Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 21:51

if children get molested by white men in their hundreds a year, should we ban all white men from school sites "in case" they molest someone? Because it is the same principle here

And burgoo, this is just fucked up logic.

Surely you realise that any adult entering a school site beyond drop off or pick up is dbs checked if they have any potential to have contact with students? Really? You didn’t know this?

If you didn’t, you are probably just showing us that you are not a parent.

So YES!! Burgoo, this already fucking happens in the UK!! Maybe get some perspective outside your own bubble and understand what people are posting.

Because your post is was simply full of misinformation, plenty of falsehoods, and logical fails.

Well done. Someone convinced you that a subset of males should not be treated like every other male. That says so much more about you than anyone else.

Boiledbeetle · 24/12/2022 21:47

I think this is another myth that ‘transwomen have always used female single sex spaces’. It sounds good to those who believe extremist activists. The reality is that some may have, but there is a very high likelihood they WERE noticed.

@Helleofabore me and you are of a similar age so we'll have been going out on the weekend to the pubs and clubs at the same time, and without a doubt, and i went to a lot of different places around England, there would be one or two blokes in awful women's clothes and bad makeup. As young women, usually fairly merry, we'd let them use the ladies, we'd pretend they looked good, we'd sympathise that they didn't feel safe in the gents, which to be honest in some of the pubs they wouldn't have been, but never ever did we think they were women.

Outside of the weekend pub crawls I don't remember seeing many transwomen, because there weren't many for starters, and on the occasions where I did see a transwomen in the toilet areas during the day they are always going to the gents.

It's only recently that transwomen have been able to have enough drugs, and surgery to sometimes pass to some people.

Maybe it's just because of my past but I've always been highly aware of a male in my vicinity, no matter how they present themselves.

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 21:36

Why would TW feeling vulnerable be more important than women feeling vulnerable?

Boiledbeetle · 24/12/2022 21:33

TW may feel more vulnerable.

And 2023 really needs to be the year that these TW realise that they are not the vulnerable ones, there is nothing traumatic about a male using the men's toilets and that it's about time they reframed their trauma and vulnerability.

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 21:31

Trans people have ALWAYS used women's spaces - this doesn't change that. I suspect that many women on here have shared a changing room with a trans-woman in the past and never even known.

I see this all the time. I think anyone saying this needs to prove it. Because from what I have read, it was only a few decades ago, maybe 90s, maybe 80s, that a male doctor was reported in the USA as telling males to go and use the female toilets.

I think this is another myth that ‘transwomen have always used female single sex spaces’. It sounds good to those who believe extremist activists. The reality is that some may have, but there is a very high likelihood they WERE noticed.

The fuckwittery about ‘you never noticed’ is multi layered.

It firstly makes females out to be gullible fools. ‘Ha ha!!! It was always happening, you just never noticed.’ And it is gaslighting.

Then it ignores the fact that women have a very high likelihood of picking males. Even with breasts. Posters who keep doing this fuckwittery, ignore the cues that have nothing to do with presentation. And everything to do with females decoding a body using gait, hands, feet, facial proportions (unless a male has had their entire face peeled off and shaved and filled - extreme surgery is an understatement). And that doesn’t include the voice.

No . Stop with the misinformation and gaslighting. If posters choose to believe that ‘they’ cannot pick the sex of an adult human male who has not had puberty blockers, that is fine. But stop trying to convince others they can’t.

Of course, females who have had testosterone is a different story. But often it is not hard to pick there too.

AuntieDickhead · 24/12/2022 21:27

@Burgoo If your trauma has led you to suspect every trans-woman is a bloke with a giant lurking in the toilet next to you then maybe that is something to work on.

You can fuck right off with that shit. It's basically the same as saying "reframe your trauma"
Why should I be the one who has to pay for therapy to work on it (because the NHS just can't offer what's needed) rather than the trans women working on their whatever it is that makes them believe they are something they aren't. There are literally a handful of men that I trust 100%.
Meeting a male bodied person in what should be a female space automatically starts off my fight/ flight/freeze response.

If trans women are so peaceful people (and I actually believe most of them are) who just want to "pee in peace" then maybe they could be kind enough to accept that women want, need and deserve single sex spaces.

And no, i won't fucking DM you. If you're going to share shitty opinions at least debate them in the open.

howmanybicycles · 24/12/2022 21:19

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 10:52

It doesn't change much other than that you can change your sex on birth certificates and other documents - from what I gather.

Trans people have ALWAYS used women's spaces - this doesn't change that. I suspect that many women on here have shared a changing room with a trans-woman in the past and never even known.

The outrage is around a mythical belief that "men in dresses" are going to "attack" girls and women in women's spaces. I say mythical because barring a handful of cases, there is NO evidence (that I am aware of) that men routinely attack women in women's changing rooms/toilets. There are ALWAYS going to be a miniscule number of people who will break the law because people are people. But it is in no way some frequent occurrence. Anyone that claims it is needs to provide some detailed, evidence based research for me on the actual stats. That is not to say that any incident is okay, of course it isn't. Though we need laws that are proportionate and justifiable. People against the bathroom issue need to explain this... if children get molested by white men in their hundreds a year, should we ban all white men from school sites "in case" they molest someone? Because it is the same principle here. A handful of "trans" people attack women in women's spaces, so we ban ALL trans women from woman's spaces?

It is also interesting that trans people (esp. trans-women) are hugely demonised with no actual basis in evidence, yet if that happened to other minorities there would be uproar. Imagine saying that some black men are predators and therefore all black men should be treated with suspicion? Or some disabled people are benefits cheats therefore they are all out to screw over the system. Or some women kill their children, therefore we should send a safeguarding officer to every woman's house just in case. It is utterly ludicrous.

The fact is FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable. I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

BTW I am not on either side of the "debate". I can see WHY people may have this horrified response to these laws, especially if they have been traumatised by men who have sexually assaulted them. At the same time, we need to take a measured approach. If your trauma has led you to suspect every trans-woman is a bloke with a giant lurking in the toilet next to you then maybe that is something to work on.

I may be totally wrong and that is also okay. If you want to talk about my thoughts please feel free to DM me.

I'm not going to DM you because these conversations should not be hidden. Your argument seems to be that most TW do not assault anyone so we should not exclude them from female spaces. But the fact is that most men, whatever their gender identity - if they even have one -do not assault people. So why allow one group of males into the ladies and not every other group of males? TW may feel more vulnerable, but they need to move away from the idea that if they feel something is valid, that is an objective reality.

I've been assaulted by men. I know that most men are not a risk to me. I feel most at risk from those who refuse to respect women's boundaries - such as any male I find in ladies facilities, regardless of what they are wearing.

Boiledbeetle · 24/12/2022 21:09

Of course there are those, and before i get jumped on I appreciate this is only a small fraction of men, but we don't know the difference, that want to use the womens to take their dick picks and then masturbate to the sound of the woman in the next cubicle. I really don't want to be sharing toilets with these ones personally.

Boiledbeetle · 24/12/2022 21:06

speakout · 24/12/2022 21:02

lol, I asked fot it to be deleted.
My point was- why do trans women want to use female toilets.
Presumably with a penis the gents is easier- having urinals etc.
What is so special about a woman's toilet?

I think purely because It's the women's. And they want to use it. how dare we have a space of our own.

No more no less. .

speakout · 24/12/2022 21:02

lol, I asked fot it to be deleted.
My point was- why do trans women want to use female toilets.
Presumably with a penis the gents is easier- having urinals etc.
What is so special about a woman's toilet?

Boiledbeetle · 24/12/2022 20:55

speakout · 24/12/2022 20:53

wow no idea why that came out so big- I wouldn't even know how to do that if I tried! I'm not shouting honest!

The internet obviously thought it needed shouting very loudly😂

speakout · 24/12/2022 20:53

wow no idea why that came out so big- I wouldn't even know how to do that if I tried! I'm not shouting honest!

speakout · 24/12/2022 20:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

babyjellyfish · 24/12/2022 20:29

I don't understand how you could even make a policy or a law banning some trans women from women's spaces but not all.

Where do you draw the line and how do you enforce it?

You let the nice ones in and keep the bad ones out? Great, how do we tell which are which?

You let the ones with a GRC in and keep the rest out? Great, are you going to have a bouncer on the door of every toilet checking for GRCs? And how does that help in Scotland once anyone can get a GRC as easy as pie?

You let the ones who have had their penises removed in and keep the intact ones out? Great, are you going to have people doing genital checks on the door of every women only space?

The only logical place to draw the line, and the only rule we have any hope whatsoever of being able to enforce, is to keep ALL males out. No exceptions.

YouSetTheTone · 24/12/2022 20:28

so we ban ALL trans women from woman's spaces
Yes. Transwomen are a ‘subset’ of men. They are not a ‘subset’ of women.
My (lovely) DH, DF and DB are excluded from women’s single sex spaces because they are men. There should be no ‘special exceptions’ - all men need to be excluded for the privacy, safety and dignity of women and girls where appropriate.

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 20:11

so we ban ALL trans women from woman's spaces

Yes.

Why do we have same sex spaces to begin with?

Why would being transGENDER impact anyone's rights to SEX segregated spaces?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/12/2022 19:55

so we ban ALL trans women from woman's spaces

Yes, that's fine by me. They're male so they don't belong in women's spaces and when it comes to the majority who keep their penises most women don't want them there, so they should stay out.

OneTC · 24/12/2022 18:44

The only reason society is bending over backwards to accommodate them is because they are men.

The long and the short of it.

No one's getting up on their hind legs about f2m trans persons

Waitwhat23 · 24/12/2022 18:37

To add on to @babyjellyfish 's excellent post -
thecritic.co.uk/neither-marginalised-abused-nor-vulnerable/

babyjellyfish · 24/12/2022 18:28

Oh, and by the way.

Apart from the whole, "having a penis" thing, this is THE biggest clue that trans women are men, not women.

Because if they were women, no one would care about their feelings, no one would care about their identities, no one would care about their safety, they would just be expected to lump it.

The only reason society is bending over backwards to accommodate them is because they are men.

babyjellyfish · 24/12/2022 18:23

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 10:52

It doesn't change much other than that you can change your sex on birth certificates and other documents - from what I gather.

Trans people have ALWAYS used women's spaces - this doesn't change that. I suspect that many women on here have shared a changing room with a trans-woman in the past and never even known.

The outrage is around a mythical belief that "men in dresses" are going to "attack" girls and women in women's spaces. I say mythical because barring a handful of cases, there is NO evidence (that I am aware of) that men routinely attack women in women's changing rooms/toilets. There are ALWAYS going to be a miniscule number of people who will break the law because people are people. But it is in no way some frequent occurrence. Anyone that claims it is needs to provide some detailed, evidence based research for me on the actual stats. That is not to say that any incident is okay, of course it isn't. Though we need laws that are proportionate and justifiable. People against the bathroom issue need to explain this... if children get molested by white men in their hundreds a year, should we ban all white men from school sites "in case" they molest someone? Because it is the same principle here. A handful of "trans" people attack women in women's spaces, so we ban ALL trans women from woman's spaces?

It is also interesting that trans people (esp. trans-women) are hugely demonised with no actual basis in evidence, yet if that happened to other minorities there would be uproar. Imagine saying that some black men are predators and therefore all black men should be treated with suspicion? Or some disabled people are benefits cheats therefore they are all out to screw over the system. Or some women kill their children, therefore we should send a safeguarding officer to every woman's house just in case. It is utterly ludicrous.

The fact is FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable. I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

BTW I am not on either side of the "debate". I can see WHY people may have this horrified response to these laws, especially if they have been traumatised by men who have sexually assaulted them. At the same time, we need to take a measured approach. If your trauma has led you to suspect every trans-woman is a bloke with a giant lurking in the toilet next to you then maybe that is something to work on.

I may be totally wrong and that is also okay. If you want to talk about my thoughts please feel free to DM me.

Oh dear, you've got this completely upside down.

We know that most males are not violent. But we also know that women and girls are at risk of male violence, which is why we keep all males out of women's spaces. We don't know which males are dangerous, therefore we keep them all out.

There is no reason why the same should not apply to males who identify as women.

There is no evidence to suggest that they are any less likely to be dangerous than other males. This is doubly the case with self ID, since literally anyone, even a rapist, can say they are a woman and we are supposed to just believe them.

Transgender males are male, like all other males, which means none of them should be in women's spaces.

They may feel vulnerable. They may feel marginalised. They may feel that they are female. Although they cannot possibly know that because they are not, and never have been, female. But none of these feelings are based in reality. The statistics show that over the last decade the number of trans people murdered has been less than one per year, compared to 2-3 women per week. They have the Labour Party, the Lib Dems, the Greens, half the Tories, the civil service, the police, the NHS, Stonewall and tons of other trans activist groups banging on about how marginalised they are, whilst other groups don't get a look in. They have charities and services dedicated to trans people, whereas women are denied single sex services.

As you say, FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable.

The reality is that trans people are not particularly vulnerable, nor marginalised. They are in fact a very privileged group whose demands have been prioritised over the rights and safety of women and children.

Trans women are men. They have nothing in common with women that we do not all have in common with men. We share neither a sex nor any kind of identity, and there is no logic whatsoever for them to be in women's spaces or women's sports.

Literally the only reason for including them is that they want to be included. And of course, what they want matters, and what the rest of us want doesn't.

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 15:58

LangClegsInSpace · 24/12/2022 15:45

Why should they clearly be in a women's prison? They are not women.

Do you think any other men who have been victims of male sexual violence and are in for financial fraud should be moved to the women's estate?

If the majority of male trans prisoners are housed in the male estate then there is clearly no reason why they all can't be.

I think this is a very interesting study to have come out of Nederlands and Denmark this month.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36534950/

In prostate cancer patients, resistance exercise training counteracts the adverse effects of ADT on body composition, muscle mass, muscle strength and aerobic capacity, with no additional benefits of protein supplementation.

If prostate cancer patients can counter adverse effects of lack of testosterone, why are people still trying to tell us that a special group of males are more like ‘females’ physiologically? Just about every study in the past few years has disproved that males lose their advantage to be similar of females.

This is not just important for sport, the implications to women generally is that these males will simply be more likely to overpower the average female vs the likelihood of other females overpowering another females.

It just continues the fuckwittery to continue to deny this.

Waitwhat23 · 24/12/2022 15:53

@Helleofabore no need for an apology at all - I thought that was probably the meaning of your post - I just thought I should clarify just in case.

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 15:50

Waitwhat23 · 24/12/2022 15:32

My comment about the MOJ was meant very much as a criticism of the decision made.

I am sorry wait, I am in full agreement. I was using your words to bounce off for those posters who persistently post ‘what abouts’ and ‘but if a male has truly transitioned’! Because those have become very repetitive on this thread.

I am saying that those who keep posting about ‘lack of evidence of crimes while in prison’, and ‘Whatabout those with full surgery’ and ‘I did x with my mate and I was all right’ and ‘those saying ‘transwomen are predatory’.

I mean the last one is clear fuckwittery. I am sure not one poster on this thread has said ‘all’ males are like that, however, that is exactly what lazy posting implying that posting about safeguarding risks is saying just that.

It is not new. But I think some posters think they are stating something never seen before.

I should have been clearer wait. I apologise.

LangClegsInSpace · 24/12/2022 15:45

aseriesofstillimages · 24/12/2022 12:43

You say that a trans woman who has committed sexual offences against women shouldn’t be placed in a women’s prison, and I agree.

On the other hand, I think that a trans woman who transitioned 20 years ago, has had full gender reassignment surgery, has been a victim of sexual violence at the hands of men, and is in prison for financial fraud, should clearly be in a women’s prison.

The are many cases in between that are less clear cut. The important thing is careful risk assessment.

Why should they clearly be in a women's prison? They are not women.

Do you think any other men who have been victims of male sexual violence and are in for financial fraud should be moved to the women's estate?

If the majority of male trans prisoners are housed in the male estate then there is clearly no reason why they all can't be.