Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
AlisonDonut · 24/12/2022 13:37

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 13:18

Fair enough. Do we know what percentage of transwomen are sex offenders?

Stats earlier in the year stated that 60% of men who say they are women were in jail were there for sex offences as opposed to 18% of men who do not say they are women who are in jail for sex offences.

So 3 times the number. The more that we dilute the stats by calling men women the less likely anyone can report actual figures which works in favour of those sex offenders. Especially if some are not included in the male stats but are starting to bump up the female stats.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 13:31

You say that a trans woman who has committed sexual offences against women shouldn’t be placed in a women’s prison, and I agree.

On the other hand, I think that a trans woman who transitioned 20 years ago, has had full gender reassignment surgery, has been a victim of sexual violence at the hands of men, and is in prison for financial fraud, should clearly be in a women’s prison.

The are many cases in between that are less clear cut. The important thing is careful risk assessment.

You're making a distinction based on the nature of the offence, surgery, time since transition and history of violence perpetrated against someone rather than sex. If we are not segregating on the basis of sex and given what we know about violence and sexual assault in male prisons then why not house all vulnerable males in the female prison estate? Because it would be a seriously dangerous idea, women are not human sheilds for vulnerable males.

The number of transwomen who have surgery or take hormones is tiny compared to the number who claim to be transwomen.

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 13:18

Fair enough. Do we know what percentage of transwomen are sex offenders?

Rainbowshit · 24/12/2022 13:04

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 09:02

I do understand the concerns around this topic, but on the whole, I feel it’s overblown. Predatory men will always look for ways to attack women, and trans people are a small minority.

Iain Huntley was ONE man. Yet DBS check were introduced.

Dunblane was ONE incident, yet a all handguns were banned.

Because for DECENT people the threshold of harm is zero. That's what safeguarding is all about.

Ramblingnamechanger · 24/12/2022 13:03

there is absolutely no reason that makes it ok for any man to feel so entitled as to use womens facilities, however he identifies. They are there for a reason, we don’t want males of any description in them, and all males should respect that.
where is the pressure on males to be kind

Rainbowshit · 24/12/2022 13:00

Rainbowshit · 24/12/2022 12:55

Perhaps read this interview with the "woman" sex offender with a GRC and tell us we shouldn't be outraged and concerned for the safety of our daughters.

www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/exclusive-transgender-fugitive-who-spurred-wi-spa-riots-bares-all/

*"Woman" sex offender at the heart of the wi spa controversy.

For those that are not aware. The women and mothers complaining about a sex offender with an erect penis where them and their daughters were changing were attacked as transphobes and bigots.

The "woman" has been arrested.

Self ID and the GRA are a huge risk to females. We are called bigots for calling out blatant sexual offences.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 24/12/2022 12:58

And what careful risk assessment?

We have sex segregated spaces for the dignity of all and the safety of women and girls. We already have a societally accepted risk assessment that acknowledges the increased risk posed to all women by all men.

Why are you trying to create a new caste for some men?

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 24/12/2022 12:55

Full gender assignment surgery? So 2 - 5ish percent (and shrinking) of all transwomen.

At least know what you are talking about.

The vast majority of all of those long term transwomen have no genital surgery. The current transitioners even less so

Rainbowshit · 24/12/2022 12:55

Perhaps read this interview with the "woman" sex offender with a GRC and tell us we shouldn't be outraged and concerned for the safety of our daughters.

www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/exclusive-transgender-fugitive-who-spurred-wi-spa-riots-bares-all/

howmanybicycles · 24/12/2022 12:55

Full gender reassignment is still limited. It cannot make a man a woman.

aseriesofstillimages · 24/12/2022 12:43

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 03:19

So no. You have nothing but someone’s say so .

Good for you that your trust this data. But I don’t and no other reader should. If you cannot back it up with published information, please don’t expect anyone to give it any credibility.

And you talk about other’s posts as misleading.

Besides what is the number that is your personal accepted collateral for imprisoned females to be sharing an estate with a male? 21? 50? 100?

“Obviously you think that’s 20 to many, but it’s certainly not hundreds.”

Why are you saying 20 is ok because it is not hundreds? Because that is how I read this.

It is quite clear you have no concerns with males being in the female estate and the impact on female prisoners and staff. Why? Because you don’t believe 1 woman negatively impacted is enough to fight for?

Having had a female family member in prison recently, I am horrified that there are people in this world that would play so casually with her safety and her peace of mind.

You say that a trans woman who has committed sexual offences against women shouldn’t be placed in a women’s prison, and I agree.

On the other hand, I think that a trans woman who transitioned 20 years ago, has had full gender reassignment surgery, has been a victim of sexual violence at the hands of men, and is in prison for financial fraud, should clearly be in a women’s prison.

The are many cases in between that are less clear cut. The important thing is careful risk assessment.

Justnot · 24/12/2022 12:26

www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668426-petition-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex?page=24&reply=122466828

not sure if someone has already posted this - let’s get the equality act updated so sex means biological sex - need 40k more signatures to get it debated in parliament

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 24/12/2022 12:23

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 10:52

It doesn't change much other than that you can change your sex on birth certificates and other documents - from what I gather.

Trans people have ALWAYS used women's spaces - this doesn't change that. I suspect that many women on here have shared a changing room with a trans-woman in the past and never even known.

The outrage is around a mythical belief that "men in dresses" are going to "attack" girls and women in women's spaces. I say mythical because barring a handful of cases, there is NO evidence (that I am aware of) that men routinely attack women in women's changing rooms/toilets. There are ALWAYS going to be a miniscule number of people who will break the law because people are people. But it is in no way some frequent occurrence. Anyone that claims it is needs to provide some detailed, evidence based research for me on the actual stats. That is not to say that any incident is okay, of course it isn't. Though we need laws that are proportionate and justifiable. People against the bathroom issue need to explain this... if children get molested by white men in their hundreds a year, should we ban all white men from school sites "in case" they molest someone? Because it is the same principle here. A handful of "trans" people attack women in women's spaces, so we ban ALL trans women from woman's spaces?

It is also interesting that trans people (esp. trans-women) are hugely demonised with no actual basis in evidence, yet if that happened to other minorities there would be uproar. Imagine saying that some black men are predators and therefore all black men should be treated with suspicion? Or some disabled people are benefits cheats therefore they are all out to screw over the system. Or some women kill their children, therefore we should send a safeguarding officer to every woman's house just in case. It is utterly ludicrous.

The fact is FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable. I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

BTW I am not on either side of the "debate". I can see WHY people may have this horrified response to these laws, especially if they have been traumatised by men who have sexually assaulted them. At the same time, we need to take a measured approach. If your trauma has led you to suspect every trans-woman is a bloke with a giant lurking in the toilet next to you then maybe that is something to work on.

I may be totally wrong and that is also okay. If you want to talk about my thoughts please feel free to DM me.

Shared a space with a transwoman and not noticed? Or noticed and chosen not to show any sign of having done so - for fear, anxiety, embarrassment?

And all that racism? How can you not see that a black woman is a woman. A transwoman is not. And yes, because TRAs have pushed so hard, because Stonewall have lobbied to dismantle sex as a protected characteristic ( there on their website and part of their submission to a government committee) many women are now saying no to ALL MEN in female spaces.

And can you not see how you contradict yourself? Mythical harm, oh except, of course, for a few instances. Really? You think that is logical? Some men who identify as transwomen have harmed women. Transwomen are men and commit, provably, the same statistical rider of violent offences against women as every other man.

As for the 'bring it to my DMs' who the hell do you think you are? Someone 'speshul'? Women have no need to hide their discussions about men, male violence against women and girls or the reality of transwomen and violence and the very real, already happening violence committed by them.

And all of that is apart from the utter illogic of allowing some men to be women in legislation that traduces health care, social and medical research, bastardises all social and medical statistics and removes while areas of life from women, e.g. sport.

Wake up!

RambamThankyouMam · 24/12/2022 12:10

I suspect that many women on here have shared a changing room with a trans-woman in the past and never even known.

Oh, we've known. I have clocked every single transwoman who has ever crossed my path. They're always quite obviously blokes in bad makeup and shite clothes.

This will no doubt be deleted but I don't care. My compassion died long ago.

Mumsanetta · 24/12/2022 12:03

I have read through every post in this thread and it actually makes me feel hopeful. The “vast majority” (to borrow a phrase used by a PP) agree that what is happening is wrong and have clearly and unashamedly articulated why. This is a huge difference from even a couple of years ago when women were shamed into voicing their opinions behind closed doors for fear of being labelled a bigot. Women are waking up to what is happening and won’t allow it to continue without a fight.

SnowAndIceLobelia · 24/12/2022 11:33

I suspected that from the beginning tbh. But, this thread is in AIBU which means it is more visible to people who don't make a habit of being on FWR and the replies are very clear so I suspect it's bringing in alot of sunlight.

acrimoniousone · 24/12/2022 11:30

Poinsettas · 24/12/2022 07:14

Why have you just copied and pasted your earlier message - which has already been explained and answered?

I'm suspecting Sealioning at this point. Everything has been clearly answered

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 24/12/2022 11:12

@Burgoo

Yes there have always been Transwomen, few and far between, and generally respectful of the space they are in and just getting on with their life.

Now we have men with beards and stereotypically male clothing wandering into primark changing rooms and recording women or flinging open the curtains so they can get a look.

www.doncasterfreepress.co.uk/news/womans-warning-after-creep-puts-camera-phone-in-doncaster-primark-changing-room-3869412

www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-england-cambridgeshire-63052284

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-south-yorkshire-62616681

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/07/22/police-officer-who-filmed-woman-getting-changed-primark-avoids/

Now we have men who have history of sexually abusing women being welcomed into rape crisis and domestic abuse services.

www.womenarehuman.com/male-transgender-boasts-of-harassing-women-in-crisis-shelter/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11392601/Transgender-paedophile-caught-duping-staff-71-day-stay-domestic-violence-refuge.html

We have rape crisis services being vandalised and threatened with closure for daring to offer a female only service

globalnews.ca/news/5824446/vancouver-rape-relief-womens-shelter-graffiti/

This isn't men who want to live as women, this is men who want to intimidate and have power over women.

yadaya · 24/12/2022 11:09

The issue for me is that it makes it significantly easier for predatory men to access women and young girls.

This is harming trans rights because how do we know which men accessing women's spaces are the safe ones? We don't, so we do what we need to do to keep ourselves safe as we do in countless other situations.

I know that statistically I'm probably going to be okay walking home at night but I still don't do it because there is a small chance it won't be.

Pushing back on this is our way of keeping ourselves safe.

GCAcademic · 24/12/2022 11:07

The fact is FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable. I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

I completely agree. Just because a male person feels that they are not male, doesn’t make that true. And there is no reason for them to feel vulnerable in the male toilets. Since there is no evidence that trans women are attacked in male toilets, so they can simply stay in the toilets that pertain to their sex, surely.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 11:06

So much to respond to in your post Burgoo but the irony of this was so delicious it warrants its own post and replication 3 times in bold

I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 11:03

Oh yes. Let's have that number.

How many is a handful? So they're okay collateral, got it. How many more would be acceptable?

Kinda sounds like that number could go quite high for you while you're simultaneously gaslighting women that their feelings of vulnerability aren't valid.

Gross

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 11:00

The fact is FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable. I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

I have a friend who was violently raped. A horrific situation.

She struggles with all men she doesn't know now. To come across a male body in an intimate space - no matter how innocent - would trigger her into a total meltdown. She's had years of therapy, but it runs that deep.

So you're telling me her feeling arent valid? Fuck right off with that.

Also, why are you telling women that what they feel isn't valid and we should be seeking more objective knowledge, when you're also telling men that what they 'feel' is more important than biological reality? What could such a double standard signify?

richlydetailed · 24/12/2022 10:56

*I say mythical because barring a handful of cases, there is NO evidence (that I am aware of) that men routinely attack women in women's changing rooms/toilets
*
Is a handful of cases ok? How many rapes and attacks on women are an acceptable amount to you, in comparison to the hurt feelings of transwomen?

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 10:52

It doesn't change much other than that you can change your sex on birth certificates and other documents - from what I gather.

Trans people have ALWAYS used women's spaces - this doesn't change that. I suspect that many women on here have shared a changing room with a trans-woman in the past and never even known.

The outrage is around a mythical belief that "men in dresses" are going to "attack" girls and women in women's spaces. I say mythical because barring a handful of cases, there is NO evidence (that I am aware of) that men routinely attack women in women's changing rooms/toilets. There are ALWAYS going to be a miniscule number of people who will break the law because people are people. But it is in no way some frequent occurrence. Anyone that claims it is needs to provide some detailed, evidence based research for me on the actual stats. That is not to say that any incident is okay, of course it isn't. Though we need laws that are proportionate and justifiable. People against the bathroom issue need to explain this... if children get molested by white men in their hundreds a year, should we ban all white men from school sites "in case" they molest someone? Because it is the same principle here. A handful of "trans" people attack women in women's spaces, so we ban ALL trans women from woman's spaces?

It is also interesting that trans people (esp. trans-women) are hugely demonised with no actual basis in evidence, yet if that happened to other minorities there would be uproar. Imagine saying that some black men are predators and therefore all black men should be treated with suspicion? Or some disabled people are benefits cheats therefore they are all out to screw over the system. Or some women kill their children, therefore we should send a safeguarding officer to every woman's house just in case. It is utterly ludicrous.

The fact is FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable. I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

BTW I am not on either side of the "debate". I can see WHY people may have this horrified response to these laws, especially if they have been traumatised by men who have sexually assaulted them. At the same time, we need to take a measured approach. If your trauma has led you to suspect every trans-woman is a bloke with a giant lurking in the toilet next to you then maybe that is something to work on.

I may be totally wrong and that is also okay. If you want to talk about my thoughts please feel free to DM me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread