Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if squatting on the toilet to do your business is really a thing?

183 replies

AmazonPrim · 23/12/2022 01:03

I visited a suppliers office for work (a major British company with a swank Central London head office). I used one of the loos in the lobby (there was 3 unisex loos, each with their own separate door and sink inside completely separate from the next).

On the back of the door was a sign showing a person squatting with their feet on the seat and a line drawn through it to indicate no squatting. Like this was a common problem they were dealing with? Do people actually squat with both feet on the seat to do their business on a western style toilet?! I know squatting toilets are common in parts of Asia, but they are on the ground. If I tried to squat on a western toilet I would no doubt fall in and break my ankle Confused

This brought my thoughts back to about 15 years ago when I dated an Asian guy. We went to his mums house to visit her and his sister. His dad was away on business so it was just the mum and sister at home. I went to use the toilet and the seat was up which I thought was a bit weird since there were no men in the house. Anyway, I put it down, did my business and came back and we visited and ate lunch. I went back to the loo again before we left and the seat was up again. My boyfriend at the time hadn't been to the toilet the entire time we were there. So why was the seat up again??

I didn't have the confidence to ask him, but the first scenario about the signs in the office loos got me thinking about this situation as well.

OP posts:
swapcicles · 23/12/2022 07:03

I worked for a short while at Amazon. The toilets there all had this sign but they also had at least one squat loo in every set of toilets.
Only discovered it by accident as it just looked like all the others. It's a good idea if there's a lot of staff.
Now where I work has a public loo, not a diverse area at all but the loo seat has been broken before by feet (footprint evidence) surely it's safer to lift the seat if you want to squat?

Nimbostratus100 · 23/12/2022 07:00

I haven't read the whole thread, but certainly in many places toilet seats are always left in the up position so no poisonous spiders take up residence under the seat. In some places I have been in the USA, it was against the law to leave a public toilet with the seat down

picklemewalnuts · 23/12/2022 06:55

@AmazonPrim re the seat being up, it's considered the polite way to leave it in Asia. It allows the seat to drain/dry if it's become wet. I had to adjust when I lived away. It feels so wrong to leave the seat up on purpose!

daisychain01 · 23/12/2022 06:38

Shadope · 23/12/2022 01:13

It’s a much more natural position to assume and makes pooing easier. I mean I’ve never done it but it’s not some kind of backwards thing

Exactly, the human bowel is arranged so that squatting is a much more natural and effective way to poo. There are many things in our modern society that aren't ergonomically designed. The other one is seats and chairs, appalling for the back.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 23/12/2022 06:31

It's been a problem where I work, not just because of broken toilets but also because the success rate at hitting the toilet wasn't that high and the poor cleaners had to deal with that.

Mariposa26 · 23/12/2022 05:46

Yes, I work in HR and over the years have had this issue in a few different offices. The main problem is how the toilets/floor/cubicle are often left afterwards which causes difficulty for the poor cleaners who I’ve dealt with a few complaints from.

NewHouseNewMe · 23/12/2022 05:37

Japanese toilet are the best! Mine doesn’t play music but has nozzles, self-cleaning, dryer.. The Japanese have it when it comes to toilet cleanliness.

Back to the squatting, I can’t work out how their clothes aren’t a state? Imagine squatting while wearing high heels and tights..

scrivette · 23/12/2022 05:21

Poppins2016 · 23/12/2022 04:14

Slight tangent but @scrivette my little boy suffers with constipation too. I have a fairly high bathroom storage step (like this and when he's constipated he uses it to bring his feet and legs up into a better position for pushing. Just thought I'd share as I find it much easier than holding a small child (and I know my DS finds it easier too, as he's more in control when pushing and not thinking about falling into the loo/holding tightly onto me)!

Thank you, we have a little stool too but sometimes when it's really difficult squatting works best!

Morestrangethings · 23/12/2022 05:20

sashh · 23/12/2022 04:45

I have actually always thought it would be nice if public toilets provided sanitizer spray and paper towels to clean the seat before and after use… I thought maybe I was being OCD to think this but perhaps not 🤔

There are places where you buy a 'pack' either from a woman at the toilet entrance (Ecuador) or from a machine (Germany) the pack contains toilet paper, sanitizing wipe, toilet seat cover.

Someone mentioned Japanese toilets, I have a friend who has visited a few times, he says he never uses any of the buttons because he is scared it will do something like attempt to wash itself while he is still sitting there.

I recently bought one. Heaven. I needed a new sofa and a new toilet. Decided to buy a cheap second hand sofa and the expensive toilet.

Speedweed · 23/12/2022 05:12

I worked for a global bank in London, obviously male-dominated, and they had these signs - I was told the men's loos always had broken seats because of men standing and squatting on them - nothing to do with being Asian, more to do with the Brirish men eating high protein diets to stay in shape which made them constipated, and apparently this was the way the internet told them to deal with it...

Whattheladybird · 23/12/2022 05:11

My dad was creating signs like this in the 70s (working with recently arrived immigrants). It’s not news

Damnloginpopup · 23/12/2022 05:06

I do.

starrynight21 · 23/12/2022 05:03

I have actually always thought it would be nice if public toilets provided sanitizer spray and paper towels to clean the seat before and after use… I thought maybe I was being OCD to think this but perhaps not

I once used a toilet in the casino in Monaco. When I stood up and flushed , a mechanism came out from under the seat ( a dampened brush type of thing) , and it swept around the entire seat, cleaning it with some kind of disinfectant which smelled lovely. So civilised !

starrynight21 · 23/12/2022 05:00

Rainbowshit · 23/12/2022 01:11

Yes. It's a common problem at my DH's work.

I agree - my son works for a large corporation and he has said that sometimes you see shoe marks on the seats where someone has squatted there. I guess if people have always squatted to do their business, they will continue to do it that way .

MarshaMelrose · 23/12/2022 04:52

Someone mentioned Japanese toilets, I have a friend who has visited a few times, he says he never uses any of the buttons because he is scared it will do something like attempt to wash itself while he is still sitting there.

I know what he means. You never know when you're sat there what might happen. But they play white noise so no one can hear you. All sorts of stuff. I really need a japanese toilet.

sashh · 23/12/2022 04:45

I have actually always thought it would be nice if public toilets provided sanitizer spray and paper towels to clean the seat before and after use… I thought maybe I was being OCD to think this but perhaps not 🤔

There are places where you buy a 'pack' either from a woman at the toilet entrance (Ecuador) or from a machine (Germany) the pack contains toilet paper, sanitizing wipe, toilet seat cover.

Someone mentioned Japanese toilets, I have a friend who has visited a few times, he says he never uses any of the buttons because he is scared it will do something like attempt to wash itself while he is still sitting there.

KevinsChilli · 23/12/2022 04:41

I worked at a University where they had to put these signs up as the international students would do this.

CockingASnook · 23/12/2022 04:24

Squatting and washing is actually a far better way of ‘doing your business’ than sitting and wiping. I’d love to have a bidet in my next house though I’m not sure a squat loo is possible.

Poppins2016 · 23/12/2022 04:14

Slight tangent but @scrivette my little boy suffers with constipation too. I have a fairly high bathroom storage step (like this and when he's constipated he uses it to bring his feet and legs up into a better position for pushing. Just thought I'd share as I find it much easier than holding a small child (and I know my DS finds it easier too, as he's more in control when pushing and not thinking about falling into the loo/holding tightly onto me)!

smooththecat · 23/12/2022 04:08

Yes they do and it breaks the toilet seat.

constantindigestion · 23/12/2022 04:06

Muslims wash faces hands and arms and feet before prayers (AFAIK).
They wash themselves after using the toilet for either wee or poo.
The shataf (or bum gun) is a game changer - I use ours all the time. Definitely more hygienic

aurynne · 23/12/2022 04:05

ILoveeCakes · 23/12/2022 01:36

You're missing the point. If I took the time to read up on the science of pooing (maybe I'll get to this topic if I live to 1000 years old!) I'd then take 2 mins to try it out. I don't believe you'd spend all this time reading about pooing (why anyway?) and then not even take one Euro squat out of scientific curiosity.

What else do you read up about? But then not do?

I like to read about the Hadron Collider, but I haven't tried to play with subatomic particles in my free time yet.

Are you usually this obtuse or is it a special day today?

Spartak · 23/12/2022 04:01

My lodgers are Indian - a married couple. They always leave the seat up, and don't use any toilet paper.

They've discreetly left a small jug by the side of the loo which I assume they are using for washing afterwards. Sometimes I'll hear the shower going for a minute or two afterwards as well.

Doesn't bother me, my last lodger used to get through rolls and rolls of paper.

constantindigestion · 23/12/2022 04:01

Common in the ME and Asia

Suzi888 · 23/12/2022 03:59

I am impressed with the level of dexterity required to adopt the position - outstanding.