Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be envious of those with lots of children

192 replies

Noonesingsthischristmassong · 22/12/2022 22:51

I’m talking four children really, or more if you’re very wealthy.
I’ve always loved kids but was never massively maternal. Dh and I then started trying for kids and it took 9 years and lots of losses. We now have an amazing Dd and frozen embryos, but I’m 44 so thinking it’s too late now anyway.
I adore Dd but am a person who likes/needs space and don’t get it and have found motherhood hard at times..my head says I’d be crazy to want lots of kids as it’s hard work and life is more stressful etc. But I often look at those with four or so kids and think how nice it would be, you’d never be lonely, a bustling, full house, four children with their different personalities, four times feeling that love of having a child. All your children around you in your old age.
I travelled lots when younger and had a great career, but sometimes wonder how different life would have been if I’d just put more importance on family and tried to conceive younger and maybe have a big family full of love.

OP posts:
ICanBoogieWoogie · 23/12/2022 19:52

We have one DS, now 16.

I’ve had pangs of guilt that he has no siblings, but I have no regrets. He’s ND and secondary school has been hell, the thought of going through what we have with multiple DC, I don’t think I could have coped. He’s needed lots of support, his MH has also suffered.

I have 2 siblings, enjoy having them in my life, although would love to see them more, but growing up wasn’t great, lots of arguments etc

YANBU for feeling the way you do, OP but don’t let it eat away at you. Focus on what you have, rather than regretting what you don’t have.

kikisparks · 23/12/2022 19:13

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/12/2022 11:24

OP do you think you're depressed? You post just sounds that you are very low about life in general, and to have a real case of the grass is always greener. If you think that's the case go see your GP in the NY?

You can be lonely in a big group as well as on your own. Plenty of mothers of big families feel like a function more than a person. Having 4 kids can be great - it can also mean that people are overstretched emotionally and financially, so the kids don't get enough resources or attention. As for more than 4 kids - I think that's almost impossible to do well, regardless of how much money you have, unless there are huge age gaps.

Kids need attention and yours will get plenty. If you want to try for a second, do. 44 is older for sure, but life is never perfect - if you want to try do. But be realistic with yourself - if you think it's too much just focus on giving your kids lots of opportunities to build the skill of making friends. I think most people would agree only children aren't ideal, in the same way that sole parents aren't ideal - but it's got lots of strong points, and is a lot better than 2 kids that parents can't cope with.

Over Christmas do some thinking about what you want out of life. I suspect you have just got stuck and are fixating on something rather than thinking deeper about what the problem is. See your GP. Think about the fact that there are lots of positives to one child, and a lot of big families aren't having an easy time - it doesn't sound that it would ever have worked for you. Build up the skill of noticing when you are building yourself into a funk. CBT might be helpful. You mention having had a good career - it might be worth thinking of how you can open your life up with some meaningful work. You daughter will be FT at school soon if she isn't already, so it's a good time for that., and in mid 40s is a good time to build a second career.

“I think most people would agree only children aren't ideal”

What? There’s nothing wrong with having a single child, in fact for many families it is very much ideal! I think most people would agree that dysfunctional, unhappy families aren’t ideal, but family size doesn’t come into it.

BabyFour2023 · 23/12/2022 18:10

Fleabigg · 23/12/2022 16:14

But the assertion I responded to was you have to be a better parent to raise 4 children. The implication being parents of 4 children are better than parents of 1. How else are you supposed to read that statement? I’m a cracking parent to my 1 child. The reason I only have 1 child is not because I’m a lesser parent. I might have been an excellent parent to 4. I don’t have 2 dining tables though, so…

Yeah deffo a shit mum then aren’t ya 🙄 I was agreeing with you til you turned petty.

SpicyFoodRocks · 23/12/2022 17:45

I wouldn’t want to do the teen years with more than one or two. Being emotionally there for them and supporting them through the highs and lows of teen/young adult life, exams and university applications would be a stretch if I had more than two. My brain wouldn’t cope with the worry!

Lentilweaver · 23/12/2022 17:13

DNBU · 23/12/2022 17:04

We have one, by choice - partly because of health concerns, partly because in reality we would struggle financially with more then one, partly because we’re able to comfortably balance our social lives, careers, passions, hobbies, family time and relationship. I know the last point sounds selfish and maybe it is.

I daydream about living in a small commune/small village of made up of our family/friends! So I definitely understand the large family/chaotic household element.

Nope not selfish at all. Just got back from a solo European trip. With any more DC I wouldn't be able to do that. I am 50 now and plan to spend the next 25 yrs focusing mostly on myself, selfish or not.Of course DC still need support. But they dont need me to be physically present.

DNBU · 23/12/2022 17:04

We have one, by choice - partly because of health concerns, partly because in reality we would struggle financially with more then one, partly because we’re able to comfortably balance our social lives, careers, passions, hobbies, family time and relationship. I know the last point sounds selfish and maybe it is.

I daydream about living in a small commune/small village of made up of our family/friends! So I definitely understand the large family/chaotic household element.

excelledyourself · 23/12/2022 17:01

I couldn't think of much worse. Apart from having 5, I suppose.

My son is the absolute apple of my eye and was a pretty easy kid to raise, but the worry of the teen years is not something I could put myself through multiple times.

neverbeenskiing · 23/12/2022 16:52

I think you are envious of something you probably would find very difficult in reality.

This is often the way envy works, I think. My best friend is childfree and single, and I sometimes envy the peace, solitude and freedom she has but in reality I would probably find it very lonely.

OP, I personally found going from one to two DC incredibly challenging. Like you, I am someone who craves time alone and it becomes much harder to get this with any regularity once you have a second child. Youngest is now 4 and I feel like I'm starting to see light at the end of the tunnel, but some days are still very hard. From what you've said about your experience of motherhood so far, I think starting again at 45 would be taking a big gamble with your mental wellbeing, even if you were lucky enough to have no complications and a healthy DC.

Justwantsomepeaceforchristmas · 23/12/2022 16:48

Get an@Wanderingoff Definitely a touch of protesting too much..seems personal, I mean, who minds when other women have children 🤷🏻‍♀️

Wanderingoff · 23/12/2022 16:40

@PurpleButterflyWings i often find that people
who say they have made ideal life choices very rarely actually feel thst they have and it is often driven by a fear that they have not….

malificent7 · 23/12/2022 16:40

Each to their own but the planet does not need more humans.

Wanderingoff · 23/12/2022 16:38

@PurpleButterflyWings i didn’t say it was common. I said it was not unheard of. Which it’s not. It is possible - but not likely - to become pregnant naturally late 40s into 50.

you do sound a tad narrow minded yourself tbh

Justwantsomepeaceforchristmas · 23/12/2022 16:32

@PurpleButterflyWings How awful
to say all the things you’ve said for the poor women who weren’t able to have children earlier, for whatever reason.
Good for you that you could have them young and planned for that, not everyone has that privilege, your posts are massively insensitive

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/12/2022 16:27

Wanderingoff · 23/12/2022 00:56

@PurpleButterflyWings not to derail - but before modern contraception a woman having a baby at 50 was far from unheard of.

if it was me and I had the embryos I’d get them implanted. 45 is not too old.

You're deluded. It WAS rare to have a baby at 50 all those years ago, (before modern contraception,) and it still is. It has never been 'common' for women to have a baby at 50.. not naturally. All the women who had a baby at 50 were very likely raising their grandchild. I know a number of women (pre 1980s) who suddenly had a baby at 47-52 years old, and everyone knew it was their daughter's baby. Yeah, maybe a small handful of women had a baby (naturally) at 42-44-ish, but to suggest it was common to have a baby at 50 before contraception, well, that's just ridiculous.

I stand by what I said, 45 is too old to have a baby. It just is. For soooo many reasons. And I don't care how many posters pop on here to claim they/their mother/their nan/their friend/their colleague/LOADS of people in their 'social circle' had 2 or 3 babies after 40, (and at least one after 45/46,) in REAL-LIFE this is quite rare.

And people can jog on with the 'it's a class thing' bollox, I have upper, middle, and working class people in my 'social circle, (because I am not so narrow minded that I only speak to/hang around with people of my own class,) and not a single one has had a baby past 45. Two women I know had a baby at 41 and 42, but the rest of the people I know had babies before 40. And that is across several different 'classes.'

MarshaBradyo · 23/12/2022 16:24

RambamThankyouMam · 23/12/2022 00:18

I pity any schmuck who has more than two. Absolute nightmare.

I have three but this made me laugh

Huge families are not for me - when people say on here they have eight or you see it on Instagram and it’s loads. Too much but generally they get well done etc

Favouritefruits · 23/12/2022 16:23

I’d love more children, I’ve just got two but we just couldn’t afford more with driving lessons, house deposits, university it seems unattainable.

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/12/2022 16:23

@antelopevalley

Parenting a newborn is fine. But parenting a teenager in your seventies is very different.

Well, she would be more like mid 60s, but I do agree with your sentiment. I am in my mid 50s, and couldn't think of anything worse than having young, school age kids around now! (And teenagers in my mid 60s!!) Shock

I loved having mine around for the 18-19 years they lived at home, (they're only a year apart in age, mid 20s now,) but having your total freedom back, and having NO responsibility for children by your mid to late 40s, is ideal IMO. If I could go back 30 years I wouldn't change a thing, and I have loved every minute of my kids and raising them, but no WAY would I have started again in my late 40s/early 50s. LOL fuck that!

@SomeoneNamedGabriella

Also, Its been shown that people who give birth at 35 or older have much higher chances of their baby being born unhealthy. Getting kids at 50 Is not a great idea.

100% this. Incredibly unfair on the child too. They will very likely be a carer by their mid 20s, or an orphan. And please spare me the 'my auntie Fluff is 97 and she runs a marathon a day, and works 77 hours a week, and could run rings around women a third of her age' trope, because it's a fact that for the vast majority of people, their health will start to take a fairly rapid nosedive when they hit their early 70s. (For some it will be earlier.)

Allaboutthecough · 23/12/2022 16:21

I am one of 4 and feel extremely lucky, as an adult it is so amazing to have so many people in my immediate family, especially as we all get on brilliantly and hang out a lot.

I wish I could have given this to my DC too but we're stopping at 2. I am happy that this means I can give them all the support and attention they need and be my best self. When they are ill or sleep goes awry it is hard enough. 4 would have been way more than I can chew.

But yes, like you, I'm envious of the big families who seem to be smashing it!

DisneyChops · 23/12/2022 16:21

Goodness no thanks.
It would be my worst nightmare.

One 3 year old is enough to tear my hair out.

PurpleButterflyWings · 23/12/2022 16:18

gogohmm · 23/12/2022 11:38

@Delectable

Older parents don't mean better parents!

My kids had friends with older parents (esp the dads) who were intolerant, grumpy and generally distant, farming out child rearing to others eg one family had an au pair despite the mum being a sahm and the dad was semi retired so they could go out all the time without their dd, the dd wasn't allowed in the living room or dining room either only her playroom, bedroom (both beautifully decorated of course) and ate with the au pair in the kitchen, poor kid

This. ^ The very idea that older parents make better parents is offensive and rude and ageist. (And wrong.) Age makes fuck-all difference, you're either a good parent or you're not.

Fleabigg · 23/12/2022 16:14

BabyFour2023 · 23/12/2022 15:53

In an ideal world, everyone would be a good parent. We all know it’s far from true. Thankfully many women, including ones on this threads, have said they stopped at 1/2 because they know they couldn’t give more. I think that’s amazing and to be admired. I think you’d find the children of parents like the ones you mention are the ones who didn’t have a great experience of growing up in a big family, again, like the ones on this thread. There are equally many only children and children who have 1 sibling who didn’t have good childhoods.
Maybe PP should’ve said “to have happy children, you need to be a better parent”

But the assertion I responded to was you have to be a better parent to raise 4 children. The implication being parents of 4 children are better than parents of 1. How else are you supposed to read that statement? I’m a cracking parent to my 1 child. The reason I only have 1 child is not because I’m a lesser parent. I might have been an excellent parent to 4. I don’t have 2 dining tables though, so…

Chikapu · 23/12/2022 15:59

Sounds like hell on earth to me.

Soozikinzii · 23/12/2022 15:58

I have 5 DSs and 1 SS who we had every weekend so 7 or 8 in the household all the time . It was a lovely time when they were all little but now they're grown up I constantly feel that we can't help them get on the housing laddër and with other finances because everything has to be shared by 6 . I notice those with smaller families eventually double in number if they get on with their kids partners .We always seem the kind of second fiddle family maybe because we're pread thinner? If we have a family occasion it's very crowded so you don't actually get much time for a nice chat with each of my DSs. Obviously I wouldn't be without one of my lovely DSs but I though that might help you xx

BabyFour2023 · 23/12/2022 15:53

Fleabigg · 23/12/2022 15:47

So you don’t “have to” be a better parent then?

In an ideal world, everyone would be a good parent. We all know it’s far from true. Thankfully many women, including ones on this threads, have said they stopped at 1/2 because they know they couldn’t give more. I think that’s amazing and to be admired. I think you’d find the children of parents like the ones you mention are the ones who didn’t have a great experience of growing up in a big family, again, like the ones on this thread. There are equally many only children and children who have 1 sibling who didn’t have good childhoods.
Maybe PP should’ve said “to have happy children, you need to be a better parent”

Fleabigg · 23/12/2022 15:47

BabyFour2023 · 23/12/2022 15:39

They clearly aren’t the better parents pp is referring to then.

So you don’t “have to” be a better parent then?