Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 23/12/2022 12:34

Your initial take on this is what the SNP, TRAs, Stonewall etc want you to understand. However they lie, obfuscate, hide, or in SNPs case utterly ignore, the realities of legally/globally replacing sex with gender - which is what they are attempting to do!

Put as simply, bluntly as possible: gender recognition will, already does, override sex as a protected characteristic. This leaves no effective right to single sex spaces, same sex intimate care etc.

This leaves women and girls with no effective, immediate, automatic safeguarding against any man who chooses to "present as a woman".

Think that through. In order to remove any man from a female space women would have to appeal to an organisation, the law. Any male wishing to enter a female, single sex space would not have to do anything, be vetted, have a piece of paper, a certificate etc.

The assumption, the law, expectation changes from single sex spaces being single sex to them being used by whoever wants to. That makes a total mockery of all safeguarding and many equality laws.

Basically it requires a change of thinking. This would mean that men are automatically accepted women in law and women would have to make a legal challenge to maintain any single sex space.

Utter madness.

speakout · 23/12/2022 12:30

Not gender non conforming young people who are now being encouraged to believe that if they don't fit a certain stereotype they are probably trans.

Yes- it is dangerous, and in fact deepens gender stereotypes.
This is all making the situation worse.

I remember as a child feeling "odd"- I much preferred helping my father fix the car or bulld a fence than decorate cakes or knit with my mother.
At school I gravitated towards science subject, and still though there was something a little "wrong" with me.
I did wonder if I should have been born a boy, but back in those days there was no talk of trans.

Looking back it was sad that I felt like this- the only thing that was odd or wrong was the gender stereotypes - those were warped, not me.

I don't know what trans people are aiming for- a warped and charicatured image of womanhood, all kitten heels and false lashes.

skippingthroughthedaisies · 23/12/2022 12:29

ILoveeCakes · 23/12/2022 11:21

Mumsnetters think that everyone is out to assault them and abduct their kids - despite stuff like that being super super rare. The "safety" argument is also good cover for their anti-trans stance

Of course it’s going to be “super rare” because going forward there will be no requirement to audit or record this, which was one of the amendments voted down.

It will now be a case of “look away”, “nothing to see here”, “it didn’t happen”.

Classic gaslighting.

Oher · 23/12/2022 12:28

Rainbowshit · 22/12/2022 23:47

16 year olds who are still at school can now get a GRC. This means that my daughter will be forced to accept males changing beside her for PE.

The haldane ruling states that people with a GRC must be treated as their acquired sex in all situations.

It's a direct affront on my daughter's right to privacy, dignity and safety.

This.

lifeturnsonadime · 23/12/2022 12:24

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 12:15

Yes, it's beyond grim that they rejected an amendment to prevent sex offenders from being able to change their gender - and therefore their identity - more easily.

Because it's more important to validate sex offenders' imaginary identities than to be able to verify their actual identities, eh?

Women just don't matter.

We don't exist any more in Sturgeon's Scotland.

The refusal to address genuine concerns of survivors of abuse, the Geneva Convention on Human Rights, The Cass Report , the will of the people of Scotland (two thirds of Scots opposed the Gender Reform Bill) etc , is illustrative of the fact that the only people who matter are the male ones.

And if this is simply politicking then women are just collateral damage to Sturgeons bigger agenda. It's abhorrent either way.

speakout · 23/12/2022 12:21

ChaToilLeam · 23/12/2022 12:19

This is grim for Scotland. I think Sturgeon may have overplayed her hand though. While the whip ensured that it was supported by the majority of MPs (shame on them all) it is not popular with the electorate in general. I know many independence supporters who no longer support the SNP and would welcome Westminster intervention on this. Which will surely now come.

I am one of these scots.
These legal changes are not democratic.
I hope Westminster does intervene.

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 12:20

Skyellaskerry · 23/12/2022 12:14

Not all that long ago I was unaware and probably of the ‘be kind’ attitude. However, and I can’t remember what, why or when, but my eyes were opened and once you see and question, you can’t unsee. I am just sorry I was so late to become aware. I am also left leaning, labour voting environmentalist, so have found myself conflicted in agreeing and being thankful for the Tories in this issue. Hopefully the sunlight on it can only be a good thing.

The "be kind" nonsense does my nut.

Who is it kind to?

Not women - the female kind.

Not children and young people who are struggling with various mental health issues and have got caught up in this.

Not gender non conforming young people who are now being encouraged to believe that if they don't fit a certain stereotype they are probably trans.

Not harmless trans people who have now found themselves at the centre of a culture war which is making a lot of people start to question whether they should actually have some of the rights that they currently have.

So who benefits?

Men who want access to women's spaces. And privileged people who don't need to worry about prisons, rape crisis centres, refuges or even public toilets ot changing rooms, since they will never need to use them, but get to look cool and woke by having the right opinions.

ChaToilLeam · 23/12/2022 12:19

This is grim for Scotland. I think Sturgeon may have overplayed her hand though. While the whip ensured that it was supported by the majority of MPs (shame on them all) it is not popular with the electorate in general. I know many independence supporters who no longer support the SNP and would welcome Westminster intervention on this. Which will surely now come.

Skyellaskerry · 23/12/2022 12:16

@babyjellyfish its indefensible

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 12:15

Yes, it's beyond grim that they rejected an amendment to prevent sex offenders from being able to change their gender - and therefore their identity - more easily.

Because it's more important to validate sex offenders' imaginary identities than to be able to verify their actual identities, eh?

Skyellaskerry · 23/12/2022 12:14

AWaferThinMint · 23/12/2022 10:54

I may pop a look at that too. I've only come to this from the news stories this week. I'm appalled

Not all that long ago I was unaware and probably of the ‘be kind’ attitude. However, and I can’t remember what, why or when, but my eyes were opened and once you see and question, you can’t unsee. I am just sorry I was so late to become aware. I am also left leaning, labour voting environmentalist, so have found myself conflicted in agreeing and being thankful for the Tories in this issue. Hopefully the sunlight on it can only be a good thing.

lifeturnsonadime · 23/12/2022 12:12

It is not anti trans to point out that at least 122 sex offenders have identified as trans. .

This is the evidence that Nicola Sturgeon refused to listen to instead accusing those who wanted to raise it of bigotry.

whynotwhatknot · 23/12/2022 12:09

JellySaurus · 23/12/2022 11:26

Any MAN can say he's a woman.

sorry yes

TofuonToast · 23/12/2022 11:58

bellinisurge · 23/12/2022 08:27

Existing law assumes a GRC has been given after a safeguarding process- an ineffective one where organisations are fearful of enforcing single sex spaces :Karen White, Katie Dolatowski, Edinburgh Rape Crisis- but a safeguarding process of sorts.
Holyrood has changed the parameters by which a GRC can be obtained and has removed what safeguards there were.
So that is why there is a problem. Scottish law has, in effect, messed with UK law.
Discussion of this means more sunlight.

I don’t think sunlight matters anymore. Not with a twisted electoral process and politicians with an agenda.

RhannionKPSS · 23/12/2022 11:58

ILoveeCakes · 23/12/2022 11:21

Mumsnetters think that everyone is out to assault them and abduct their kids - despite stuff like that being super super rare. The "safety" argument is also good cover for their anti-trans stance

I’m not anti trans people, I’m pro women’s rights and safeguarding children, it’s that simple.
As it said on our banner yesterday Safety Dignity Privacy.

JazbayGrapes · 23/12/2022 11:57

You can't fight for Women's Rights when "women" don't officially exist.
This is basically woke version of Taliban.

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 11:53

GentlySobbing · 23/12/2022 11:46

I didn't say that they have amended the Equality Act. The FWS case (albeit a case from a lower court) confirmed that sex in the EA means legal sex (ie, it already includes everyone who has legally changed their sex). The Scottish gov have now changed the criteria by which you can change legal sex. They didn't need to amend the EA to do that.

The EA continues technically unamended, but has a dramatically different effect now.

Does it though?

The EA specifically envisages scenarios where sex does not include legal sex, i.e. it acknowledges that there is a difference between the two.

Either Lady Haldane is wrong, or the EA needs to be amended to ensure that biological sex is a protected category.

GentlySobbing · 23/12/2022 11:51

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/12/2022 11:42

That is true @GentlySobbing

bit I would say every women everywhere is affected by the deep misogyny that says ‘woman is an adult human female - and also a feeling in a man’s head or a costume to be worn’

how fucking insulting is it to all women everywhere that we can be reduced a feeling or a costume?

is that all we are to them?

True, but I see that as just a continuation of everyday misogyny. Part of the general package that society throws at women. By which I don't mean that it should be ignored, but that it isn't exceptional in itself.

Telling female prisoners that they are now to be locked up with male sex offenders, and they are liable to get further sentences for hate crimes if they express any fear about this, is a different kettle of fish. It's an off-the-scale abuse of human rights. It needs to be objected to in the strongest possible terms.

lifeturnsonadime · 23/12/2022 11:49

ILoveeCakes · 23/12/2022 11:21

Mumsnetters think that everyone is out to assault them and abduct their kids - despite stuff like that being super super rare. The "safety" argument is also good cover for their anti-trans stance

Oh so that's OK then. Not enough children been molested by trans identified sex offenders for you then? The likes of Katy Dolotowskihave been given a free pass to women's prisons and we should all stop clutching our pearls.

And lets not worry about the vulnerable kids who are going to be put on a path to transition in Scotland which will remove their sexual function and render them infertile. Let's not think about the fact that many of these children are disabled, neurodiverse or living in care.

GentlySobbing · 23/12/2022 11:46

I didn't say that they have amended the Equality Act. The FWS case (albeit a case from a lower court) confirmed that sex in the EA means legal sex (ie, it already includes everyone who has legally changed their sex). The Scottish gov have now changed the criteria by which you can change legal sex. They didn't need to amend the EA to do that.

The EA continues technically unamended, but has a dramatically different effect now.

TheKeatingFive · 23/12/2022 11:45

It's like they think we are just extras in the film of their life. There to validate their perception of reality, not as actual humans in our own right

Thats depressingly accurate

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 11:44

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/12/2022 11:42

That is true @GentlySobbing

bit I would say every women everywhere is affected by the deep misogyny that says ‘woman is an adult human female - and also a feeling in a man’s head or a costume to be worn’

how fucking insulting is it to all women everywhere that we can be reduced a feeling or a costume?

is that all we are to them?

It's like they think we are just extras in the film of their life. There to validate their perception of reality, not as actual humans in our own right.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/12/2022 11:42

That is true @GentlySobbing

bit I would say every women everywhere is affected by the deep misogyny that says ‘woman is an adult human female - and also a feeling in a man’s head or a costume to be worn’

how fucking insulting is it to all women everywhere that we can be reduced a feeling or a costume?

is that all we are to them?

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 11:41

GentlySobbing · 23/12/2022 11:39

And the idea that this bill does not affect the Equality Act is absolutely nonsense. It dramatically changes the meaning of "woman" as used in the Act. The word now means "female sex unless they don't want to be included and any of the male sex who do want to be included".

Saying that it has no effect on the Equality Act is like changing the definition of "money" to include "bananas", then starting to pay Universal Credit in bananas whilst claiming that no change has been made to Universal Credit.

The Scottish parliament doesn't have the right or the ability to change the Equality Act though. Any legislation purporting to do so would be overreaching their devolved powers.

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 11:40

GentlySobbing · 23/12/2022 11:36

Men now have to ability to opt in to spaces where there are vulnerable women and girls. The point of self ID is that they can do this at will, with no checks or requirements. They literally just have to fill out a form.

Your average predatory man is unlikely to bother to do this in order to access every day single sex facilities - toilets, changing rooms at the shops. They've already got lots of other opportunities to prey on women. And in truth, they don't need to, as the current fashion is for these service providers to provide mixed-sex facilities anyway, so a change of legal sex is irrelevant.

But there are situations where single sex facilities are not just for everyday use. Refuges, rape crisis centres, intimate medical care. Prisons. Predatory men can now decide that they want to use female facilities, and there is absolutely nothing that can be done about it. I would be surprised if any male sex offenders remain in male prisons in Scotland now, they'll all have a much nicer time in the women's prison.

This bill isn't going to do a thing to the everyday experience to a lot of women, because a lot of women do not have a need for rape crisis or DV support and aren't likely to be sent to prison. The women who will be affected by this are among the most vulnerable in society.

The reality is that they can do most of this anyway, with or without a GRC.

Nobody is checking your GRC at the toilet door.

I think in practical terms what it will do is either make it harder for any organisation which wishes to provide single sex spaces or services to justify excluding people who have a GRC, or in conjunction with the Haldane ruling, oblige those organisations to consider that someone who has a GRC is the opposite sex and cannot be excluded.

And it will have an impact on things like crime statistics, with men's crimes being recorded as women's crimes. This will make it more difficult to combat things like male violence against women and girls, because we will no longer be able to point to the fact that 100% of rapes - as defined in UK law - are committed by males, and 98% of all sex offences are committed by males.

It'll be "but women rape too, so single sex spaces don't actually make you any safer". Bollocks they do.