Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL wants DC to save presents to she can watch them open them

164 replies

MiseltoeAndWhine · 23/12/2022 20:47

MIL and FIL are coming on Christmas Day. They've been invited for the full day but are coming at 1pm (fair enough that's their choice). They don't live far they could pop over on the morning if they want to but said they're not early risers. Our two DC are 3 and 5. MIL has asked us to save some of their Santa presents so they can watch them open them. I don't really want to do this - I don't want to "control" the kids joy on Christmas Day and we haven't got them loads so don't want the pile to look small on the morning. Plus I want them to have the full day to enjoy their gifts.

I think it's really selfish of them. I was caught off guard when she asked and said I don't think they'll be able to wait plus they can open the gift from her when she gets to us. She then asked the kids to save gifts for granny and they looked upset and said they didn't want to. She then said to us it's not much to ask and seeing that is the best part of the day.

WIBU to ignore all this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tiani4 · 24/12/2022 11:35

Whoops that was a random
'But I wouldn't' added in the end

I meant to add that I wouldn't Brook passive aggressive digs all day at me. Not being put down by anyone in my own home and especially not on Xmas day

"I don't enjoy you saying that/ speaking to me that way '
' I don't appreciate the little digs' are often a go to reply from me

You could also say
' Don't be ridiculous, no loving grandparent would put themselves first above their grandchildren's joy at seeing what Santa brought as they can't wait to get out of bed . That's would be selfish of those grown adults'

mumof3now2 · 24/12/2022 11:32

Can she FaceTime in the morning to watch them? We are doing this tomorrow with my mum

Tiani4 · 24/12/2022 11:27

@MiseltoeAndWhine

Surely it depends on how many Santa presents and overall presents they have ?

If they have huge number then we would always set a few aside to open after lunch As didn't want DCs overwhelmed. However if they only have a few no way would I be saving presents as opening presents early Xmas morning is fun that children and their parents have!! They had their time. They'll see DCs open their present as are bringing it with them

It's not about DGP who decide to visit late in the day- that's their tough.

Besides you can do a video chat for few minutes in morning to PIL to show them DCs face seeing it all under the Xmas tree and opening a present each

But I wouldn't

PortiasBiscuit · 24/12/2022 11:27

I always put family presents under my ye tree to open after lunch. Could you do that?

NandoReindeer · 24/12/2022 11:25

Don’t invite her to come early, just in case she does.

DC get up early on Christmas Day. It’s the best part of the day when you have young children! Don’t let her spoil it.

If she tries to come then tell her the DC will be opening presents any time from 6am onwards, depending on when they wake up. So she will need to set alarm for 5.30 so they are ready to come as soon as you phone, as you are not making DC wait around for anyone on Christmas morning.

Ban · 24/12/2022 11:18

Definitely this!!!

Can't you just say 'so and so's grandparents turn up in the morning at an appropriate time to watch the grandkids open their presents, isn't that thoughful and appropriate if them?' !!

Knittingnanny2 · 24/12/2022 11:11

Ps I’m not sure I’d even encouraging them to come at 6/7 am - it’s lovely it just being the 4 of you at that time of day. What on earth is it with these women wanting to do the little ones stuff again.
Unless I had them staying I wouldn’t be opening up the door at 6 am - and I wouldn’t be turning up at my local childrens houses at that time.
Im perfectly happy to go at the agreed time and enjoy them showing me all of the lovely things they opened when I was still in bed enjoying my “retired person with no alarm clock” lie in on Christmas morning.
I know everyone is different but I just don’t get it.

booklovingmum · 24/12/2022 11:05

YANBU - I'd just tell her when she comes that the kids didn't want to wait to open their presents from Santa. End of discussion.

Thehop · 24/12/2022 10:05

This is a bit of an issue for her - she always says "so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?" And says children should learn to wait and they all get too much. It can feel quite judgmental.

you reply

"do you really think so? I think it's cruel personally, poor kids. Aren't ours lucky rhey have me to give them such a lovely time?"

or

"did you do that with your MiL then?"

MrsToothyBitch · 24/12/2022 09:59

3 and 5 is still really little to wait. If your MiL wants to do that, I'd get her to bring their gifts and maybe a few others with her to stagger them out but as a surprise to the DC.

Otherwise, they open when they open. You can tell your MiL to either get up & facetime early/get her ass round yours early or if she insists upon a later time, she can still see her own DS open stuff.

anythinginapinch · 24/12/2022 09:56

@ShandaLear yes I have acknowledged my mistake - I skimmed the OP (slaps own wrist) and failed to spot the MIL was requesting delay of opening ALL gifts rather than just her gifts. I was wrong.

Crazyinlove123 · 24/12/2022 09:15

I wouldn’t say anything to them. The kids get up and open all of their presents. Only say something if PIL ask then just say the kids couldn’t wait sorry.

ipreferthecat · 24/12/2022 09:07

No way

Your kids are at peak magic age for Christmas !

Holly60 · 24/12/2022 08:44

MiseltoeAndWhine · 23/12/2022 20:58

Thank you so much for the replies. I'm so sick of the selfish requests from her and it upsets me because we have been desperate to make Christmas special for the kids and this suggestion threw me as I thought this would derail the whole day. Probably silly I know. DH was more laid back than me but did say he thought it was selfish of her.

What can I say when she inevitably makes a comment about it on the day?

This is a bit of an issue for her - she always says "so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?" And says children should learn to wait and they all get too much. It can feel quite judgmental.

Offer again for her to come over earlier and then when she says something later just reiterate 'well it was your choice not to be here'

Alternatively don't invite her earlier and if she says anything just say 'this is just how DH and I have decided to organise our christmases. I'm sure you did christmas your way when you had small children. Another drink Maureen?'

Holly60 · 24/12/2022 08:41

PinkiOcelot · 23/12/2022 20:52

What?! If she wants to see them open their gifts she gets her arse out of bed!

This! If it's the best part of the day then it's no real hardship to just get up a bit earlier for it!

What a fool

userh79 · 24/12/2022 08:34

I was surprised by the replies because I was siding with MIL, not realising it was Santa presents she wanted to hold back, not her own 😂 cheeky mare.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 24/12/2022 08:16

PinkiOcelot · 23/12/2022 20:52

What?! If she wants to see them open their gifts she gets her arse out of bed!

This! She's the selfish one. Ignore her OP.

LovelyDaaling · 24/12/2022 08:13

When my FIL said the same to us, I said something like 'that isn't going to happen ' and it wasn't mentioned again! Just say no.

hettie · 24/12/2022 08:06

You can wait to teach the 'delayed gratification' when is developmentally appropriate... Not at this age...
You need to rehearse some responses to the passive aggressive digs
"so and so's child saved the presents for the grandparents to see as it's the best but which is really thoughtful and kind - isn't it?"
Oh that's nice Xand Ys granny got up early especially so that she could see the kids open santa presents. Wasn't that thoughtful (big smile)
"children should learn to wait"
Yes it's such an important skill, the latest research suggests that the best way to help them learn is to play board games with turns from about age 4-5 onwards (true btw)t
they all get too much/I only got one present
that's ok granny if you find it uncomfortable/upsetting to see so much then we can find you a quiet space in another room

ShandaLear · 24/12/2022 07:56

anythinginapinch · 23/12/2022 21:05

Good grief teaching them
Deferred gratification can only help them. Explain - these presents are from grannie and grandpa, so we'll
Wait until they come at lunch time to
Open them" will not fucking hurt your DC. Being able to control one's immediate urges is a life skill. Thinking of others is a social skill.

But they are opening their Christmas presents from Granny and Grandad later when they come round. Granny wants them to save presents from other people until later because she can’t be arsed getting out of her bed at a reasonable hour to enjoy the excitement of little kids opening their presents on Christmas morning. Surely Granny modelling positive behaviours by not being self centred and controlling can only help them in the long run.

sjxoxo · 24/12/2022 07:47

They shouldn’t have already given you the gifts then.

You can’t give a gift then retain control over opening! That’s just ridiculous. She should just bring them at 3pm and if she’s already given them say oops sorry that’s kids! Also maybe the kids can tell her they opened it and loved it. Do you have to be the messenger? I’d let them tell her and thank her. Not really anything to do with you that way! Gift was theirs and given; currently you’re playing gatekeeper. I’d turn that role down!

Wdib78 · 24/12/2022 07:45

Film it on your phone and sent it to her 😅

StickofVeg · 24/12/2022 07:43

We've always just given given gifts from us/Santa first thing on Christmas Day. Then if PILs or my parents were coming over the kids would open the gifts from their grandparents when they were there. I certainly wouldn't expect kids to wait on Christmas Day I think that's pretty unreasonable of her.

Crimsonripple · 24/12/2022 07:02

Oh just ignore her and do what you want to do. It's your family and your Christmas. She's already got you where she wants you, to feel bad/guilty, so push it aside and enjoy watching your children open their presents.

Vebrithien · 24/12/2022 06:57

I hope you have a wonderful Christmas morning, with your lovely family.

Another vote here, for reminding MIL that of she wanted to see the DGC opening their other presents, then she really should make the effort to get there early.

Our morning is different again, as we have always had family staying/visiting from a distance, so in a hotel). The DC will have their Santa present, and usually a present from us (or a small stocking). Then, everyone arrives about 10ish, and we do presents from GPs, aunts, uncles and cousins.

Boxing Day, we do a couple more presents from us, and then each day after they will have a few more presents.

I've never before though about how strange that is, it's just something we've fallen into. Mainly because PIL harp on about how much they get, or DP get them lots, so it would take all day to sit down and open.

Hey ho, nowt as strange as family!

Have a wonderful time, and Merry Christmas!