Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be envious of those with lots of children

192 replies

Noonesingsthischristmassong · 22/12/2022 22:51

I’m talking four children really, or more if you’re very wealthy.
I’ve always loved kids but was never massively maternal. Dh and I then started trying for kids and it took 9 years and lots of losses. We now have an amazing Dd and frozen embryos, but I’m 44 so thinking it’s too late now anyway.
I adore Dd but am a person who likes/needs space and don’t get it and have found motherhood hard at times..my head says I’d be crazy to want lots of kids as it’s hard work and life is more stressful etc. But I often look at those with four or so kids and think how nice it would be, you’d never be lonely, a bustling, full house, four children with their different personalities, four times feeling that love of having a child. All your children around you in your old age.
I travelled lots when younger and had a great career, but sometimes wonder how different life would have been if I’d just put more importance on family and tried to conceive younger and maybe have a big family full of love.

OP posts:
QS90 · 23/12/2022 00:57

We needed IVF for our first, and I remember when we were trying, always thinking how much I'd like 3 or 4 children. I am due our 2nd any day now, conceived without IVF (I'm 32). Now I feel it's possible to have more, I think I'm probably happy with just the 2. There's nothing like thinking / knowing you can't have something that makes you romanticise it in your mind.

If you crave being around more children / having a bustling house, you could always have cousins / extended family over if you have any, or lots of your DC friends if not. That way you can get them to leave too, when you are tired of the noise!

Wanderingoff · 23/12/2022 00:56

@PurpleButterflyWings not to derail - but before modern contraception a woman having a baby at 50 was far from unheard of.

if it was me and I had the embryos I’d get them implanted. 45 is not too old.

melcalfe · 23/12/2022 00:46

justgettingthroughtheday · 23/12/2022 00:33

As someone who now has zero chance of having any children. I do feel sad seeing anyone with small children now. Bastard cancer!

Sorry to hear that Flowers would be hard. Hope you have nieces or nephews. A lady I knew didn't have kids but she had two gorgeous spaniels, they were literally her babies and filled her life with so much love.
I know it's not the same.
X

melcalfe · 23/12/2022 00:38

We have one but we can afford a few more. Every time I think I want more kids, I give my nanny a day off and I get bloody exhausted with a very active baby. I'm glad when she comes back and I'm firmly back into 'nope, I'm done' camp.

The thread of exhausted parents of adult children helped me. It shows children are a constant hard work even when they grow up, so I am going to reserve my energy for the one I already have.

Does your DD have lots of friends? I have a sister (2 years apart) but we never played together, we preferred our own friends instead.

FoodieToo · 23/12/2022 00:35

We have 5 and feel very lucky . It was mad when they were small. Now they are age 19 down to 12 .
They are such fun and there is nothing more I love than us all being together. Eldest is now at university ( local , in Dublin ) and am so grateful as couldn't bear her to leave yet !!!
I grew up in a pretty dysfunctional family so feel especially thankful for every day with my gang !

justgettingthroughtheday · 23/12/2022 00:33

As someone who now has zero chance of having any children. I do feel sad seeing anyone with small children now. Bastard cancer!

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/12/2022 00:27

I am sorry you feel this way @Noonesingsthischristmassong and yes, and I don't mean to sound rude but you did ask.... 44 is too old to try for another baby - you'll be 45 when you have the baby. Too old by far IMO.

Also, you seem to have some romanticised idea of this big lovely cuddly family like you get in Disney movies. Real life is not like that for many. My mom's 2 sisters (my maternal aunts) have 7 kids between them, (one 4, one 3.) All 7 are my cousins.

In the one lot with 4 siblings, the 2 don't speak to the other 2. And the other lot with 3 siblings; all 3 don't speak, and haven't for some 15 years. Totally separate lives, and all the children of those 3 siblings (8 in all) don't know their cousins. In addition, my 2 aunts fell out 3 or 4 years ago and have not spoken since.

I also know about half a dozen families with 5 to 8 siblings. Not ONE family has all the siblings who get on. Many are estranged and have split into little factions of 2 and 3. Some of the families have one member who is estranged, and has been pushed out of the family for some reason or other.

I have a brother, who I have always got on with OK, but frankly I never see him. He moved away some 12 years ago to the other side of the world, and I have seen him twice (in 2012 and 2014.) I don't even know my 2 nephews. (They're 11, and 9 now.) Same story with my DH. One brother, never been best mates but never enemies either. Just drifted apart... Hasn't seen him for 4 years. (He lives 50 miles from us.)

Real life is not like in the movies, or like Corrie and Eastenders where everyone lives closeby and is always there for one another.

I feel like it WAS like that some 40+ years ago, for me anyway. 7 cousins, a brother, large extended family, 4 grandparents, many friends... all within walking distance, big Christmases, beach holidays with 10 of us in 2 cars, and lovely long hot summers with 15 or so kids from the neighbourhood.... Playing footie, netball, hopscotch, and hide and seek, and cycling for miles, playing in the woods, and staying out from 9am til 9pm some days in the holidays and at weekends. Not like that now. Hasn't been for a LONG time.

I blame women being expected to go out to work, and have a career whilst also having a family, and the incredibly shit pay most people have now... (along with the high cost of living.) Community Spirit has gone, mums HAVE to work as well as dads to make ends meet, many couples don't stay together anymore, and families are fractured, and live at different ends of the country (and even different ends of the world.)

The life I knew pre mid 1980s has long gone......... And as I say, the big Disney family you speak of, really does not exist. Well, there probably are a handful, but probably less than 1% of families.

My 2 DC get on well (both mid to late 20s,) but even THEY moved away and live 15-20 miles from me and DH and about 10 miles from each other. And they only see each other maybe once a month. Me and DH see them together (all 4 of us,) maybe 7 or 8 times a year. So again, they didn't stay in the community. Their careers took them away. They live in urban areas now. Me and DH prefer the little rural village we live in.

Choccolatte · 23/12/2022 00:27

I have 4, sort of accidentally. It's wonderful BUT so expensive especially when they are older. And very hard to give them the attention that is expected nowadays.

Wait2see2 · 23/12/2022 00:24

I'm in the same situation now OP. I always wanted 4 kids as I felt that growing up with only 1 sibling was so dull but it never happened and now I have just one DD who is 4 and I feel desperately sad for her and wish I could go back in time and focus on family rather than career. I am 41 now and trying to have another but at the same time I feel I am passed the baby stage and don't really want to go through it all again and value my freedom and space. I think about this every day and it makes me so sad.

MsRosley · 23/12/2022 00:21

cestlavielife · 22/12/2022 23:02

Envy wont help anyone.
Sorry for your losses.
You dont know if trying earlier. Would have resulted in more children or not.
But you have a real live child
What does your daughter need from you?
Positivity and love.
Regardless of siblings or not.
Try some therapy in the new year.
Celebrate your lovely family

Is this supposed to be poetry?

RambamThankyouMam · 23/12/2022 00:18

I pity any schmuck who has more than two. Absolute nightmare.

InvincibleInvisibility · 23/12/2022 00:16

I have 2. I would love to have 3 or 4 BUT that would mean being a different person.

I just couldn't cope with more pregnancies physically. And mentally/emotionally I am drained with the 2 I have. But they are ND (and I expect I am too).

As it is, I throw myself into being the best mum I can and we have a lot of fun. I also do everything in my power to support them getting the help they need.

I would love to have given them more siblings but I have to acknowledge that it would have broken me. But I still wish I had been mentally able to have more..

Weatherwax13 · 23/12/2022 00:11

I had five OP. It was pretty mental but it was actually in their teens/20s that the real stress (and ultimately a tragedy) occurred. As children it was freaking busy and chaotic but I was very young and tough. I'd have hated to go through what we have in the last few years if I were in my 60s now.
My DDs have each stuck at 1 DC so far and they find they have the best of both worlds. My close friend also has an "only". Her sister had 7. Her sister's life is one crisis after another whereas my friend has a lovely relationship with her 25 yr old DS. And he had the benefit of her being able to afford everything he needed plus a large pot of savings she gave him when he left hone.
I love my children but if I had my time again, knowing what i do now, I'd have stuck at one. Or maybe not had any.
We all wonder about what we don't have but you have to make peace with it or wondering turns to obsessing. Enjoy your lovely DC.

JadeandGreen · 23/12/2022 00:09

Dacadactyl · 22/12/2022 23:12

Where are you getting that from, that 50 year old women make good parents to newborns? 😂

Why wouldn't they?

SNWannabe · 23/12/2022 00:09

Sorry, I voted YABU as it doesn’t sound like you’d have coped well with 4 or more children… having had my four children over a 15 year period, I chose to sacrifice a career until my 40s and my younger children have only experienced two foreign holidays in ten years due to no spare money.
I second guess myself all the time and never feel I can please everyone at the same time. So I can be a good mum to one or two at a time… but rarely all four children. Yes life can be fun at times and certainly busy… four times the expense, four times the hobbies and interests to ferry kids to, four times the angst and four times the heartache.
i always knew I wanted children and have been so very blessed to have overcome the odds to have them and lucky to not have experienced any losses so I do feel incredibly grateful and fortunate. But I think your life sounds pretty damn great too… a career and travel and a much- wanted child to dote on who will want for nothing. Im sorry for your losses though. Even if your family is smaller it is still a family full of love I’m sure.

AllTogetherAllAlone · 23/12/2022 00:07

I’m one of four. I remember arguments, ALWAYS having to share, never quite enough attention, room or money. Now one doesn’t see or talk to our parents, one lives in another country andthe other two have minimal contact with them. I can take or leave my siblings. I have one child.

Beseen22 · 23/12/2022 00:07

I feel a bit the same but think it's loss related for me. I have 2 DC, took 10 years to have them and have had a mc. I know I could stop and have the loveliest little family, I'm incredibly lucky to have my two. DH would be on board if I said let's not put ourselves through this again.

I'm absolutely terrified to try again but I can't say I'm done. Can't bring myself to chuck out the baby gear, probably going to keep myself super depressed trying and failing to conceive. Wonder if I'll ever feel like our family is complete because there's always one missing.

bumblybeehive · 23/12/2022 00:05

I'm the same OP. Have one dc and am almost 37 but I have no family myself and dh family aren't interested at all.

Wish everyday I could have another but don't even own a house and been saving forever and would quite like to head towards being financially stable vs broke with more dc. Have many friends with 3+ dc and love the noise at theirs vs our very quiet home. Sigh. I remind myself I am happy to have at least one having had losses too. Sorry for your losses also.

RewildingAmbridge · 23/12/2022 00:04

@Noonesingsthischristmassong the noise, the mess, the bickering, the ability to trash a room in seconds, the sheer relentless chaos , and triple the amount of Lego to tread on 😂

PyongyangKipperbang · 23/12/2022 00:00

Are you wishing you had a big family or wishing that you were a different kind of person who could have coped with a big family?

I have 6 and I have to say....it wasnt easy. It wasnt all big hugs and siblings loving each other and instaworthy moments in patching pj's, it still isnt with the eldest at 32 and the youngest at 11. Bad days (for me) outweighed the good over the years. I wouldnt change it for the world but a fantasy always ends well, real life....not so much.

Yes they will have each other but also........they will have each other. You know? Just read MN to see how many siblings fall out over the years.

Accepting who and how you are can be the biggest gift you can give to yourself. As someone who also had a lot of losses over the years, I am sorry xx

BabyFour2023 · 22/12/2022 23:59

Ivyonafence · 22/12/2022 23:52

@BabyFour2023

I was just providing some context as your situation doesn't apply to everyone. You are saying that 3/4 children can be calm and doable, by describing how it worked in your large childhood home and your (presumably large enough) current home.

If there is a lot of room, and ample resources then a lot of the difficult aspects of a large family won't touch you.

Sorry, I get it now! Yes absolutely agree with you. It would be completely different trying to raise 4 in a small 2 bed without a doubt. We are lucky with space, as I was growing up.

Ginger1982 · 22/12/2022 23:59

Noonesingsthischristmassong · 22/12/2022 23:16

Is two the magic number?

There is no magic number. 2 is just trotted out by the media to try and project an image of what they consider to be the perfect life. So many folk buy into it too.

ridemesideway · 22/12/2022 23:58

DH Is one of four. All perfectly spaced two years apart in age.
Two live abroad. None of them are close as adults.
The bustling house doesn’t last for long.

antelopevalley · 22/12/2022 23:57

Byfleet · 22/12/2022 23:26

@Dacadactyl I don’t understand why you think a 50 year old parenting a new born is funny. In my 50s I was far fitter than in my 30s and 40s because I took better care of myself, stopped binge drinking etc. I am in my 60s now and perfectly fit enough to take care of a baby. There is no reason at all why someone in their 50s would find this difficult. Most people don’t choose to do it but that doesn’t mean it’s not possible.

Parenting a newborn is fine. But parenting a teenager in your seventies is very different.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 22/12/2022 23:55

I'm jealous of emotionally healthy families......that's what makes for a.happy family, not the size of it.