Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
aseriesofstillimages · 29/12/2022 17:52

Helleofabore · 29/12/2022 11:49

Thank you everyone who has signed this petition.

here is a link for those who are interested in signing.
www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668425-sex-matters-petition

And here is a link for those who want to understand more:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4668404-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex?page=1

I enjoy reading threads such as this where posters who are not regular posters from the feminism boards discuss this issue with insight and knowledge. Even 6-12 months ago this thread would have been littered with posters repetitively stating ‘you are all hateful! You are an extremist minority!’ and ‘You are all old dinosaurs and are dying soon’.

Well, we still regularly see this last one, but given the rise of the young women now posting their disgust that a person declaring themselves to be a ‘girl of x days’ gets an audience with Biden for being what??? A girl of x days?…, I expect that that ridiculous claim will also be seen as the falsehood the ‘you are all hateful’ and ‘you are the extremist minority’ went too.

Hint: if you cannot support your claims with anything more than falsity and emotional manipulation, that is a sure sign you are the dishonest one.

This past month has highlighted exactly where this end result of these demands leads. For instance, any woman who thinks that a board that is supposed to be balanced by sex so females have equal representation but now has the majority male thanks to an poorly written law is just fine, will never see the inherent and obvious issues with that. That was just the direct result of the FWS judicial review.

The GRR is most definitely harmful. I have yet to see any trans activist describe exactly how under the current laws that males can be excluded at an individual level from
services, if ID has been changed and no one can question further. Not one activist.

Why is that? Why is it that they tell women that the GRR will have no impact on women, because there are supposedly these protections already, but cannot explain the exact actions a refuge can take to refuse a male access legally?

Anyone believing the placating words from such activists really need to start reading more widely or to own their own ignoring of fact and truth. Not someone’s twisted truth, the material reality.

Loopholes forced into poorly worded laws are harmful to those needing that law’s protection.

The GRR is most definitely harmful. I have yet to see any trans activist describe exactly how under the current laws that males can be excluded at an individual level from
services, if ID has been changed and no one can question further. Not one activist

My understanding is that a GRC is not required to change ID such as a passport or drivers license, so even if a single sex service required proof of sex by ID (which obviously isn’t the case for things like toilets anyway), how would making it easier to get a GRC make it harder to exclude trans women?

Helleofabore · 29/12/2022 11:49

Thank you everyone who has signed this petition.

here is a link for those who are interested in signing.
www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668425-sex-matters-petition

And here is a link for those who want to understand more:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4668404-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex?page=1

I enjoy reading threads such as this where posters who are not regular posters from the feminism boards discuss this issue with insight and knowledge. Even 6-12 months ago this thread would have been littered with posters repetitively stating ‘you are all hateful! You are an extremist minority!’ and ‘You are all old dinosaurs and are dying soon’.

Well, we still regularly see this last one, but given the rise of the young women now posting their disgust that a person declaring themselves to be a ‘girl of x days’ gets an audience with Biden for being what??? A girl of x days?…, I expect that that ridiculous claim will also be seen as the falsehood the ‘you are all hateful’ and ‘you are the extremist minority’ went too.

Hint: if you cannot support your claims with anything more than falsity and emotional manipulation, that is a sure sign you are the dishonest one.

This past month has highlighted exactly where this end result of these demands leads. For instance, any woman who thinks that a board that is supposed to be balanced by sex so females have equal representation but now has the majority male thanks to an poorly written law is just fine, will never see the inherent and obvious issues with that. That was just the direct result of the FWS judicial review.

The GRR is most definitely harmful. I have yet to see any trans activist describe exactly how under the current laws that males can be excluded at an individual level from
services, if ID has been changed and no one can question further. Not one activist.

Why is that? Why is it that they tell women that the GRR will have no impact on women, because there are supposedly these protections already, but cannot explain the exact actions a refuge can take to refuse a male access legally?

Anyone believing the placating words from such activists really need to start reading more widely or to own their own ignoring of fact and truth. Not someone’s twisted truth, the material reality.

Loopholes forced into poorly worded laws are harmful to those needing that law’s protection.

YouSetTheTone · 29/12/2022 10:49

Thank you! I’ve signed this petition. I read it now has 60,000 signatures. It is important to establish that biological sex is a protected characteristic, and not to allow it to be corrupted by linguistics. ‘Gender’ is not the same thing as ‘sex’ and they must not be seen as the same thing when it comes to rape crisis centres, prisons, sport, healthcare settings and protocols etc. IMO given the current situation* it is more important than ever to be crystal clear that rights pertaining to biological sex are firmly established as being based on biological sex and not ‘gender’ or for holders of a GRC for that sex.

*The recent Haldane ruling in Scotland is worrying - that a GRC is not ‘just paperwork’ (as is often claimed) - it affects your legal sex in all areas.

TheSnowWillGoOn · 28/12/2022 11:24

Giving this petition a bump for those who want to protect single sex spaces

Petition: Update the Equality Act to make clear the characteristic “sex” is biological sex www.mumsnet.com/Talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668426-petition-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex?msgid=-4668426#-4668426

Boiledbeetle · 28/12/2022 02:47

Furries · 28/12/2022 02:10

Of course they did, not surprised at all.

Am not on Twitter, but really pissed off if they’ve posted a screenshot of a smear invite. That speaks volumes re their mindset. It is SO offensive that their need for validation overrides the reality of women who actually need screening.

And India also inadvertently shines a big spotlight on the stupidity of a system that let's a male of the species obfuscate their true identify so much, that a man gets a smear test appointment.

I mean it's important info that f or m on medical records, so many emergency treatments have different treatment protocols depending on the sex of the patient. It's private confidential info, why does India's need to be validated override India's bloody common sense.

Furries · 28/12/2022 02:10

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 27/12/2022 13:45

India encountered a unisex toilet in an airport, (labelled "gender-neutral"), which had a sign on it explaining that single-sex provision was available for those who needed it, in another part of the airport.

India trotted off across the airport to use the female-only facilities, and boasted that they'd "made a point of it". Why?

It clearly wasn't about "needing to pee" because there was a "gender-neutral" toilet right there.

Of course they did, not surprised at all.

Am not on Twitter, but really pissed off if they’ve posted a screenshot of a smear invite. That speaks volumes re their mindset. It is SO offensive that their need for validation overrides the reality of women who actually need screening.

FOJN · 27/12/2022 23:10

This is an interesting related thread.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4703437-whilst-we-are-being-told-that-gra-will-make-no-difference-to-women-please-remember-what-stonewall-are-currently-campaigning-for

Here is what Stonewall are campaigning for:

A review of the Equality Act 2010 to include ‘gender identity’ rather than ‘gender reassignment’ as a protected characteristic and to remove exemptions, such as access to single-sex spaces

Stonewall started campaigning for this several years ago but then denied it and put it on the back burner when clearly they thought they wouldn't get any takers but now it's back on their agenda.

They have not offered a workable definition of "gender identity" and it's impossible to prove what anyone's gender identity is because it's transphobic to refuse to accept gender is fluid and changeable and someone's gender identity is whatever they say it is at any moment in time.

Stonewall thinks this is adequate justification for getting rid of single sex services and spaces. If anyone tells you that self ID does not pose a threat to womens rights, they are lying and they know they are lying.

Time to give this petition another push, please sign and share.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668426-petition-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex

And if you don't think anyone should be able to demand a falsified birth certificate then there is also this petition. Please sign and share.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4688427-repeal-the-gra

nilsmousehammer · 27/12/2022 17:16

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 27/12/2022 13:45

India encountered a unisex toilet in an airport, (labelled "gender-neutral"), which had a sign on it explaining that single-sex provision was available for those who needed it, in another part of the airport.

India trotted off across the airport to use the female-only facilities, and boasted that they'd "made a point of it". Why?

It clearly wasn't about "needing to pee" because there was a "gender-neutral" toilet right there.

I remember the tweets. They were finding it hilariously funny to intentionally deprive females of any resources at all.

Dog in the manger. All own needs met: then sets out to prevent equality of access for mere females.

howmanybicycles · 27/12/2022 14:20

Boiledbeetle · 27/12/2022 13:26

Because India is a bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep.

Sorry can't answer I would absolutely be banned.

Don't worry. I know what you mean. All people who actually want genuine equality also know.

skippingthroughthedaisies · 27/12/2022 14:18

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 27/12/2022 13:45

India encountered a unisex toilet in an airport, (labelled "gender-neutral"), which had a sign on it explaining that single-sex provision was available for those who needed it, in another part of the airport.

India trotted off across the airport to use the female-only facilities, and boasted that they'd "made a point of it". Why?

It clearly wasn't about "needing to pee" because there was a "gender-neutral" toilet right there.

Because it’s all about control and invasion.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 27/12/2022 13:45

India encountered a unisex toilet in an airport, (labelled "gender-neutral"), which had a sign on it explaining that single-sex provision was available for those who needed it, in another part of the airport.

India trotted off across the airport to use the female-only facilities, and boasted that they'd "made a point of it". Why?

It clearly wasn't about "needing to pee" because there was a "gender-neutral" toilet right there.

PaterPower · 27/12/2022 13:31

The dodgy suicide ‘study’ and resulting oft-repeated “most vulnerable” shtick are what surgeons use to justify the harm they do to healthy breast tissue and genitalia.

That and do everything they can to shut down any sort of studies into regret, detransition rates or anything else which would force them to own the truth (and stop the gravy train).

Boiledbeetle · 27/12/2022 13:26

howmanybicycles · 27/12/2022 12:48

Why is India proud of wasting valuable NHS resources?

Because India is a bleep bleep bleep bleep bleep.

Sorry can't answer I would absolutely be banned.

speakout · 27/12/2022 13:23

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision I agree.

Do doctors still take an oath " First do no harm?"

Slicing off a healthy penis and testicles then making some bad attempt at a "lady hole" is very much harm imo.

If a fit person believes he is a one legged person and asks a surgeon to cut of a healthy functioning leg- would that not be classed as assault?

I see "gender affirming " surgery as assault too- and the surgeon is paid to do it.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 27/12/2022 12:55

The surgeons may be rewarded too well, frankly. After what I have read concerning the recovery period post-surgery, I would not wish this procedure upon my worst enemy. It's hard to stomach the idea anyone makes a living from performing it on multiple patients.

speakout · 27/12/2022 12:49

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 27/12/2022 11:57

I did once read that a post-operative individual ended up needing surgery to repair their neo-vagina, after they'd seen a non-specialist for a check-up? The HCP proceeded as if it were a vagina, and used a speculum, which caused internal tearing.

Wow - there is so much wrong with this.
Why did they even attempt a smear test?
I don't think a smear test would be offered or attempted in women who have had some forms of hysterectomy, including cervix removal.
Was the nurse under duress because of policy?

The "neo" vagina is not a vagina thanks for using the phrase NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision - it is a stoma, a hole or opening into the lower abdominal cavity.
Epidermal skin is used to line the opening, electrolysis is used to remove any hair roots.
Women have vaginas lined with mucosal membrane, and very efficient at self cleaning.
A neo vagina or stoma doen't have this mechanism, so have to be washed out with soap and water a few times a week ( it is just "normal" skin) as you would skin elsewhere on your body.
Normal skin is not supposed to live internally, so very prone to infection, the laser hair removal is nor always completely successful, so may grow pubic hair inside the stoma.
The stoma has to be dilated frequently otherwise the hole may close as the body tries to heal itself.
I am sure surgeons are rewarded well.

howmanybicycles · 27/12/2022 12:48

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 26/12/2022 11:38

India posted a screenshot of their invite to a cervical smear the other day. If they have really booked in and forced a nurse to pretend examine their cervix then that says an awful lot about what they think of women.

Why is India proud of wasting valuable NHS resources?

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 27/12/2022 11:57

I did once read that a post-operative individual ended up needing surgery to repair their neo-vagina, after they'd seen a non-specialist for a check-up? The HCP proceeded as if it were a vagina, and used a speculum, which caused internal tearing.

Boomboom22 · 26/12/2022 19:55

I'd actually worry the instrument would damage a neo vagina, don't they need daily dilation to stay open at all? Even full surgery doesn't actually change your sex it's just plastic surgery approximations without much sensual sensation.

Boomboom22 · 26/12/2022 19:54

If IW turns up for a smear how would that ever work? There is no cervix just a small hole surely or does she still have her penis? 🤔

nilsmousehammer · 26/12/2022 19:40

There honestly is a belief in some parts of the ideology that as woman/female is a chosen identity, oppression is a part of it and anyone choosing that word is willingly embracing the oppression and subordinate passive service animal role.

(Which never explains why only the biologically female ones get the actual oppression and the biologically male ones just flirt with the fun aspects of it in consenting adult games, but logic and sense isn't a visitor in these parts.)

We have had visitors on FWR trying to explain that women here protesting this are TM in denial, because real women wouldn't mind.

It was explained that real women can do absolutely bloody anything they feel like, they just do it while having a biologically female body. And that's the one thing that makes them women.

babyjellyfish · 26/12/2022 19:14

YouSetTheTone · 26/12/2022 18:56

The New York Times recently published an article claiming that perhaps Louisa May Alcott - author of Little Women - was in fact transgender.
No! Successful women in the past who defied stereotypes, and who railed against the limitations of being female (mostly in pursuit of being taken seriously professionally) are WOMEN who knew damn well they were women and just wanted the freedom to behave as a woman in a man’s world without the pressure to conform. Stop saying that successful/ interesting/ powerful/ clever women weren’t in fact women. That these features meant they ‘were really men’.
Why is it seen as progressive to now strip yet more female role models from the new generation of girls?
So sick of this shit, and sick of Nicola Sturgeon and the wilful rampaging over women and girls.

"Feminism" in 2022: every successful woman in history who defied gender stereotypes and didn't just sit at home doing embroidery was in fact a man.

YouSetTheTone · 26/12/2022 18:56

The New York Times recently published an article claiming that perhaps Louisa May Alcott - author of Little Women - was in fact transgender.
No! Successful women in the past who defied stereotypes, and who railed against the limitations of being female (mostly in pursuit of being taken seriously professionally) are WOMEN who knew damn well they were women and just wanted the freedom to behave as a woman in a man’s world without the pressure to conform. Stop saying that successful/ interesting/ powerful/ clever women weren’t in fact women. That these features meant they ‘were really men’.
Why is it seen as progressive to now strip yet more female role models from the new generation of girls?
So sick of this shit, and sick of Nicola Sturgeon and the wilful rampaging over women and girls.

YouSetTheTone · 26/12/2022 18:46

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 26/12/2022 11:38

India posted a screenshot of their invite to a cervical smear the other day. If they have really booked in and forced a nurse to pretend examine their cervix then that says an awful lot about what they think of women.

And no one cares whether that nurse is going to feel uncomfortable pretending to look at a cervix that doesn’t exist, while in close proximity to a man.
If she DID say she was uncomfortable IW would obviously shriek ‘transphobe!’ rather than apologise for the situation and ask for someone else who might feel more comfortable performing the examination.
A real woman is socialised to put the feelings of others first, which is another way you can see the misogyny baked into gender ideology- trans rights activists NEVER care that women might be uncomfortable/ in danger as a result of the policies, but women are expected to put the feelings of men above all else.

Murdoch1949 · 26/12/2022 12:43

This whole issue is a time bomb. Men being the chief executive of a women's refuge, men being in charge of a women's rape crisis centre, how can this be acceptable? Women at their most vunerable may be searched by a man, may be counselled by a man, and unable to request a woman because it is a (trans) woman. Transwomen are men. The overwhelming majority have fully intact male genitalia, many have not taken hormones. The vociferous, aggressive and often violent 'transwomen' are men in frocks (sometimes), frequently just men who make no attempt to pass as a woman, but who want, for their own sexual needs to claim I am a woman and scream in gender critical women's faces, block women from speaking at public events, stop them viewing films.We are on an incredibly slippery slope, way down it actually, all women need to wake up to what we are losing.