Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how the huge American families can afford it?

104 replies

00100001 · 23/12/2022 11:32

So you have blogging families who have like 9,10,11,12+ kids.

HOW??

OP posts:
MadCattery · 24/12/2022 01:40

Drivers Ed is offered in schools. Here in Florida, they used to be legally required to offer it. I don’t know if it’s different now but I know the kids in my county do. Some instructors in school are authorized to certify that a student has met the testing requirements and the teen can get a license that way. I wasn’t that good, so spent a couple more years practicing. Once you have a learners permit, you may drive in any car with any licensed driver who is over 21.

As for swimming, I think some people do pay, but in Coastal Florida it is considered a critical skill. Swim lessons are through recreation centers, service clubs, private clubs, community centers. I suppose some people make a little money by teaching privately, but I don’t know anyone who learned that way.

GarlandsinGreece · 24/12/2022 01:29

Salaries are much higher. The average cop in the US earns $55k, but often they earn way more with overtime. Our local police and fire chiefs earn $250k per year.

lurkinglittleladybug · 24/12/2022 01:14

Families like the duggars/ Bates etc make money from the reality TV shows they do, and books and stuff.

Before they were famous ‘God would provide’ … They would get charity from church, buy clothes from thrift stores/ hand me downs and they would all be crammed into a too small house and sharing bedrooms. I imagine it would be awful for the children all living on top of each other like that, having to follow strict religious rules and dress codes, unable to have any privacy and growing up homeschooled without much social interaction outside the family, also older kids having to be parents to their younger siblings … Sounds like a recipe for childhood trauma and potential abuse. The eldest Duggar brother apparently abused his sisters and is now in prison for child abuse images on his computer…

Also they seem to be expected to marry the first person they date, and not allowed to have their first kiss till they marry. I also suspect they teach against contraception. Personally I think it’s irresponsible keep having children without the space, money and time needed for them.

BritWifeInUSA · 24/12/2022 01:00

I don’t have a dozen children but I do live in the US. Families like the Duggars are not a good example of how large families live here. Before TV found them they lived in an old, small house. I think they had 3 bedrooms and at that stage 15 or so children. Along came TLC and found them and suddenly they move into the big tin mansion, the children are having music lessons, and they’re going on overseas trips. Just as the Radfords are not really raising 20+ children on the income of a small pie shop (and anyone who believes that they are needs a calculator), the Duggars and other TV/Instagram families are being paid handsomely through sponsorships, etc.

Housing, fuel, and taxes are lower here. Everything else is more expensive but wages are higher. We have a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom house with an office, double garage, hobby shed, pool, hot tub, a few acres of land and we are oceanfront. Cost? $250k. Bought 3 years ago. My salary is $182k a year doing the same job I was paid £70k in the UK for. My taxes are less than 20%. In the UK I was in the 40% bracket and there was NI on top too. Sales tax (equivalent of VAT) is less than 10% in this state. It’s easier to be better off here.

socialmedia23 · 24/12/2022 00:53

00100001 · 23/12/2022 21:59

I am.

It's just intend to see more American families in SM I suppose.

Like someone (I think the Dougherty Dozen) or something did a Costco "haul" the bought something like600 bottles of water, 300 bottles of Gatorade,250 Sunny D and 100 bottles of Fruit Shoot equivalent (can't remember the name) it's jus got me wondering how can they afford that kind of thing. They're hardly essentials.

Yes, it would probably be more interesting to see how a family raises 11 kids in the UK with everything being more expensive in relative terms.

There are ultra orthodox Jewish families with 12 kids. Mainly live in London or Manchester so not the cheapest places. Kosher food is generally more expensive too..they do manage it so it does exist here's.

BritWifeInUSA · 24/12/2022 00:49

elp30 · 23/12/2022 23:45

I'm American, from Texas, and I no one paid for my swimming lessons or my driving lessons. In fact, I paid for swimming lessons from my pocket money at the YWCA and I didn't learn to drive until I was 28 because only then could I afford the lessons.

No driver’s ed offered at your school?

Dibbydoos · 24/12/2022 00:31

I've just come back from 9 days on Long Island, NY and I can confirm supermarket prices there are through the roof, even Lidl was expensive - about 2 to 2.5 times more than here. I was shocked. My friends house was $750k it's about 1500sq feet - same as my house in West Midlands which is valued c£450k. Outside of the city and now 'well to do' areas, houses are much cheaper.
We were told that base salaries in NY are c$80k, so quite a bit more than UK salaries, so maybe they can afford more kids... However imo having that many kids is immoral when we're facing a climate emergency...

LateAF · 24/12/2022 00:29

MadCattery · 24/12/2022 00:09

i am American and love to visit this site and love reading about life there, so it makes sense that people would be curious about here. Especially if what you know of Americans is from watching TV or online. That said,I have to say that I can’t remember being without health insurance except maybe when I was very young. It’s offered at most jobs. And the cost for family coverage is the same, regardless of the family size. My son is 33, I have know people in four different states who have had babies over the years and have friends in nursing (delivery) and never heard of a mother being put on a “ward” until I came here to mumsnet. Even the poorest mother gets Medicaid, which is government insurance for the poor, and she will get a private room like anyone else. Some people choose midwives, but most people have a doctor deliver. As for vacation time, I think I get more than average with 27 full days off a year. I am not rich, by a long shot. I earn $52,000 a year and DH is on disability and a part time job so adds maybe $20,000-so we are really very average here. My house is small, 1200 square feet and a large garage. It would cost about $400,000 to buy now. I live in Florida and never heard of anyone having to pay for swim or driving lessons. I think the average American family has less than two children now. A family with more than four is extremely unusual, a family with eleven kids is rare, usually half adopted. And not everyone eats processed crap. I work full time and when I say I cook from scratch, I mean I can turn out a loaf of bread without an issue, and bake and cook everything myself. Son is a chef and also cooks, as do most of my friends. I love reading mumsnet and I know people on mumsnet are fascinated by the different life here, too. I have learned so much about another country just by being on this site, and I hope people will look at our part of the world with an open mind, too.

Thanks for the insight- that’s fascinating. The average family home in the UK is 1000sq ft so your home wouldn’t be considered small here- though I can imagine relative to American standards it’s small.

Who pays for swimming or driving lessons if you don’t- are they provided free of charge by the government?

MadCattery · 24/12/2022 00:09

i am American and love to visit this site and love reading about life there, so it makes sense that people would be curious about here. Especially if what you know of Americans is from watching TV or online. That said,I have to say that I can’t remember being without health insurance except maybe when I was very young. It’s offered at most jobs. And the cost for family coverage is the same, regardless of the family size. My son is 33, I have know people in four different states who have had babies over the years and have friends in nursing (delivery) and never heard of a mother being put on a “ward” until I came here to mumsnet. Even the poorest mother gets Medicaid, which is government insurance for the poor, and she will get a private room like anyone else. Some people choose midwives, but most people have a doctor deliver. As for vacation time, I think I get more than average with 27 full days off a year. I am not rich, by a long shot. I earn $52,000 a year and DH is on disability and a part time job so adds maybe $20,000-so we are really very average here. My house is small, 1200 square feet and a large garage. It would cost about $400,000 to buy now. I live in Florida and never heard of anyone having to pay for swim or driving lessons. I think the average American family has less than two children now. A family with more than four is extremely unusual, a family with eleven kids is rare, usually half adopted. And not everyone eats processed crap. I work full time and when I say I cook from scratch, I mean I can turn out a loaf of bread without an issue, and bake and cook everything myself. Son is a chef and also cooks, as do most of my friends. I love reading mumsnet and I know people on mumsnet are fascinated by the different life here, too. I have learned so much about another country just by being on this site, and I hope people will look at our part of the world with an open mind, too.

elp30 · 23/12/2022 23:45

Nancydrawn · 23/12/2022 23:27

Most Americans don't pay for swimming lessons or driving lessons. Maybe the former, though it can be cheap. But driving lessons are usually done by family members on private land or in a big parking lot (at certain schools there are driving lessons, but they tend to be brief/large). In rural places, a lot of kids are taught to drive really young (like 13 or 14) on private land or back roads. And a lot of the children I've met here just were taught to swim by family too. It was very different from my own experience at home, but it makes a certain degree of sense.

Food and cars tend to be more expensive. Petrol, housing, and taxes are less. Most of these families don't go on holidays outside of visiting family or going to national parks.

I'm American, from Texas, and I no one paid for my swimming lessons or my driving lessons. In fact, I paid for swimming lessons from my pocket money at the YWCA and I didn't learn to drive until I was 28 because only then could I afford the lessons.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 23/12/2022 23:38

Out of over 330 million people, you're seeing a handful of wealthy ones, ones with inherited property and land, ones with jobs that are far better paid compared to in the UK, and they've fitted a particular demographic (usually white/preferably blond and almost always Protestant of some description) that attracts interest from people and sponsors. It's a larger pool for these people to emerge from.

Nancydrawn · 23/12/2022 23:27

Most Americans don't pay for swimming lessons or driving lessons. Maybe the former, though it can be cheap. But driving lessons are usually done by family members on private land or in a big parking lot (at certain schools there are driving lessons, but they tend to be brief/large). In rural places, a lot of kids are taught to drive really young (like 13 or 14) on private land or back roads. And a lot of the children I've met here just were taught to swim by family too. It was very different from my own experience at home, but it makes a certain degree of sense.

Food and cars tend to be more expensive. Petrol, housing, and taxes are less. Most of these families don't go on holidays outside of visiting family or going to national parks.

Ugzbugz · 23/12/2022 22:58

Have you seen the dougherty dozens outgoings????

Wheredoallthepensgo · 23/12/2022 22:57

@Cantstandbullshit Thank you mam, and in the spirit of Christmas let’s stop creating foolish threads to bash and make fun of other people

That's three quarters of the Internet gone then Grin the rest is just cat videos

GrouchyKiwi · 23/12/2022 22:38

Changechangychange · 23/12/2022 22:35

@Cuppasoupmonster I thought we were talking about a specific, famous Mormon homesteading/home ed family - obviously not all large families live on farms, home educate, or are deeply religious. But that particular family do.

I don't know if we're talking about the same family here? I wouldn't think the one I'm thinking of is famous.

Changechangychange · 23/12/2022 22:35

@Cuppasoupmonster I thought we were talking about a specific, famous Mormon homesteading/home ed family - obviously not all large families live on farms, home educate, or are deeply religious. But that particular family do.

GrouchyKiwi · 23/12/2022 22:34

For a start they don’t all live on farms Wink secondly, when you have loads of kids they’re never the same age, usually a mix of babies through to mid or older teens. So many people now have 2 kids 2 years apart that they’re used to only parenting one age category at a time. Teens can make their own lunch, get themselves to school, do most of their own chores like laundry etc. So the pressure is off there. It’s not ‘unpaid labour’ to occasionally watch your younger sibling or have chores to do in the family home.
This is a good point too. When you have a large family you might have adult children and still have babies/pre-schoolers in the house. The adult children might have left home.

My two youngest sisters were born when I was a teenager, and I'm the 3rd child in our family. My oldest sister was a uni when #6 came along, and then big bro and I were at uni when #7 was born and big sis had started working.

Cuppasoupmonster · 23/12/2022 22:24

Changechangychange · 23/12/2022 22:05

Yeah but how does that work? Where do you find the time/energy to homeschool 15 children, cook, clean, do laundry for an enormous family, run a successful business and grow your own food

If you have 15 kids, most of them are unpaid labour. The older girls will do the cooking and cleaning and look after the younger kids. The older boys will be working on the farm.

None of them are going to college or swimming lessons (local municipal pool will likely be an hour’s drive away, so that isn’t really a thing in really rural areas).

This is kind of bollocksy and a misconception about big families.

For a start they don’t all live on farms Wink secondly, when you have loads of kids they’re never the same age, usually a mix of babies through to mid or older teens. So many people now have 2 kids 2 years apart that they’re used to only parenting one age category at a time. Teens can make their own lunch, get themselves to school, do most of their own chores like laundry etc. So the pressure is off there. It’s not ‘unpaid labour’ to occasionally watch your younger sibling or have chores to do in the family home.

So many kids are lazy/selfish/incompetent now, relying on their parents to do everything for them - I know 16 year olds who still have their packed lunch made and all their cleaning and laundry done by their mum. It’s actually very good for older kids and teens to take responsibility for themselves, learn to live communally and not have their parents catering to their every last whim.

GrouchyKiwi · 23/12/2022 22:23

Changechangychange · 23/12/2022 22:05

Yeah but how does that work? Where do you find the time/energy to homeschool 15 children, cook, clean, do laundry for an enormous family, run a successful business and grow your own food

If you have 15 kids, most of them are unpaid labour. The older girls will do the cooking and cleaning and look after the younger kids. The older boys will be working on the farm.

None of them are going to college or swimming lessons (local municipal pool will likely be an hour’s drive away, so that isn’t really a thing in really rural areas).

I don't know exactly how they do it, but the Mum seems to have boundless energy. And she's bloody good at organising, which I suspect is a must. Some of the children have, in fact, gone to college. They choose their life path and she helps them follow it, whether that's college or entrepreneurship. The older ones all seem to have fulfilling careers (and of course, you only see the best stuff on social media.)

I'm one of seven children, and yeah, you do get used to helping out around the house, but IMO that's not a bad thing. I had to teach my husband how to do household stuff because his parents (Dad too) did it all for him as he was growing up. That was annoying. I also knew how to take care of babies when I had my own so that was jolly helpful. None of the childcare element of having a baby was a problem, just the parenting bit. Wink

It's an older fashioned lifestyle with the help of the technology our grandparents didn't have. Much easier to keep on top of laundry with a washing machine and dryer, or keep the house clean with a vacuum cleaner. Not the life for me, but that family seems to do it well.

MissTrip82 · 23/12/2022 22:18

I grew up with families of 9-13 (not in the US). They mostly had multiple children in one bedroom and did stuff like go to the bakery and buy the bread that they had left at the end of the day etc. They had an apple for a snack, not a punnet of blueberries. Things like that.

Changechangychange · 23/12/2022 22:05

Yeah but how does that work? Where do you find the time/energy to homeschool 15 children, cook, clean, do laundry for an enormous family, run a successful business and grow your own food

If you have 15 kids, most of them are unpaid labour. The older girls will do the cooking and cleaning and look after the younger kids. The older boys will be working on the farm.

None of them are going to college or swimming lessons (local municipal pool will likely be an hour’s drive away, so that isn’t really a thing in really rural areas).

Untitledsquatboulder · 23/12/2022 22:00

GrouchyKiwi · 23/12/2022 13:15

One of the home edding families I follow in the US has 15 children (half of the children are adopted). Both parents work - the father outside the home, the mother started a very successful business creating home ed resource books.

AFAIK, they have a large homestead-type house, and grow a lot of their own produce, so that helps. They also don't live in one of the big cities, but rather in a farming community.

Yeah but how does that work? Where do you find the time/energy to homeschool 15 children, cook, clean, do laundry for an enormous family, run a successful business and grow your own food.

00100001 · 23/12/2022 21:59

Baconking · 23/12/2022 13:13

Why are you only asking about American families?
I know a family in England with 11 children.
Are you not interested in how they afford it?

I am.

It's just intend to see more American families in SM I suppose.

Like someone (I think the Dougherty Dozen) or something did a Costco "haul" the bought something like600 bottles of water, 300 bottles of Gatorade,250 Sunny D and 100 bottles of Fruit Shoot equivalent (can't remember the name) it's jus got me wondering how can they afford that kind of thing. They're hardly essentials.

Yes, it would probably be more interesting to see how a family raises 11 kids in the UK with everything being more expensive in relative terms.

OP posts:
00100001 · 23/12/2022 21:55

Eupraxia · 23/12/2022 12:29

I'm not from USA and don't have a super sized family, but we do have four children (3 of which are now teens).

FYI after the first child (and definitely after the second child) each subsequent child costs less as a whole than first/second. For example:

  • we already have tons of tech in the house. So no need for younger children to have an xbox / tablet / phone / switch etc, because we already have multiple of these in the home
  • similarly, there's loads of existing toys, books, tons of legacy, arts and crafts stuff etc. So younger children grow up already having this stuff, therefore need for less
  • Clothes can be passed down or pooled. Currently my 3 teens and DH all fit in Mens Medium clothes. So we pool football tops, sports kit, designer name hoodie etc
  • Once you need more than a 5 seater car, adding extra one or two children doesn't mean bigger car us needed
  • Once you accept holidays need to be a massive villa rather than hotel, extra children doesn't add as much to the cost of holidays
  • If you embrace the children sharing rooms and they have space, no need for bigger house (that said, we did move so all ours could have own room)

Ok.

But things like (say) swimming lessons or clubs or going out as aa family or school events etc must be prohibitively expensive?

I can't imagine putting 4 kids though swimming lessons at the same sort time.

Or is it a case of them not doing things like that?

OP posts:
00100001 · 23/12/2022 21:52

coldfeetmama · 23/12/2022 13:43

I am from Scotland .. went to school with a boy who had 13 siblings

Now a nurse and have worked with a colleague who had 11 kids

Know if a family local to me with 9 boys

It has never occurred to me to wonder how they afford it because I mind my own fucking business

It's not a crime to be curious...

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread