Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 12:32

Why I wonder would you intentionally set out to avoid ensuring equality for all (not just the current favoured pets) and to ensure your actions have worked?

Oh I wonder.

We have never seen such corrupt times. And the TQ+ lobby are insane. They are setting up their own downfall. Another group will come along and be the new pets and they will have established how it's fine to harm others and abandon the old in order to favour the new fashionable group for your own purposes. Live by filthy, grotty politics....

skippingthroughthedaisies · 26/12/2022 12:23

Boiledbeetle · 26/12/2022 00:24

This one from the above link by@TheKeatingFive is a chilling read on the lack of records now being kept and collated in Belgium after five years of self ID. It's worth clicking through to read the whole thread by Roisin

One of the amendments to the Scottish bill was to audit crimes/issues arising from the bill and it was voted out.
If you don’t look for a problem it doesn’t exist…

Boiledbeetle · 26/12/2022 11:48

nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 11:35

And really, anyone in any doubt about whether sexism is at the bottom of all this and thriving in modern society, only has to look at who gets what they want (not need) at the expense of removing access, inclusion, equality of legal and civil rights from others. Whatever lipservice is paid in language, it shows everyone knows exactly who the men are.

Exactly men's wants have always been, are now, and at this rate will also be in the future, prioritised over a woman's needs.

When all the shouting and fighting is done this is what this is all about.

nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 11:43

I'm sure that invite was a very nice feeling in validation terms. But I can't stop reflecting on that these very nice emotional experiences for male people are happening at the expense of females people getting raped in prisons and getting no help from rape crisis services, and being afraid to you know, go for actual needed medical care through actually owning said body part, and staying in life threatening relationships because the refuges are inaccessible.

Which says again: these are very, very sex based decisions. And there is a limit to how much female people can play along at their own expense and male people can expect this never ending 'mummy will sacrifice for you' female indulgence.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 26/12/2022 11:38

nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 11:31

Oh you've only got to look at the response when you explain that you could provide mixed sex spaces (we'll call them women's spaces if necessary) plus single sex female spaces.

Won't do. You have India Willoughby for example intentionally trotting off giggling to use the single sex female space to ensure that territory is pissed on and that no female escapes uncontrolled and punished.

It's getting plainer and plainer. Unless females are visibly suffering the sacrifice to the god of Gender has not been big enough and the harvest will fail. Or something. It's all so very 1st century.

India posted a screenshot of their invite to a cervical smear the other day. If they have really booked in and forced a nurse to pretend examine their cervix then that says an awful lot about what they think of women.

nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 11:35

And really, anyone in any doubt about whether sexism is at the bottom of all this and thriving in modern society, only has to look at who gets what they want (not need) at the expense of removing access, inclusion, equality of legal and civil rights from others. Whatever lipservice is paid in language, it shows everyone knows exactly who the men are.

nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 11:31

Oh you've only got to look at the response when you explain that you could provide mixed sex spaces (we'll call them women's spaces if necessary) plus single sex female spaces.

Won't do. You have India Willoughby for example intentionally trotting off giggling to use the single sex female space to ensure that territory is pissed on and that no female escapes uncontrolled and punished.

It's getting plainer and plainer. Unless females are visibly suffering the sacrifice to the god of Gender has not been big enough and the harvest will fail. Or something. It's all so very 1st century.

Boiledbeetle · 26/12/2022 11:27

a) either women can keep their existing rights or TQ+ people can have 'rights' and it's now acknowledged that the two things are incompatible.

Now I'm still trying to work out why at this first point they didn't say

Women as in AHF get to keep their rights, AND TQ+ people will need some rights of their own, e.g. Third spaces third inclusive sport categories etc as it's completely unacceptable to force women out of their own spaces.

But nooooooo that wasn't fucking good enough was it

nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 11:23

oh and f)

somehow everyone in favour of this is managing to blot out the awareness that any good and moral civil rights movement does no harm to others, never mind gleefully embraces harm to others.

A civil rights movement busy doing that and ok with it is FUBAR, and not actually in truth a civil rights movement.

There are ways perfectly able to manage meeting all needs. This movement requires the harm and subordination of female humans.

(Which don't exist. Unless you're talking about who gets raped/killed/reframes trauma/isnt allowed to be homosexual/can't have equality/no access or inclusion allowed. THEN we know. And without genital checks.)

nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 11:20

In both the Scot govt response and the German govt response mentioned today in threads it's getting increasingly clear that they mean that

a) either women can keep their existing rights or TQ+ people can have 'rights' and it's now acknowledged that the two things are incompatible.

b) a 'good' and 'progressive' thing to do is strip away rights from biological females and award new special rights to biological males ,

c) this is entirely on a sex based basis, while at the same pretending it's because those males have changed sex

d) they believe 'good' females (whatever they are, we all know but are supposed to pretend otherwise sometimes when males like it) would gladly throw down their rights and lay down beneath the feet of males for the good of..... some kind of odd religious righteousness

e) (this when said by a female always somehow refers to other females, they don't actually plan to suffer themselves, it's the 'lesser' females that are being sacrificed in this odd rite. Definitely not them or their mates.

The whole thing just gets steadily more bizarre.

Boiledbeetle · 26/12/2022 02:12

Toast, this is one of those times i want to time travel 100 years into the future so I can read the history books written about all this. It's going to be fascinating for future generations, even if it is a nightmare to live through.

moomoola as a 50 year old woman who can count on fingers of one hand how many dresses or skirts I've owned since I stopped wearing school uniform I find that heartbreaking. I hope you and her both find your way through this.

Toastandavocado · 26/12/2022 01:53

So sorry to hear that at @Moomoola and really shows both sides of the argument. Hope your lovely dd gets the support she/he or they, or whatever pronoun they decide for themselves and which makes them happy in life. Still a child- because I believe they are still a child deserves a big cuddle from you and a big cuddle from here ❤️

Moomoola · 26/12/2022 01:46

As a mum of a 17 year old dd, it’s not just that she’s no longer entitled to privacy. She says changing at school for pe is hard enough with other girls.
more sinisterly this bill opens up massive pressure on her. She says she is trans. She really only likes wearing boys clothes but this bill is pushing her towards hormones. She is putting herself through so much stress and of course now hates us as transpose.
I never thought this would happen to our funny, happy dd.
the whole thing is sinister and beyond dangerous.

Toastandavocado · 26/12/2022 01:42

@Boiledbeetle I am so confused. It’s not a direction I thought they would take. I actually thought of Nicola, here’s a Leader who could really run with this… the UK are a shambles. She’s a Paisley girl who knows the ‘ills’ of the world. Run with policies that reflect that. People need protected, people need wider support, people need truthful Politicians, people need the Politicians to understand the true meaning of being a constituent in their constituency/country, and the relevant and fair risks of harm to them and their children, and you as Politicians legislate and campaign accordingly. What am I missing?! Corruption? Is it economic? Is it popular? They are not stupid so surely they’ve risk assessed this? I DO NOT UNDERSTAND.

Furries · 26/12/2022 01:40

Boiledbeetle · 26/12/2022 01:33

I’d like to know their motivation for this

@Toastandavocado so would I. I want to know how they came to so fervently believe any cause that meant throwing half the population of Scotland under the bus was worth the sacrifice?

This. Can’t put into words how bloody depressing it is.

Boiledbeetle · 26/12/2022 01:33

I’d like to know their motivation for this

@Toastandavocado so would I. I want to know how they came to so fervently believe any cause that meant throwing half the population of Scotland under the bus was worth the sacrifice?

Toastandavocado · 26/12/2022 01:19

Scottish Government had independence at their fingertips after the shambles of covid/lockdown and a completely incompetent and inadequate UK government. Nicola has more than shot herself in the foot. She has imploded. It’s a shame as they’ve done some great work and the chance to rejoin the EU was a massive step forward for Scottish Nationals but this has sets the tone and any (particularly female) leader of a country who will bend to a minority over the welfare of women and children- when this should be at front and centre stage in any leadership campaign (just look at the statistics of women and children who lose their lives due to gender based violence or sustain life long injuries or disabilities, it’s bigger than illness or car crashes or accidents) and then you have the assaults and violence and abuse in between that goes unreported that utterly ruin FEMALES lives. It’s a travesty. Huge back step for independence and hard to understand. I’d like to know their motivation for this 🤔

Boiledbeetle · 26/12/2022 00:24

This one from the above link by@TheKeatingFive is a chilling read on the lack of records now being kept and collated in Belgium after five years of self ID. It's worth clicking through to read the whole thread by Roisin

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?
TheKeatingFive · 25/12/2022 09:36

Right, for anyone who thinks that men won't identify as women to attack the. Please read this.

twitter.com/helensteel12/status/1606198398226296832?s=46&t=Sz_aoYebiVI5UdjU1Lh4Vw

Jellycatspyjamas · 25/12/2022 05:48

if children get molested by white men in their hundreds a year, should we ban all white men from school sites "in case" they molest someone?

We don’t ban white men from schools, but we do check the criminal record of everyone (male and female) working with children (a measure brought in following male violence towards children) - even in some circumstances checking not just convictions but also cautions and soft intelligence. We put safeguards in place.

Or some women kill their children, therefore we should send a safeguarding officer to every woman's house just in case.

It is vanishingly rare for a woman to kill their own child, which is why when they do there’s such publicity and outrage. However universal services that come into contact with children (education and health) do monitor and raise concerns about any child where there’s an indication they may nor be safe. Again we put safeguards in place.

The issue with this legislation is that there are no safeguards, even with known sexual predators. They can change their gender identity and gain immediate access to female prisons, hospital wards, etc without safeguards in place to protect those women. Or is being raped in prison, by someone serving time for rape, a fitting punishment?

If your trauma has led you to suspect every trans-woman is a bloke with a giant lurking in the toilet next to you then maybe that is something to work on.

In my experience male violence can lead women to be scared of men, not trans identifying men, but men as a sex class. Where can women work on this if there is no space available to them without male presence? I don’t know any such woman who would deny they need to work on the terror caused to them by male violence, how can they do that when group members, staff, even their own counsellor can claim to be a woman regardless of biological sex and the traumatised woman has no way of refusing to work with them?

Furries · 25/12/2022 04:15

Burgoo · 24/12/2022 10:52

It doesn't change much other than that you can change your sex on birth certificates and other documents - from what I gather.

Trans people have ALWAYS used women's spaces - this doesn't change that. I suspect that many women on here have shared a changing room with a trans-woman in the past and never even known.

The outrage is around a mythical belief that "men in dresses" are going to "attack" girls and women in women's spaces. I say mythical because barring a handful of cases, there is NO evidence (that I am aware of) that men routinely attack women in women's changing rooms/toilets. There are ALWAYS going to be a miniscule number of people who will break the law because people are people. But it is in no way some frequent occurrence. Anyone that claims it is needs to provide some detailed, evidence based research for me on the actual stats. That is not to say that any incident is okay, of course it isn't. Though we need laws that are proportionate and justifiable. People against the bathroom issue need to explain this... if children get molested by white men in their hundreds a year, should we ban all white men from school sites "in case" they molest someone? Because it is the same principle here. A handful of "trans" people attack women in women's spaces, so we ban ALL trans women from woman's spaces?

It is also interesting that trans people (esp. trans-women) are hugely demonised with no actual basis in evidence, yet if that happened to other minorities there would be uproar. Imagine saying that some black men are predators and therefore all black men should be treated with suspicion? Or some disabled people are benefits cheats therefore they are all out to screw over the system. Or some women kill their children, therefore we should send a safeguarding officer to every woman's house just in case. It is utterly ludicrous.

The fact is FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable. I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

BTW I am not on either side of the "debate". I can see WHY people may have this horrified response to these laws, especially if they have been traumatised by men who have sexually assaulted them. At the same time, we need to take a measured approach. If your trauma has led you to suspect every trans-woman is a bloke with a giant lurking in the toilet next to you then maybe that is something to work on.

I may be totally wrong and that is also okay. If you want to talk about my thoughts please feel free to DM me.

There is so much to unpick from this post, am not sure where to start.

Actually, I’ll start with safeguarding on a site for adults - you know, those people that have more life experience. WTF would you encourage people to DM you with their views re this? That is beyond creepy in this day and age of social media and goes against everything that adults should be warning children about. Never trust someone who encourages you to engage privately online. If you want to discuss your thoughts further, then post them on here and explain your reasoning.

Secondly, do you not realise that all concerns listed here are NOT against the trans community? Do you not realise that the concern is against men? Literally no-one, on any thread I’ve read on various boards on this site, is saying that the trans community are dangerous. They are, quite rightly, pointing out the huge risks with regards to predatory MEN taking advantage of loopholes.

I am not great with tech, so not sure how to highlight and post a single sentence from another post. But your comment re “if your trauma has led to ..” is bloody gross. How dare you. A fair number on here will liken that to a comment made, by a person with a penis, who oversees a rape crisis centre in a Scottish city. So fuck you for insinuating that it is something women should work on. It is so insulting that I’ll never find the words to articulate how gross that comment is.

And the pp who highlighted your “feelings vs knowledge” sentence got it bang on.

There should be no sacred castes, we’ve all learnt over time how well (not) that goes. And it’s very strange how each sacred caste that’s been exposed and condemned over time is mostly caused by … drum roll … men.

Oh, and you’re “not on either side of the debate” comment is a lie. It’s very obvious which side you’re on.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/12/2022 23:32

I think this is another myth that ‘transwomen have always used female single sex spaces’. It sounds good to those who believe extremist activists. The reality is that some may have, but there is a very high likelihood they WERE noticed.

The fuckwittery about ‘you never noticed’ is multi layered.

It firstly makes females out to be gullible fools. ‘Ha ha!!! It was always happening, you just never noticed.’ And it is gaslighting.

Then it ignores the fact that women have a very high likelihood of picking males. Even with breasts. Posters who keep doing this fuckwittery, ignore the cues that have nothing to do with presentation. And everything to do with females decoding a body using gait, hands, feet, facial proportions (unless a male has had their entire face peeled off and shaved and filled - extreme surgery is an understatement). And that doesn’t include the voice.

No . Stop with the misinformation and gaslighting. If posters choose to believe that ‘they’ cannot pick the sex of an adult human male who has not had puberty blockers, that is fine. But stop trying to convince others they can’t.

This.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 23:00

I wonder how Canada would deal with John McMahon now? Bill C16 was passed in 2017, how would they know his claim to be trans was false?

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 24/12/2022 22:20

This happened in Canada in 2014. Toronto Sun

If it happened in today's Scotland, would he be accepted as transgender and rewarded for raping women with a sentence in a women's prison, with a pool of victims who can't get away?

extract
A sexual predator who falsely claimed to be transgender and preyed on women at two Toronto shelters was jailed indefinitely on Wednesday. Justice John McMahon declared Christopher Hambrook — who claimed to be a transgender woman named Jessica — was a dangerous offender. The judge said he imposed the indefinite prison sentence because there’s a great risk that Hambrook will commit more sex crimes and require strict supervision if he returns to the community.

TheKeatingFive · 24/12/2022 22:07

if children get molested by white men in their hundreds a year, should we ban all white men from school sites "in case" they molest someone? Because it is the same principle here

It's not the same principle. As you well know.

The same principle would be removing safeguarding for white males and making it easier for them to access these sites.

That would be dumb and dangerous, no?