Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be envious of those with lots of children

192 replies

Noonesingsthischristmassong · 22/12/2022 22:51

I’m talking four children really, or more if you’re very wealthy.
I’ve always loved kids but was never massively maternal. Dh and I then started trying for kids and it took 9 years and lots of losses. We now have an amazing Dd and frozen embryos, but I’m 44 so thinking it’s too late now anyway.
I adore Dd but am a person who likes/needs space and don’t get it and have found motherhood hard at times..my head says I’d be crazy to want lots of kids as it’s hard work and life is more stressful etc. But I often look at those with four or so kids and think how nice it would be, you’d never be lonely, a bustling, full house, four children with their different personalities, four times feeling that love of having a child. All your children around you in your old age.
I travelled lots when younger and had a great career, but sometimes wonder how different life would have been if I’d just put more importance on family and tried to conceive younger and maybe have a big family full of love.

OP posts:
BabyFour2023 · 23/12/2022 15:39

Fleabigg · 23/12/2022 15:38

Better or different? The onus is on me to be the one to play with my 5 year old and facilitate the development of her peer relationships. She doesn’t have older siblings for me to palm her off on as my friends with 2+ freely admit they do (and as my parents did).

They clearly aren’t the better parents pp is referring to then.

Fleabigg · 23/12/2022 15:38

antelopevalley · 23/12/2022 13:20

I think different type of family structures suit different children. Some love being only children, some love busy and noisy houses. And raising more children does I think mean you have to be a better parent, which not everyone is up to.

Better or different? The onus is on me to be the one to play with my 5 year old and facilitate the development of her peer relationships. She doesn’t have older siblings for me to palm her off on as my friends with 2+ freely admit they do (and as my parents did).

ColourMeExhausted · 23/12/2022 14:28

DH is one of five. He only really gets on with two siblings and even then they're not hugely close. They all spent a lot of time in foster care. Because of this, he only wanted two DC at the most, as did I. Any more and I'd really struggle with patience and being a good and present parent. DD and DS constantly fight and the other day DD said she wanted to be an only child!

My DB and I are not close at all. I've colleagues I have better relationships with him than him.

What I'm saying is, the grass will always be greener when it comes to family size. I get your feeling of sadness, but as long as you have plenty of people in your DD's life, she'll be more than fine.

aSofaNearYou · 23/12/2022 14:04

There's a big leap between 1 and 4+

Why not be envious of people that have 2? That sounds like it would suit someone that also values space better. It's what I've gone for for that reason!

Kentlassie · 23/12/2022 13:57

I have 3. I’ve only realised recently how important the busy house is to me, because I was very lonely as a child. Chaos, noise, fun, yes. Never ending noise and no time on my own (ever), yes again.

SomeoneNamedGabriella · 23/12/2022 13:29

antelopevalley · 22/12/2022 23:57

Parenting a newborn is fine. But parenting a teenager in your seventies is very different.

This. Also, Its been shown that people who give birth at 35 or older have much higher chances of their baby being born unhealthy. Getting kids at 50 Is not a great idea.

antelopevalley · 23/12/2022 13:20

I think different type of family structures suit different children. Some love being only children, some love busy and noisy houses. And raising more children does I think mean you have to be a better parent, which not everyone is up to.

Kfjsjdbd · 23/12/2022 12:15

I’m one of four. My parents didn’t have capacity to support all of us, even though they were very very wealthy. Four children was too much for them. As a result we aren’t close at all. I have some resentment to them for having too many kids that they could cope with.

gogohmm · 23/12/2022 11:38

@Delectable

Older parents don't mean better parents!

My kids had friends with older parents (esp the dads) who were intolerant, grumpy and generally distant, farming out child rearing to others eg one family had an au pair despite the mum being a sahm and the dad was semi retired so they could go out all the time without their dd, the dd wasn't allowed in the living room or dining room either only her playroom, bedroom (both beautifully decorated of course) and ate with the au pair in the kitchen, poor kid

RedHelenB · 23/12/2022 11:32

Noonesingsthischristmassong · 22/12/2022 22:52

It also hurts my heart to think of Dd just with us, no siblings,,

Has she got cousins? Every day I'm thankful for my 3 dc, I wouldn't change a thing so I do sympathise with you for wanting a bigger family.
But she'll be loved and cherished amd at the end of the day that's all that really matters for any child

Blueskies3 · 23/12/2022 11:27

I understand why you want more.

For a while I wanted more and I have two.

But I am an only child and I loved it, so that made me question why I wanted more. I loved having lots of time with my parents and grandparents. I could play with cousins, neighbours and friends but then go home to my nice life! I didn't want what they had. So you could build that more for your daughter if needed, park playdates and so on. But she might be super happy with the way things are. My parents suffered secondary infertility and I remember Mum wanting another badly, but I couldn't understand when I loved what we had. She came to terms with it in time.

I have stopped at two because we can't stretch our emotional and financial resources any further. I owe it to our current children to have the bets mental health that I can have.

My friend from school has one. They are the loveliest family.

You do what is right for you, if you want to try IVF again that's ok too. just know there isn't a right number at all.

As women I think we have been conditioned to think more is better.

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/12/2022 11:24

OP do you think you're depressed? You post just sounds that you are very low about life in general, and to have a real case of the grass is always greener. If you think that's the case go see your GP in the NY?

You can be lonely in a big group as well as on your own. Plenty of mothers of big families feel like a function more than a person. Having 4 kids can be great - it can also mean that people are overstretched emotionally and financially, so the kids don't get enough resources or attention. As for more than 4 kids - I think that's almost impossible to do well, regardless of how much money you have, unless there are huge age gaps.

Kids need attention and yours will get plenty. If you want to try for a second, do. 44 is older for sure, but life is never perfect - if you want to try do. But be realistic with yourself - if you think it's too much just focus on giving your kids lots of opportunities to build the skill of making friends. I think most people would agree only children aren't ideal, in the same way that sole parents aren't ideal - but it's got lots of strong points, and is a lot better than 2 kids that parents can't cope with.

Over Christmas do some thinking about what you want out of life. I suspect you have just got stuck and are fixating on something rather than thinking deeper about what the problem is. See your GP. Think about the fact that there are lots of positives to one child, and a lot of big families aren't having an easy time - it doesn't sound that it would ever have worked for you. Build up the skill of noticing when you are building yourself into a funk. CBT might be helpful. You mention having had a good career - it might be worth thinking of how you can open your life up with some meaningful work. You daughter will be FT at school soon if she isn't already, so it's a good time for that., and in mid 40s is a good time to build a second career.

NeedToChangeName · 23/12/2022 11:24

Gagaandgag · 23/12/2022 11:02

Why don’t you foster?

Fostering is very rewarding, but ENTIRELY different from raising your own children

Anotheanon · 23/12/2022 11:11

I am one of five. We really didn’t get along. Three now have nothing to do with the family. I haven’t seen them in over 20 years.

mamabear715 · 23/12/2022 11:08

I have seven, over many years & three marriages, so there's about a 20 yr gap between oldest & youngest, so they weren't all at home at the same time. Great fun! I could follow six conversations all at the same time! :-)
They are the light of my life, & all get on well. I just don't get the families who don't speak. So sad.

Scriabin · 23/12/2022 11:05

This is my daydream too - four children, lots of lovely emotionally healthy extended family, lots of money, can afford to pay for help as needed.

The reality though is the one child was right for us, I had wobbles when he was younger but now I know it was the right decision. You can only play the best hand with the cards you're dealt.

Gagaandgag · 23/12/2022 11:02

Why don’t you foster?

thecoffeewasthething · 23/12/2022 10:59

FourTeaFallOut · 23/12/2022 10:53

I wonder if people would appreciate those with more children scanning their social circle to pick out cautionary tales of those with only one and offering them up as evidence of having made the right choice?

An old friend had her 10th over lockdown, and I genuinely worry for her. (Still enmeshed in religious beliefs, etc)

I don't think it's a healthy life for any of them, having a large brood myself.

Falalalallamadahdahdahdah · 23/12/2022 10:54

I have 2 and could not manage any more than that. They have a beautiful bond and are playing upstairs together right now.

Even with two I find splitting attention hard, keeping up with school,my work, events, the school run in 2 different schools, homework, illnesses. The fighting also drives me up the wall.

That's with 2 parents and healthy children.

I often think how peaceful life would be just with one. Right on time a fight has broken out upstairs and I will now have to go and intervene

FourTeaFallOut · 23/12/2022 10:53

w0rkschmurk · 23/12/2022 10:48

Just to add, whenever I start doubting our choice to only have one, I think of a mum of 3 that I know who is completely unable to socialise on any weekday evening because she and her husband have to ferry the kids to several different activities simultaneously. They also both work full time, live in a large, new build home and regularly run out of money each month. And I'm sure they're not the only family living like this. Not my cup of tea.

I wonder if people would appreciate those with more children scanning their social circle to pick out cautionary tales of those with only one and offering them up as evidence of having made the right choice?

w0rkschmurk · 23/12/2022 10:48

Just to add, whenever I start doubting our choice to only have one, I think of a mum of 3 that I know who is completely unable to socialise on any weekday evening because she and her husband have to ferry the kids to several different activities simultaneously. They also both work full time, live in a large, new build home and regularly run out of money each month. And I'm sure they're not the only family living like this. Not my cup of tea.

Iwannabeacrocodilehunter · 23/12/2022 10:48

Damn-it! I clicked YANBU by accident.

I have one child, he’s 17 1/2 and he’s actually a really good kid. He can argue and he can be very entitled at times, which drives me nuts, but he’s never gotten into real trouble, so I’m incredibly proud of him.

Even though I love him to bits! I am starting to get incredibly excited at the prospect of him starting work/uni; going off to live with a partner or friends and being an independent adult. It doesn’t seem too far away….and then I can enjoy my own independence pahahaha!!!

I can have cheaper holidays! The food in my kitchen will last so much longer! There wasn’t be anyone setting the alarms off at 3am because they’ve decided to make (and burn) toast!

I’ll be FREEEEEEEEEEEEEE (crazy laughter)
and I can’t believe anyone would want more kids to spoil that feeling.

Just wanted to reiterate that I do love my son, very, very much….but teenagers…they can be mean and selfish! Roll on adulthood 😁

BertieBotts · 23/12/2022 10:44

I have 3 but I had a big gap between DC1 and DC2, so I have been there desperately wishing he had a sibling. It was worth it for me, but I am younger.

w0rkschmurk · 23/12/2022 10:41

I can understand where you're coming from. I never thought we'd only have one, but I've found it so difficult that I know the best decision for my mental and physical health is not to have any more. I'd never realised before just how much I value independence, time alone and SLEEP. I developed insomnia after my child was born (and still struggle with it) and there are never enough hours in a day anymore to spend time with my husband or friends consistently. Plus I love to travel to other countries (something that is important to me and I'm not willing to sacrifice)and the price is completely unaffordable with more than one child.

I do feel pangs of sadness and longing when I see pregnant women or families with multiple children, but I know I need to think rationally about what I can realistically cope with. Hang in there x

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 23/12/2022 10:32

I have 4 op. And all young aged 3 to 9. Yes it is lovely and there are times when it's funking stressful! It will get easier as they get older. But by the time my youngest is in secondary school I would have spent 19 years raising children. We don't have any help and dh works nearly 7 days a week and I do all his admin.

It's not an easy life at all. I think your life sounds ideal and it really is Rose tinted glasses.

I'm sure it will be better when my kids are older but larger families do come with sacrifices. I haven't been out socially in 9 years as I don't have child care and now we have 4 I don't know anyone who would want to look after 4 kids. Don't blame them. Appointments are a nightmare to navigate. Especially when covid was rife because I couldn't take any of the others with me to any Appointments. So I didn't go. Now I have some issues that are harder to resolve because they had to wait.

It's difficult to go to all their activities, performances etc

Take heart op I think 1 or 2 is a good number