a house of his own he can bring back who he likes.

it really is that simple

Minfilia · 24/12/2022 09:58

My DC have their long term partners stay with them at home and I don’t mind that at all - I know they are using contraception and they’ve had the talk on consent. (16&17YO).

19YO is single and if he brought a random home and then disrespected me I’d be seriously unhappy. It’s a totally different kettle of fish.

YANBU at all to insist one of them sleeps on the sofa and the fact that they both ignored you is disgraceful tbh.

VickyEadieofThigh · 24/12/2022 09:58

My older brother did this one night when I was 17 (I'm now 64) - brought home a girl he'd just met that night with some story that she had been kicked out by her parents.

He ended up blackmailing my mother into allowing her sto stay for several months and my mother made me share mor room (we'd only moved into a 3 bed house that year and previously I'd had to share with the older, then the younger brother so had my own room for only a few months).

It's the fact that this is not his established girlfriend and he's treating his mother's house with contempt that is the issue for me, with the additional issue for the OP that she has some wider concerns about her son being accused of something later (I'd also be worried about unplanned pregnancy but then that's me for you).

CranberryPecan · 24/12/2022 09:53

WandaWonder · 24/12/2022 04:39

She could be taking advantage of him, but regardless to me 18 is no different to 30 or 40 or whatever

18 is an adult and it is perfectly legal, the last thing in the world I want to is what my son is doing when he gets to 18, but I also won't judge something perfectly legal and it's his house too

Sure having wild parties or being totally inconsiderate is one thing, having someone stay over is normal

I don't think it's normal behaviour in a family situation! It would raise more than eyebrows in this house if I brought a random man home from a nightclub to sleep in my bed - I wouldn't do it and neither would my kids.

Unforgettablefire · 24/12/2022 09:49

U2HasTheEdge · 24/12/2022 07:41

I would be very pissed off. My teen/adult sons wouldn't dream of bringing anyone back here without asking me first.

I am happy for my son's girlfriend to stay because we know her and are comfortable with her. I don't want anyone staying over who I do not know, or have never heard of, at least not without a conversation and prior agreement first.

This. My dd would bring randoms (friends) to the house late at night and couldn't get why it annoyed me.

Great username by the way!

KettrickenSmiled · 24/12/2022 09:49

The problem is, that for reasons I'm not going into here, I am terrified of him ending up in a situation where he could be accused of something. It is too close to home for us. That may be completely irrational of me, but yes, it worries me massively.
I'm not going to pry, but your son is old enough for you to convey whatever this is about to him surely?

Apart from that, i just do not want any part in him bringing random women back to the house, just as I would not bring men back to stay if he was home. If this was actually a girlfriend, I would be okay with that.
So tell him this.
Lay it on the line, tell him he doesn't get to challenge YOUR house rules just because he pays something toward his own costs.
Get him to understand how the concept of consent doesn't just apply to sexual relations, but to all reasonable dealings between decent people.
This could be a good discussion to have, & a valuable life lesson for him. He doesn't get to play Billy Big Balls to his own mother just because he's earning, & paying toward his keep now.

KettrickenSmiled · 24/12/2022 09:43

sonotprepared · 24/12/2022 04:09

I've just said it's my house and he says he pays to live here. Yesterday was literally the first time he's paid dig money.

And he's adamant I would t care if it was his good friend that I've met plenty of times. Not so sure about that, but just feel he's out me in a really awkward position

She's over 18, so no - you can't police who SHE sleeps with,

I would have been more bothered about why she's upset & what's going on with her parents that she's been locked out. I'd also be screening whatever that story is with a bullshit detector, but first instinct must surely be to believe her, & be concerned for her?

You made a rod for your own back by first 'asking' - therefore cementing in his mind that it was up to him - then 'telling' him once you already knew that his preferred outcome was opposite to yours. That was only end in a confrontational win/lose situation.

That's probably why he came back with his "but I pay for my digs" comment. It was his way of defending his challenge to your authority, & you maybe need to take issue with that, but NOT NOW as it is a separate issue. (Deal with it by pointing out that if you were a landlady with lodgers, you could have a 'no overnight guests' rule, becuase it is YOUR house, not his ... but really - I wouldn't lock horns over that one, as you're looking for a win/win here, surely, not a chance to win while your son feels that he has 'lost'?)

She seems happy to share the bed. Certainly hasn't said 'I'll sleep on the couch'.
And there was your solution.
ENTHUSIASTIC consent - remember? Going along with it because you feel you don't have much option isn't consent.
It should never have been up to your son where she sleeps.
Unless you want to be draconian about guests & alienate your son, it shouldn't have been up to you either.
You should have asked HER. Empathised with her upset, asked her if she needs to borrow overnight things, has she messaged her parents to let them know she can't get in but is SAFE with your son, not to worry, his mother is here too ...
then ask her if she'd like you to make up the couch for her.

& then stopped worrying. Because even if you'd forced your son's hand & done a myhousemyrules on him, you know one of them would have sneaked to join the other in the dead of night anyway, if that's what they both wanted?