Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not let daughter join in

135 replies

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 12:30

We have some issues with my DD’s behaviour. She is generally a lovely kid - kind, conscientious, does well at school, etc.
However, I am worried that she is becoming quite entitled and spoilt. We do well enough financially to pay for our kids to do lots of extra-curricular clubs, go on nice trips, buy whatever big toys they ask for at Christmas, within reason, etc (this year she’s getting a drum kit and only a few small presents to go with that as it’s so expensive). As a child, my upbringing was different as We didn’t have much money.
I’m worried that this is all being taken for granted and she does not appreciate the value of things and how lucky she is. She’s become very demanding, and doesn’t seem excited about trips and activities we book. Today, we booked a Tag Active session, as it was raining and we wanted to get out of the house. She loves Tag Active. She woke in a foul mood, ordered us around, tried to get us to change the time of the session, tried to engage in long arguments over small issues like the dress code at the venue, refused to get out of bed, or get dressed, refused to put shoes on or get in the car. This happens a lot. If she is in a bad mood, it’s as if she’s on a mission to ruin the moods of everyone else in the house. She often ruins trips out. She can be very argumentative and sulky.
So, she is now going to Tag Active, but as a spectator to watch her brother do it. I feel there needs to be some consequence for the way she speaks to us. She showed no excitement or gratefulness for the fact that we were treating her today. I am sick of having to go through this with her, and feel that she needs to learn that the way she acts and speaks to others has consequences. I don’t want her to grow up to be a spoilt, entitled, little rich kid. Do you think I’m being too harsh? We have lots of lovely times together, but if things don’t go her way, or she feels annoyed about something, it’s a real challenge dealing with her attitude.

OP posts:
TheUsualChaos · 23/12/2022 15:24

Yep, as soon as you said she is 10, I thought hormones! She sounds tired and moody. Not excusing the behaviour but actually maybe consider if she does too many actives. Sometimes less is more. They need plenty of downtime at this age.

WelshNerd · 23/12/2022 15:20

I really want to go to Tag active after reading the OP. Sounds great.

Yanbu.

bellac11 · 23/12/2022 15:17

I think this sounds like good parenting, natural consequences. Of course she wont like it and has tantrumed and so you're now questioning yourself.

midlifecrash · 23/12/2022 15:15

I have a colleague who is sometimes a bit like this - moody, wants to change agreed things at the last minute, trying to make everything run to her timetable or with a finishing touch by her. It probably does stem from anxiety but it is exhausting and I am going to look for another job.

Blondlashes · 23/12/2022 15:13

Things to do that don’t cost too much money and do involve spending time together and have encouraged my child and I to chat:
Going for a walk in the country side - there are books and websites with circular walks
Swimming
Playing board games.

Mine from a young age have looked after small pets when the owners are on holiday. Rabbits, fish, Guinea pigs. Earnt a little money and some responsibility

Does she have chores? eg bring the washing to the washing machine, sorting the recycling, emptying the dishwasher etc. No reward for these or her allowance is dependent on these being completed. These activities are part of participating in family life.

Nocutenamesleft · 23/12/2022 15:12

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 12:48

This is my concern. I agree. We don’t do loads, but I am worried the kids have no awareness of the monetary value of anything. I was definitely aware when we were young. That’s part of the reason why I said she must sit out today.

My husband had a wealthy childhood, and I’m trying to get him to realise that we need to make sure we are not ‘rewarding’ bad behaviour by going ahead with treats, when we are receiving rude, demanding behaviours.

In your OP you said you do lots of extra-curricular activities. But in this post you said you don’t do loads!!?

it sounds very much like you’ve got a spoilt daughter alongside a very tired and probably hormonal one

i take it she doesn’t have SEN at all?

CottonSock · 23/12/2022 15:10

My 9.5yo doesn't want for much, loads of activities etc- so possibly a bit spolit in terms of what she has. However, she is polite and grateful. I think you need to get a lot tougher.

wildseas · 23/12/2022 15:00

On a more overall thought, I don’t think it’s problematic that children take their normal for granted - it’s part of creating a sense of security - and that sense of security is a huge part of why people strive to be financially comfortable.

In terms of teaching them the value of money I wonder whether you have ever really talked about your childhood with them. 10 seems a good age to start having more nuanced conversation about things like that.

Id also suggest that Christmas is a really good time to start talking and learning about charity. Do you do anything like food bank donations? Do you make charity donations? Do you volunteer ? Now might be a good time to start sharing with the kids what you do and why, and maybe get the kids involved in something new.

toffeeapple77 · 23/12/2022 14:59

I agree with others on here that when you don't have money as a child you are very aware of it. Trying to teach the opposite to a child is much more difficult. Their age means they take things as a given / it's how things have always been and it would be unreasonable for them, at 10, to go around practicing self awareness about the haves and have nots.
That said, you can expect politeness and reasonable behaviour (not necessarily gratitude), and are right to punish bad behaviour.

gamerchick · 23/12/2022 14:54

I'd say puberty is on its way. It sucks a lot.

You're doing the right thing with consequences and I agree with a PP that praise the good stuff and install natural consequences for the negative will probably go a long way in navigating it.

I'd also start the chores thing also if she doesn't already.

soundsystem · 23/12/2022 14:50

Is she NT? Just because she sounds very like my autistic 9-year-old who - actually - just sometimes really has difficulty with anxiety and transitions, even doing things she really really wants to do. And then the difficulty in communication kicks in and it comes off as bratty-ness...

(The description in your first post - kind, conscientious, does well at school - applies to my DD too!)

Bookworm20 · 23/12/2022 14:47

I think you have done exactly the right thing OP.

You have noticed a pattern of entitled behaviour and are now addressing it. And a consequence of missing the activity after the morning shenanigans from her is a perfect way of letting her know she cannot do/say whatever she wants and still gets to join in with treats.

So I think you are handling it well. She may well tantrum as shes used to getting whatever she wants, but it won't take long for her to realise you mean business now and actions have consequences. If shes behaving entitled at 10, imagine if you don't address it what she would be like at 13!

I know of a couple of young teens (friends of dds) who seem to have never heard the word no, and they are absolutely awful to be around. In my opinion their parents have actually done them a huge disservice by giving them whatever they want, when they want and zero consequences for bratty behaviour, as they come across as not very nice dc much of the time. I have heard them talk to their parents like absolute shit, its quite shocking.

So stick in there. Giving consequences is what a loving parent does, because you want your dc to grow up with values and not be one one of those spoilt kids noone likes.

Its termed 'spoiling' your child for a reason. As thats exactly what it does.

Also never heard of tag active before, but it sounds fun!

billy1966 · 23/12/2022 14:41

Slapping a child is absolutely not necessary to instil manners and good behaviour.

I found saying "your behaviour is unacceptable, you must be very tired, we will take a complete break from all technology/TV for a couple of days" worked a treat.

After doing it a couple of times I only had to start the sentence and it had the desired effect.

Children change their behaviour out of self interest IMO.

So making it in THEIR interest to behave well worked in my house.

Remaining absolutely calm and in control of yourself is far more lethal in parenting terms.

I very rarely had to punished my children because I ALWAYS followed through with a threat.

So they knew if I warned of a consequence it WOULD happen and that was usually enough.

I removed the PS4 for a weekend because my boys were getting into a habit of roaring at each as to who was going to go on with their friends.

They were bereft!...........but they never roared at each other like that again.

One of my children used to drive me mad in the morning by keeping me waiting in the car so I told them I would start driving off without them and they could bus.......and I did.

They couldn't believe it, but they were in the car the following morning.
It worked for a while and things started to slide and I didn't give a warning, I just drove off without them.

Again it worked.

Once children know you mean what you say life is much calmer for everyone!😁

"You choose that behaviour, you accept the consequences" is a great saying.

GrinAndVomit · 23/12/2022 14:37

YANBU

She’s ten. She’s old enough to reconsider her behaviour at any point in the morning. She didn’t. She continuously attempted to ruin it for her brother.

She now misses out on the fun that she tried to ruin.

Good for you, mum.

FlibbertyGibbitt · 23/12/2022 14:32

You have bought her a drum set ? 😱

Choconut · 23/12/2022 14:31

You can't 'make' someone appreciate something, especially things they have always had, had for a long time or haven't had to work for. She doesn't currently feel lucky because she's never known anything different.

You know someone can only argue if the other person argues back. Just don't get into it with her. Tell her it's the dress code and she is free to disagree with it but if she doesn't follow it then she won't be able to participate - her choice and you won't be discussing it further. If she tries to argue just walk away. Insist that if she wants something then she asks nicely (I mean she should have been learning that since she was three). Don't allow her to order you around - 'I think you're old enough to do that yourself'. If she's rude 'please don't talk to me like that' and walk away.

Maybe she's starting to need more independence. Choosing her own clothes, making her own breakfast, making her own lunch, making dinner for everyone, hoovering her bedroom, taking more responsibility for things, feeding/walking any pets, that sort of thing. That's what I did when ds starting being a bit like this, gave him more and more responsibility for things and I think it really helped him to grow up a bit and appreciate more what others did for him. Perhaps even give her a budget for activities and she has to decide how to spend it.

Littlemissprosecco · 23/12/2022 14:19

Sometimes it can be as simple as going back to basics, it might be hard, but just spending proper time together without spending any money and truly appreciating the simple things is the way to go. So a walk in the park, whatever the weather, laugh if you all get completely soaked, bake simple biscuits, homemade pizzas. Forget about the niceness that money brings.

Riu · 23/12/2022 14:16

The thing is, the activity probably isn’t very exciting for her. It is all relative. You have created a situation and now you are punishing her for not reacting with gratitude. You sound guilty about your privileged life. Dial down the treat activities and go for a walk if you feel need to get out.

pointythings · 23/12/2022 14:13

Good old-fashioned parenting absolutely doesn't include hitting! It just means teaching the word No from as soon as language emerges. So you've missed the boat a bit, but it can be saved. If she misbehaves, you give a warning and inform her of the consequence, and if the behaviour continues she gets the consequence. Any tantrumming afterwards is met with a 'you were told this would happen and you didn't listen' and repeat. Calmly.

Mariposista · 23/12/2022 13:57

Well done you! Stamp out bratty behaviour like a fag butt!!!

Blossomtoes · 23/12/2022 13:54

I am worried the kids have no awareness of the monetary value of anything. I was definitely aware when we were young.

I had zero awareness when I was ten and I’m pretty sad that my son did. The way to teach it is to make her choose between two things she wants and not give her both. Expecting gratitude from a ten year old for things that are part of her normality is a fruitless exercise.

OriginalUsername2 · 23/12/2022 13:54

So she’s supposed to act like everything is special even though it’s a normal day for her to get everything she wants? That would require some actual acting!

Theres a reason why rich and famous people who can get anything they want turn to drugs.

Just like Christmas would lose its charm if we did it too often.

NancyJoan · 23/12/2022 13:53

I’m not sure the two are as related as you think they are.

She’s rude, stroppy, manipulative - and is hopefully realising today the consequence of that. No NT 10 yr old should be tantrumming, for any reason.

Your lifestyle is a separate thing. Being able to do extra curricular stuff/have holidays etc is great, and it’s what you are working to give her and your son. It’s unreasonable to expect children to be grateful for that, though, when they have only known that, and their friends prob all do the same.

To answer your question, you’re right not to let her join in. No one gets to behave like that and still do the nice thing, regardless of how much money they do or don’t have (I know it’s hard when things have been booked and paid for).

scooobie · 23/12/2022 13:53

BeepyBoo · 23/12/2022 12:39

I would like to add, in anticipation of responses here, that this is not an attention-seeking thing as a result of not spending time with us or being shipped around. I was a stay-at-home Mum and I now only work part-time. Dad works from home. The extra-curricular activities she does are ones she’s requested to do - I am up for cutting them back, but she doesn’t want to. She wanted to go to Tag Active today and is now very upset that she’s missing out.
I think this is to do with her getting everything she wants, and not realising lots of children don’t. It’s become her norm, and that worries me.

I work full time and the reason my 10 year old is sometimes challenging is totally because of that and nothing to do with being tired at the end of a long school term and the hormones cursing through her body.

10 is a tough age.

diddl · 23/12/2022 13:49

Did she really want o do it or only because her brother was?

I know it's an activity but it's still indoors.