Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and future privilege

163 replies

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:16

Need to caveat this that I am foreign and grew up in a country that doesn't really have private schools. Was bored this morning and Google a few people from tele, academics and a few others and realised they've all been to private schools (perhaps with a tiny minority who went to a grammar). Got mr thinking- is it that private schools really propel their students to make a success of themselves or is it just privilege shining through and those same kids would have got ahead anyhow? Like if you send an ordinary kid to a private school would they make such a success of themselves?

OP posts:
Reugny · 23/12/2022 12:31

Hoppinggreen · 23/12/2022 12:28

There is also the time and resources they have.
DD was on track for an 8 at GCSE in a particular subject. The teacher really pushed her to get a 9 but he had a class of just 6 DC. I don’t see how (or even why) a teacher would do that with a class of 30 with very mixed abilities

The "good" comps stream.

So the 20-30 in the top stream will be expected to get 9. And there is competition within the class to get the highest mark.

There is also no bullying for being in the top class(es).

It is if your child is in the middle they miss out and where sending them to a private school would help them.

Hoppinggreen · 23/12/2022 12:28

Amboseli · 23/12/2022 12:24

I think the difference between state and selective private is behaviour and expectations. DS is at a super selective private school in London and as pp said a 7 is considered low. There is no tolerance of bad behaviour or class disruption and pupils are politely asked to look at other schools if rules are breached.

Compare this to friends and relatives at comprehensive school where working hard and wanting to do well is not "cool", if homework isn't done it's not a problem, and the only expectation is to pass maths and English GCSE.

There is also the time and resources they have.
DD was on track for an 8 at GCSE in a particular subject. The teacher really pushed her to get a 9 but he had a class of just 6 DC. I don’t see how (or even why) a teacher would do that with a class of 30 with very mixed abilities

Tallulasdancingshoes · 23/12/2022 12:24

I think sometimes those from very wealthy families are willing to take more of a risk because they have family money to fall back on if needs be. Those from poorer backgrounds are more risk averse because there’s no safety net.

Amboseli · 23/12/2022 12:24

I think the difference between state and selective private is behaviour and expectations. DS is at a super selective private school in London and as pp said a 7 is considered low. There is no tolerance of bad behaviour or class disruption and pupils are politely asked to look at other schools if rules are breached.

Compare this to friends and relatives at comprehensive school where working hard and wanting to do well is not "cool", if homework isn't done it's not a problem, and the only expectation is to pass maths and English GCSE.

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 12:19

In terms of a good comprehensive - how good is good?

OP posts:
Fenella123 · 23/12/2022 12:18

It's 50/50 OP.
Half is just reflecting the fact that the parents pay attention to their kids and explicitly value education. Imagine what it's like if your parents either set you to doing chores when you get home and never give a stuff if the teacher complains you don't do homework, or worse, if they're barely around at all.

Half is being in an environment where learning is not disrupted by bad classroom behaviour, and where the teacher can go at a faster pace and get more progress because the private school class kids are more or less the upper half or third smartest of the regular state school. It's having the school really motivated to get the kids good exam results and into good unis (and otherwise visibly excel and thrive in SOME way) because they literally will be out of a job otherwise.

If the comp is good with involved parents, good exam results, well mannered kids, no point paying for private school TBH as long as DC is working well and happy there.

I went to state primary and secondary and the good private school in my town after that. Not sure the teachers were any better at the last school BUT the classroom discipline was perfect, the pace of learning was faster, and crucially I got lunchtime tutoring for the Oxbridge entrance exam (as was at the time). I did have still to get up at 6am to practice past papers but the point is I got that support, and I got the place, got the degree to put on my CV, met my DH there.

FWIW my peer went to the good comp and then Cambridge and is a liver consultant so he did ok on the free track!

HOWEVER when I look at my contemporaries who went on to get doctorates it seems (and this is just my finger in the air, not proper science!) a lot more of them went to state schools. So there's that. Arguably not being burned out by an "academic hothouse" (my middle school English teacher's description of my high school - thanks for trying, Mr K!!) and having the earlier experience of needing to motivate and organize your own work have long-term benefits.

If OTOH the "good comp" turns out to be a stabby nightmare of a place where your kid cowers in the corner from the rival drug gangs... Yeah money well spent getting them somewhere peaceful!

Fairislefandango · 23/12/2022 12:11

If you have a good comprehensive school use it.

If it's honestly really good, sure. Rather than Ofsted good, which means little. I have worked in 'good' comprehensives where parents would be appalled if they could be a fly on the wall. Unfortunately the 'good' school my dc currently attend is one of them.

socialmedia23 · 23/12/2022 12:02

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:16

Need to caveat this that I am foreign and grew up in a country that doesn't really have private schools. Was bored this morning and Google a few people from tele, academics and a few others and realised they've all been to private schools (perhaps with a tiny minority who went to a grammar). Got mr thinking- is it that private schools really propel their students to make a success of themselves or is it just privilege shining through and those same kids would have got ahead anyhow? Like if you send an ordinary kid to a private school would they make such a success of themselves?

Another factor is also that people who are prominent in public life are likely to be late 30s and older. My DH is 32, grew up in north londn and he had many friends who went to private school from regular middle class backgrounds. It was expensive, but not as expensive as it is today.

He had a friend whose father was a part time barrister/teacher and mum was a journalist who went. Not sure about the grandparents and if they funded it. They lived in a 2 up 2 down in zone 4 north london. They probably wouldn't be able to afford it today.

queenofthewild · 23/12/2022 11:59

The ones who do well from other backgrounds are the ones who survive the process, so would probably have that edge wherever they were educated.

I loved my small cosy prep school, but secondary school was a whole different thing. I was bullied relentlessly for being "common".

I wouldn't put my own child through private school.

MissyB1 · 23/12/2022 11:56

Hoppinggreen · 23/12/2022 11:23

If you have a good comprehensive school use it.
My DC are at Private because that option wasn’t available to us

Same as us, if we had access to a really good state school I would not be paying 18k a year.
Although a pp made a good point about the extra curriculars at private school. Ds has got involved in lots of things that he probably wouldn’t have tried at state school.

purpledalmation · 23/12/2022 11:55

Kids attending private schools already have an advantage as their parents are ambitious for them, want them to achieve good exam results and progress in a career and also have money in the family and live in a good area. So they have advantage in all areas. It's not just the private education

theworldhas · 23/12/2022 11:55

It's self selection. Those in power appoint and recruit people 'like me' who they feel comfortable with. Takes huge effort and a progressive government to break the cycle

Also exactly why the country is in such a mess. Over the last 20 years the Conservatives have confined themselves to an ever narrower pool in terms of social and political outlook, and of course that went into hyper drive with the Brexit purge of Conservative remainers. When it came time to replace Johnson, the only viable options were all far to the right of Johnson at a time when they needed to pull decisively to the left.

Throughabushbackwards · 23/12/2022 11:52

It's also the old boys/girls networks that afford privilege. The school I work in (regularly top 5 co-ed public school) has a networking organisation for ex-pupils that means they have connections with contacts all over the world. They host closed social media channels where work experience and internships can be arranged, networking events, posh dinners and parties all over - Asia, Australia, USA.

Reugny · 23/12/2022 11:50

theworldhas · 23/12/2022 11:46

@Lndnmummy
Of course ethnic minorities are more aware of race. I am an ethnic minority myself. But I still think that after a year or two of primary school, pupils still differentiate their classmates far more based on their attitude to study + sporting/academic etc ability than they do on race/cultural background etc. Hench the racial makeup of a school simply isn’t as important to me as the personality and attitude to study of the pupils and their families.

No they don't.

Also if you go to a state school you are more likely to have black or black mixed teachers.

BungleandGeorge · 23/12/2022 11:49

What was your sample and how did you find out what schools they had attended? I think the career path makes a difference. For instance the vast majority of performing arts schools are private (with some government funded places), private schools have better arts provision and offer subsidised places for talented students. Thus you’d expect a higher percentage of people in the arts to
come from private schools. They also work hard to attract the most academic and incentivise them financially. It’s not quite as simple as presuming the school has ‘made’ those pupils successful.
also worth remembering that 20% go to private sixth forms, so they’ve not necessarily gone all the way through private.
and of course as pointed out many people who can afford private are privileged, parents have attributes to be successful, or they have connections. Both independent of school but incredibly important in success of their offspring.
is the state school near you good? London schools are better funded than elsewhere so many state schools are good. In which case don’t pay private. If it’s a failing school/ behaviour problems etc then I’d find the money. Does your child have Sen or special talents? If so might get a better experience in private. You can always consider private for sixth form which is what many do to get the breadth of course choices and smaller classes when the work is more complex.

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 11:48

@theworldhas I don't believe private school doesn't have bullying. I went to one in NZ and bullying was rife. Younger boarders had to polish shoes and make beds for the older ones and were thrown into wheelie bins regularly. My DC go to state and I can't say it's got no bullying either. They don't have boarding so at least it's not all day.

I wouldn't call the catchment of my DC comprehensive very diverse. It is more diverse than independent, but most are well off families. I suspect most of the better comps have this type of catchment.

One of DC11 friend went to a independent and the difference I see is that she is doing two modern foreign languages and Latin, two instruments at school, and must participate in one team sport. The girl always has a sense of self confidence so she doesn't need the school to tell here that.

Andsoforth · 23/12/2022 11:48

Connections - who you know will always take you further than what you know.

Soothsayer1 · 23/12/2022 11:47

Summerhillsquare · 23/12/2022 10:28

It's self selection. Those in power appoint and recruit people 'like me' who they feel comfortable with. Takes huge effort and a progressive government to break the cycle.

This!

theworldhas · 23/12/2022 11:46

@Lndnmummy
Of course ethnic minorities are more aware of race. I am an ethnic minority myself. But I still think that after a year or two of primary school, pupils still differentiate their classmates far more based on their attitude to study + sporting/academic etc ability than they do on race/cultural background etc. Hench the racial makeup of a school simply isn’t as important to me as the personality and attitude to study of the pupils and their families.

VenusClapTrap · 23/12/2022 11:44

Dd was at an excellent state primary and very much a ‘quiet middle’; neither a genius nor struggling, but happy enough pootling along with average grades.

At 11 we moved her to a private school, principally for the extra curricular stuff and better facilities (because the local state secondary is actually very good, so we didn’t feel the need to do it for teaching quality reasons).

Suddenly at the private school she is flying and getting A*s in all her exams. Didn’t see that coming at all.

ditalini · 23/12/2022 11:44

I think it's already been said, but it depends on the school.

I come from a city where a higher than average proportion of children from middle class families go to private school.

I would consider these schools as mostly "bog standard" - parents pay for their offspring to mix with children from families like themselves, definitely better resources, arguably less disruption in class.

Outcomes wise though, the academic destinations and future careers of my naice middle class state primary school contemporaries who went state and private have been broadly the same.

The "old boys" network for these schools is very, very limited.

Lndnmummy · 23/12/2022 11:41

theworldhas · 23/12/2022 11:38

@Lndnmummy
You have several private options in Dulwich. We live in the area but have opted for state schools as diversity is more important to me than anything else.(also from a country where private schools aren't a thing)

that’s interesting, but to me that would be prioritising adult politics/outlook over a child’s outlook. I don’t think the majority of children pay that much attention to the race or social economic background of their classmates - or at least not until they are say 14 or 15. What they are more keenly aware of/care about is how well behaved their classmates are, whether they cause trouble, or whether there is much bullying going on.

Ideally it would be great to have both - a truly diverse school with no discipline issues where all children can feel safe to express themselves socially and academically without fear of judgement. But in reality we often have to priotise one or the other, as sadly poverty and social issues often go hand in hand in most western countries.

My children are black so their and mine experiences differ massively from what you describe.

theworldhas · 23/12/2022 11:38

@Lndnmummy
You have several private options in Dulwich. We live in the area but have opted for state schools as diversity is more important to me than anything else.(also from a country where private schools aren't a thing)

that’s interesting, but to me that would be prioritising adult politics/outlook over a child’s outlook. I don’t think the majority of children pay that much attention to the race or social economic background of their classmates - or at least not until they are say 14 or 15. What they are more keenly aware of/care about is how well behaved their classmates are, whether they cause trouble, or whether there is much bullying going on.

Ideally it would be great to have both - a truly diverse school with no discipline issues where all children can feel safe to express themselves socially and academically without fear of judgement. But in reality we often have to priotise one or the other, as sadly poverty and social issues often go hand in hand in most western countries.

Newgirls · 23/12/2022 11:38

I think it’s changing

in my local area I see families choosing private schools for social mobility. The families live in cheaper areas and spend on the education (sometimes for the boys of the family only).

The rich white families in the big houses are choosing the good state schools. Even if the kids are clever enough to get into private. And even if parents went to private. One factor is they can buy in the catchments but also they want to be seen as more liberal. Those kids will have many other advantages in music, travel etc. the families socialise and the kids get the contacts etc. Parents also know top universities are recruiting from state schools.

Private school is not a guarantee that a kid will hang out with posh kids but that seems to be what some parents want to buy

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 11:38

@Luredbyapomegranate one of the private selective here are advertising they will not admit those with SEN. So much for helping anyone with mild learning disabilties. It's selective and I'm sure the pushy parents prefer that than diverting resources for their bright kids to those who need extra help.