Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 10:42

As Labour couldn't give two shits about women, not a big surprise.

TonTonMacoute · 24/12/2022 10:37

According to today's Telegraph Kier Starmer has pledged to introduce the Scottish legislation across the rest of the UK.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 24/12/2022 09:56

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 17:31

I’m not arguing for the sake of arguing, or to try and ‘win’. You raise issues that need to be considered properly and objectively. But it doesn’t help anyone if you go around confidently believing and stating things that aren’t true - such as that it is not legally possible to exclude a trans woman with a GRC from a single sex service.

You have that reversed.

TRAs say that. Stonewall has long counselled that in its various expensive sessions, bought and believed by many government departments as well as large organisations. That their claims of being "ahead if the law"were shown, in a court, to mean they were misinforming all, hasn't stopped them.

Women here are saying that institutional capture means that it can effectively be impossible to insist on single sex spaces.

That you choose to spin that to make us out to be fucking stupid is your gamez not ours!

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 24/12/2022 09:50

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 12:44

I haven’t read the whole thread, but every response I’ve read so far has either been misleading or outright false.

The EA allows single sex services/spaces to exist (and not be unlawfully discriminatory on the basis of sex, despite excluding men, or women, as the case may be) in certain contexts, as long as they are a proportionate means to achieve a legitimate aim. The EA also provides that such services are not unlawfully discriminatory on the basis of gender reassignment, if they meet the same test.

So a women-only service or space can exclude trans women if it is a proportionate means to achieve a legitimate aim, regardless of whether the trans woman has a GRC or not. The recent court case that held a trans woman with a GRC is a woman for the purposes of the EA does not alter this.

Come to work with me. See what gender ideology did to our funding for 4 or 5 years. As a rape crisis centre we chose to remain single sex. And lost our lottery funding specifically for not being diverse enough - baldly stated that we did not include men in any part of our organisation. We had to make a permanent arrangement, sending money to a shelter for men, in order to meet the unwritten criteria and get some funding reinstated.

The men's shelter, by men for men, male only, has no similar funding restrictions.

Open your eyes and ears. When women spend so much time and effort explaining the realities, identifying existing examples of how gender ideology overrides the legal rights if women try listening instead of repeating the insipid and deliberate obfuscations.

We know how it is supposed to work. We also know how much time, money and effort is put into tryna Ng to maintain single sex female spaces. Stop pretending you have no idea what we are talking about

FOJN · 24/12/2022 09:42

Because every one of us knows this will impact some unfortunate woman.

Of course people know but their belief it will never happen to them allows them to display their "be kind" credentials without worry. Often it's incredibly privileged women who think they will never need rape crisis, a domestic abuse shelter or end up in prison.

I'm sure all the law abiding post masters/mistresses who were wrongly convicted of theft and sent to prison due to an IT glitch never thought they'd see the inside of a prison cell either.

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 09:39

If that were the case then we wouldn't have all those predatory men who go through years of schooling and create entire false personalities to become priests, doctors, nurses, scout leaders, physios, teachers

And part of the reason for that is that it's all about power and control. It's not just about opportunity, feeling legitimised is a really important aspect of it all. So the Scottish Gov have just handed predators that legitimisation. Nice one lads 🙄

Waitwhat23 · 24/12/2022 09:34

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 09:25

keating

there rarely is a number, is there?. Because I think subconsciously some posters actually understand the issues and understand that even one person harmed due to safeguarding loopholes is too much.

FFS - you only have to look at the stories beginning to come out about the Scottish LGBT Youth organisation and think ‘WTF were people thinking it was ever appropriate to group 13 year olds with 25 year olds!!!

The loopholes are now even more easy to take advantage of, that some posters cannot put a number on ‘how many is acceptable collateral’ shows they understand. They just don’t want to admit it.

Although, didn’t we have a poster on a thread last night say ‘there is only 20 males in female prisons in the UK’…. When just 1 has the potential to harm vulnerable women who simply cannot get away.

(I know you know this Keating)

It's astounding isn't it -

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/12/23/lgbt-charity-refers-police-sexual-exploitation-fears/

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 24/12/2022 09:33

This is slightly left of topic but it's something I read/hear so much in this discussion and it is creating full on rage response in me now so gonna get it out here.

"Predatory men aren't going to bother getting a GRC why would they, if they're gonna abuse women they'll just do it without the GRC".

If that were the case then we wouldn't have all those predatory men who go through years of schooling and create entire false personalities to become priests, doctors, nurses, scout leaders, physios, teachers......

They do what is needed to give themselves an air of respectability and to gain access. What Scotland have done is said, hey don't bother wasting all that time and effort, just fill out this form and you can become a woman just like magic, no one will be able to question your presence, and hey if you get caught raping one of them we'll lock you up with a load more vulnerable women so you can have your fill even while in prison. Whoop whoop!

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 09:31

there rarely is a number, is there?. Because I think subconsciously some posters actually understand the issues and understand that even one person harmed due to safeguarding loopholes is too much.

Thats why I've started to ask for a number.

Because every one of us knows this will impact some unfortunate woman.

So for those who support it/think it's no big deal, then I would like to know how many is acceptable? These are real women so let's do them the courtesy of not brushing them under the carpet. You have to look them in the eye and say, we knew this would happen and we were fine with it. 🤷‍♀️

FOJN · 24/12/2022 09:26

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 09:02

I do understand the concerns around this topic, but on the whole, I feel it’s overblown. Predatory men will always look for ways to attack women, and trans people are a small minority.

What other safeguards do you think we should do away with?

Paedophiles will always find children to abuse so there's no point in DBS checks.

You can't eliminate deaths from traffic accidents so let's do away with seat belt laws, speed limits and drink driving laws.

Terrorists will always find a way to hurt some people so let's stop wasting time on airport security.

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 09:25

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 09:11

Predatory men will always look for ways to attack women, and trans people are a small minority

So how many additional attacks on vulnerable women are you happy with as collateral? Let's have a number.

keating

there rarely is a number, is there?. Because I think subconsciously some posters actually understand the issues and understand that even one person harmed due to safeguarding loopholes is too much.

FFS - you only have to look at the stories beginning to come out about the Scottish LGBT Youth organisation and think ‘WTF were people thinking it was ever appropriate to group 13 year olds with 25 year olds!!!

The loopholes are now even more easy to take advantage of, that some posters cannot put a number on ‘how many is acceptable collateral’ shows they understand. They just don’t want to admit it.

Although, didn’t we have a poster on a thread last night say ‘there is only 20 males in female prisons in the UK’…. When just 1 has the potential to harm vulnerable women who simply cannot get away.

(I know you know this Keating)

AlisonDonut · 24/12/2022 09:23

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 09:02

I do understand the concerns around this topic, but on the whole, I feel it’s overblown. Predatory men will always look for ways to attack women, and trans people are a small minority.

One way of attacking women is to waltz right into their spaces.

But just a minority of women and as those women are unlikely to be you, you're alright jack so who cares?

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 24/12/2022 09:22

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 09:02

I do understand the concerns around this topic, but on the whole, I feel it’s overblown. Predatory men will always look for ways to attack women, and trans people are a small minority.

The question then becomes why make it easier for the predatory men rather than harder?

Problem: predatory men are using cameras to record women in toilets and changing rooms, violating their privacy, putting footage of them in a state of undress online, using them as porn against their will.

Solution a) make it harder for this to happen by making it clear that all male bodied people are not allowed in female spaces, enforce this policy where it is breached and provide third spaces for anyone not identifying within their sex.

Solution b) completely erode all barriers to entry to female spaces by advertising how 'inclusive' you are and allowing anyone to self identify by saying the magic words 'I identify as a woman'. Make it so no one can question a male bodied persons presence in a female space for fear of being arrested for a hate crime or publicly named as a transphobe.

We know what solution has been chosen so what messaging do we now give to our daughters, mine is 8, do I teach her to trust her instincts, to alert someone if a male is making her feel uncomfortable, is giving 'creep' vibes? Where do I tell her to go, as a teen/early 20s when out out, if a man was getting handsy or being too insistent I'd go to the ladies toilet to get away but now he's welcome in there too?

Whateveryouwant1 · 24/12/2022 09:22

I don't understand why we can't use our genetic chromosomes if everything is getting so bloody stupid. Why not just xx and xy? There's no arguing with that. I know there can be anomalies but the minority that are born with said anomalies get to choose already.
Anyone who is xy and wants to be seen as a woman uses separate services, along with xx who wants to be seen as a man.
Sorry HRTWT someone might have already said this.

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 09:18

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 09:02

I do understand the concerns around this topic, but on the whole, I feel it’s overblown. Predatory men will always look for ways to attack women, and trans people are a small minority.

A question then, do you lock your doors? How about your car?

If so, why do you treat the risk for woman and children so haphazardly?

Either all males carry the exact same risk to women and children for safeguarding assessment, or you (general you here) disregard safeguarding. Either safeguarding reflects the risks as assessed with accurate data, or you acknowledge that the safeguarding process is flawed.

You, personally, may feel that a small minority of males are different from the others, but that is not good safeguarding. We discovered that with other small minority groups of males.

So while you feel it is ‘overblown’, others don’t. Why would you shame others who look and see reasons for concerns?

Because you think it is transphobic to treat them like males?

Do you have any statistics that show they commit crime at anything close to female rates?

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 09:11

Predatory men will always look for ways to attack women, and trans people are a small minority

So how many additional attacks on vulnerable women are you happy with as collateral? Let's have a number.

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 09:02

I do understand the concerns around this topic, but on the whole, I feel it’s overblown. Predatory men will always look for ways to attack women, and trans people are a small minority.

DoraSpenlow · 24/12/2022 08:49

Was recently at a local National Trust place and there were a group of about 4 men walking around literally dressed like this -

pbs.twimg.com/media/ESlcyNYWoAMxDFr.jpg

I thought they must be part of some entertainment, but no. When I went into the ladies they all followed me in. From overheard conversations they were just itching to be challenged so that they could claim their 'rights'. Twats. Why should we have to put up with this crap.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 08:19

OP you might find these websites useful for gaining a global perspective on this new manifestation of misogyny.

www.womenarehuman.com/

reduxx.info/

Waitwhat23 · 24/12/2022 08:15

The question about health care has just reminded me of this (which appears to be genuine) -

www.tumblr.com/edinburghath/163521055802/trans-health-manifesto

Quincythequince · 24/12/2022 08:06

The one question I have now though is if all you have to do is say you’ve been living as a female (WTF…) then presumably this removes any responsibility from the state for helping you manage your non-medical condition, because it’s simply a preference.

How can you say with on hand you don’t need a medics diagnosis but then expect things paid for by the medical system (NHS Scotland in this instance).

Bit of an own goal maybe in that respect for all these men cos playing women?!

iamop · 24/12/2022 08:06

FOJN · 24/12/2022 08:01

If there's already trans females in female prisons then do they all have GRC's? Or do they simply identify as female? If they all have GRC's then surely the problem lies with GRC's in the first instance, rather than reforms being made to that initial legislation?

Humans cannot change sex so there is no such thing as a trans female, it's the same as saying a male female.

You are correct that the problem lies with codifying a legal fiction, it's bad law. The major difference now is that there are no safeguards, literally any man can claim to be a transwoman. The GRR does not define what "living as a woman means" so a transwoman could look like any other man. You can't ask to see a GRC; are you going to gamble being charged with a hate crime by challenging the naked bloke in the showers at your gym who may or may not have a GRC. The flood gates have been opened.

Stonewall have spent the last 7 years misrepresenting the EA 2010 so many organisations who paid for their training incorrectly believe that gender and gender identity are protected characteristics and that it's unlawful to segregate facilities and services by sex. Add in the bullying by trans activists it's easy to see why many organisations find it easier not to make themselves a target. Women have been raped in domestic abuse refuges in countries where self ID is law or culturally accepted.

Trans activists successfully campaigned to have Vancouver Rape Crisis defunded because they maintained a female only policy but not before they had nailed a dead rat to the door, vandalised the building with offensive slogans and threats and posted the entrails of a dead animal through the letter box. Lovely people, coming soon to women's spaces near you.

Okay thank you for explaining, this makes it clear to me.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 24/12/2022 08:03

Barnowl25 · 24/12/2022 04:49

It's disgraceful. My view is if you still have a penis while dressing and identifying as a woman you shouldn't be allowed in female only spaces. I am amazed that female politicians voted for this shit.

You shouldn’t be allowed in single sex spaces if you are a male full stop.

With or without a penis - still a male bodied person.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 08:01

If there's already trans females in female prisons then do they all have GRC's? Or do they simply identify as female? If they all have GRC's then surely the problem lies with GRC's in the first instance, rather than reforms being made to that initial legislation?

Humans cannot change sex so there is no such thing as a trans female, it's the same as saying a male female.

You are correct that the problem lies with codifying a legal fiction, it's bad law. The major difference now is that there are no safeguards, literally any man can claim to be a transwoman. The GRR does not define what "living as a woman means" so a transwoman could look like any other man. You can't ask to see a GRC; are you going to gamble being charged with a hate crime by challenging the naked bloke in the showers at your gym who may or may not have a GRC. The flood gates have been opened.

Stonewall have spent the last 7 years misrepresenting the EA 2010 so many organisations who paid for their training incorrectly believe that gender and gender identity are protected characteristics and that it's unlawful to segregate facilities and services by sex. Add in the bullying by trans activists it's easy to see why many organisations find it easier not to make themselves a target. Women have been raped in domestic abuse refuges in countries where self ID is law or culturally accepted.

Trans activists successfully campaigned to have Vancouver Rape Crisis defunded because they maintained a female only policy but not before they had nailed a dead rat to the door, vandalised the building with offensive slogans and threats and posted the entrails of a dead animal through the letter box. Lovely people, coming soon to women's spaces near you.

iamop · 24/12/2022 07:35

Poinsettas · 24/12/2022 07:14

Why have you just copied and pasted your earlier message - which has already been explained and answered?

It hasn't though.

OP posts: