Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and future privilege

163 replies

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:16

Need to caveat this that I am foreign and grew up in a country that doesn't really have private schools. Was bored this morning and Google a few people from tele, academics and a few others and realised they've all been to private schools (perhaps with a tiny minority who went to a grammar). Got mr thinking- is it that private schools really propel their students to make a success of themselves or is it just privilege shining through and those same kids would have got ahead anyhow? Like if you send an ordinary kid to a private school would they make such a success of themselves?

OP posts:
SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 10:53

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:45

So we have no connections in this country, could at a push (maybe and thats a big maybe) send our one kid to a local private school (it's in London but not a big name of anything). Would it really make that much of a difference than sending them to a good comprehensive?

When I checked this morning it wasnt just politicians - media personalities but also talking heads on radio4 i.e. experts and academics.

No one has a crystal ball. Don't forget that the kids themselves also have parents who are well connected, not just their friends.

You also have to weigh up the sacrifice you take to send them to independent school. If they are going to university, how much more debt will they have if you use the money to pay for university instead? It's a graduate tax so they'll be poorer for most of their working lives compared to coming out with no debt. I read somewhere the biggest financial gift you can give a child is now a deposit to their first home. Will you be able to afford that if you pay school fees? All the money they might earn more in their working live may never make up for the £50,000 deposit in their early 20s.

MissyB1 · 23/12/2022 10:50

EnyoClytemnestra · 23/12/2022 10:25

In the UK, a private school is referred to as a public school, which is very confusing!
So kids have a private education at a public school...
in answer to your question, public schools tend to push pupils harder (after all, you are paying for this), but have better standards, extra-curricular activities, pastoral care, and the chance to make useful friends and contacts

This isn’t really accurate. Public schools are a very particular type of private school, (and are usually boarding) those are the schools where the networking and connections are probably most useful.
There are lots of private schools that are not public schools. My ds goes to a small independent senior day school.

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 10:48

I'm foreign and went to a private school in NZ. My view will be from an outsider. It's self selective because the people who go there have parents who are priviledged and have connections. By going to school with these priviledged people, you have a network of old friends who are all well connected. Also, because of their priviledge, they believe they are better than the commoners. (See the incident at Eton where state school girls were booed in the talk of Farage. Or how Rees-Mogg talks about common people).

The more privilege the school you go to, the better your advantage.

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:45

So we have no connections in this country, could at a push (maybe and thats a big maybe) send our one kid to a local private school (it's in London but not a big name of anything). Would it really make that much of a difference than sending them to a good comprehensive?

When I checked this morning it wasnt just politicians - media personalities but also talking heads on radio4 i.e. experts and academics.

OP posts:
Maximinimalist · 23/12/2022 10:40

Summerhillsquare · 23/12/2022 10:28

It's self selection. Those in power appoint and recruit people 'like me' who they feel comfortable with. Takes huge effort and a progressive government to break the cycle.

True, yet many in this society would have you believe that this country operates on merit and it’s the fault of women, ethnic minorities and working class folks why they are not at the top of the ladder.

Meritocracy is a myth. The top of the ladder looks the way it looks not because of merit.

Maximinimalist · 23/12/2022 10:36

There are many, many private schools across the country. Most are not anywhere near the league if the public schools such as Eton, Harrow, Westminster, etc.

It’s mainly at these public schools connections matter. For the vast majority of other private schools, connections are not more “lucrative” than if you went to a good grammar or comprehensive.

While it is true that many from the top private schools will land good jobs, the vast majority of people in top jobs will come from other schools, including from abroad. So going to a top private school might increase your chances but that’s all. It does not mean that other people from other type of schools can’t or won’t make it. In fact, in terms of numbers rather than proportion, more of them do.

amigababy · 23/12/2022 10:33

I went to a tiny private school, now closed down. I was on a scholarship, IRL I was from a very poor background. Academically I've done OK, but careerwise, nope. Just followed dh round the country supporting his career.
I scrub up well and can mingle socially and feel happy in smart society, which dh doesn't (he went to a comprehensive, but has been really successful in his work)

So I'd say it gave me "polish" but no big advantage workwise.
And there are different private schools. Mine was all religion and being young ladies. The teaching and expectations were good. But it had no serious reputation to uphold.

gogohmm · 23/12/2022 10:29

It's a combination. My dd went on a bursary, shes still young but doing amazing. That said she has privilege due to the fact us her parents worked our way up to this point

WatchoRulo · 23/12/2022 10:28

Like if you send an ordinary kid to a private school would they make such a success of themselves?
Take a look at some people of very average abilities in charge of things in government for the answer to this.

Summerhillsquare · 23/12/2022 10:28

It's self selection. Those in power appoint and recruit people 'like me' who they feel comfortable with. Takes huge effort and a progressive government to break the cycle.

EnyoClytemnestra · 23/12/2022 10:25

In the UK, a private school is referred to as a public school, which is very confusing!
So kids have a private education at a public school...
in answer to your question, public schools tend to push pupils harder (after all, you are paying for this), but have better standards, extra-curricular activities, pastoral care, and the chance to make useful friends and contacts

Seashor · 23/12/2022 10:22

Well I sent my ‘ordinary kid’ to private school and he has done quite well for himself. He owns his own business and employs people. He has definitely used connections from school but the biggest influence and leg up has been utter sheer hard work and commitment.

LunaTheCat · 23/12/2022 10:22

It’s privilege.. the stats say there is no difference in academic outcome but it means your kids mix with similar very privileged kids and develop a sense of being able to do anything.. just look at the Prime Ministers who come from Elton.

Swipe left for the next trending thread