Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and future privilege

163 replies

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:16

Need to caveat this that I am foreign and grew up in a country that doesn't really have private schools. Was bored this morning and Google a few people from tele, academics and a few others and realised they've all been to private schools (perhaps with a tiny minority who went to a grammar). Got mr thinking- is it that private schools really propel their students to make a success of themselves or is it just privilege shining through and those same kids would have got ahead anyhow? Like if you send an ordinary kid to a private school would they make such a success of themselves?

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 23/12/2022 11:36

Sorry - I didn't mean to quote. But actually I think the PP is falling into the trap of thinking most independent schools deliver the networking that major public schools do. They don't.

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/12/2022 11:34

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 10:48

I'm foreign and went to a private school in NZ. My view will be from an outsider. It's self selective because the people who go there have parents who are priviledged and have connections. By going to school with these priviledged people, you have a network of old friends who are all well connected. Also, because of their priviledge, they believe they are better than the commoners. (See the incident at Eton where state school girls were booed in the talk of Farage. Or how Rees-Mogg talks about common people).

The more privilege the school you go to, the better your advantage.

I think a good private school (they aren't technically all called public schools) gives you confidence and a belief that the world will work for you more than anything else.

There are great state schools (if you happen to live in the right place) that will give a motivated child the same results. But what really helps in life is the belief that the world's your oyster, plus the extracurricular / extra depth to the curriculum that gives you skills and cultural capital.

The smaller class sizes and more structured teaching can also be helpful for kids who are less organised or have mild learning challenges and would easily fall through the net in a huge state school. All being reasonably well, private schooling also reduces the pressure on parents - more is provided, and smaller classes mean the teachers are more attuned to your child, so you don't have to do quite so much in support. If you are stretched this is obviously helpful.

I think it's important not to confuse the vast majority of private schools with the famous few that give you a great network. Most kids in the private sector are at local independent day schools and they won't get that.

Janesmom · 23/12/2022 11:31

Probably self selecting. I’m state school but work in an industry dominated by (very clever and able) people who went to private school.

At my state school, there were plenty of kids who clearly couldn’t care less about their education and had no work ethic. I suspect that’s mainly their family circumstances / upbringing. If you have parents willing to spend a small fortune on your education, it’s likely that they’ll promote the value of learning and hard work more generally.

And, yes, there are exceptions of hard working kids/parents in the state system, but in my own experience they were very sadly a minority.

theworldhas · 23/12/2022 11:29

The school itself/teachers aren’t as important as the child’s peer group and home environment. The majority (not all) rich parents will already be providing an excellent home environment conducive to learning - steady schedule, lots of books, variety of activities, decent diet etc.

What the private school/decent state school then guarantees is the excellent peer/influence group - which research shows is far, far more important than people assume. Much more important than what teachers are at the school or computers to students ratio etc

DdraigGoch · 23/12/2022 11:26

Like if you send an ordinary kid to a private school would they make such a success of themselves?

Depends upon the school, not all are the same. Small class sizes often help kids with ASD be better supported, private schools often have a strong emphasis on extra-curricular activities, sport and the arts which have been neglected by many state schools ever since the league tables started concentrating on other subjects. General behaviour is often better (I'm sure that chair-throwing isn't half as common as it was in the comp I went to) though some of the less popular private schools are more reluctant to kick out troublemakers than the ones with a waiting list. Plenty of state school pupils do come out with high grades, but what they often lack is confidence.

NoelNoNoel · 23/12/2022 11:26

Two of my friends went to private schools, they both have lovely manners, no qualifications and average jobs.
My DC’s cousins went to private school, their A levels were slightly below my own DC’s grades. All the DC went to similar universities and now all have careers they are happy in.

Fairislefandango · 23/12/2022 11:26

It's a combination of things. If you come from a privileged enough background and your family have connections, you'll probably do very well in life even if you don't go to a top private school. If you're not especially privileged but go to a top private school, the education you get, plus thr extra-curricular opportunities,the general level of expectations and the connections you make may well propel you into a more successful life than you'd otherwise have had.

Having said that, some private schools are shit. I've taught in one outstanding private school, one highly-regarded but not very academic (and imo not that good) one, a grammar school and several comprehensives. Even the better of the comprehensives did not remotely compare with either of the private schools or the grammar school, largely because all of the latter are in one way or another selective. Also, nice schools attract good teachers, especially in a system which is haemmorrhaging teachers.

PrinceHaz · 23/12/2022 11:25

Private schools vary so much. My dd went to an an academic independent school in the north. The girls there work very hard but are really, really normal, not posh at all. The only advantage I can see the school has conferred is the ability to be able to achieve academically in an environment with relatively few behaviour problems.
When people talk about the confidence and connections a private school gives you, I think they’re taking about public schools in the south east ad the famous public schools around the country.

Lndnmummy · 23/12/2022 11:24

You have several private options in Dulwich. We live in the area but have opted for state schools as diversity is more important to me than anything else.(also from a country where private schools aren't a thing).

Hoppinggreen · 23/12/2022 11:23

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 11:11

Yes, so we're potentially looking at an excellent London comprehensive in South London or a nothing exceptional private school (also in South London). Not sure that DS would get into the super selective South London private schools.

If you have a good comprehensive school use it.
My DC are at Private because that option wasn’t available to us

Turmerictolly · 23/12/2022 11:23

There are children that travel to the grammars from Dulwich - St Olaves for example has dc from that area but the journey will be up to an hour. It is, admittedly, very hard to get a place there. You are spoilt for choice in Dulwich with good private schools and can also access the central London schools. What about Kingsdale as a state option (appreciate it's a lottery system).

Hoppinggreen · 23/12/2022 11:22

EnyoClytemnestra · 23/12/2022 10:25

In the UK, a private school is referred to as a public school, which is very confusing!
So kids have a private education at a public school...
in answer to your question, public schools tend to push pupils harder (after all, you are paying for this), but have better standards, extra-curricular activities, pastoral care, and the chance to make useful friends and contacts

Not true. Not all Private schools are called Public schools
I think it’s partly privilege and partly do do with academic success and confidence.
I have done well in life but no part of my financial success could be linked to connections I made at school

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 11:18

@Turmerictolly I am not sure we have any grammar schools around us. We're in Dulwich so it's either state or private here

OP posts:
Turmerictolly · 23/12/2022 11:18

If the private school isn't any good OP then what are you paying for? There are plenty of London state schools with excellent academics, sport and music opportunities. Grammar schools are an obvious starting point.

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 11:18

Financial it wont be easy and will mean staying in our flat rather than getting a house - which is ok as we only have the one but still. Private school also seem pretty hard to get into around here

OP posts:
Lilgamesh2 · 23/12/2022 11:17

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 11:11

Yes, so we're potentially looking at an excellent London comprehensive in South London or a nothing exceptional private school (also in South London). Not sure that DS would get into the super selective South London private schools.

Surely worth a try, no?

Most (but not all) private seconds schools require the children to pass exams to get in, which sets an expectation that everyone there is capable of doing well enough. In the state system you can have the same by sending them to a grammar school but there aren't that many around and you pay via inflated house prices instead.

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 11:16

If money isn't a problem, I'll choose private because it's easier to arrange the extra curricular activities.

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 11:11

Yes, so we're potentially looking at an excellent London comprehensive in South London or a nothing exceptional private school (also in South London). Not sure that DS would get into the super selective South London private schools.

OP posts:
NeedToChangeName · 23/12/2022 11:10

ichundich · 23/12/2022 11:01

I think that's unfortunately quite accurate when you look at the UK employment statistics. It's rooted in the deeply entrenched class system, I believe.

That's so not true !

Flammkuchen · 23/12/2022 11:09

I have one at a London super selective private school and one at a good London comprehensive.

There are two main differences:

  1. The private school works the kids way harder. At least an hour’s extra homework per day and high standards expected (a grade 7 at GCSE is seen as low).
  2. Confidence and polish. DD is proud of her school and has high expectations of what she can achieve, partly by being surrounded by kids of professional parents.

So I think it is a mixture of both the group of people but also because achievement is improved through extra work.

Think of it as the kids coming out of an intensive music academy. Yes, they select kids with potential but the extra years of intensive work make a huge difference to achievement. It is possible for highly motivated and disciplined individuals to make it without going to the specialist school but much harder.

ichundich · 23/12/2022 11:01

ILoveeCakes · 23/12/2022 10:54

State schools still basically churn out factory workers. Except there aren't many factories any more. Still, keep believing that the system was set up in your best interests........

I think that's unfortunately quite accurate when you look at the UK employment statistics. It's rooted in the deeply entrenched class system, I believe.

EnyoClytemnestra · 23/12/2022 10:56

MissyB1 · 23/12/2022 10:50

This isn’t really accurate. Public schools are a very particular type of private school, (and are usually boarding) those are the schools where the networking and connections are probably most useful.
There are lots of private schools that are not public schools. My ds goes to a small independent senior day school.

My bad - apologies!

ILoveeCakes · 23/12/2022 10:54

State schools still basically churn out factory workers. Except there aren't many factories any more. Still, keep believing that the system was set up in your best interests........

ichundich · 23/12/2022 10:53

I think it's the networking opportunities that private schools provide. They offer such a range of activities that pupils are bound to find something they like and use this to connect with people. They also help a lot with uni applications and place a strong emphasis on speaking "properly", which will impress certain employers.