Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how the huge American families can afford it?

104 replies

00100001 · 23/12/2022 11:32

So you have blogging families who have like 9,10,11,12+ kids.

HOW??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SleekMamma · 26/12/2022 18:29

These families come from communities where contraception or family planning is not allowed. At all. So therefore they have lots of children. Every woman should be allowed to plan her family imo.

MrsCarson · 24/12/2022 21:24

BritWifeInUSA

My kids did the drivers class in high school (California). It's no long the gym teacher with three kids in the car taking turns like my Dh did in the 70's. Now it's class based and they have to pass to get a pink slip that they take to DMV and apply for the Provisional license (learners permit as they call it) Rules changed to where we were they needed 4 professional lessons and the instructor told them what to practice before the next lesson. So they would drive me all over for practice. No extra cost on our insurance to have a learner driving, and no L plates.

knitnerd90 · 24/12/2022 18:14

The media-friendly hyper-Christian families are, I think, very unrepresentative. Most of these families don't have a lot of money. A lot of the churches who promote this lifestyle discourage higher education. The Duggars' group basically doesn't allow it. Some slightly more liberal ones do, but only at religious universities like Bob Jones or Liberty. They also tend to live in less expensive parts of the country, which makes housing more affordable. Some of them also don't believe in health insurance, like the Duggars, so they're just not paying for that either. They do those Christian "health shares" that aren't real insurance.

The LDS church (mormons) doesn't routinely provide members with assistance. Quite the opposite: you tithe 10% of your income and they check. If you don't pay your tithe, you don't get your temple recommend. What the church does give you are connections. If you're willing to work, you will have a job. The church also heavily subsidises tuition at BYU, which helps encourage LDS youth to marry young. It's not uncommon for them to marry while still at university.

The US taxes on joint income, which is more favourable to families where one spouse earns significantly more than the other. There is a large tax free allowance (If you don't itemise) and child tax credits. The tax system is hugely complicated but families with children do fairly well; the problem is that you're left to pay more of your health and child care costs. Salaries in the USA are higher in many fields. Housing here is as bad as UK, Canada, Australia if you're in a major city, and yes groceries are higher... though IME still not as bad as Canada or Australia.

Not all American houses are huge. They always show massive ones on TV and often news articles cite average sizes of new build houses--not all houses. New build size has gone up substantially over the years, not just because of buyer demand, but because of builder profit. The municipality will say to the builder, you can build X houses on Y acres. They can't build more houses to increase profit, but they can make each unit bigger as long as they don't exceed the buildable area per lot, and it's all profit since making a house bigger is relatively inexpensive. Since a lot of municipalities insist on relatively large lots, they can build massive houses. My house was built in the 1970s. It's nicely sized (about 2k SF), not as big as a modern one would be. But I have the same if not larger land size as a new build. Nowadays they'd put something nearly twice the size on it if they were allowed, though my county now insists on higher building density in most areas.

American housing stock and size varies quite a lot by age and location. So in East Coast cities you have row houses (terraces) that are quite like what you'd see in Britain. In LA and San Diego there's lots of small bungalows. 1950s suburban houses are relatively small: the original mass produced Levitt house was 750 SF (most have been renovated and expanded now) and the ranches and split levels were 1200-1500. There's still loads of Americans living in houses like that.

Whee · 24/12/2022 16:18

lurkinglittleladybug · 24/12/2022 01:14

Families like the duggars/ Bates etc make money from the reality TV shows they do, and books and stuff.

Before they were famous ‘God would provide’ … They would get charity from church, buy clothes from thrift stores/ hand me downs and they would all be crammed into a too small house and sharing bedrooms. I imagine it would be awful for the children all living on top of each other like that, having to follow strict religious rules and dress codes, unable to have any privacy and growing up homeschooled without much social interaction outside the family, also older kids having to be parents to their younger siblings … Sounds like a recipe for childhood trauma and potential abuse. The eldest Duggar brother apparently abused his sisters and is now in prison for child abuse images on his computer…

Also they seem to be expected to marry the first person they date, and not allowed to have their first kiss till they marry. I also suspect they teach against contraception. Personally I think it’s irresponsible keep having children without the space, money and time needed for them.

I agree there seems to be a big reliance on god (or the church) providing. Kendra Duggar (married into the Duggar family) was pregnant at the same time as her mother, who was on something like her 10th child. The parents were homeless so the Duggars provided a home for them. Imagine getting pregnant for a TENTH time when you can't afford to house the 9 you have. Kendra Duggar is fascinating in herself. Has had 4 children in about 4 years and is only about 22...

Blueisthecolour1 · 24/12/2022 14:22

@Wheredoallthepensgo

That's three quarters of the Internet gone then Grin the rest is just cat videos😆😆

thelobsterquadrille · 24/12/2022 13:30

Blueeyedgirl21 · 24/12/2022 13:24

The Collins kids are the most alarming to me
the mum says she will continue to get pregnant until basically it kills her

I recall the Duggar’s had a really tragic thing happen and baby number 22/23 I think , died. She was called Jubilee if I recall. The baby before her was also a girl who was a 24 weeker premature baby and was very ill. She recovered well but then they got pregnant again shortly after and the baby was even more premature and died. Just so sad. Seemed unnecessary to me but they believe they only stop when god feels it’s right. I follow a few families on Instagram with over 6 kids and they are all religious so don’t believe in contraception I think that’s why it’s often an American thing as the religion part of it can be unique to their culture

Karissa Collins is highly concerning - her youngest almost died of sepsis caused by an untreated UTI recently and she still posts photos of her in soaking nappies with urine dripping everywhere 😡

Blueeyedgirl21 · 24/12/2022 13:24

The Collins kids are the most alarming to me
the mum says she will continue to get pregnant until basically it kills her

I recall the Duggar’s had a really tragic thing happen and baby number 22/23 I think , died. She was called Jubilee if I recall. The baby before her was also a girl who was a 24 weeker premature baby and was very ill. She recovered well but then they got pregnant again shortly after and the baby was even more premature and died. Just so sad. Seemed unnecessary to me but they believe they only stop when god feels it’s right. I follow a few families on Instagram with over 6 kids and they are all religious so don’t believe in contraception I think that’s why it’s often an American thing as the religion part of it can be unique to their culture

MadCattery · 24/12/2022 13:15

2023willbemyyear asked “what have you learned about The UK from being on here, that you didn't know before, how different is your perception of life here from what it was before, and what are the things about The UK which you think are better or worse than The USA? Just super curious to know :)”. I didn’t want to quote the whole post, as it would take up the page! Mine tend to be too long. Well, husbands, families, cheeky fuckers, inflation woes, and jobs all seem to be things we have in common. The most surprising things, good and bad? Your food costs are so much lower. We have Aldi here, and yours costs less. But when I follow threads looking for meal ideas, I think our diets are far more varied. I don’t eat beef or pork, so no roasts, very little pasta and curry is an occasional thing to make at home. Our take out (“take away” there) tends to be pizza or Chinese. I don’t know if there is a place that I could order curry, or fish and chips, here. We eat a lot of fish, scallops, shrimp, chicken, etc. but not as much fried. We have a store here that sells British imports so I bought some of your bacon and I intend to use it for breakfast tomorrow, because I learned about it here and want to try it. Your homes seem to be attached to each other a lot, while most of ours aren’t. Familiarity with five different states here, and rarely see stairs. Most are just flat plain houses on a plot of land, with individual garages and driveways, so that seems surprising to me. We have very little open land left in this crowded corner of Florida, but everyone still owns a small bit of land. I was so surprised that in the UK it is common to let cats out to roam! Maybe because we have coyotes here, but nobody lets their cats out. Mine will step out on the patio and panic, looking to get back inside. Oh-and the thing about having a baby and being on a ward with other people is so strange to me! But I am as fascinated as you are with the differences in daily living! Here’s what an average, plain, typical house in my area looks like. www.redfin.com/FL/Seminole/9056-136th-St-33776/home/48072693

justgettingthroughtheday · 24/12/2022 11:18

I watch a few large families, two in the US and one in Canada. None of the ones discussed here though. They each have 8-9 kids.
They are more homesteading/ cooking channels too through.
But the one thing all 3 have in common is none of them regularly feature their children. They are around and sometimes dip into the videos but they are not the focus at all.
All of them homeschool and that is largely not shown but is discussed. So mum will tell us about what she's doing with them etc but you don't often see the kids participating in it as they are not in the videos.
Sometimes the older kids are in it. A few weeks ago one of the elder sons of one family was doing a bread making session and wanted to share his passion. Or a younger child might be with a parent doing jobs outside and so they naturally become involved but they are not exploiting their children in the way some of them do.
So not all of them are bad!

00100001 · 24/12/2022 11:12

Yes, there's been a phrase bandied about UK is a poor country where some rich people live

Britain and the US are poor societies with some very rich people Ftimes

Britain is a poor country pretending to be rich

OP posts:
Fishwifer · 24/12/2022 11:03

We are not a rich country in the UK.

www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2016/03/07/still-true-even-mississippi-is-richer-than-britain/amp/

wages are higher. We have a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom house with an office, double garage, hobby shed, pool, hot tub, a few acres of land and we are oceanfront. Cost? $250k. Bought 3 years ago. My salary is $182k a year doing the same job I was paid £70k in the UK for. My taxes are less than 20%. In the UK I was in the 40% bracket and there was NI on top too. Sales tax (equivalent of VAT) is less than 10% in this state. It’s easier to be better off here.

I've heard similar from colleagues with international experience, they are usually shocked at how little professional work (with huge responsibility) pays here. Those with mainland Europe experience are then also similarly shocked at how little we see for taxes - I won't repeat the words of a particularly blunt Danish guy I worked with about how terrible the childcare provision and quality is here, we all know he's right.

The UK is not a high productivity, high wage economy any more. Hasn't been for a long time.

Liorae · 24/12/2022 10:46

You expect the older of the 15 children to participate in the running of the home rather than demanding one mile lifts.

Comedycook · 24/12/2022 10:32

Fifi00 · 24/12/2022 09:57

Looking at the wages it's a lot higher for the same job I do here. I can get at least 120k usd which is nearly 100k, I'm a specialist nurse. 😳. If your DH was earning similar money it's easy to see why they can afford things.

I was watching a reality show in the US and the dad was in sales and the mum was a sahm...same as dh and me at the time. We were barely getting by but the family we were watching had a really amazing, luxurious lifestyle in comparison.

Fifi00 · 24/12/2022 09:57

Looking at the wages it's a lot higher for the same job I do here. I can get at least 120k usd which is nearly 100k, I'm a specialist nurse. 😳. If your DH was earning similar money it's easy to see why they can afford things.

unclebuck · 24/12/2022 09:50

Also a majority of Americans do not think children are something you can "afford" and choose how many you have according to this. I see this on MN all the time but it is not how most of my family/friends think (US/Caribbean)

Bbq1 · 24/12/2022 09:44

Liorae · 24/12/2022 03:34

That's extremely location specific. It wouldn't be the case in boston, new york or San Francisco.

I agree with that but generally speaking properties over the pond are bigger and cheaper.

Virginiaplain · 24/12/2022 06:01

I would guess that Mormon families get support from the church. It’s common for them to have large families and used to be several wives.
American houses are big because fuel (oil and gas) is found there and so much cheaper than here, hence also huge cars, so if that’s not an issue then it’s building costs and they don’t use brick, more wood and chipboard so cheaper. You see them flattened in tornadoes.

caroleanboneparte · 24/12/2022 05:46

Or is it a case of them not doing things like that?

Yes.

Low income big families in the U.K. don't do those things either!

Paid swimming lessons are very middle class.

My DCs learned by going with relatives to the local pool for £1.

I've worked with plenty of poor dcs who've never been out for a meal with their parents/siblings not even weatherspoons.

If you are in social housing in the U.K. it's very hard to get more than a 3 bed. There were 4 bed (max) council houses built in the 50s/60s but they mostly went through RTB. So bigger families just bunk bed up in those rooms or sometimes parents sleep on sofa beds in the living room. Usually older ones would get their own council house once they were 16 (back in the day).

Liorae · 24/12/2022 03:34

Bbq1 · 23/12/2022 14:18

Yep, very true. For an average family house over here, you'd get one twice the size in us.

That's extremely location specific. It wouldn't be the case in boston, new york or San Francisco.

WeDontNeedToTalkAboutJamie · 24/12/2022 02:30

MadCattery · 24/12/2022 00:09

i am American and love to visit this site and love reading about life there, so it makes sense that people would be curious about here. Especially if what you know of Americans is from watching TV or online. That said,I have to say that I can’t remember being without health insurance except maybe when I was very young. It’s offered at most jobs. And the cost for family coverage is the same, regardless of the family size. My son is 33, I have know people in four different states who have had babies over the years and have friends in nursing (delivery) and never heard of a mother being put on a “ward” until I came here to mumsnet. Even the poorest mother gets Medicaid, which is government insurance for the poor, and she will get a private room like anyone else. Some people choose midwives, but most people have a doctor deliver. As for vacation time, I think I get more than average with 27 full days off a year. I am not rich, by a long shot. I earn $52,000 a year and DH is on disability and a part time job so adds maybe $20,000-so we are really very average here. My house is small, 1200 square feet and a large garage. It would cost about $400,000 to buy now. I live in Florida and never heard of anyone having to pay for swim or driving lessons. I think the average American family has less than two children now. A family with more than four is extremely unusual, a family with eleven kids is rare, usually half adopted. And not everyone eats processed crap. I work full time and when I say I cook from scratch, I mean I can turn out a loaf of bread without an issue, and bake and cook everything myself. Son is a chef and also cooks, as do most of my friends. I love reading mumsnet and I know people on mumsnet are fascinated by the different life here, too. I have learned so much about another country just by being on this site, and I hope people will look at our part of the world with an open mind, too.

This is really interesting thank you.

By comparison my (rented) home in England is about 750sq ft, with no garage or off street parking. A house on my road sold recently for $313,000.(£260k) My income is just over $23,000 (£19k ish) per year.

2023willbemyyear · 24/12/2022 02:22

MadCattery · 24/12/2022 01:40

Drivers Ed is offered in schools. Here in Florida, they used to be legally required to offer it. I don’t know if it’s different now but I know the kids in my county do. Some instructors in school are authorized to certify that a student has met the testing requirements and the teen can get a license that way. I wasn’t that good, so spent a couple more years practicing. Once you have a learners permit, you may drive in any car with any licensed driver who is over 21.

As for swimming, I think some people do pay, but in Coastal Florida it is considered a critical skill. Swim lessons are through recreation centers, service clubs, private clubs, community centers. I suppose some people make a little money by teaching privately, but I don’t know anyone who learned that way.

@MadCattery what have you learned about The UK from being on here, that you didn't know before, how different is your perception of life here from what it was before, and what are the things about The UK which you think are better or worse than The USA? Just super curious to know :)

Yfory · 24/12/2022 02:11

Some you tube family vloggers earn hundreds of thousands of dollars - which easily explains how they afford everything. The price being their childrens privacy, constantly being pimped out online for all to see.

HamBone · 24/12/2022 02:09

@MadCattery where we live, the driver’s Ed offered at schools isn’t free. My DD (17) took it last summer and we paid for it. She has friends at other local high schools and they’ve all had to pay.
Is it really free in Florida- If so I’m envious?!

ScrabbleRabbler · 24/12/2022 02:07

MadCattery · 24/12/2022 00:09

i am American and love to visit this site and love reading about life there, so it makes sense that people would be curious about here. Especially if what you know of Americans is from watching TV or online. That said,I have to say that I can’t remember being without health insurance except maybe when I was very young. It’s offered at most jobs. And the cost for family coverage is the same, regardless of the family size. My son is 33, I have know people in four different states who have had babies over the years and have friends in nursing (delivery) and never heard of a mother being put on a “ward” until I came here to mumsnet. Even the poorest mother gets Medicaid, which is government insurance for the poor, and she will get a private room like anyone else. Some people choose midwives, but most people have a doctor deliver. As for vacation time, I think I get more than average with 27 full days off a year. I am not rich, by a long shot. I earn $52,000 a year and DH is on disability and a part time job so adds maybe $20,000-so we are really very average here. My house is small, 1200 square feet and a large garage. It would cost about $400,000 to buy now. I live in Florida and never heard of anyone having to pay for swim or driving lessons. I think the average American family has less than two children now. A family with more than four is extremely unusual, a family with eleven kids is rare, usually half adopted. And not everyone eats processed crap. I work full time and when I say I cook from scratch, I mean I can turn out a loaf of bread without an issue, and bake and cook everything myself. Son is a chef and also cooks, as do most of my friends. I love reading mumsnet and I know people on mumsnet are fascinated by the different life here, too. I have learned so much about another country just by being on this site, and I hope people will look at our part of the world with an open mind, too.

Thankyou, really interesting post and informative

Duckskitbank · 24/12/2022 01:59

They make a huge amount of money from social media and most of their “hauls” will be sponsored.
Before they find fame, I would assume it’s a combination of living frugally and a reasonable income. Those with children who are fostered/ adopted will get a monthly allowance for them and healthcare covered. I don’t live in the US so I can’t comment on how generous the allowances are.