Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 15:07

ThorsBedazzler · 23/12/2022 14:51

Have thought more on this.

I don't understand why men can't accept that some men like wearing dresses and skirts or wearing makeup.

Women have always been accepting of women who have short hair and wear masculine clothing. We have widened our bandwidth of what women look like, within our sex. We have butch women, feminine women, women who wear makeup and women who don't. Women who are engineers and women who are nurses. Doctors, cleaners, office workers and athletes. We share our biology.

Why can't men do the same? Be more accepting of a wider range of what man and men look like. What is it that makes them not want to be male any more or what makes them not want to accept different looking men?

”Women have always been accepting of women who have short hair and wear masculine clothing.”

this is a very rose-tinted view of women’s attitudes towards non-gender conforming women. For example, one of my teachers at school was quite butch (I had a massive crush on her). Other girls were always making jokes about her being a pervert, a dirty lesbian, how they were scared she was going to touch them.

Hopefully the vast majority of them have changed their attitudes as they grew up and times changed, but that sort of view was in my experience pretty common (among adults as well as teenagers) as recently as the 90s, and I’m sure is still around today to an extent.

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 14:57

ThorsBedazzler · 23/12/2022 14:51

Have thought more on this.

I don't understand why men can't accept that some men like wearing dresses and skirts or wearing makeup.

Women have always been accepting of women who have short hair and wear masculine clothing. We have widened our bandwidth of what women look like, within our sex. We have butch women, feminine women, women who wear makeup and women who don't. Women who are engineers and women who are nurses. Doctors, cleaners, office workers and athletes. We share our biology.

Why can't men do the same? Be more accepting of a wider range of what man and men look like. What is it that makes them not want to be male any more or what makes them not want to accept different looking men?

Because that wouldn't get them access to women's spaces and sports?

Odessafile · 23/12/2022 14:57

Looking at the womens aid website they are saying they will protect female only spaces. I've read through it quickly so may be wrong and am happy to be corrected.
Whole thing is a mess though.
www.womensaid.org.uk/womens-aid-single-sex-services-statement/

Waitwhat23 · 23/12/2022 14:53

And we are told again and again, 'it will never happen' -

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3348290-It-will-never-happen-resource-thread

ThorsBedazzler · 23/12/2022 14:51

Have thought more on this.

I don't understand why men can't accept that some men like wearing dresses and skirts or wearing makeup.

Women have always been accepting of women who have short hair and wear masculine clothing. We have widened our bandwidth of what women look like, within our sex. We have butch women, feminine women, women who wear makeup and women who don't. Women who are engineers and women who are nurses. Doctors, cleaners, office workers and athletes. We share our biology.

Why can't men do the same? Be more accepting of a wider range of what man and men look like. What is it that makes them not want to be male any more or what makes them not want to accept different looking men?

TheSnowWillGoOn · 23/12/2022 14:41

No2SelfID · 23/12/2022 13:10

Here is the thread with the petition linked.
Please sign, no matter where you live in UK as this has consequences for all of us. Ask you husbands, friends, neighbours to sign

Petition: Update the Equality Act to make clear the characteristic “sex” is biological sex www.mumsnet.com/Talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668426-petition-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex?msgid=-4668426#-4668426

@twoandcooplease

twoandcooplease · 23/12/2022 14:37

Can someone link the petition mentioned above please?

twoandcooplease · 23/12/2022 14:37

forgotmyusername1 · 23/12/2022 13:35

If I self identify as a pensioner can I claim my pension? Sounds ridiculous but when in rome and all that

Quite

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 23/12/2022 14:33

Boomboom22 · 23/12/2022 14:03

People don't get it. I don't know why. My gay friends think I'm being really horrible to the nice trans people who just want to live their lives and this is like it was for gay people before. They will not recognise the concerns and just find it offensive so refuse to actually listen. It's so hard as i can't believe they genuinely support what is happening, but even when told, even age 16, even sex offenders they just don't or won't get it.

Maybe show your friends this delightful specimen using the f*** word to insult someone. twitter.com/MrAndyNgo/status/1594430891123564544?s=20&t=suhCzG1mI7xCrt5wwCAMgw Incredibly homophobic stuff.

Then there's Juno Dawson: 'A lot of gay men are gay men as a consolation prize, because they couldn't be women'. www.independent.co.uk/voices/juno-dawson-attitude-magazine-interview-transgender-gay-man-lgbt-trans-woman-a7752701.html

Boomboom22 · 23/12/2022 14:03

People don't get it. I don't know why. My gay friends think I'm being really horrible to the nice trans people who just want to live their lives and this is like it was for gay people before. They will not recognise the concerns and just find it offensive so refuse to actually listen. It's so hard as i can't believe they genuinely support what is happening, but even when told, even age 16, even sex offenders they just don't or won't get it.

forgotmyusername1 · 23/12/2022 13:35

If I self identify as a pensioner can I claim my pension? Sounds ridiculous but when in rome and all that

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 23/12/2022 13:21

I wish the GRA 2004 had never been passed into law. Parliament rushed it through in response to a case the UK government had lost at the European Court of Human Rights. Some farsighted MPs and Lords pointed out many obvious problems, but the Labour government of the time still curtailed discussion on the grounds that this was just a very minor matter that would hardly affect anyone at all. Their advice was that there would only ever be about 5000 GRCs issued because so few people would qualify. That proved pretty accurate but of course what they hadn't grasped was the activists regarded the GRA as just a first step, and lo and behold, here we are with massive changes pushed through in Scotland, dispensing with most of the safeguards from the original Act.

Skyellaskerry · 23/12/2022 13:14

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 12:20

The "be kind" nonsense does my nut.

Who is it kind to?

Not women - the female kind.

Not children and young people who are struggling with various mental health issues and have got caught up in this.

Not gender non conforming young people who are now being encouraged to believe that if they don't fit a certain stereotype they are probably trans.

Not harmless trans people who have now found themselves at the centre of a culture war which is making a lot of people start to question whether they should actually have some of the rights that they currently have.

So who benefits?

Men who want access to women's spaces. And privileged people who don't need to worry about prisons, rape crisis centres, refuges or even public toilets ot changing rooms, since they will never need to use them, but get to look cool and woke by having the right opinions.

I completely agree with you. I have changed - I don’t believe that this old dog cant change her spots, late, true, and I’m actually ashamed at myself for that. I yelled at the ‘little bit kinder Scotland’ references the last few days in the SP. Be kind does my nut now too.

No2SelfID · 23/12/2022 13:10

Here is the thread with the petition linked.
Please sign, no matter where you live in UK as this has consequences for all of us. Ask you husbands, friends, neighbours to sign

Petition: Update the Equality Act to make clear the characteristic “sex” is biological sex www.mumsnet.com/Talk/petitions_noticeboard/4668426-petition-update-the-equality-act-to-make-clear-the-characteristic-sex-is-biological-sex?msgid=-4668426#-4668426

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 13:03

Good post, @GentlySobbing.

I've been wanting to write to my MP about this for a while but was unsure what to focus on and didn't want it to come across as an unhinged rant.

Maybe this would be a good topic to focus on.

stopthebarking · 23/12/2022 13:00

Anything that continues this insane trend of denying the real, unchangeable, biological differences between men and women can only be a bad thing. I can't honestly believe it has gone as far as it has. Attitudes that I once thought the stuff of science fiction are being normalised. It truly does feel as though a vocal minority of the world has gone mad, and they're dragging the rest of us along with them!

JazbayGrapes · 23/12/2022 12:56

I wonder when is it enough for women to properly protest. Like to the baricades!

midgetastic · 23/12/2022 12:53

It's the misinterpretation of the equality act - there should be no need to state that transwomen should not be in female prisons if they have committed sec offences because the equality act allows all transwomen to be excluded as a class from women's prisons

But the equality act is being ignored with regard to sex and then they make it easier for people to get the gender reassignment characteristics

GentlySobbing · 23/12/2022 12:52

"Either Lady Haldane is wrong, or the EA needs to be amended to ensure that biological sex is a protected category."

I think both are true. Haldane's interpretation means that the treatment of sex in the EA makes very little sense (although to be fair to her, the nonsense started in 2004 with the "for all purposes" in the GRA). Sadly it isn't uncommon for legislation to fall apart under scrutiny (eg, consumer protection law was completely impenetrable until the Consumer Rights Act made an effort to sort it out).

This absolute mess of conflicting legislation is only going to be sorted out if cases come to the courts that address each inconsistency in full (unlikely to happen), or if Westminster feels sufficiently motivated to change the legislation (possible but won't be quick). Until either today those things happen then we are stuck with service providers interpreting the EA as best they can, and in the face of Haldane's judgment and the "all legal purposes" part of the GRA, we are in all practical terms stuck with the "self ID changes legal sex for all purposes including single sex exemptions" interpretation for the foreseeable future, no matter how egregious the effects of that are.

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 12:52

@Chesneyhawkes1

Why is it that we cannot be allowed to express any opinion which may offend a trans person, but it doesn't matter if we are offended?

Personally I find the very idea that a woman is something a male person can just "identify as" deeply offensive.

If being a woman is just an identity then the implications of that are that we are to blame for the pay gap, for our own street harassment, for having FGM performed on us, for being made to wear the hijab, for being underrepresented in business and politics, because we are women because of how we choose to identify, not because of what we are. It implies that we could avoid all of these things and benefit from the same privilege males enjoy, if we all just decided to be men instead.

No. It doesn't work like that.

Being a woman is a material reality, not a costume you can choose to put on or take off.

midgetastic · 23/12/2022 12:50

In many ways it's the fact that trans people expect to access these spaces and want women to prove that they should be excluded that is the real problem

Buy making it easy to change gender without clarifying that it's gender not sex simply makes it harder for women to object

By making it easy to change gender it actively promotes gender as a real thing whereas it's a cage used to hold women back and make men suffer in different ways

aseriesofstillimages · 23/12/2022 12:44

iamop · 23/12/2022 07:55

So is the argument basically - that only trans people with GRC's are able to use single sex spaces and the Scottish Government are making GRC's too easily attainable now if this bill is passed?

I haven’t read the whole thread, but every response I’ve read so far has either been misleading or outright false.

The EA allows single sex services/spaces to exist (and not be unlawfully discriminatory on the basis of sex, despite excluding men, or women, as the case may be) in certain contexts, as long as they are a proportionate means to achieve a legitimate aim. The EA also provides that such services are not unlawfully discriminatory on the basis of gender reassignment, if they meet the same test.

So a women-only service or space can exclude trans women if it is a proportionate means to achieve a legitimate aim, regardless of whether the trans woman has a GRC or not. The recent court case that held a trans woman with a GRC is a woman for the purposes of the EA does not alter this.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 23/12/2022 12:42

God it's depressing.

I had comments removed off a women's page recently as I commented on a post expressing that I didn't agree with trans women competing against women in sport.

My comments were removed, so as not to offend our trans women members.

This is a women's specific union page and a woman can no longer express an opinion on it 🤦‍♀️ basically women are being silenced.

I recently entered a local 10k and had the pleasure of competing against a transwoman.

I was determined he wouldn't beat me. But he beat plenty of other poor women. Women who may have finished in the top 10 or top of their age category etc.

forgotmyusername1 · 23/12/2022 12:40

I have young boys and my 10 year old goes to the mens bathroom unaccompanied (my 6 year old comes with me)

if I had young girls instead and my husband had taken them out I would be very warey of allowing my children to use the girls toilets unaccompanied - who knows who could be in there now

babyjellyfish · 23/12/2022 12:37

I don't know what trans people are aiming for- a warped and charicatured image of womanhood, all kitten heels and false lashes.

The more charitable explanation is that performing feminine stereotypes is the only way they can signal to the world that they are women, because a male person wearing jeans and a t-shirt just looks like a man, unlike a female person wearing jeans and a t-shirt, who doesn't need to "pass" because she is, and therefore looks like, a woman no matter what she wears.

The less charitable explanation is that it is a sexual fetish, and I don't see why the rest of society should be expected to accommodate or participate in that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread