Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What age should bottle of milk and dummy stop?

56 replies

susiesuelou · 23/12/2022 10:06

My DD is 20 months old. She still has a bottle of milk (cows milk) on an evening before bedtime (the only thing that successfully gets her to sleep), and a dummy when she's either tired or upset (the only thing aside from a cuddle that will soothe her when she's upset - she sometimes even goes to the place in the kitchen where she knows the dummies are kept and reaches up for them when upset).

I know this can be a contentious issue that sparks a lot of debate... Just want to know general opinions on whether it's OK for me to continue both of these things until she turns 2, and then start to phase them out? As that was my plan.

Thanks.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
samstownsunset · 24/12/2022 19:39

My DC never had bottles but the younger two had/have dummies.

Youngest is 2.5 and loves his so I wouldn't dream of taking it away cold turkey. He can have it for as long as he wants, I really don't care.
Only rule I have is that he takes it out when talking.
I find as they get older they have it less and less anyway and most dummies are orthodontic so I don't worry about his teeth.

peanutbutterjelly500 · 24/12/2022 19:17

@Reugny have you heard of a Thumbsie? I got one for my thumb sucking son when he was in reception and he kicked the habit with ease within a week or so

miltonj · 24/12/2022 15:45

Whenever you like! Milk and a dummy won't do a child any long term harm if it's led by the child. As in as long as you're not sticking a dummy in a 5 year olds mouth and telling them to shut up 😅 other than that, you're fine!

voxnihili · 24/12/2022 15:40

My DD (almost 4.5) still has a bottle of milk before bed. She just won’t ditch it and at the moment I don’t have the energy for the battle. We clean her teeth afterwards. We’ve tried all manner of cups (she uses a normal cup fine in the day) but she won’t entertain anything except for a bottle in the evening.

surreygirl1987 · 24/12/2022 14:15

Mine still has a bottle before bed (followed by brushing teeth) and a dummy for sleep, and he's 2 and a half. We plan to take him off both in a few months, before he is 3. Same as my eldest son - he was 3 when we stopped his dummy at night time (I think he stopped his bottle before that though). Asked a dentist about it with my first, and he didn't seem the slightest bit concerned, as long as we brushed teeth after bottle. He also said dummy is far better than them getting into the thumb-sucking habit.

The 'dummy fairy' is how we got it off my eldest - he was perfectly willing to give it up and it was very easy.

Pastash · 24/12/2022 14:08

In terms of the actual evidence, it is not going to cause any problems at all for your child to continue
a) the evening bottle until whenever as long as you brush her teeth afterwards
b) dummies are only associated with orthodontic issues age 4+

you can absolutely wait until age 3 and then tell her as there are only a finite number of bottles and dummies in the world she needs to send hers on to a new baby, but she can get whatever big girl toy she likes instead

wouldthatbeworse · 24/12/2022 13:58

My kids LOVED their bottles. Both had morning milk in a baby bottle until nearly 3. Bottles then replaced to sippy cups with due warning. Both survived unscathed.

Reugny · 24/12/2022 13:58

oakleaffy · 24/12/2022 13:54

DS never had a dummy or bottles-
but was a thumb sucker
One cannot take a thumb away!
Luckily it had no impact on teeth.
Sippy cup was what we used.

I have one of those.

Funny thing is if the thumb falls out when she is asleep she doesn't automatically put it back in her mouth.

IToldYouAmillionTimesAlready · 24/12/2022 13:56

JJJSchmidt · 23/12/2022 10:07

I'd be aiming to stop both by 1st birthday due to the impact on teeth

The child is already 20 months old

oakleaffy · 24/12/2022 13:54

DS never had a dummy or bottles-
but was a thumb sucker
One cannot take a thumb away!
Luckily it had no impact on teeth.
Sippy cup was what we used.

Looneytune253 · 24/12/2022 13:49

We removed the dummy at 6 months and 5 months. 5 months was too young as she then turned into a finger sucker. Didn't bother too much with bottles but they both had a sippy cup with milk in until about 3 or 4.

SomeCommonThing · 24/12/2022 13:01

I removed the dummy at 8months, DS only had it for sleeping so I've no advice on that.
The bottle was more of a gradual transition, he started having water in a beaker or cup in the day, and then around 18months had his bedtime milk in a beaker (too sleepy for a cup). He loved his bedtime milk and at 2 was only having a cup of milk at breakfast and bedtime.
Maybe a transition to a special cup to encourage removing the bottle?

Plantmum2047 · 24/12/2022 12:49

susiesuelou · 23/12/2022 10:16

That's a really good point about brushing teeth after the bottle. I brush her teeth after her bath and then she has her bedtime bottle half an hour afterwards and falls asleep with it. I could maybe try the bottle sooner straight after bath, brush teeth and then dummy to get her to sleep.

Feel really daunting to try to get her to sleep without that bedtime bottle, it's all I've ever done 😬

Do you take the bottle off her before she sleeps? I don't want to scaremonger but I know someone who let baby fall asleep with bottle, child chewed teat off, choked and tragically passed away from this.

RunLolaRun102 · 24/12/2022 12:47

Depends on the child. If she has additional needs or sleep / weight gain issues then I’d keep going & resolve the dental issues if and when they arise. I still breastfeed my 3 yo to sleep but we are serious about toothbrushing and so there aren’t any issues.

Sundala · 24/12/2022 12:43

Ds2 had severe reflux and it was recommended he use a dummy to keep swallowing down saliva. He was 3 when he stopped using the dummy which was in the day time too due to the reflux. He still has reflux today, he is 16. Bottles of milk it was just before he was 2 for the night time one. In the day he never had a bottle past 1 year old. He did have an older sibling though so he modelled cup drinking at the table with meals.

Teeth wise his teeth are lovely however, he learned to speak around the dummy so needed speech therapy at nursery to relearn words. He could pronounce the sounds but would mispronounce words he already knew. The dummy prevented scarring of his oesophagus which was the important thing.

Basically it is up to you when you want to stop it. I would never advise around Christmas purely because of all the extra stuff that usually occurs with visitors or visiting and she may need that dummy. But after that you just teach her a new way to sleep ie without the bottle. You just have to know that it will take several nights, she will be upset but it won't last forever. You have to stand strong and hopefully you have a very supportive partner and you are a team who can do things together.

AccountDetail · 24/12/2022 12:25

Hv advice is 12 months, which I follow. Never did dummies, hospital advised against the, but I hazing seem to recall advice if you do give them is 6 months? But maybe it is thr same as bottles.
My mother was a bit lazy, she thought I'd naturally move away. I remember the fits and arguments at 4, just before school because I still wanted my bedtime bottle. It is so unnecessary. The younger the better.

elevenplusdilemma · 24/12/2022 11:47

12 months. Milk in a sippy or open cup after that point. No need for dummies at this age.

sheepdogdelight · 24/12/2022 11:27

susiesuelou · 23/12/2022 10:47

@TheBirdintheCave

That's one of my main considerations- I want to be able to communicate these things to her in a way she has a chance of understanding. If that makes sense.

In answer to your question, I'd agree with trying to wean off by age 1 because of impacts on teeth (one poster telling you their DC's teeth are fine despite bottles past this age is irrelevant).

But you can't possibly wait to make decisions about your child until she's old enough to fully understand them. I'd switch to milk out of a cup earlier in the evening and offer water (from a cup) at bedtime if she insists she's thirsty. Yes, she may complain at first, but she's not going to find it any easier and likely we will find it harder the longer you leave it.

riotlady · 24/12/2022 11:11

DD had a bottle of milk until about 2, dummy til 3. With the milk, I started by switching to a Tommy tippee insulated sippy cup, then eventually replaced the milk with water.

littleducks · 24/12/2022 11:02

I didn't use dummies or bottles with my three, so not personal experience in that respect but I'm work with families of children needing feeding support and have taught many babies to use open cups and straws. These are better for oral development then sippy cups.

Rather than focusing on removing the bottle focus on introducing a new exciting cup she can choose herself and switch to that?

OodieBoogie · 24/12/2022 10:55

Hangupsrus · 23/12/2022 10:30

My 3 dc all had dummies and bottles of milk until they were 3 and all have lovely, straight, healthy teeth. Dentist used to warn about use of them but now comments how perfectly lovely/straight their teeth are. I'm glad I didn't listen because they all got so much comfort from the dummies and bottles.

Whereas in our house, we tipped up at the dentist with a 2.5 yr old and the dentist (who we'd never seen before, never mentioned dummy use before) said "the dummy is affecting his teeth and palette, it's pulling his front teeth forward". The dummy went that night. Couple of evenings of major sadness and crying and it was ok.

Sceptre86 · 24/12/2022 10:24

Every posters advice is going to vary massively as all kids are different. The hv would probably advised that you should have stopped already. My dd2 is 15 months, she started taking a dummy at 6 months. I'll take it away when she is about 2. She only uses it at bedtime and naptime so I've got no issues with it. As for bottles, she will gradually reduce them and I tend to get rid of them when I toilet train.

The best advice I can give is to be aware of the generic advice but tailor your approach to your child and go by their needs. So if baby won't take a beaker with milk in yet, carry on with a bottle and try again in another 2-3 months etc.

gogohmm · 24/12/2022 08:53

Weaned onto a sippy cup around 16 months (from breastfeeding) no dummy. They don't need them at this point

AmySma1 · 24/12/2022 08:47

Mu DD had a bottle until just after 3 for bedtime only, she's just turned 4 and still has a dummy at home and in the car. We take it out when she goes to sleep but it's bit affected her teeth and it is still a real comfort to her. If it makes them happy there's no rush at the moment

Survey99 · 23/12/2022 14:35

ds went to a free flow sippy cup at bedtime around his first birthday.

We feed after his teeth were brushed until he was around 3ish. We weighed up milk after brushing vs having to wait 30 mins after milk to brush and went for brushing after milk.

If you are going to wait until she can understand why there is going to be a change you are going to be waiting too long...