Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
RhannionKPSS · 23/12/2022 23:34

It was fantastic that Pam Gosal mentioned Beira’s Place when she spoke in Parliament yesterday. The women who will be working there are experienced in many areas and are not beholden to anyone.

Waitwhat23 · 23/12/2022 23:25

I suspect organisations which choose to use the single sex exemptions they are entitled to use as stated in the EQA2010 (and are brave enough to risk being targeted by TRA's and are able to not have to rely on funding offered by an utterly captured Government, like in Scotland) will find themselves in unpleasant conversations with intimidating males who insist that they are literally females and so denying them from using a single sex service is literally a hate crime. I've seen various TRA's on Twitter insist that Beira's Place is illegally discriminating against transwomen and many have declared their intention to challenge the service. I wonder how many organisations will have the courage to hold firm.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 23/12/2022 22:56

A question, if you are unable to ask if someone has a grc and if they do then they have an altered birth certificate how do you exclude natal males with a grc, so for example you want a same set health care provider- you can see its a male in front of you but they can prove they are a woman. In that situation how does the single sex exemption help?

2nd question for situations where you wouldn't be able to request a birth certificate again you can see its a male born person but they state they are female how the hell do you exclude them?

Sugarfree23 · 23/12/2022 22:42

Given the "live like a woman / man" is 100% based on stereotypes, how could you ever prove beyond all reasonable doubt that someone did lie?

Are transwomen only ever allowed to wear skirts?? 🤔

Ofcourseshecan · 23/12/2022 22:33

Ofcourseshecan · 23/12/2022 22:08

They do have to pledge that they will live forever as the opposite gender.

Which of course is impossible to predict. It’s not even possible to know if the person making the pledge is lying.

At least one transman (ie natal female) in England had artificial insemination a few days after receiving a GRC, and went on to give birth.

And there is no penalty if they do lie.

Sugarfree23 · 23/12/2022 22:13

Define life forever, marriage is meant to be forever but plenty are broken and nobody actually cares.

Ofcourseshecan · 23/12/2022 22:08

DesertSolitaire · 23/12/2022 08:27

They do have to pledge that they will live forever as the opposite gender. There is no explanation of what it means to live as the opposite gender. The example given is to change your name on households bills. In reality there is no particular way of living as a man or a women.

I'm still waiting for a definition of what living as a women looks like. I suspect I'm womaning wrong.

They do have to pledge that they will live forever as the opposite gender.

Which of course is impossible to predict. It’s not even possible to know if the person making the pledge is lying.

At least one transman (ie natal female) in England had artificial insemination a few days after receiving a GRC, and went on to give birth.

GentlySobbing · 23/12/2022 21:29

The EHRC guidance posted below is new, and published after the appointment of Akua Reindorf's appointment as an EHRC commissioner. Reindorf is not a gender adherent, and her appointment led to a notable change in EHRC policy (on a side note she has today been appointed a KC, so huge congratulations due to her).

The EHRC's previous advice contained a little table which set out how service providers should treat people who have undergone gender reassignment without a GRC, and those that have. The advice was that excluding a male with a GRC from a women's single sex service was a very high bar to reach, and was higher than the bar for excluding those without a GRC. So technically legally possible (as per Sch 3 of the EA), but unlikely to happen in practice. Possession of a GRC therefore, under that guidance, led to a change in ability to be admitted to women's spaces.

This advice then filtered down to policy makers, meaning that it is a common position that GRC holders cannot be excluded from single sex spaces. This is the relevant clause of the Ministry of Justice's policy (upheld last year at judicial review) for the treatment of GRC holders:

‘4.64 The Gender Recognition Act 2004 section 9 says that when a full GRC is issued to a person, the person’s gender becomes, for all purposes, their acquired gender. This means that transgender women prisoners with GRCs must be treated in the same way as biological women for all purposes. Transgender women with GRCs must be placed in the women’s estate/AP unless there are exceptional circumstances, as would be the case for biological women.'

So the EHRC's current guidance on what service providers can legally do is not having an effect on what service providers are actually doing. Possibly because it is still very new, but more likely because it gives service providers a nice clean line for policy making ("GRC = in. Bish bash bosh").

Waitwhat23 · 23/12/2022 21:20

It's also interesting to note that there are currently 230 transgender prisoners in the UK prison system, of whom 97 have been convicted of a sexual offence - questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2022-11-25/96653

Helleofabore · 23/12/2022 20:37

Thanks everyone but I would like seriesofstillkmages to provide the evidence of what they are declaring.

It is absolutely up to them to evidence their assertions. And if they cannot with confidence that that it is currently 20, and that it includes any transitioned male with a GRC, they need to stop posting misinformation.

howmanybicycles · 23/12/2022 19:51

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 17:20

Yes, exactly. Because of the exception in the EA, a trans woman, with or without a GRC, can be excluded from a single sex women’s service/space. The EHRC guidance makes this clear.

it’s amazing how many people here believe that a person having a GRC means they cannot be excluded.

Can you not see that they're NOT being excluded? Pretty much all 'women's' spaces are now mixed sex. The conflation of sex and gender is causing this problem. The pretence that TWAW is causing this problem. If gender recognition really was just the smoke screen that we thought TW wanted and they continued to be excluded from all single sex provision (rape crisis centres, prisons, changing rooms, toilets, hospital wards, sports etc.) then women would not be up in arms. The fact is, though, that they are demanding their right to make all such spaces mixed sex and the right to tell women how they (the women) identify in order to support their belief that they have more in common with me than other men do.

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 19:05

Helleofabore · 23/12/2022 18:24

Have we got any links of evidence for the exact number of males in female prisons in the UK? Or are we just relying on a poster’s word that there are ‘only 20’?

Nobody knows, because transgender males with a GRC aren't counted in the statistics.

We only know how many transgender males have been housed in women's prisons despite not having a GRC.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/12/2022 18:34

Figures

this is the most recent I could find which said 125 in England & wales.

but it does not include prisoners which have a GRC

nilsmousehammer · 23/12/2022 18:33

If it is 'only 20' ... only....

those twenty males have managed to do a lot of damage between them by the accounts of female prisoners and guards.

Helleofabore · 23/12/2022 18:24

Have we got any links of evidence for the exact number of males in female prisons in the UK? Or are we just relying on a poster’s word that there are ‘only 20’?

speakout · 23/12/2022 18:11

aseriesofstillimages

Thankyou for the reference.
Although this legislation will seek to supercede the EA definitions of gender.
"Trans" becomes female- and therefore all the protection for women only places is meaningless.
As is seen already in scotland- trans women working in refuges, being transferred to female prison.

nilsmousehammer · 23/12/2022 18:03

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 17:31

I’m not arguing for the sake of arguing, or to try and ‘win’. You raise issues that need to be considered properly and objectively. But it doesn’t help anyone if you go around confidently believing and stating things that aren’t true - such as that it is not legally possible to exclude a trans woman with a GRC from a single sex service.

The judgement just last week has thrown all this into doubt (again) hasn't it?

And TQ+ lobby groups have been vigorously teaching everyone a false version of law that the exceptions can't really ever be used, haven't they?

And the TQ+ lobby groups harass, persecute, threaten and do their best to shut down any group that dares to try and use an exception don't they?

So in reality, the exceptions do not work, female people do not have quality of access, hence women pushing for the EA to be updated with a hell of a lot more clarity. Hence pretty much three quarters of the threads here. Had you noticed Sarah's thread at all? Her issues with an accessible service?

(Here we get the terribly reasonable 'yes but NICE services just don't want to and you can't make them.)

Yes. The EA needs updating to insist that for equality of female people single sex services must be part of the provision to avoid female people taking their choice between surrendering to mixed sex provision if able, or being punished by exclusion if not. Because lets be honest about this, the goal of the TQ+ political lobby is that no such spaces are allowed to exist, isn't it?

If they'd spare a tiny inch of equality of compassion for female people and allow them equality of access we could all go and do something else with our lives. And fuck me would I be grateful because this is so fucking depressing it's getting ridiculous.

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 17:59

speakout · 23/12/2022 17:40

aseriesofstillimages

such as that it is not legally possible to exclude a trans woman with a GRC from a single sex service.

With regard to the new legislation/proposals, can you post links or references. I would hate to be in a state of ignorance.

The EHRC guidance on single sex spaces and the equality act, which applies to England, Scotland and Wales, page 5.

The Scottish changes to the GRC process don’t change this.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?
babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 17:54

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 17:31

I’m not arguing for the sake of arguing, or to try and ‘win’. You raise issues that need to be considered properly and objectively. But it doesn’t help anyone if you go around confidently believing and stating things that aren’t true - such as that it is not legally possible to exclude a trans woman with a GRC from a single sex service.

This isn't terrible helpful if in practice organisations are behaving as though it is not legally possible to exclude a transgender male with a GRC - or indeed without one - from a female only service.

That's why the law now needs to change to mandate the provision of single sex services from which all members of the opposite sex - GRC or not - are in fact excluded, where women have a genuine need for those services to be single sex.

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 17:52

midgetastic · 23/12/2022 17:36

I love the term vast majority for a population that is meant to be so small we shouldn't be concerned about them

You are probably true as it takes sone time to get transferred and only the most serious offenders are in prison long enough to get through the process

Having a grc will speed that up

‘Vast majority’ refers to proportion, not number. If there were ten trans women and 9 were in the male estate, that would still be the vast majority of them.

speakout · 23/12/2022 17:47

OneTC like you I have not seen " criteria exclusion"

OneTC · 23/12/2022 17:43

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 17:20

Yes, exactly. Because of the exception in the EA, a trans woman, with or without a GRC, can be excluded from a single sex women’s service/space. The EHRC guidance makes this clear.

it’s amazing how many people here believe that a person having a GRC means they cannot be excluded.

So considering the type of criminal that has been allowed in women's prisons what's the criteria for exclusion then?

speakout · 23/12/2022 17:40

aseriesofstillimages

such as that it is not legally possible to exclude a trans woman with a GRC from a single sex service.

With regard to the new legislation/proposals, can you post links or references. I would hate to be in a state of ignorance.

PaterPower · 23/12/2022 17:37

The vast majority of trans women in the prison estate are housed in male prisons, which suggests otherwise.

You state that with such confidence, I assume you’re relying on published stat’s to back up your assertion?

The same stat’s, one assumes, that FOI requests have revealed aren’t routinely being recorded…?

midgetastic · 23/12/2022 17:36

I love the term vast majority for a population that is meant to be so small we shouldn't be concerned about them

You are probably true as it takes sone time to get transferred and only the most serious offenders are in prison long enough to get through the process

Having a grc will speed that up