Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if squatting on the toilet to do your business is really a thing?

183 replies

AmazonPrim · 23/12/2022 01:03

I visited a suppliers office for work (a major British company with a swank Central London head office). I used one of the loos in the lobby (there was 3 unisex loos, each with their own separate door and sink inside completely separate from the next).

On the back of the door was a sign showing a person squatting with their feet on the seat and a line drawn through it to indicate no squatting. Like this was a common problem they were dealing with? Do people actually squat with both feet on the seat to do their business on a western style toilet?! I know squatting toilets are common in parts of Asia, but they are on the ground. If I tried to squat on a western toilet I would no doubt fall in and break my ankle Confused

This brought my thoughts back to about 15 years ago when I dated an Asian guy. We went to his mums house to visit her and his sister. His dad was away on business so it was just the mum and sister at home. I went to use the toilet and the seat was up which I thought was a bit weird since there were no men in the house. Anyway, I put it down, did my business and came back and we visited and ate lunch. I went back to the loo again before we left and the seat was up again. My boyfriend at the time hadn't been to the toilet the entire time we were there. So why was the seat up again??

I didn't have the confidence to ask him, but the first scenario about the signs in the office loos got me thinking about this situation as well.

OP posts:
BoxOfCats · 23/12/2022 03:56

Once many years ago when I was visiting China, not only was the toilet in a place I visited a squat toilet, it was actually just a hole in a small bridge that went over a stream. Out in the open air, no privacy at all. I was only about 8 years old at the time and I refused to use it!

Fireandflight · 23/12/2022 03:54

I'm elderly. If I tried to stand on a toilet seat, I would 'have a fall " and no doubt be waiting hours for an ambulance.

lurkinglittleladybug · 23/12/2022 03:52

Happyhappyday · 23/12/2022 02:12

My husband’s office had an issue with men taking a dump in the corner of the toilet stalls so honestly squatting on them when that’s what you grew up with seems completely normal…

Ugh this is so gross! The mind boggles why someone would even do this … It’s the poor cleaners dealing with this madness I feel for! 😱🤢

Maybe places should start to provide toilet cubicles which are just a hole in the ground type toilet for those who are not civilised enough to sit on a toilet in the way it’s made to be used? Or foot stools they can stand on so they are not damaging property and breaking toilet seats every time they go to the toilet?

Then at least those of us who like to sit on a toilet that’s not broken/ covered in shit or had someone’s feet on the seat before us can still do so 🤢

I have actually always thought it would be nice if public toilets provided sanitizer spray and paper towels to clean the seat before and after use… I thought maybe I was being OCD to think this but perhaps not 🤔

Delectable · 23/12/2022 03:49

It's a healthier and more natural position. Same as with giving birth. It's safer and makes childbirth much easier than lying on your back. Imagine being constipated and going against gravity lying on your back but in Western medicine for the doctor's convenience women generally lay on their backs or sit up to give birth.

sausagedogpookie · 23/12/2022 03:39

Maybe instead of ‘No feet on the seat’ type posters in toilets, employers/universities/service stations/wherever should be putting up educational-type picture posters, with simple illustrations as to how to use a western toilet correctly and cleanly without breaking it? Seems obvious if the reasoning (if posts on here are anything to go by) is that some people just don’t actually know how to use a western loo?🤷🏻‍♀️

DPotter · 23/12/2022 03:10

I had to show an elderly gentleman from an Arabic country how to sit rather than squat on a toilet - we shared no common language either so it was interesting. I was working as a nurse in a hospital at the time

Thisisconfusing · 23/12/2022 02:55

I saw a tv programme about this once .Squatting is supposed to be better . If you can’t do that you can use a stool to create the similar angle so poo just slips out of you . Less chance of piles etc .

I first saw the no squatting sign on holiday in Finland a few years ago And was similarly puzzled that it was needed. It obviously is - I went to a concert when I got back to U.K. and found that previous occupant had left shoe prints on the seat 😬

MarshaMelrose · 23/12/2022 02:52

Easy to say 'surely you adapt' but if you don't know how another culture does it, and you don't feel you can ask (nor until the issue arises, realise theres any need TO ask)... what do you do?

That's nonsense. We're not talking about a one time action. This happens repeated times. They now how to use a toilet. No one who has sufficient English and education to come to a university is incapable of working it out. They make friends with other people on the course. They see other people in the toilets, they hear other people using the toilets. They know how to use the toilet correctly.
It's quite insulting to say they don't understand.

Morestrangethings · 23/12/2022 02:48

AmazonPrim · 23/12/2022 02:25

In what persons right mind would they choose to take a shit on the floor in the corner of a stall rather than sit for a minute on a toilet and flush their business away.

I mean seriously. What goes through their heads when they see that as a better option!?!

I used to work in an office (finance) where luckily I didn't encounter anything this bad. But the backs and sides of the stall doors were littered with crusty dried boogers and at times the stalls were left kind of grim and the toilets not flushed. I would walk out onto the main office floor and look at everyone working away and think to myself - Jesus, which one of you is the filthy fucking animal that leaves the loo in such a state. You rank people! And I have to work with you and encounter dIly interactions and you could be the phantom booger bathroom plasterer. 😑

Think of the cleaner. I used to work early mornings cleaning a pub while putting myself through uni and bringing up a family.

The mens toilets were the grossest. The woman’s toilets the messiest. Although neither were nice to clean, I used to rage silently in my head while cleaning the mens.

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 23/12/2022 02:47

When I lived in an Asian country with a largely westernised infrastructure, there were horrific photos off the injuries that can be got from squatting on a western toilet on the doors. It was really regular you became kind of immune to horrific dismemberment pictures.
Funny when I tried to Google it just now I couldn't find a single one, apart from nice clean bandaged amputee after pictures. That suggests to me they were personal pictures from the venues so that horrific injuries were far more common than I thought.
It's pretty annoying injuries and breakages aside as they usually got shit everywhere.

mackthepony · 23/12/2022 02:46

Yet another reason to WFH

lurkinglittleladybug · 23/12/2022 02:36

scrivette · 23/12/2022 01:12

My friend once told me that at her place of work many years ago they had to put up signs as people were breaking the toilet seats by squatting.

I sometimes get little DC to squat but only at home, as he suffers from constipation and it does seem to work. (I hold him so he doesn't fall in).

I have noticed at my work place the toilet seats are always broken, as soon as they are replaced they get broken almost immediately… It’s actually kind of annoying… I need to sit to pee … It’s that bad a situation that I’m considering taking a shewee to work 🫣 … It’s fucking annoying and actually really inconsiderate, if people are doing this I wish they would lift the seat and not just break them! … Must be costing work an absolute fortune too… It’s also dangerous, I work in a care home so elderly residents can fall if they sit on a broken seat and slip off the toilet. (It’s almost happened to me a few times and I’m not frail with poor balance unlike the residents).

I actually had no idea this was a thing but it makes complete sense now and I suspect this is what many staff are doing at my work.

Wingedharpy · 23/12/2022 02:29

RunLolaRun102 · 23/12/2022 01:50

My Muslim friends all squat as they have to wash down their with water before prayers & it’s the most hygienic way to do it in British toilets. Our workplace have a bidet toilet outside the prayer room but it gets taken over by men and can be so gross until the cleaner can get in

I don't think Muslims wash their nether regions before prayer.
Washing of nether regions after toilet use - ok.
I think before prayer it's hands, face, mouth, ears and feet.

I'm not Muslim but have a Muslim Brother-in-law who, AFAIK, has never stood on my toilet.

He does find a bidet very helpful as a foot bath though!

WiddlinDiddlin · 23/12/2022 02:26

The seats with the gap in the front are supposedly so its easier to wipe yourself in front without touching the seat with your hand.

Easy to say 'surely you adapt' but if you don't know how another culture does it, and you don't feel you can ask (nor until the issue arises, realise theres any need TO ask)... what do you do? Our conditioning to how and where we urinate/defecate is incredibly strong, changing how we do that is not easy (see, any of the threads about female squat urinals at festivals).

And of course everyone thinks their way is better so thats another reason to be reluctant to change.

AmazonPrim · 23/12/2022 02:25

In what persons right mind would they choose to take a shit on the floor in the corner of a stall rather than sit for a minute on a toilet and flush their business away.

I mean seriously. What goes through their heads when they see that as a better option!?!

I used to work in an office (finance) where luckily I didn't encounter anything this bad. But the backs and sides of the stall doors were littered with crusty dried boogers and at times the stalls were left kind of grim and the toilets not flushed. I would walk out onto the main office floor and look at everyone working away and think to myself - Jesus, which one of you is the filthy fucking animal that leaves the loo in such a state. You rank people! And I have to work with you and encounter dIly interactions and you could be the phantom booger bathroom plasterer. 😑

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 23/12/2022 02:17

Happyhappyday · 23/12/2022 02:12

My husband’s office had an issue with men taking a dump in the corner of the toilet stalls so honestly squatting on them when that’s what you grew up with seems completely normal…

But surely you adapt when you go to another country, no matter how weird the practice seems to you?

Seeingadistance · 23/12/2022 02:16

MarshaMelrose · 23/12/2022 01:49

Say what? They're on the back of the motorway toilet doors.

I rarely travel long distances by motorway, so I’ve not seen them there.

AmazonPrim · 23/12/2022 02:14

Happyhappyday · 23/12/2022 02:12

My husband’s office had an issue with men taking a dump in the corner of the toilet stalls so honestly squatting on them when that’s what you grew up with seems completely normal…

Say what now!?!?? 🥴🤢

OP posts:
Happyhappyday · 23/12/2022 02:12

My husband’s office had an issue with men taking a dump in the corner of the toilet stalls so honestly squatting on them when that’s what you grew up with seems completely normal…

blameless · 23/12/2022 02:11

I used to have to visit a government building which had those posters on the back of the cubicle doors. Loose stools when a bum is six inches above the the rim is not something that the cleaners should have to deal with.
Decades ago, I remember a friend's wife struggling to deal with a strike where the predominantly female workforce at a luxury baked goods factory wanted an open drain and hose arrangement because toilet pans were considered dirty.

MarshaMelrose · 23/12/2022 02:09

Japanese toilets are just the best, with all the electronic gadgetry. But there were a mix of thrones and holes in the same toilet block. It was bizarre to us westerners.

sashh · 23/12/2022 02:05

FeliciteFaff · 23/12/2022 02:03

My Muslim friends wash sitting on the loo, never heard of anyone squatting. From what I’ve seen they don’t leave any wetness on the floor. Some of the cleanest women I’ve ever seen. Also, Jamaican and African women too, very neat about toilet habits and fastidious about hand washing.

Some Muslim men sit down to pee on sit toilets, they may also hold a piece of toilet paper to aim at so they don't splash.

OP

Yes it can be a problem, even if it isn't you might as well have a sign, it's cheaper than replacing the seat.

FeliciteFaff · 23/12/2022 02:03

My Muslim friends wash sitting on the loo, never heard of anyone squatting. From what I’ve seen they don’t leave any wetness on the floor. Some of the cleanest women I’ve ever seen. Also, Jamaican and African women too, very neat about toilet habits and fastidious about hand washing.

tiredfriday · 23/12/2022 02:02

Imagine a woman in heels trying to do that Shock

Is this the reason some toilet seats aren’t closed to create a full oval? To help prevent them breaking if a squatter comes aboard?

MarshaMelrose · 23/12/2022 01:56

RunLolaRun102 · 23/12/2022 01:50

My Muslim friends all squat as they have to wash down their with water before prayers & it’s the most hygienic way to do it in British toilets. Our workplace have a bidet toilet outside the prayer room but it gets taken over by men and can be so gross until the cleaner can get in

Ugh. The poor cleaner. 🤮

Swipe left for the next trending thread