Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let daughter join in

135 replies

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 12:30

We have some issues with my DD’s behaviour. She is generally a lovely kid - kind, conscientious, does well at school, etc.
However, I am worried that she is becoming quite entitled and spoilt. We do well enough financially to pay for our kids to do lots of extra-curricular clubs, go on nice trips, buy whatever big toys they ask for at Christmas, within reason, etc (this year she’s getting a drum kit and only a few small presents to go with that as it’s so expensive). As a child, my upbringing was different as We didn’t have much money.
I’m worried that this is all being taken for granted and she does not appreciate the value of things and how lucky she is. She’s become very demanding, and doesn’t seem excited about trips and activities we book. Today, we booked a Tag Active session, as it was raining and we wanted to get out of the house. She loves Tag Active. She woke in a foul mood, ordered us around, tried to get us to change the time of the session, tried to engage in long arguments over small issues like the dress code at the venue, refused to get out of bed, or get dressed, refused to put shoes on or get in the car. This happens a lot. If she is in a bad mood, it’s as if she’s on a mission to ruin the moods of everyone else in the house. She often ruins trips out. She can be very argumentative and sulky.
So, she is now going to Tag Active, but as a spectator to watch her brother do it. I feel there needs to be some consequence for the way she speaks to us. She showed no excitement or gratefulness for the fact that we were treating her today. I am sick of having to go through this with her, and feel that she needs to learn that the way she acts and speaks to others has consequences. I don’t want her to grow up to be a spoilt, entitled, little rich kid. Do you think I’m being too harsh? We have lots of lovely times together, but if things don’t go her way, or she feels annoyed about something, it’s a real challenge dealing with her attitude.

OP posts:
YouSoundLovely · 23/12/2022 13:47

Tinselpipes · 23/12/2022 13:27

Also try to remember that when she is "tantrumming" that she is trying to communicate something. Getting upset about timings and clothes etc sounds like some anxiety to me.

Yes. You say she tries to control situations. That's a classically anxious behaviour. All behaviour is communication.

Aldidl · 23/12/2022 13:46

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 13:18

Not at all. I absolutely disagree with physical punishment. I think it’s disgusting. But actually, it was the norm in previous generations. Give other examples of good, old fashioned parenting then please.

You’re not wrong. There’s a hand-wringing thread going on right now because a child has been shouted at 🙄

nameisnotimportant · 23/12/2022 13:46

I think you need to nip it in the bud with some firm boundaries and consequences.

Speak calmly and firmly

O it seems you have woken up with a bad attitude today, acting and speaking rudely and it is spoiling the day for everyone. You have 5 minutes to improve your behaviour or you won't be coming with us today.

Then follow through with the consequence.

I would then follow up later with a conversation. She needs to learn that it's okay to be in a mood or feel down, we all have those kind of days but it's not okay to take it out on everyone else by being rude and unkind.
Try and also see if anything else is going on in her life that may be making the behaviour worse. Is she being bullied at school, is she worried about not seeing school friends over the break. Does she feel your attention is always on the other siblings etc

Killingmytime · 23/12/2022 13:44

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 13:12

We do model good behaviour. And today, I am setting a firm boundary. Remember that good, old fashioned parenting included hitting, and a clip round the ear. These days, our options are very limited! I would like to hear your suggestions, because I am probably already doing them. I make it clear that we don’t tolerate rudeness or back-chat, and I treat my children with respect.

You’ve done the right thing op! She was rude and tried to ruin today.
she has missed the activity, so consequences of her own actions!

YouSoundLovely · 23/12/2022 13:44

'Sometimes if I am honest though I find MN a bit uncomfortably close to getting ‘revenge’ on a misbehaving child than actually helping shape and form their will and spirit.'

This PP has it spot on.

OP, this is going to sound harsh, possibly: I think you're projecting your consciousness of your relative wealth onto your daughter, putting a huge and tbh very transactional emphasis on 'gratitude', and not cutting her the slack we all need sometimes, however old we are. The message you are giving her is 'look how well I am doing, giving you what I didn't have - reward me with the kind of behaviour I want to see'. Her acting out against that is entirely natural. And there is something quite vindictive about making her sit out and watch her brother do an activity which, frankly, will probably improve rather than impact her behaviour if you let her engage in it - physical activity, distraction from the hype of Christmas, letting off steam and all that.

BobLemon · 23/12/2022 13:41

Well done for giving consequences.

My SDCs are in an affluent area and the entitled and spoilt behaviour from some of their friends over the years has been properly cringey. With so often no apparent consequences through either gentle parenting or just no parenting.

The SDCs have grown up with pretty much no financial barriers on their DM’s side and their attitude to possessions and experiences really surprises me sometimes. It’s something I don’t recognise at all from my own life. It’s very different to what I know but that doesn’t mean there’s anything wrong. If they grow up in different circumstances to what you did, it is inevitable that they will have different attitudes and values.

bloodyplanes · 23/12/2022 13:39

Could be hormones starting to kick in before puberty.

Whatshername17 · 23/12/2022 13:36

I wouldn't stop her from joining in today. It's almost Christmas and she doesn't know she's behaving so negatively, it's still a positive memory for her.
But I would sit her down with both of you and have a very firm talk afterwards about behaviour and consequences and THEN take things away if she doesn't go along with it.

RedRosie · 23/12/2022 13:35

OP. Could this be puberty? A friend of mine's ten year old girl became like this overnight, and my friend was so upset. It doesn't necessarily make any difference in relation to managing the actual behaviour, where I'm sure you are doing all the right things ... But perhaps it just provides more context?

Notanotherusername4321 · 23/12/2022 13:34

I used to do this. 🤷‍♀️.

for me it was self sabotage. I was insecure and lacked self confidence, was an introvert etc.

I’d get left at home and it would “prove” to me that it didn’t matter if I wasn’t part of the family, they wouldn’t miss me or have less fun if I wasn’t there. Fuelling my “nobody cares about me” thought processes.

it’s very hard to deal with. I agree that you need to find a way to break the self loathing cycle. Tough though.

Virginiaplain · 23/12/2022 13:33

Xmas is a funny time of year -bad weather so you don’t get out enough - all the work and excitement about present giving. I would let it go.
she leant her lesson by not being allowed to do tag. But keep a watch out for the future.

July70 · 23/12/2022 13:33

OP, blame yourself.
We've never done that and our daughter has a nasty mouth on her for her dad usally and now me as he stays quiet and we don't do handouts. Just imagine if we did.

Giving money like that to your children is a recipe for disaster. in my culture, the sensible avoid that and tell them to p off and work, does them good and we slag off the workshy for the benefit of our children and grandchildren so they understand work ethics.

Tinselpipes · 23/12/2022 13:33

Nowthenhere · 23/12/2022 13:15

Sounds like he's exhausted. Does she get much down time? Sometimes just wanting to switch off can look like bad behaviour. Read between the lines and ask her if she needs some quality time just doing calm things about the the house with just you etc.

Agree with this too. Extra curricular clubs and family trips out are all very well, but I bet if she could just sit with her mum and do some colouring/lego/baking/whatever she enjoys her behaviour would improve.

Hankunamatata · 23/12/2022 13:29

Is this a waking up issue?

Tinselpipes · 23/12/2022 13:27

Also try to remember that when she is "tantrumming" that she is trying to communicate something. Getting upset about timings and clothes etc sounds like some anxiety to me.

HomeAGnome · 23/12/2022 13:22

Ah thank you @Monkeytapper

Tinselpipes · 23/12/2022 13:22

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 13:12

We do model good behaviour. And today, I am setting a firm boundary. Remember that good, old fashioned parenting included hitting, and a clip round the ear. These days, our options are very limited! I would like to hear your suggestions, because I am probably already doing them. I make it clear that we don’t tolerate rudeness or back-chat, and I treat my children with respect.

Ignore the challenging behaviour (unless it's dangerous in some way). But praise all the good (and neutral) behaviour. She'll soon learn what gets attention and you'll see more of that pretty quickly.

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 13:22

billy1966 · 23/12/2022 13:16

OP, she sounds really bratty.

She needs to learn consequences or you are going to have a nightmare teen on your hands.

The behaviour you describe is dreadful and I wouldn't have tolerated it for a minute with my children.

You need to firm up your parenting boundaries before you have a real problem.

I have reared 4 children without ever having to deal with tantrums.

Not because I am a great parent, but because I wouldn't have ever tolerated tantruming behaviour.

I know teens have hormones and can be moody but if it strayed into rudeness to me they would have been pulled up not to speak to me like that.

It is possible to rear privileged children without them being spoiled brats, but it is absolutely dependent on parents establishing what behaviour is expected of them.

I agree with everything you are saying. I do think my husband is a bit too soft. I had to persuade him this morning that this is the right course of action. I don’t tolerate this tantruming, but she keeps doing it. She gets time out in her room. There was one occasion when I didn’t take her to a play date due to her behaviour beforehand, and then today she missed out on this.

I have a son, who does not behave like this, and I do think there is some personality trait here - she has always been very headstrong.

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 23/12/2022 13:20

Getinajollymood · 23/12/2022 13:19

I’m not sure good and old fashioned necessarily go together to be honest.

Old fashioned parenting did focus around physical chastisement, real or threatened.

I don't think PP meant old-fashioned parenting in that sense.

They meant just basic parenting - consequences for your behaviour and not being rewarded with treats and days out when you've had a tantrum and mucked around.

Getinajollymood · 23/12/2022 13:19

I’m not sure good and old fashioned necessarily go together to be honest.

Old fashioned parenting did focus around physical chastisement, real or threatened.

thelobsterquadrille · 23/12/2022 13:18

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 13:12

We do model good behaviour. And today, I am setting a firm boundary. Remember that good, old fashioned parenting included hitting, and a clip round the ear. These days, our options are very limited! I would like to hear your suggestions, because I am probably already doing them. I make it clear that we don’t tolerate rudeness or back-chat, and I treat my children with respect.

What an odd thing to say.

I don't know anyone who was raised being hit or clipped around the year, and yet we all seemed to have turned out fine with no major sense of entitlement.

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 13:18

luxxlisbon · 23/12/2022 13:13

Remember that good, old fashioned parenting included hitting, and a clip round the ear. These days, our options are very limited!

No it doesn’t, and what a truly strange thing to jump to - including the follow up comment that seems to imply you are annoyed you are limited by not being able to hit your child.

Not at all. I absolutely disagree with physical punishment. I think it’s disgusting. But actually, it was the norm in previous generations. Give other examples of good, old fashioned parenting then please.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 23/12/2022 13:16

OP, she sounds really bratty.

She needs to learn consequences or you are going to have a nightmare teen on your hands.

The behaviour you describe is dreadful and I wouldn't have tolerated it for a minute with my children.

You need to firm up your parenting boundaries before you have a real problem.

I have reared 4 children without ever having to deal with tantrums.

Not because I am a great parent, but because I wouldn't have ever tolerated tantruming behaviour.

I know teens have hormones and can be moody but if it strayed into rudeness to me they would have been pulled up not to speak to me like that.

It is possible to rear privileged children without them being spoiled brats, but it is absolutely dependent on parents establishing what behaviour is expected of them.

thelobsterquadrille · 23/12/2022 13:15

That she is used to getting what she wants, even when she has behaved in an unreasonable way, and when we are trying to go out and have fun. So it comes across as not appreciating treats.

But that's not her fault.

If you've always given her whatever she wants, regardless of her behaviour, why would she suddenly change her ways now?

Nowthenhere · 23/12/2022 13:15

Sounds like he's exhausted. Does she get much down time? Sometimes just wanting to switch off can look like bad behaviour. Read between the lines and ask her if she needs some quality time just doing calm things about the the house with just you etc.