Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
Kendodd · 22/12/2022 16:06

CinnamonJellyBeans · 22/12/2022 16:03

It's not crap. It's entitled people, wilfully abusing the gift of good health, knowing they can go to hospital for gastric bypasses, new knees and medication. taking resources just because they can, leaving no money, equipment, beds or staffing for the people who cannot avoid ill-health through sheer bad luck or genetics.

If there was no NHS to pick up the bill, we'd all adopt a preventative attitude to our own health.

Yeah, poor people in America are all slim and healthy.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 22/12/2022 16:03

IDontWantToBeAPie · 22/12/2022 15:23

The idea of the deserving and undeserving unwell is Puritanism crap spouted by the church in the Victorian era.

If you're sick you're sick.

It's not crap. It's entitled people, wilfully abusing the gift of good health, knowing they can go to hospital for gastric bypasses, new knees and medication. taking resources just because they can, leaving no money, equipment, beds or staffing for the people who cannot avoid ill-health through sheer bad luck or genetics.

If there was no NHS to pick up the bill, we'd all adopt a preventative attitude to our own health.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 15:59

@Findwen No, it wouldn't work: people would cheat by getting allotments and growing their own leafy greens!

midgetastic · 22/12/2022 15:59

The unhealthy people cost a lot more than the healthy ones as very few healthy people spend 2 years never mind 30 in care!

Most people -90%- die without needing care

If we could get rid of type 2 diabetes that would help a lot

I still think we should legalise and tax drugs
Prohibition is failing , the war on drugs is failing , we might as well get the tax revenue

Kendodd · 22/12/2022 15:53

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 15:43

@CinnamonJellyBeans I believe the main way we can ease the burden is by healthy people looking after our bodies as best we can

At 64 I was on no medication at all, took no drugs, didn't smoke, drank moderately and took exercise. A routine checkup led to me being diagnosed with blood cancer and the rest of my life on chemo drugs. Any suggestion about how I could have stopped my bone marrow DNA mutating with my lifestyle?

You know what? shit happens. And - putting this as politely as I can - piss off with your That way the NHS could spend its time and energy on the deserving people who have become unwell or were born unwell through no fault of their own - not having this was why the welfare state was set up in the first place.

Something tells me you'd just love workhouses coming back.

I do always wonder if the 'healthy lifestyle' thing even adds up as a financial saving anyway.
Person A - Overweight, smokes, drinks, no exercise, on diabetes medication, dies at 60 because of lifestyle.
Person B - Slim, fit, healthy lifestyle, lives to 95, after spending 30 years in retirement and five years in a care home.

Findwen · 22/12/2022 15:52

Green leafy veg should be £30 a bag. Huge cakes should be 10p.

Average age of death drops to 45, pensions, elderly social care, expensive end of life drugs are essentially gone. NHS saved.

QueueEtwo · 22/12/2022 15:52

Didn't Johnson increase NIC to help fund the NHS initially & Social Care in the long-term but Truss put it back down again?

Can't remember wether Sunsk has put it back up or not - I'm passed following the incompetence of our current Govt! 🙄

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 22/12/2022 15:51

No. The same level of waste and inefficiency would still be there because nobody is brave enough to strip it right back and rebuild.

Findwen · 22/12/2022 15:50

People who live healthy lives are a horrible drain on the NHS and social care. They live to 90 taking an ever increasing cocktail of absurdly expensive drugs, have an army of carers and draw their pensions for decades. End of life care is where all the money goes.

Really fat people die of a heart attack in their 50s, few drugs, no carers, no pension drawn.

Huge tax of fruit and veg needed, subsidise fat and sugar to make them essentially free.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 15:50

At 64 I was on no medication at all, took no drugs, didn't smoke, drank moderately and took exercise. A routine checkup led to me being diagnosed with blood cancer and the rest of my life on chemo drugs. Any suggestion about how I could have stopped my bone marrow DNA mutating with my lifestyle?
The NHS should treat everyone that requires professional healthcare and that certainly includes you.

The point is that people looked after themselves better, reduced alcohol consumption, cooked healthily most days, didn't fall to temptation every evenings in front of the TV and gave 1h 4 times a week to exercise, their chance of developing diabetes and other lifestyle conditions would reduce. We are not talking about people with health conditions that prevents them to do so, who put on weight due to medication etc...we are talking about common Jo who let themselves put in a stone every year, know they should do something about it, but opt for denial instead.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 15:46

Where did the OP go?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 15:43

@CinnamonJellyBeans I believe the main way we can ease the burden is by healthy people looking after our bodies as best we can

At 64 I was on no medication at all, took no drugs, didn't smoke, drank moderately and took exercise. A routine checkup led to me being diagnosed with blood cancer and the rest of my life on chemo drugs. Any suggestion about how I could have stopped my bone marrow DNA mutating with my lifestyle?

You know what? shit happens. And - putting this as politely as I can - piss off with your That way the NHS could spend its time and energy on the deserving people who have become unwell or were born unwell through no fault of their own - not having this was why the welfare state was set up in the first place.

Something tells me you'd just love workhouses coming back.

Annabel073 · 22/12/2022 15:36

Kendodd · 22/12/2022 11:59

Might help if richer people paid the same rate of National insurance as poorer people.

www.gov.uk/national-insurance/how-much-you-pay

They do pay the same rate. The lower rate of NI is for any earnings above the threshold only.

Cheshiresun · 22/12/2022 15:34

I would pay more tax to save the NHS - but social care is also in a critical state and affects the NHS, with "bed blocking" etc, so that needs reforming too. Except changes to that have been delayed further. Both need to be overhauled.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 15:33

The three best known HMOs in the USA are Kaiser Health in California, Health Insurance Plan of Greater NY and Puget Sound. They're not new: the NY programme started in 1947, the same year as the NHS, and they are not-for-profit corporations. The membership and their employers pay a fixed per capita or family rate but are restricted to the choice of practitioners and hospitals that are contracted to the HMO. Few exclusions and no opting out of covering people with pre-existing or chronic conditions. I don't know about restrictions for genetic conditions as when I was a member, there was little understanding of the human genome... it was the 1980s. They tend to be favoured by academic institutions affiliated to the national non-profit pension and insurance system which was created for universities, museums and the like in 1917.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 15:32

@Hereeverysaturdaynight - I like to deal with the facts.

The fact is that many Tory politicians retain links to the US medical industry.

If there had been any appetite at all for the changes you are describing, then they could have been done a decade ago. These issues are not new.

The point is you are talking about changes that would require a different set of politicians to be in charge: what makes you think that the systems you describe have a fighting chance given the way the majority of British people vote?

Would they arrive in five years, ten?

Or would the trajectory which had been set a decade ago be followed? Which is a US style system, by degrees? I feel your angst, but people do not vote for that. There are enough people who say they cannot afford more on tax or other payments: do you think most voters do anything other than vote in their own self interest?

It is not stupid to look at where you society is headed, is it? And plan accordingly

KnickerlessParsons · 22/12/2022 15:25

I'm not a politician but many have retired at 60 living until 90s even 100s. They haven't paid enough in for the scale of care needed. Every UTI , medications , every fall, dysphagia , special diets, 24/7 supervision, pressure ulcer all needs funding out of the pot

I would add that the number of staff the NHS pays pensions to is also increasing. DM, for example, was a Dr. She retired at 55 and is now 90. She's been receiving an NHS pension for longer than she ever worked for the NHS. I imagine this applies to lots of people.

And then, people are much more litigious these days. All the law suits and compensation paid comes out of the NHS budget.

MrsMurphyIWish · 22/12/2022 15:24

KnittedCardi · 22/12/2022 13:17

The majority of GP appointments are for muscle/skeletal issues. There is very little a GP can do for you. So, back to personal responsibility. Take pain killers, move, exercise, lose weight, go a physio. Going direct to a physio costs about £40, same price as seeing a GP. Perhaps if we all had our own pot of health spend, we could use it more wisely.

@KnittedCardi I have had to reply to this as I’ve always had
back pain but ignored it with painkillers. At aged 33 I was admitted to hospital as after a particularly acute pain, I couldn’t walk. Lo and behold, have scoliosis and degenerative spinal disease. I will now be a strain on the NHS. If at 10 when I first cried in pain I was taken seriously, wouldn’t be facing life in a wheelchair.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 22/12/2022 15:23

CinnamonJellyBeans · 22/12/2022 12:07

I don't think it's lack of money that's killing the NHS.

The NHS can no longer cope with giving free care to people, as the care we expect and can be provided has changed so much: Elderly care, as we no longer look after our elderly parents and people live an extra decade, but that final decade is spent in poor health. Lots of lifestyle illnesses due to smoking, alcohol and sedentary lifestyles Research and technology has resulted in treatment for diseases that would have killed us back in the day, like type 1 diabetes, kidney disease and cancer.

I believe the main way we can ease the burden is by healthy people looking after our bodies as best we can and not getting complacent about the fact that abusing the gift of health will automatically get us new knees, livers, cancer treatments, metformin, BP tablets, mobility scooters, gastric bypasses. We take the NHS for granted. Everyone should receive a virtual bill when they leave, that lets them know how much their treatment would have cost if they had paid.

That way the NHS could spend its time and energy on the deserving people who have become unwell or were born unwell through no fault of their own.

The idea of the deserving and undeserving unwell is Puritanism crap spouted by the church in the Victorian era.

If you're sick you're sick.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 22/12/2022 15:22

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:07

I also think we need to start looking at what, realistically the NHS can and can't do. There would have to be some unpopular choices but should things like fertility treatment, gender realignment, even maybe sporting injuries, be dealt with by the NHS? Perfect world, of course they should, but when resources will always be insufficient to do everything?

Why would sporting injuries not be covered? What happens when someone who isn't well off plays a game of football and breaks their ankle? You'd just leave them in the road?

Weird.

lljkk · 22/12/2022 15:18

We didn't fix the roof while the sun shined.

Or in this case, the escape valve which is actually the foundations of a nationalised health service: Social Care. Bed-blocking was recognised as major problem in 1980s, known to be getting worse in 1990s. WTF has been done about it?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 15:18

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 14:42

I'm not a politician but many have retired at 60 living until 90s even 100s. They haven't paid enough in for the scale of care needed. Every UTI , medications , every fall, dysphagia , special diets, 24/7 supervision, pressure ulcer all needs funding out of the pot.

So at what level of income would you start levying NI on pensions?

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 15:16

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 14:08

@Hereeverysaturdaynight - it is extremely expensive in the UK and the US.

Ten years ago, 44000 spent in London. Insurance paid.

Please tell my colleagues in the US private medicine is cheap. They will laugh at you.

I'm not sure whether you're an idiot or deliberately attempting to misconstrue what I stated. The US system is not something to be desired. The NHS is even less desirable. Other countries, European countries, have far superior health systems to the NHS.

Why can't you even deign to look at them?

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 15:16

But that would require the general public having the self-awareness to recognise their obesity and the determination to correct it
Indeed, much better to blame the proportionally very few executives for the fall out of the NHS!

The facts are there, clear and real but let's keep talking about the waste of pencils. Honestly, it's utterly pathetic. If people started to take even a once of responsibility, the NHS would be much healthier but instead, people continue to ignore the obvious and blame anything and anyone else instead! The NHS is only going to collapse as a result. It's the public's fault!

KnickerlessParsons · 22/12/2022 15:14

£1 how often?
I'd guess at about 30m people in U.K. paying tax. So a monthly £1 would bring in £360m pa. Nowhere nearly enough.