Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools and future privilege

163 replies

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 10:16

Need to caveat this that I am foreign and grew up in a country that doesn't really have private schools. Was bored this morning and Google a few people from tele, academics and a few others and realised they've all been to private schools (perhaps with a tiny minority who went to a grammar). Got mr thinking- is it that private schools really propel their students to make a success of themselves or is it just privilege shining through and those same kids would have got ahead anyhow? Like if you send an ordinary kid to a private school would they make such a success of themselves?

OP posts:
Haydugee · 23/12/2022 21:29

There seems to be a misconception that somehow public schools can take an average or struggling DC and churn them out with top grades.

Public schools are highly selective, so only take the top % of applicants. Therefore they naturally get better than average results and more DC in to top universities.

pocketvenuss · 23/12/2022 21:28

EnyoClytemnestra · 23/12/2022 10:25

In the UK, a private school is referred to as a public school, which is very confusing!
So kids have a private education at a public school...
in answer to your question, public schools tend to push pupils harder (after all, you are paying for this), but have better standards, extra-curricular activities, pastoral care, and the chance to make useful friends and contacts

Only a very few private schools are called public schools. Certainly not the run of the mill independent schools. Merchant Taylors' School, St Paul's School, London, Eton, Shrewsbury, Harrow, Winchester, Rugby, Westminster, and Charterhouse are the only real public schools. The others are independent schools. Girls private schools are not referred to as public school either.

XingMing · 23/12/2022 21:21

Your child is sitting next to a classmate whose parents value education enough to pay twice for it. That's a lot of the difference.

Nimbostratus100 · 23/12/2022 21:13

Flammkuchen · 23/12/2022 11:09

I have one at a London super selective private school and one at a good London comprehensive.

There are two main differences:

  1. The private school works the kids way harder. At least an hour’s extra homework per day and high standards expected (a grade 7 at GCSE is seen as low).
  2. Confidence and polish. DD is proud of her school and has high expectations of what she can achieve, partly by being surrounded by kids of professional parents.

So I think it is a mixture of both the group of people but also because achievement is improved through extra work.

Think of it as the kids coming out of an intensive music academy. Yes, they select kids with potential but the extra years of intensive work make a huge difference to achievement. It is possible for highly motivated and disciplined individuals to make it without going to the specialist school but much harder.

you've glossed over the "super-selective" bit here.

The private school has not only cherry picked the most able, to start with, but also has the ability to expel any child not making the grade.

SO of course their ex students do well - state schools cant just chuck students out if they are going to affect the statistics badly.

The other advantage independent schools has over state is this. Your child is sitting next to a classmate who's parents value education enough to pay for it.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 23/12/2022 21:08

It is connections - once was having a problem with a new manager at a place I freelanced for. Got stuck in a taxi with him after a meeting, discovered we went to the same uni and neighbouring colleges and after that - no more problems, and in fact a big contract came to me. Did I deserve it? I think so, but it is not clear to me that it was not the old school tie thing.

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 20:58

@LolaSmiles yes, the difference between a flat/house in the catchment of our outstanding state school versus outside is at least 100k which at the current rate of interest is basically 200k. Same as the price of putting one kid through private school.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 23/12/2022 20:51

Most are not anywhere near the league if the public schools such as Eton, Harrow, Westminster, etc.

It’s mainly at these public schools connections matter. For the vast majority of other private schools, connections are not more “lucrative” than if you went to a good grammar or comprehensive.
Agree with this.

The children from middle class families in my area will tend to go to 2 of the state comprehensives or the two private schools in the area.

Depending on where you live in our area it can be cheaper to send your child to a private school than to buy in catchment. In Mumsnet world posters would claim that the family paying private fees are awful ladder climbers who want to trample on all the other children, whilst ignoring the fact that to move to the same house in catchment for some state schools would be close to £100k more on the house.

XingMing · 23/12/2022 20:47

@tickticksnooze is snoozing.

XingMing · 23/12/2022 20:42

Competent state schools do well if they stream academically. My 10 form entry comprehensive streamed from Y10, into grammar equivalent classes, and mainstream. The grammar equivalent classes went to Oxbridge, RG and medical school on a level with any independent school. The other eight forms became brickies, nurses, carers, carpenters, hairdressers, fencers, farmhands and electricians. We need them all.

Oher · 23/12/2022 20:35

I can only speak for my area, but I pulled my child out of state school to go private because:

  • the state school actively disliked clever kids and did nothing to progress them. The school were obsessed with making the whole class the same level. Good news for the bottom of the class, bad news if you’re clever.
  • Many of the state school teachers were often rude and sarcastic to the children and crushed their confidence.
  • there were some incidents that made it clear my child was not physically safe there which was again damaging his confidence.
  • the school was teaching the children that bad behaviour gets attention and those who are well behaved go nowhere.

At private school:

  • there’s an expectation that he will do well academically, and if this isn’t happening he gets extra help
  • the teachers are polite and respectful to the children, who learn to expect this from others (and to be polite themselves).
  • badly behaved kids get kicked out, well behaved kids get extra status like a cool badge/tie.
  • There is a huge focus on developing the children’s confidence.

Of course private school kids go further. But we shouldn’t be talking about ‘privilege’ we should be asking why state schools teach fuck all and crush children’s confidence. I don’t blame the teachers btw it’s decades of incompetent government and inadequate funding.

Hoppinggreen · 23/12/2022 20:30

tickticksnooze · 23/12/2022 18:53

Other posters will now get aggressive because pointing this out invalidates their self-image.

Or because it’s a complete generalisation

whumpthereitis · 23/12/2022 20:18

tickticksnooze · 23/12/2022 18:53

Other posters will now get aggressive because pointing this out invalidates their self-image.

Aha, a preemptive invalidation. Because people can’t merely disagree with you, they have to secretly agree you’re right whilst feeling compelled to defend themselves.

XingMing · 23/12/2022 19:43

@tickticksnooze when you say "unqualified" teachers, you suggest they have no qualifications when you really mean they don't have a PGCE or or a B.Ed... but most private schools are very concerned that teachers have a degree or better in the subject they teach. Personally, I would rather they had a degree and experience in the subject than a PGCE, which is the equivalent of the one-year conversion course for people with other academic degrees planning to be lawyers.

TheaBrandt · 23/12/2022 19:13

The end result in our small city is utterly interchangeable 😁. Actually the teens state and private tend to all socialise together. But maybe area specific our comp is full of doctors and lawyers kids as well as kids not from those backgrounds.

tickticksnooze · 23/12/2022 18:53

Other posters will now get aggressive because pointing this out invalidates their self-image.

tickticksnooze · 23/12/2022 18:52

The point of private schools was (is) to buy the network, connections, status and reputation. It had nothing to do with being a superior education, that's just PR - it was the norm in private schools to use unqualified "teachers".

They have slick and aggressive marketing.

Hence why they covered up child sexual abuse because it would have damaged their reputation - and that has always been the most important.

Jonnywishbone · 23/12/2022 18:51

I'm in the middle east. Kids at private schools here are the children of hugely ambitious parents and children do hours more homework than other schools. Was the same with my kids in the UK when they were at school there.

If you do another 500 hours homework a year for 10 years eg 5000 hours you will probably do better in exams and life no?

silverbe11 · 23/12/2022 18:44

I'm sorry, I don't really know any of the particular schools you mention OP. If the results seem similar between the state and the smaller private schools in your area, you would need a very good reason to go for the private options, on my opinion. It totally depends on the needs / personality of your son.

In terms of 'future personalities,' I don't think a minor private school would make any difference whatsoever really. Sure, the standards of behaviour might be higher in the private school (easier to expel bad behaviour). There might be marginally more opportunities for public speaking etc? I think there is something about most independent schools that seems to promote 'soft skills' perhaps - such as looking people in the eye when you shake hands etc? It's hard to put your finger on, but you tend to get less teenagers of the type who sort of skulk about and avoid making eye-contact. I think that's the kind of 'confidence' some people allude to when they talk about private schools? It's more the 'famous' schools where this kind of 'confidence' tends to be more marked though - not just the big boarding schools, but also the 'big name' London Day Schools. They seem to instil a sense that there are no limits to what you can do. But also you can give them all this at home probably, depending on the type of family you are.

TheaBrandt · 23/12/2022 18:32

It’s not as simple / binary as private school good / state bad. Depends where you live, your family’s attitudes and your child’s talents/ personality.

If you have a good state option and are confident educated parents private school seems an utter waste of money to me. But that’s just my subjective experience.

Potsnpans23 · 23/12/2022 18:21

Yes, I wonder whether as many personalities will be from private schools going forth seeing as they've become so much more expensive

OP posts:
Radiatorvalves · 23/12/2022 17:11

Sorry that was in response to the comments about streaming.

Radiatorvalves · 23/12/2022 17:09

That’s why we went private. Nearest “good” comp was too far away (we are talking 100m) so we were allocated a further away school (distance wasn’t a big issue). But that school very proudly stated there was no streaming. I had an issue with that approach.

whumpthereitis · 23/12/2022 15:38

I went to private school. My parents were immigrants, and they actively wanted to send me to a British private school based on reputation.

What you get from it is often dependent on the school itself. Some will provide more opportunities in the way of networking, for example. The funding that goes into them usually means excellent amenities, as well as a broader range of subjects. Add in smaller class sizes, and a ‘work hard’ ethos (at least in mine). This was of course backed up at home.

It definitely opened doors, and provided a solid foundation upon which to build.

Fraine · 23/12/2022 15:28

I am surrounded by privately educated white people at work. Their privilege really shows.

NewToWoo · 23/12/2022 15:24

The private school system tends to encourage a work hard ethos that celebrates academic success - crucially not just from teachers down to pupils, but within peer groups. Nothing makes a child work harder than when their peers cheer because they got an A. That means they are encouraged to strive from a young age, and to plan strategically for their future.

They get loads more extra support - particularly careers advice - which unis to apply for, courses to take, work placements to go for. There's money in the system which state schools can't begin to compete with.

Then there's the old-boy network which is fostered. Lots of connections, friends in high places offering jobs to people they know. Powerful parents of school mates being in a position to offer interesting internships and work experience and freelance projects etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread