Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and future privilege

163 replies

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:16

Need to caveat this that I am foreign and grew up in a country that doesn't really have private schools. Was bored this morning and Google a few people from tele, academics and a few others and realised they've all been to private schools (perhaps with a tiny minority who went to a grammar). Got mr thinking- is it that private schools really propel their students to make a success of themselves or is it just privilege shining through and those same kids would have got ahead anyhow? Like if you send an ordinary kid to a private school would they make such a success of themselves?

OP posts:
Echobelly · 23/12/2022 15:19

NB, should add I didn't want to go to the private girl's school which would have been equivalent of my brother's - it wasn't that his education was seen as worth more than mine!

Echobelly · 23/12/2022 15:18

I can usually spot former public school kids - they have this certain aura of confidence that state schools don't seem to produce, even excellent ones. I went to one of the best state schools in the country, which was selective and thus academically hard to beat, but it still didn't give that confidence that private education seems to supply. In terms of the education we got, it was at least as good as my older brother got privately and my parents kind of wished he'd gone there as well!

To some degree it's connections, but a lot is confidence and feeling sure you deserve to do well somehow. My dad started his career in stockbroking, but didn't stay in it, though he remained friends with contacts in that field - one told him they were putting their kids down for Eton and Roedean and said 'It's all right for your kids, they're academic, ours will need the connections'

I think state schools have got much better since I was a kid - even my privately educated husband, when I humoured him and viewed a (very well rated) private secondary for our eldest, admitted that although the facilities were great, it didn't otherwise seem amazingly better than the state schools we'd seen. Boy, was I relieved!

Hawaii4 · 23/12/2022 15:11

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 14:53

What I mean is that it is not streaming because their tutor groups are mixed ability. But individual subjects are then separated into multiple ability sets by combining multiple tutor groups.

Thanks, my local state comp said the English classes are all mixed ability for example. The only rationale given was 'we don't believe in academic selection'. But I know other comps do have academic sets for English and Maths, just annoying that individual Headteachers can make this decision based on their own ideology.

The government should make all comprehensives have sets by ability, it would increase the number of children with top grades.

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 14:53

What I mean is that it is not streaming because their tutor groups are mixed ability. But individual subjects are then separated into multiple ability sets by combining multiple tutor groups.

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 14:52

Hawaii4 · 23/12/2022 13:47

Ime my closest state comprehensive was more interested in pushing non-selective education crap. So they proudly stated they don't stream etc on their open day. For an academic child this is crap, they are being taught alongside others who struggle to access the curriculum.

If state schools were more ambitious and always streamed the kids, I suspect they'd do better. But from what I could tell, this offended their comprehensive ideology. I am hoping my dc doesn't have to go to that state school.

My DC is at a state comprehensive and claim they don't stream. They have regrouped the kids into different maths classes not along tutor groups. This is after assessment in the first couple of weeks. They still say they aren't streaming, but DC says all the kids in her maths group have the top marks. I think what they will claim is that they don't stream but have aligned the children into multiple ability sets, and they have more than one class in each set. It's not the strictest definition of streaming.

Fairislefandango · 23/12/2022 14:33

is that why its more popular to send children to private secondary rather than prep because it is that age where disruptive behavior from other kids really makes a difference?

I guess so. But also perhaps because the extra-curricular activities and potentially highly-qualified teachers might make more of a difference then too.

LimeTwists · 23/12/2022 14:31

EnyoClytemnestra · 23/12/2022 10:25

In the UK, a private school is referred to as a public school, which is very confusing!
So kids have a private education at a public school...
in answer to your question, public schools tend to push pupils harder (after all, you are paying for this), but have better standards, extra-curricular activities, pastoral care, and the chance to make useful friends and contacts

There’s a little bit more to the naming than that. Any paid-for non-state school is a private school. Within that group of private schools, public schools are very specifically the group of elite old boys’ schools such as Eton, Harrow, Westminster etc etc. This is because when they were first founded they educated ‘the public’ - non royalty etc, but those pupils were still from the elite of society. That’s why schools like Eton are still magnets for the landed gentry but many more recently built ‘private schools’ are less esteemed. It’s also where the ‘out of touch with reality public-school boy’ stereotype comes from. I’ve worked in both types of schools and the public schools do feel very different. Much more traditional. They attract the sons of such powerful, famous and wealthy people that it helps pupils build a truly extraordinary network of contacts so former public school boys often get such a leg up in life. Work experience at any law firm, bank, newspaper, in parliament etc etc is much more accessible if you boarded with the son of the CEO.

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 14:30

I guess in terms of state we'd be thinking Charter or Kingsdale and private Dunstans, Colfe's or maybe Alleyns. I'd really rather go mixed rather than all boys. I have heard about the lack of secondary school teachers in many subjects but how would one go about finding out?

OP posts:
socialmedia23 · 23/12/2022 13:59

Fairislefandango · 23/12/2022 13:37

I don't think people are just paying school fees for GCSE and A level results however. It's the connections and extra curriculars.

Lots of parents send their children to private or grammar schools mainly to avoid the bad influence and heavy loss of learning time caused by poor behaviour. Not that there aren't badly-behaved students at private schools, but often far fewer and it's a lot easier to expel them.

Parents of pupils at the excellent private school I taught at often admitted that they chose the school mainly for its intake, not its impressive facilities.

Girls at the girls' grammar school largely seemed to be glad to be separate from the boys, many of whom they considered badly-behaved and disruptive (based on experience from primary school and on stories from their brothers).

Behaviour is a massive problem, even at a lot of theoretically good comprehensive schools. Students (and some teachers) often don't see it as being particularly bad, because they've never known anything different.

is that why its more popular to send children to private secondary rather than prep because it is that age where disruptive behavior from other kids really makes a difference?

Amboseli · 23/12/2022 13:49

@Hoppinggreen yes the small class sizes make a huge difference. DD was in a class of 8 for maths GCSE and DS in a different school was in a class of 6 for French. They were both on course to get 6 or below but got 8s which for DS in french was frankly a miracle!

lanthanum · 23/12/2022 13:49

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 12:19

In terms of a good comprehensive - how good is good?

With a bright child, I looked at the GCSE results to see whether there was a set's worth of top grades in core subjects. If yes, then there was likely to be a peer group and staff capable of teaching them to that level.

Hawaii4 · 23/12/2022 13:47

Ime my closest state comprehensive was more interested in pushing non-selective education crap. So they proudly stated they don't stream etc on their open day. For an academic child this is crap, they are being taught alongside others who struggle to access the curriculum.

If state schools were more ambitious and always streamed the kids, I suspect they'd do better. But from what I could tell, this offended their comprehensive ideology. I am hoping my dc doesn't have to go to that state school.

Fairislefandango · 23/12/2022 13:37

I don't think people are just paying school fees for GCSE and A level results however. It's the connections and extra curriculars.

Lots of parents send their children to private or grammar schools mainly to avoid the bad influence and heavy loss of learning time caused by poor behaviour. Not that there aren't badly-behaved students at private schools, but often far fewer and it's a lot easier to expel them.

Parents of pupils at the excellent private school I taught at often admitted that they chose the school mainly for its intake, not its impressive facilities.

Girls at the girls' grammar school largely seemed to be glad to be separate from the boys, many of whom they considered badly-behaved and disruptive (based on experience from primary school and on stories from their brothers).

Behaviour is a massive problem, even at a lot of theoretically good comprehensive schools. Students (and some teachers) often don't see it as being particularly bad, because they've never known anything different.

neverbeenskiing · 23/12/2022 13:26

What the private school/decent state school then guarantees is the excellent peer/influence group

The kids at the 'outstanding' state school where I work buy their drugs from kids at the private school down the road. They also connect with kids from other schools (state and private) on social media. I don't think any school "guarantees" that your child won't be exposed to negative peer influences anymore, although this does seem to be what many parents believe about private education. I went to a private school where drugs, bullying, casual sex and sexual harassment were all rife but the kids were either clever enough to not get caught or, if they did it was very much brushed under the carpet.

vivainsomnia · 23/12/2022 13:24

There's private schools and private schools. Some are selling themselves as offering smaller classes, sports, music, after school activities, but ultimately, it is attended by average to above average income families who like the idea that they kids get a private education.

You then have the very prestigious ones that only the very rich can afford by famies who are already in the business anyway and their kids follow on their parents or get help from friends parents.

They are not multitude of the latter but many smaller private schools that don't offer that much more than other schools but for better pastoral care.

NoelNoNoel · 23/12/2022 13:23

Of course this is made possible by the absence of problem families, lack of commitment to education, smaller class sizes, etc
I haven’t heard the phrase ‘problem families’ for quite a few decades.

Rafferty10 · 23/12/2022 13:12

Its a combination of things,

All motivated,largely academically inclined parents, You don't find any parents who care little for education at a private school, and all that goes with that at home, conversation, news, debate, etc.
State schools are not generally pushy, eg the guidance for state schools in the Pandemic as reported on here by teachers was to 'take care of the pupils well being' Lack of computers at many homes, took weeks or months, to get any lessons online, no follow up or marking in many cases. Of course some state schools did brilliantly just not all.

The message from my Dcs Independent schools was, 'under no circumstance let your grades slip, work just as hard from your home computer on teams'
Full school day 8.30 till 4pm no excuses, up and running in a week. Every set lesson marked, parents contacted for EVERY missed lesson. Total follow up as if in school. Assumed in the trenches, just make the best of it and crack on, attitude.

Of course that is just a couple of examples, but l have seen many similar having had Dcs in both.

Even small Independents have (imo) higher expectations and aspiration, of all their children. Much less mollycoddling, zilch woke attitude. Robust attitude to sorting out problems and standing on your own two feet.

Of course this is made possible by the absence of problem families, lack of commitment to education, smaller class sizes, etc.

There are good and bad Private and State schools and no one size fits all for children.

My DD is academic and flourishes in a strict,, no nonsense high achieving school with like minded pupils. Probably with excellent 'contacts' She loves her school.

My DS is flourishing in a non selective small gentle school which achieves good grades but has great pastoral care. Probably no future contacts. He loves his school.

SnowAndFrostOutside · 23/12/2022 13:07

silverbe11 · 23/12/2022 12:58

Hi OP. As others have pointed out, talking about 'private schools' as if they are all one and the same, is extremely misleading. Some private schools are excellent. Some are frankly atrocious.

The 'private v state' issue is also highly regionally specific.

I am not in Dulwich (I'm SW London), but I know a little about the independent schools in Dulwich. For a boy, I think the more selective ones would be Dulwich College or Alleyns?

Those schools are academically selective, but not so much as the more Central London ones such as Westminster, St Paul's (Girls and Boys), Godolphin and Latymer, Latymer Upper, CLGS, etc. So there are kids going for those schools who may live in South London (or reasonable transport connections to SE London) who may apply for Alleyns or Dulwich College as a slightly 'safer' option (in terms of whether they are likely to get in or not). So, it may be worth your son having a go?

Where you live, there is marked degrees of wealth and marked degrees of deprivation existing side by side, as I'm sure you know.

The comprehensive school may be 'outstanding' - but have a look at the results. Excellent comprehensives in more wealthy areas may achieve 30% 9-7 at GCSE (higher than the national average). But at somewhere like Dulwich College, probably over 80% will be achieving those grades. That is the difference in a selective school. The pace is faster. The 'accepted norms' in terms of academics, focus and behaviour are higher. Not just in the classroom, it translates into peer groups and consequently out of school. Children get carried along by each other basically. Teachers are less stressed because they're not having to think about 'extension work' for the most able, while supporting others to scrape a pass. Also, class sizes tend to be around 20 (often smaller) rather than the standard 30.

I don't know the independent school you are considering for your son, but a starting point would be to compare the GCSE and A-level results between this school and the comprehensive.

Are you sure it's just 30%? I looked at my DC's comp and it's just over 50% above grade 7 for GCSE english and maths. Definitely lower than the selective school for sure.

I don't think people are just paying school fees for GCSE and A level results however. It's the connections and extra cirriculars. A PP mentioned about a 'face that fits' too.

Radiatorvalves · 23/12/2022 12:58

I live in south London and my DCs go to one of the private schools in Dulwich. We never intended that…. Went to primary school and then (long story) ended up going private. It’s worked well for the kids and other than the horrendous expense I don’t have regrets. Interestingly I know 4 kids from DCs primary school (class of 30) who are trying Oxbridge this year. The others go to different state schools in s London and are all flying. There are some great state schools round here. Don’t discount them.

silverbe11 · 23/12/2022 12:58

Hi OP. As others have pointed out, talking about 'private schools' as if they are all one and the same, is extremely misleading. Some private schools are excellent. Some are frankly atrocious.

The 'private v state' issue is also highly regionally specific.

I am not in Dulwich (I'm SW London), but I know a little about the independent schools in Dulwich. For a boy, I think the more selective ones would be Dulwich College or Alleyns?

Those schools are academically selective, but not so much as the more Central London ones such as Westminster, St Paul's (Girls and Boys), Godolphin and Latymer, Latymer Upper, CLGS, etc. So there are kids going for those schools who may live in South London (or reasonable transport connections to SE London) who may apply for Alleyns or Dulwich College as a slightly 'safer' option (in terms of whether they are likely to get in or not). So, it may be worth your son having a go?

Where you live, there is marked degrees of wealth and marked degrees of deprivation existing side by side, as I'm sure you know.

The comprehensive school may be 'outstanding' - but have a look at the results. Excellent comprehensives in more wealthy areas may achieve 30% 9-7 at GCSE (higher than the national average). But at somewhere like Dulwich College, probably over 80% will be achieving those grades. That is the difference in a selective school. The pace is faster. The 'accepted norms' in terms of academics, focus and behaviour are higher. Not just in the classroom, it translates into peer groups and consequently out of school. Children get carried along by each other basically. Teachers are less stressed because they're not having to think about 'extension work' for the most able, while supporting others to scrape a pass. Also, class sizes tend to be around 20 (often smaller) rather than the standard 30.

I don't know the independent school you are considering for your son, but a starting point would be to compare the GCSE and A-level results between this school and the comprehensive.

iloveburmese3 · 23/12/2022 12:55

I went to public school (girls boarding school UK) and the contacts have been invaluable. I got a job at Vogue, friends for life easily as you fit into a 'club' and generally really helps you out. I didn't go to Oxbridge but I went to a top university in the north of the UK and I know my private education helped. It's helped with with everything. Not boasting just answering the q. Merry Christmas x

NeedAHoliday2021 · 23/12/2022 12:49

In my experience it’s all to do with connections you make so the majority of private school pupils will be fairly average but those reaching high professions are of a higher proportion than state school.

The other factors are confidence and financial security - if you have money or family money, you can take a risk, start a business, knowing it’ll be fine if it fails.

suzyscat · 23/12/2022 12:46

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:45

So we have no connections in this country, could at a push (maybe and thats a big maybe) send our one kid to a local private school (it's in London but not a big name of anything). Would it really make that much of a difference than sending them to a good comprehensive?

When I checked this morning it wasnt just politicians - media personalities but also talking heads on radio4 i.e. experts and academics.

I think so. A lot of my adult friends went to private school and a lot of them have jobs from connections alone. I also have friends from state comps who have excelled in prestigious careers. (And all strongly believe it makes no difference.) The difference I noticed in my early 20s was that for the most part the private school lot expected success. They felt entitled to a glamorous career and set their sights accordingly. The idea that they wouldn't have one was never a consideration. At the time I found it rather entitled but actually as a mindset did them more favours tbf.

For balance I've several friends who left private schools for state where they were happier but none of those have gone on to high profile careers, although two have vocations they're very happy in which is all that matters.

Tiredalwaystired · 23/12/2022 12:43

EnyoClytemnestra · 23/12/2022 10:25

In the UK, a private school is referred to as a public school, which is very confusing!
So kids have a private education at a public school...
in answer to your question, public schools tend to push pupils harder (after all, you are paying for this), but have better standards, extra-curricular activities, pastoral care, and the chance to make useful friends and contacts

This is not a universal truth. My children go to an outstanding state comp with GCSE options including astronomy and classics among others. They regularly out perform the local private school in GCSE results.

Extra curricular activities include over 30 different clubs and societies including cookery, engineering, all major spots, movie making etc.

which just leaves “the chance to make useful contacts”. Which is the privilege they will have in later life.

socialmedia23 · 23/12/2022 12:36

Amboseli · 23/12/2022 12:24

I think the difference between state and selective private is behaviour and expectations. DS is at a super selective private school in London and as pp said a 7 is considered low. There is no tolerance of bad behaviour or class disruption and pupils are politely asked to look at other schools if rules are breached.

Compare this to friends and relatives at comprehensive school where working hard and wanting to do well is not "cool", if homework isn't done it's not a problem, and the only expectation is to pass maths and English GCSE.

My DH's sister was kicked out of her comprehensive for having Aspergers and refusing to seek treatment (this translated to stereotypical 'bad behavior if you didn't understand her condition). That school is ranked in the top 10 comprehensives in the country based on latest ranking (faith school). The older sisters who all got straight As at A level sailed through the same school.

It happens in all 'good' schools i think.