Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants DC to save presents to she can watch them open them

164 replies

MiseltoeAndWhine · 23/12/2022 20:47

MIL and FIL are coming on Christmas Day. They've been invited for the full day but are coming at 1pm (fair enough that's their choice). They don't live far they could pop over on the morning if they want to but said they're not early risers. Our two DC are 3 and 5. MIL has asked us to save some of their Santa presents so they can watch them open them. I don't really want to do this - I don't want to "control" the kids joy on Christmas Day and we haven't got them loads so don't want the pile to look small on the morning. Plus I want them to have the full day to enjoy their gifts.

I think it's really selfish of them. I was caught off guard when she asked and said I don't think they'll be able to wait plus they can open the gift from her when she gets to us. She then asked the kids to save gifts for granny and they looked upset and said they didn't want to. She then said to us it's not much to ask and seeing that is the best part of the day.

WIBU to ignore all this?

OP posts:
JoanOfAllTrades · 24/12/2022 00:32

@MiseltoeAndWhine

Please don’t do this! It’s Christmas. I’m not even Christian but we still celebrate Christmas as we believe in the virgin birth and that Jesus was an important prophet!

Your parents are being so unreasonable. If they lived a 3 hour drive away, maybe I could understand asking, although I would still refuse but they could just jump in the car in their jammies and watch the kids open the presents and then go home and get ready. If the reason they can’t do this is because they’re having a night out on the lash, this is their problem, not yours.

If your parents want to watch the kids opening lots of presents, they need to buy more!

It’s ridiculous and unfair to make the children wait to open their gifts, especially when they don’t get heaps and heaps.

If you were a parent a là TikTok or the ones I’ve seen recently in the media, so proud that they spend thousands, with just a walkway left in the living room due to the sheer number of presents, I would say that perhaps you should consider saving a few, but in this scenario then no, your parents are being supremely selfish and I would rescind their invitation . (Ok, not really but I would totally want to do that!)

LoveBluey · 24/12/2022 00:08

Obviously MIL is unreasonable. Not only is it unfair on the kids to make them wait so long it then means you will inevitably miss lots of the fun as you'll be busy sorting out lunch / getting drinks and hosting. By doing the presents first thing you can focus on seeing them open them and then they can spend time playing with their new toys while you prep lunch.

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 24/12/2022 00:02

They are unreasonable to try to dictate your Christmas morning. I would ignore them. As far as her taking care of her one toy as a kid, can you just say that is why you gave a toy to a local toy drove in her name. Then give her a hug and say she will not see her grandkids deprived ever. Tilt your head a bit.
Ok, not really. But she is unreasonable and self centered.

Spookysparkles · 23/12/2022 23:59

minipie · 23/12/2022 20:49

YANBU. You’re saving the gifts that are from them, that’s all they can fairly expect.

Agree- save theirs back ok, but not any others! They can get out of bed and come over earlier if it’s that important

Babyboomtastic · 23/12/2022 23:59

SkylightSkylight · 23/12/2022 23:49

@Babyboomtastic one of my godsons was like that. He'd want to play with each thing before opening the next one, it was frustrating for his Dad who was/is a paramedic because he often missed out on a lot if it, we used to save the 'best presents' for when his Dad was home, but hard to time!! One set of Grandoarents lived overseas, but often came over for Christmas & they tried to hurry him along 'as we don't want 'this mess'all day now do we?!' We just used to laugh & carry on playing with him.

It's it's because they seek instant gratification in many ways, but with Christmas they just take it slow. We have a sweets and chocolates table that they are allowed to help themselves to at Christmas. I have to remind them that they can have some if they want 😂

Glad to see mine aren't the only ones though. When I was a kid, our best present was saved for last, with our kids we have to put it on top or they probably wouldn't get it on Christmas day.

I do get the frustration of those that are limited with their time like the dad paramedic, but i think it's important for kids to do it how they like, and if that's slow, that's fine. I quite like how it prolongs the excitement tbh, and it makes the guests seem more appreciated. I'm not complaining, my even if FIL is.

chickbean · 23/12/2022 23:56

My kids are all teenagers, and even they woudn't wait.

Dibbydoos · 23/12/2022 23:53

Video the kids opening their presents and play it for her when she arrives....

SkylightSkylight · 23/12/2022 23:49

@Babyboomtastic one of my godsons was like that. He'd want to play with each thing before opening the next one, it was frustrating for his Dad who was/is a paramedic because he often missed out on a lot if it, we used to save the 'best presents' for when his Dad was home, but hard to time!! One set of Grandoarents lived overseas, but often came over for Christmas & they tried to hurry him along 'as we don't want 'this mess'all day now do we?!' We just used to laugh & carry on playing with him.

Ottersmith · 23/12/2022 23:49

Tell her to go fuck herself. I'm sick of twat MIL trying to live a new mother fantasy. I bet her kids could open their presents in front of just her in the morning, now as a mother it's your turn to enjoy that.

Mummyratbag · 23/12/2022 23:40

Kids that age can hardly stop themselves from opening other people's pressies let alone their own.. I'm ancient, but still remember practically shaking to open them whilst waiting for adults (who were staying) to get themselves sorted (dressing gowns etc). Ridiculous woman - it's not about her.

JustLyra · 23/12/2022 23:35

MiseltoeAndWhine · 23/12/2022 20:58

Thank you so much for the replies. I'm so sick of the selfish requests from her and it upsets me because we have been desperate to make Christmas special for the kids and this suggestion threw me as I thought this would derail the whole day. Probably silly I know. DH was more laid back than me but did say he thought it was selfish of her.

What can I say when she inevitably makes a comment about it on the day?

This is a bit of an issue for her - she always says "so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?" And says children should learn to wait and they all get too much. It can feel quite judgmental.

"so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?"

”X’s mum and dad go round early doors to watch the grandkids open their pressies so the kids can get caught up in the excitement and not have to wait - that’s really thoughtful and kind, isn’t it?”

Highflow · 23/12/2022 23:34

Ignore her. My MIL had the same request a few years ago. I told her absolutely not.

Natty13 · 23/12/2022 23:30

With people like this I always agree with whatever nonsense they are asking of me with absolutely no intention to follow through. Then just pretend I forgot ("so sorry! my head was all over the place getting ready for the day, have you tried this red pepper dip DH made, it's delicious!")

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 23:28

PinkiOcelot · 23/12/2022 20:52

What?! If she wants to see them open their gifts she gets her arse out of bed!

This.

SkylightSkylight · 23/12/2022 23:25

anythinginapinch · 23/12/2022 21:05

Good grief teaching them
Deferred gratification can only help them. Explain - these presents are from grannie and grandpa, so we'll
Wait until they come at lunch time to
Open them" will not fucking hurt your DC. Being able to control one's immediate urges is a life skill. Thinking of others is a social skill.

@anythinginapinch

reading comprehension is a life skill, you might like to put some effort into achieving

AdoraBell · 23/12/2022 23:19

Did that OP let them open the presents and either film or take some pictures on your phone for the PIL.

Sorry if I’m repeating advice, haven’t RTFT.

theblackradiator · 23/12/2022 23:12

Do you usually video dc opening their presents? if you do then just show grandparents the video! can cast to the TV from most phones now to watch on the bigger screen. I'd have hated having to wait to open my presents as it's way too exciting for young children. if they really wanted to see them they'd make that extra effort to get up and come round earlier.

Babyboomtastic · 23/12/2022 23:07

Weirdly my children (similar ages) do like to pace their presents, and find it stressful to have to rush it. Often it takes us nearly into new year. If one unwraps a game, it needs playing before the next present. Lego needs building etc.

But that's very much initiated by them, controlled at their speed. It actually causes the reverse controversy. One grandparent buys them a LOT, but doesn't stay very long, and he always puts pressure on them to open their gifts so he can be there (fair enough in some ways), but they find it very stressful.

You know your kids and their grandparents are being extremely unfair. If they want to see them open their presents then they need to get out of bed!

DifficultBloodyWoman · 23/12/2022 23:06

The best thing about getting older is that I no longer feel the need to be agreeable, smooth things over and keep the peace with people who don’t feel the same way.

It doesn’t make me rude but it does mean that I am comfortable expressing a dissenting opinion. My thoughts and attitude towards a person or their views can, however, make me extremely rude on occasion.

We never got that many presents in my day!
Were your family very poor then?
Every generation wants more/better for their children, don’t they!

So-and-so waited until the grandparents were there to open presents. Isn’t that kind and unselfish?
OMG! Those poor children! They must have been so deflated on Christmas morning!
^^
Actually, I think it is really selfish. Christmas is for the children, not the parents or grandparents.
^^
I couldn’t do that to my children. That’s just cruel!

billy1966 · 23/12/2022 22:47

Totally ignore her.

You need your husband to tell HIS mother to back off and keep her opinions to herself or she will find she is not welcome.

You need to be less polite and far more frosty with her.

Be a lot less available.

The selfishness of that suggestion would piss me off.

Beanbagtrap · 23/12/2022 22:47

When I was little my parents made us wait until after the meal to open presents it was torture! Don't do it OP!

Gingersnappy · 23/12/2022 22:46

"so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?"

If she says anything like this on Christmas, I'd simply respond with "that was kind of them to do for you! The poor kids though, they missed out on all the fun of Christmas morning. My DM (or whoever) came over last year at 7 in the morning to watch DC open their gifts and they were so excited that she was there to see them open Santa's gifts too. Wasn't that so sweet of her?"

BMrs · 23/12/2022 22:41

YANBU. Do not put your MILs happiness above that of your children's. If they don't show up first thing then enjoy your morning as normal and she can watch them open their gift/gifts and that will have to be enough.

Some people are so infuriating!

MadeForThis · 23/12/2022 22:38

anythinginapinch · 23/12/2022 21:05

Good grief teaching them
Deferred gratification can only help them. Explain - these presents are from grannie and grandpa, so we'll
Wait until they come at lunch time to
Open them" will not fucking hurt your DC. Being able to control one's immediate urges is a life skill. Thinking of others is a social skill.

It's not the gp presents. It's the Santa presents.

Who would ask kids to wait until their gp can be bothered to get out of bed so the kids can finally open their presents.

Murdoch1949 · 23/12/2022 22:36

You decide when the presents are opened. MIL is being incredibly entitled and selfish.