Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex MIL’s hoarding

108 replies

SantasBigToe · 23/12/2022 11:55

I have posted about this before under several different usernames. It always flares up at Christmas, but happens throughout the year to a lesser extent. Ex MIL is a hoarder. She sends us a lot of her hoarded junk, at every opportunity, especially Christmas. I have asked her multiple times, and in as kind a way as possible, to please stop. She spoke to me months ago about a stack of books she wanted to send for Christmas. I asked her not to. One was a book I already own. I told her this. She has sent it anyway. One book is for dd and quite inappropriate for her age. Ex MIL warned me before sending and I asked her not to send it. She sent it anyway.
AIBU (or ungrateful) to dump them at the nearest charity shop? I am fed up with the boxes and boxes of old junk and second hand clothes she keeps sending (that she finds on eBay and in charity shops). She doesn’t have much money, but what she does have she spends on “bargains” that she either hoards or sends to us. She calls me rude and ungrateful when I ask her to stop sending us her junk. So far this month she had sent 5 small boxes of ornaments, a big bag of clothes and the 6 books.
The last time I posted about this the advice was to give it all to my ex to deal with. I have been doing this, but the kids still end up with it and it works its way back to our house.

OP posts:
Elleherd · 24/12/2022 11:42

People think this is part of hoarding disorder because a type of compulsive shopper who often also hoards, does it.
Once told it's upsetting others most will stop because the enjoyment is gone, but there is a controlling type of aquirer who will continue, because for them it's about control, not 'quality blindness' and an 'it's cheap and will do for X' attitude.

astronewt · 24/12/2022 11:40

Just agree with her that you are rude and ungrateful. Calling you that is a manipulation strategy. She does it because it works. Accepting the label tends to seriously take the wind out of people's sails. "Yep. I'm rude and ungrateful. And I'm throwing this stuff straight in the bin."

SantasBigToe · 24/12/2022 11:33

BeverlyHa · 24/12/2022 11:20

She loves your kids and wants to give with the little money she has.

She sends me a lot of junk too, not just the kids! Mainly crap off ebay(crop tops, dirty clothes, broken ornaments...)

OP posts:
SantasBigToe · 24/12/2022 11:31

BeverlyHa · 24/12/2022 11:20

She loves your kids and wants to give with the little money she has.

Yes she loves the kids, but she spends a fortune on junk rather than buying anything nice or new. Most of the junk has just been sat covered in dust for years. Surely if it was about the kids though she’d give them appropriate gifts? One year she sent them anatomy books for university students. They were aged 3 and 9 at the time.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 24/12/2022 11:25

If it’s recorded delivery-refuse the package.

BeverlyHa · 24/12/2022 11:20

She loves your kids and wants to give with the little money she has.

SantasBigToe · 24/12/2022 11:17

My ex sent me a photo of the book. It was 50p from a charity shop! The label still stuck on it! I fell less bad about rejecting it.

OP posts:
upfucked · 23/12/2022 21:24

My MIL does this every now and then. Last time it was second hand ballet shoes for a child who doesn’t even do ballet. DH reject it every time even if it’s something useful. It’s a he only way PIL get the message for a while.

They encourage the kids to bring home toys from the ridiculous amount they have at their house. We always return them next visit.

IncompleteSenten · 23/12/2022 21:16

SantasBigToe · 23/12/2022 12:49

Last time he visited her he came back with a boot full of bin bags of her junk which she said were “gifts” for us. Cuddly toys from the 90s covered in inches of dust, moth eaten books and clothes. She recently sent us some items of clothing off eBay that were filthy and huge sizes. Why oh why?!?!

The why is that she's a hoarder.
She will never stop.
It is up to you to take control.
Refuse to accept parcels at the door - you can do that. They are returned to the sender.
Tell her anything sent to your home will be thrown straight in the bin.
Don't let your ex set one foot inside your home with bags of shit from her. Tell him he either takes it to his place or puts it directly into your bin.

Unless you are willing to stop her, nothing will change.

FictionalCharacter · 23/12/2022 17:18

Elleherd · 23/12/2022 13:44

That's not about hoarding disorder even though it involves 'stuff' from it.

Forcing it on others as supposed presents after being asked not to, is about control, not hoarding.

It's no different from someone continuously sending someone they know to be vegetarian, animal products and calling them gifts because they can get it cheap, and on top of that saying they're ungrateful for not accepting it happily. Try other analogies, and hopefully it will help you see what's actually going on here.

You've told her to stop offloading it onto you, and she's refusing.

Your ex is enabling her.

Two options: return it ALL every time, or if you can't stop ex from giving it to the kids , inform her it will ALL be going in the bin every time.

Exactly this. The ex should absolutely not be enabling this.
I remember your previous thread. You have to be prepared to get much tougher and to be prepared to “upset” both this very sick woman and your spineless ex. Refuse every delivery. If anything just appears on your doorstep, take it back and dump it on hers. Literally on her doorstep so it’s in the way, and leave a stern letter with it. Or throw it on her garden, or in her wheelie bin. Get angry with her, really angry. Get angry with your ex too.
Don’t give it back to the charity shops, it just gives them more work to do.

Rubyupbeat · 23/12/2022 17:02

If she is doing it out of kindness, I would just thank her and then take it to the charity shop.

Oomph · 23/12/2022 16:57

Send it all straight to charity. She gets to give, you save yourself the effort of asking her not to send it, and ultimately someone will benefit.

At this stage you won’t change her behaviour.

JoyBeorge · 23/12/2022 16:56

I'd donate it all to her local charity shops. Eventually the penny will drop.

greenhousegal · 23/12/2022 16:52

Put some money away to rewrap parcel and send back recorded delivery.

Refuse delivery if recorded.

Bring it back and leave at her door.

I know it's not easy, and it appears that you do not want to offend her or something. She does not care if she is driving you crackers, so bite the bullet and do one of the above. What's the worst that can happen? She cuts contact? She is your EX MOTHER IN LAW, EX EX EX. Do it. It will empower you.

ChateauMargaux · 23/12/2022 16:43

That sounds like truly awful behaviour. If it's recorded deliveries - refuse, every time. Write her a letter, write your ex a letter - tell them it is not up for discussion, if they consider that you are rude, then they have a right to think that but it will not change your stance on this.

Celloma · 23/12/2022 16:32

She's your ex MIL. Be tough. Either refuse every parcel or take straight to the charity shop. Tell her every time that the stuff is unwelcome.

MinnieGirl · 23/12/2022 16:30

SantasBigToe · 23/12/2022 15:11

She sends it all recorded delivery so that she can make sure it is delivered. She then texts me to ask if I got it, because she can see it has been delivered and I have not yet “thanked” her for it. 🤷🏻‍♀️

So refuse delivery.

TheNoodlesIncident · 23/12/2022 16:29

Cuddly toys from the 90s covered in inches of dust, moth eaten books and clothes. She recently sent us some items of clothing off eBay that were filthy and huge sizes.

Please don't dump this kind of thing on charity shops. They don't deserve the extra hassle of dealing with your ex-MIL's crap. They can't sell rubbish like that without spending a lot of time and energy on it - and it's probably not worth that in the end. Just bin crud like this.

If she's sending things recorded delivery or tracked, refuse to accept them at the door. If the postie signs for them and leaves them (they shouldn't but it's not unknown) just bin them. Tell her you will be doing this with anything she sends you as you have told her to stop.

fatsocatso · 23/12/2022 16:23

SantasBigToe · 23/12/2022 15:11

She sends it all recorded delivery so that she can make sure it is delivered. She then texts me to ask if I got it, because she can see it has been delivered and I have not yet “thanked” her for it. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Come on, OP, if it's recorded delivery then you simply refuse the parcel. Every single time. I agree with PP who say this is a you problem. You said you've posted multiple times about the same problem. You've had great, simple, effective advice here. I'm guessing you've had the same advice on previous threads, so unless you are prepared to upset her further (which you will if you really want this to stop), then you're just going to have put up with it for as long as it pleases her to do it. I mean this kindly because it's clearly frustrating you, but you'll need to find your big girl pants or just accept it.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 23/12/2022 15:52

SantasBigToe · 23/12/2022 15:11

She sends it all recorded delivery so that she can make sure it is delivered. She then texts me to ask if I got it, because she can see it has been delivered and I have not yet “thanked” her for it. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Two choices there.

  1. Refuse the delivery so it gets sent back to her.
  2. Accept the delivery and take it straight to the bin, drop it in and close the lid.
newnamequickly · 23/12/2022 15:49

If she's a horder she's trying to relocate her things without parting with them completely. Classic horder stuff.

What she asking if you without saying it in words is 'please dispose of these things for me as I can't do it myself'.

That's it. Charity shop or the tip.

The only grind is she'll think she's doing you favour after favour by dumping stuff on you.

Bestcatmum · 23/12/2022 15:37

Hoarders so this I'm afraid, the only way they are prepared to get rid of any of their hoard is to give it away.
My first husband is a hoarder and he keeps sending the stuff to my DS who is 40 now.
It drives him crackers. He burnt the last lot on a big bonfire and sent the photo to my ex.
I have no idea how my ex reacted to this but I bet he was really angry.

Paq · 23/12/2022 15:32

Do you need to be in contact with her? Can you block her number/email?

BMW6 · 23/12/2022 15:30

Well tell her you are certainly not going to thank her for persisting in sending you stuff that you don't want and have repeatedly asked her to bloody STOP SENDING IT

Blondlashes · 23/12/2022 15:26

It’s horsing. I would refuse to take delivery. She will be very upset. But that’s the controlling part of borders.
Will your ex support you ? I’m refusing the parcels? He may be the key to this.