Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants DC to save presents to she can watch them open them

164 replies

MiseltoeAndWhine · 23/12/2022 20:47

MIL and FIL are coming on Christmas Day. They've been invited for the full day but are coming at 1pm (fair enough that's their choice). They don't live far they could pop over on the morning if they want to but said they're not early risers. Our two DC are 3 and 5. MIL has asked us to save some of their Santa presents so they can watch them open them. I don't really want to do this - I don't want to "control" the kids joy on Christmas Day and we haven't got them loads so don't want the pile to look small on the morning. Plus I want them to have the full day to enjoy their gifts.

I think it's really selfish of them. I was caught off guard when she asked and said I don't think they'll be able to wait plus they can open the gift from her when she gets to us. She then asked the kids to save gifts for granny and they looked upset and said they didn't want to. She then said to us it's not much to ask and seeing that is the best part of the day.

WIBU to ignore all this?

OP posts:
NewHopeNow · 23/12/2022 22:08

Absolutely ridiculous, not a chance I'd be doing this. She's had her children, she's had her turn, she doesn't get to take over your family and control what you do. And so selfish considering your children are so young.

Crack on and if she says "I thought we agreed you were waiting" just say "no, you asked but that wasn't going to work for us". Then hopefully she'll start to get the message that you're going to do what you want rather than "doing as you're told" going forward too.

Nanny0gg · 23/12/2022 22:07

anythinginapinch · 23/12/2022 21:05

Good grief teaching them
Deferred gratification can only help them. Explain - these presents are from grannie and grandpa, so we'll
Wait until they come at lunch time to
Open them" will not fucking hurt your DC. Being able to control one's immediate urges is a life skill. Thinking of others is a social skill.

Reading comprehension is a life skill too. Give it a go.

So if you'd read the OP's posts you'd see that the GPs are bringing their presents with them.

So the DCs can open those later and open everything else when they get up.

SaulHudsonDavidJones · 23/12/2022 22:06

anythinginapinch · 23/12/2022 21:05

Good grief teaching them
Deferred gratification can only help them. Explain - these presents are from grannie and grandpa, so we'll
Wait until they come at lunch time to
Open them" will not fucking hurt your DC. Being able to control one's immediate urges is a life skill. Thinking of others is a social skill.

Well we know you'd be the arsehole in this scenario.

Lenald · 23/12/2022 22:06

User359472111111 · 23/12/2022 21:58

its so much better to spread presents out. They will get much more enjoyment than a massive opening spree if you spread the presents out. But to be honest you sound like you hate the in-laws so it doesn’t really make a difference whether the request is reasonable.

Do that with your kids then (bet it’s shit for them) OP will do what she wants with hers.

TheNoodlesIncident · 23/12/2022 22:03

Being able to control one's immediate urges is a life skill. Thinking of others is a social skill.

Shame MIL hasn't learned these by now, isn't it? She is neither thinking of others, just herself and FIL, nor can she stop herself from making unreasonable requests.

She can watch them opening the presents she's brought them, can't she? Any more than that, she needs to get up earlier. Maybe she could go to bed earlier to help with that? Looking for solutions is a life skill.

YooniqueMe · 23/12/2022 22:00

PinkiOcelot · 23/12/2022 20:52

What?! If she wants to see them open their gifts she gets her arse out of bed!

This a hundred times. If she says it's not much to ask the kids to wait, then tell her it's not much to ask her to get up earlier!

User359472111111 · 23/12/2022 21:58

its so much better to spread presents out. They will get much more enjoyment than a massive opening spree if you spread the presents out. But to be honest you sound like you hate the in-laws so it doesn’t really make a difference whether the request is reasonable.

Lenald · 23/12/2022 21:58

MiseltoeAndWhine · 23/12/2022 20:47

MIL and FIL are coming on Christmas Day. They've been invited for the full day but are coming at 1pm (fair enough that's their choice). They don't live far they could pop over on the morning if they want to but said they're not early risers. Our two DC are 3 and 5. MIL has asked us to save some of their Santa presents so they can watch them open them. I don't really want to do this - I don't want to "control" the kids joy on Christmas Day and we haven't got them loads so don't want the pile to look small on the morning. Plus I want them to have the full day to enjoy their gifts.

I think it's really selfish of them. I was caught off guard when she asked and said I don't think they'll be able to wait plus they can open the gift from her when she gets to us. She then asked the kids to save gifts for granny and they looked upset and said they didn't want to. She then said to us it's not much to ask and seeing that is the best part of the day.

WIBU to ignore all this?

What a self cantered woman. If it’s the most important part of the day she needs to make sure she sets her alarm and gets there for it.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 23/12/2022 21:56

“What can I say when she inevitably makes a comment about it on the day?”-

we choose to open all our gifts in the morning in this house. I told you that. Anyway anyone want a cuppa?

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 23/12/2022 21:56

Shes being unreasonable and selfish. She had the joy of watching her own child open presents now its your turn. If its that important to her she will get out of bed earli

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 23/12/2022 21:54

You’re being unreasonable. Much better to spread the gifts out.

Rainbow1901 · 23/12/2022 21:53

We grew up knowing that presents from aunties and so on would come later in the day. Back then we were impatient (as you would be!!) for presents to open them all at once. But it actually made us appreciate the gifts more and Christmas Day lasted longer too!!
We are doing the rounds of Christmas Day visits to our grandchildren and will take their presents along with us as we go. That way we get to see their excitement of gifts already opened as well as seeing them open our gifts. But when it's called for it - we have left gifts under the tree if we won't be around.
When my kids were young we were annoyed on behalf of the aunties etc that the big man got the credit for all the gifts so stockings/sacks from Santa were left at the end of the bed and anything under the tree from family.

FlissyPaps · 23/12/2022 21:52

PinkiOcelot · 23/12/2022 20:52

What?! If she wants to see them open their gifts she gets her arse out of bed!

Yep ☝

It’s that simple. She sounds like a control freak. Don’t let her try and guilt trip you into anything. Stand your ground.

BrokenWing · 23/12/2022 21:52

Just agree with her -

This is a bit of an issue for her - she always says "so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?" - yes it is the best bit for us too, written they just cant wait to open first thing in the morning, dc tell granny what was your biggest surprise

And says children should learn to wait and they all get too much. It can feel quite judgmental. - haha, it is Christmas they learn to wait the other 364 days of the year, not today, today they definitely get too much!

Adviceneeded200 · 23/12/2022 21:51

We used to wake at 4 in the morning and take them into mum and dad's bed and open them at that age!

No way.

Main presents, yes. In fact it's a nice idea to have some later in the day, but not stocking. They are designed to be fun in the middle of the night!

Tinkerbyebye · 23/12/2022 21:51

Wouldn’t be happening

i would go back, explain they are small children and so will be opening them in the morning. As an adult she is making the choice not to get up early this once to see them open the presents. So if she wants to see them she gets up, her choice

WonderingWanda · 23/12/2022 21:51

Do what ever you had planned. When she turns up and moans about it say 'Well, I did say they wouldn't be able to wait. They were so excited, you know what kids are like!' And then ignore her.

Tallulasdancingshoes · 23/12/2022 21:50

This is absolutely bonkers. Your MIL is completely mad. Yes, save the ones specifically from them, but not the Santa ones. How ridiculous. If she wants to see then she needs to come round very early. If you give in this year it’ll become the norm. Stand your ground.

grumpycow1 · 23/12/2022 21:48

MiseltoeAndWhine · 23/12/2022 20:58

Thank you so much for the replies. I'm so sick of the selfish requests from her and it upsets me because we have been desperate to make Christmas special for the kids and this suggestion threw me as I thought this would derail the whole day. Probably silly I know. DH was more laid back than me but did say he thought it was selfish of her.

What can I say when she inevitably makes a comment about it on the day?

This is a bit of an issue for her - she always says "so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?" And says children should learn to wait and they all get too much. It can feel quite judgmental.

I’d say ‘such a shame you couldn’t get up early on this one occasion, did you know that’s what my friends in laws did and was so kind of them’ 😂

Flossflower · 23/12/2022 21:47

OP you have a lovely time with your children on Christmas morning. Please forget all about your MIL’s demands. She is being very selfish. This time of life when your children are young is very precious. We are grandparents and are going on Christmas Day for lunch. There is no way in the world I would expect any presents to be left unopened except the ones we are bringing.

Elmer83 · 23/12/2022 21:47

I’d send her the responses from this thread! She’s being totally self absorbed and selfish. Ignore her…even better tell her to F off!

diamondpony80 · 23/12/2022 21:45

Of course not. Santa opening is early in our house and I wouldn’t want grandparents coming then either as we’re still in our pyjamas. We do record the kids opening their presents as some of the reactions have been priceless and would send a video to my parents. They’d never ask though, they had their time doing Santa with me and my siblings when we were growing up. This is YOUR time with your kids.

ivykaty44 · 23/12/2022 21:44

This is a bit of an issue for her - she always says "so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?" And says children should learn to wait and they all get too much. It can feel quite judgmental.

the children have waited all of December for the day to arrive when Santa has dropped off their presents, to then make little children who are so excited to wait longer is not going to happen any year - so either get yourselves out of bed on time or miss to on the fun

Bluetrews25 · 23/12/2022 21:42

Ridiculous
At that age mine would have been up since about 0500 and all would have been opened swiftly. No way would I have wanted grandparents around at that time of day!
She's had her go as a parent to see all this.
She can watch them open her gifts. The rest, just no.

Pantomcpancoface · 23/12/2022 21:42

Could they open their Santa presents in the morning and you keep their presents from you, DH and each other back until later? We’re seeing my in laws on Boxing Day and holding a few back for it. The kids won’t know we have those presents until Boxing Day so won’t know they’re waiting. I know you say you don’t have many presents but they’re 3 and 5 - they’ll be delighted with anything and everything on Christmas morning.

I don’t really understand people’s desires to turn a request about the day into an argument (not you OP, the responses you’ve got). That said, my MIL isn’t terribly demanding so maybe this is a more irritating request if it’s the tip of an iceberg.