Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
CharityShopChic · 23/12/2022 09:55

How do you prove an application is fraudulent when you can't define what "living as a woman" means in the first place?

MandyMotherOfBrian · 23/12/2022 09:52

SydneyCarton · 23/12/2022 08:51

Actually just checked and it’s a criminal offence with imprisonment up to two years or an unlimited fine. Still not clear how a false application would be found out, although a “person with interest” can make an application to the sheriff if they suspect an application was fraudulent. Doesn’t look like any proactive checking would be made.

So detransitioning is now illegal and punishable by imprisonment? Is that what that means?

WookeyHole · 23/12/2022 09:47

Well said @CharityShopChic

CharityShopChic · 23/12/2022 09:46

I think most of us are very clear on the difference between sex and gender - even if we reject the ideas of gender.

The Scottish government? Not so much. Uses the terms interchangeably.

IdaGoodnight · 23/12/2022 09:45

Currently UK law (EA’10) has provision for single sex spaces - and this allows the exclusion of those with a GRC and working towards transition (one of the protected characteristics).

This has not been happening in practice - see prisons, changing rooms, specific jobs, toilets etc…. On both sides of the border. In effect self I.D. is already happening.

By making changes to the GRC in Scotland, it puts the new Scottish GRC at odds with the EA’10 (which is not currently being applied properly anyway). A massive legal problem for the UK as a whole and is a nightmare for any person who doesn’t wish to share intimate spaces with the opposite sex.

CharityShopChic · 23/12/2022 09:43

bellinisurge · 23/12/2022 09:12

Today, I am wearing no makeup, baggy clothes and will be doing DIY. A regular weekend for me. Am I living as a man? My other half will be food shopping and cooking. Is he living as a woman? Are we a queer couple? Rather than middle aged heterosexual married couple who divvy up the chores?

Just said similar to DH - can't remember the lat time I wore make-up, or a skirt. Does that mean i'm a man?

I'm Scottish, I have a 17 year old daughter. I don't believe that every transwomen is a threat to DD or me. I do strongly believe that ALL people should be free to use whichever name they choose, dress how they want, have whatever hobbies they want without bullying or persecution. Respect for all.

But I also know that people can't change sex. Sex is not "observed", it is innate. Dig up a skeleton 500 years from now and it will be identified as male or female. It's not that complicated.

Teenagers should not be encouraged to "change gender" and be encouraged to start on hormones and radical surgery when they are still CHILDREN. My teenage daughter should not be expected to change for PE in front of a fully intact male. My confused elderly relative with dementia shouldn't be expected a transwoman to help her in the shower if she's not uncomfortable with that. My DD shouldn't miss out on a place on a "women into science" event or similar because a few boys who think they're girls take the places. I don't want to sit in my female-only menopause support group discussing vaginal dryness and anxiety with a male.

Trans people want the right to live their "best lives" without discrimination and harassment and that's fine. But they also want women's rights. And that's not right.

Waitwhat23 · 23/12/2022 09:37

As Ash Regan said in her superb speech to Parliament during the debate -

'We're not going to be able to tell [who is genuine]. This now creates a situation where member of a dominant group can self-ID into the rights of an oppressed group. And this is absolutely unprecedented'.

WookeyHole · 23/12/2022 09:20

SerotinaPickeler · 23/12/2022 08:19

Check out the Mumsnet petitions board. There is a petition to update the Equality Act 2010 to make it clear that the single sex exceptions that allow single sex spaces and services are based on sex (biological female) not gender (mixed sex).

If you only do one thing to support women and children's rights sign this petition so that this important legal protection is sound. This is not an anti-transgender action but a positive step to support biological women.

This. With bells on.

Jellycatspyjamas · 23/12/2022 09:17

On the issue of a sex offender changing his name to a woman's name.... could he not just change his name anyway (to another man's name)? He wouldn't need to get a GRC necessarily to change name?

He could, but would be expected to declare any previous names used. Having a GRC means he can demand to be placed in the female prison estate, use female changing rooms and spaces that one wouid expect to be single sex, he can use female domestic abuse services, access counselling in female services. It literally gives convicted sex offenders access to women at their most vulnerable.

AlisonDonut · 23/12/2022 09:17

You can't ask for a GRC. As the people that worked behind the scenes made it impossible to ask, as that would constitute 'outing' them.

So it is Self ID by the back door.

Merrymouse · 23/12/2022 09:16

The original legislation was a fudge designed to protect privacy, waived through on the grounds that it would only be used by a tiny number of people. The new legislation is designed to to something completely different - recognise the identities of a far larger number of people.

Meanwhile no legislature has examined why sex is recorded E.g. on a death certificate. If it isn’t important, why is it being done at all? If it is important, what is being recorded? What is gender and why is it the government’s business to keep records of it?

TeenTraumaTrials · 23/12/2022 09:13

I'm probably clutching at straws but does the specific wording of the Haldane ruling mean there's a loophole? Her ruling is about people who obtained a GRC under the 2004 act but in Scotland GRCs will no longer be under that legislation but the new one. So will it apply?

In any case it's a complete mess.

I am not a Tory voter but I plan to write to Rachael Hamilton who is one of my regional MsPs to thank her for her efforts on all of this.

bellinisurge · 23/12/2022 09:12

Today, I am wearing no makeup, baggy clothes and will be doing DIY. A regular weekend for me. Am I living as a man? My other half will be food shopping and cooking. Is he living as a woman? Are we a queer couple? Rather than middle aged heterosexual married couple who divvy up the chores?

JellySaurus · 23/12/2022 09:10

They do have to pledge that they will live forever as the opposite gender. There is no explanation of what it means to live as the opposite gender. The example given is to change your name on households bills.

How does a 16yo do that?

How does a 16yo even know what they want to do for the rest of their life?

It is bad law made on undefined - and indefinable - assumptions and beliefs. The GRA is just as bad, but at least it slows the process down and requires some degree of support and investigation for people who want to use it.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 23/12/2022 09:10

The whole thing is a mess. There is no legal definition of what it means to 'live as a man' or 'live as a woman', because how could there be? The only way to live as a woman is to be a woman, by dint of one's biological sex.

So we end up with a position where lots of women and girls just silently drop out of things that used to be single sex.

  • Lesbian dating sites are apparently now full of transwomen who are sexually attracted to women and therefore identify as lesbian women and expect real lesbians to accept them as potential partners.
  • Online support groups for things that only affect women and girls, e.g. breastfeeding, birth, pregnancy, are now routinely opened up to transwomen.
  • Group therapy sessions at rape crisis centres used to be single-sex, now they're single-gender, so transwomen can join the women's only group. Many traumatised women just won't feel able to talk about what happened to them with a male person sitting listening.
  • Refuges - women who've complained about the behaviour of transwomen, or just finding a transwoman taking up a scarce place in a refuge, have been thrown out.
  • Sport - what's the point in even trying for a place on a team or a scholarship if there's a transwoman there with all the benefits of male puberty? Is it even safe to join in, in the case of contact sports? Will a woman from a strict religious tradition even consider trying out a women's swimming session, for example, if it's clear it's actually single-gender, not single-sex?
  • Toilets - we're already seeing girls at schools which have introduced all-gender toilets refusing to go to the loo all day, restricting fluids and ending up with UTIs.

The great elephant in the room is that decades ago the number of people who sought professional help with gender dysphoria was absolutely tiny, and mostly male. Now the trans-identifying population is growing fast and mostly young females, with the other large group adult males. Hardly any adult females. Why is this? You might think academics would be falling over themselves to research this interesting social phenomenon, but no, quite the contrary, except in the case of a very few brave and determined individuals. It's almost as if activists don't want people looking too hard at what's happening!

Two things that get shouted down:

  • We all know that adolescence is a very difficult time, and it's particularly bad now for girls because of social media and internet porn. Teenage girls have long been known to be particularly vulnerable to social contagion, e.g. eating disorders, self-harm. The very sudden and recent rise in girls trying to identify out of being girls/women/female looks like another example. But apparently it's bigoted and hateful to suggest this needs looking at.
  • What's motivating the adult males to transition? It used to be accepted by the professionals working in this area that there were two main reasons. One was gender dysphoria, often in men who had been abused as children or who were gay, or both. Transition was a coping mechanism for them, and they were not considered a threat to women. The other group were almost exclusively heterosexual and cross-dressed as part of a condition that rhymes with wettish. It's a feature of such conditions that making other people part of it, especially against their will, increases the excitement. This group were not approved for surgery by reputable psychiatrists and psychologists. But those days are gone now.
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/12/2022 09:09

MsMiaWallace · 23/12/2022 08:54

It makes me feel sick to the stomach & I'm glad I don't have a daughter

I feel the same.

Gymrabbit · 23/12/2022 09:08

SydneyCarton

it’s clearly not enforced though as Freddie Mconnell pledged to ‘live as a man’ and then gave birth!

also I believe that a grc gives a right to privacy in terms of sex. Which means that males could be working in schools or in hospitals presenting as women and it would be very difficult to prove they weren’t.
which will lead to more gaslighting like that which happened when the woman was raped in the hospital by a transwoman and was told there were no men there so that couldn’t have happened.
I had a Twitter argument with two TRAs when I was told that I had no right to know the sex of the medical professional who was performing an intimate examination on me.
This enshrines their rapey views into law.

SnowWayOut · 23/12/2022 09:08

ThorsBedazzler · 23/12/2022 08:54

I just hope that this doesn't create a reinforcement of gender stereotypes. Eg you are 16, hate having periods and breasts, don't really like pink or makeup. Fancy girls. Am I a boy?

That's already happening.

Check out some transitioners stories, they think they were always girls because the liked "girls" toys, or were more friendly with girls, or something equally as superficial.

lifeturnsonadime · 23/12/2022 09:06

SydneyCarton · 23/12/2022 08:51

Actually just checked and it’s a criminal offence with imprisonment up to two years or an unlimited fine. Still not clear how a false application would be found out, although a “person with interest” can make an application to the sheriff if they suspect an application was fraudulent. Doesn’t look like any proactive checking would be made.

But this doesn't make sense because of the lack of definitions.

Living as a woman is an undefined, and frankly, undefinable concept.

It's abhorrent that we are being asked to lie about reality here.

People can't change sex.

The word woman has been erased of all meaning. As someone else said upthread this is legislated male supremacy.

AFAIK there is no need for a man to have any form of reassignment surgery or even to change his appearance to self declare as a woman. If being a woman comes down to heels, skirts and makeup then I'm screwed if someone wants to check my womanhood.

skippingthroughthedaisies · 23/12/2022 09:05

I think they also rejected any sort of data gathering to assess the impact of the Act further down the line. So it’ll be a case of “nothing to see here”. The potential for gaslighting women is huge.

Also they have no means of proving that someone has fraudulently applied for a GRC because no proof is required to obtain one in the first place other than “living as a woman” . It’s going to be almost impossible to police.

There are people in ScotGov who want children as young as 6 or 7 to be able to have a GRC.

When you start doing research into it, it uncovers all sorts of nastiness.
Think very hard about WHO you are voting for next time, not just the party.

JellySaurus · 23/12/2022 09:01

PaleBlueMoonlight · 23/12/2022 00:36

Under the new Scottish legislation anyone who is 16 or over can decide to change their gender legally by applying for a GRC, which has the effect of changing their sex, legally, for most purposes. They do not have to have gender dysphoria or transition. They do have to pledge that they will live forever as the opposite gender. There is no explanation of what it means to live as the opposite gender. The example given is to change your name on households bills. In reality there is no particular way of living as a man or a women.

According to a recent Scottish case a man with a GRC should be regarded as a woman for the purposes of the Equality Act. If that judge is correct (and it is widely thought that she isn't ) it will mean that a man with a GRC (who under the Scottish legislation can be a man who has not transitioned and who does not have dysphoria) cannot be excluded from women's single sex spaces and services.He also must not be discriminated against for having the protected characteristic of gender reassignment when compared with women, so if a women is entitled to it then a man with a GRC must also be entitled to it. It is not possible to ask a man if he has a GRC and therefore the only way to ascertain whether a man who says he is a woman has one is to ask to see their birth certificate (because a GRC changes an individual's birth certificate). Arguably it would be discriminatory under the Equality Act only to ask men who say they are women for a copy of their birth certificate because you would be singling them out on the basis of a protected characteristic and not treating them the same as "other" women. To avoid this you would have to ask all women and men who say they are women for a copy of their birth certificate. It is rarely likely to be possible or appropriate to do this. As a result if a man says he is a woman it will be extremely difficult to turn him away.

Has Lady Haldane stated that the correct comparator for a male with a GRC is a female without a GRC? That makes no sense.

The correct comparator for a male with a GRC is another male without a GRC.

MsMiaWallace · 23/12/2022 08:54

It makes me feel sick to the stomach & I'm glad I don't have a daughter

ThorsBedazzler · 23/12/2022 08:54

I just hope that this doesn't create a reinforcement of gender stereotypes. Eg you are 16, hate having periods and breasts, don't really like pink or makeup. Fancy girls. Am I a boy?

SydneyCarton · 23/12/2022 08:51

Actually just checked and it’s a criminal offence with imprisonment up to two years or an unlimited fine. Still not clear how a false application would be found out, although a “person with interest” can make an application to the sheriff if they suspect an application was fraudulent. Doesn’t look like any proactive checking would be made.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/12/2022 08:49

Basically though TLDR version the category women now includes adult human females and men who say they feel like women (how a woman feels as opposed to a man is not defined). There is now nothing that is for women - everything is mixed sex