Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
helford · 22/12/2022 18:08

@IntentionalError The average funding for the NHS has been approx 2% less p.a. for decades and thats why it has old buildings & less staff and equipment.

What Govt s do is throw money at it on short term firefighting schemes, no long term planning, hence billions spent on agency staff because no one planned for the extra staff needed as we age and now billions more spent to get private hospitals to do nhs operations.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:02

IntentionalError · 22/12/2022 17:32

No, because it would all be wasted on bureaucracy, box-ticking non-jobs and extortionate agency fees. The NHS is NOT underfunded. It is dysfunctional, wasteful, badly run and unfit for purpose.

Agency fees are charged because the NHS can't recruit staff on existing salaries. To avoid paying agency, you have to significantly increase pay so that agency staff aren't needed!

helford · 22/12/2022 18:02

HermioneWeasley · 22/12/2022 17:44

The NHS spent £400m on diversity managers and £100k on teaching midwives about the terminology to use for trans men in their care. I don’t know how much the taxpayer funded rainbow badges cost.

I don’t trust them to spend any additional funds wisely. There needs to be a complete ban on this sort of garbage first and then much more efficient procurement

Its £40m not £400m.

and thats according to the Daily Mail, so probably £4m.

Diversity managers are quite the thing in private industry.

Do you not believe in retention and equality?

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:00

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 22/12/2022 11:56

No I doubt it. It costs 2,5 billion to run the NHS annually.

there are 32 million adults working in the uk,. So a pound is 32 million, doesn’t touch the sides.

Not sure where you got the £2.5 billion from. The 2022-23 NHS Budget was £152.6 billion

https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/nhs-in-a-nutshell/nhs-budget

Given there are 32.2 million income taxpayers (2021-22 stats) last year, a 1% increase in the NHS Budget, evenly spread, would cost each such taxpayer £4,739 per annum.

So that works out as £1 every 2 hours or so.

If you want to simply give the NHS equivalent to inflation of 10.1%, that would
mean £1 every 12 minutes and that's BEFORE any real terms increases.

I don't think the OP seems to have even the vaguest clue about how much public services cost!

HermioneWeasley · 22/12/2022 17:44

The NHS spent £400m on diversity managers and £100k on teaching midwives about the terminology to use for trans men in their care. I don’t know how much the taxpayer funded rainbow badges cost.

I don’t trust them to spend any additional funds wisely. There needs to be a complete ban on this sort of garbage first and then much more efficient procurement

NumberTheory · 22/12/2022 17:33

As others have said, £1/person wouldn’t touch the sides. But the thing that’s cracking the NHS isn’t obesity, or too many managers, or paying £50 for a lightbulb. those things don’t help, but they aren’t that significant. The NHS’s biggest challenge is dealing with an aging population. The biggest expenditure is on over 65s. Not because they’re obese or have unrealistic expectations, or are sitting under £50 lightbulbs but because we’ve put our money into learning how to stop people dying, and it’s worked.

And we’re at the tip of the iceberg. Aging is going to continue being an issue and unless we start putting our money into keeping people more able bodied and able minded rather than just alive, we’re going to find the NHS less and less able to cope.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?
IntentionalError · 22/12/2022 17:32

No, because it would all be wasted on bureaucracy, box-ticking non-jobs and extortionate agency fees. The NHS is NOT underfunded. It is dysfunctional, wasteful, badly run and unfit for purpose.

Notanotherusername4321 · 22/12/2022 17:32

Blair's trebling of the NHS didn't cure it of it's problems

this was intended to demonstrate that throwing money at the NHS wouldn’t help, and started on the road to privatisation by the back door- PFI, “social enterprise” aka privatisation of staff groups etc…

Happygirl79 · 22/12/2022 17:29

Paying more tax while this greedy incompetent government are in power is throwing money into their pockets

helford · 22/12/2022 17:28

@user1497207191

It is not possible to blanket sweeping statements about the NHS based on your terrible experience.

I had excellent treatment in 2007 but that does not mean the NHS was excellent back then either!

Because the fact remains, we did not have the levels of disruption and awful waits 15/20 years ago, that we have had in the NHS for many years now - 3.2m waiting list in 2020 pre Covid.

Personally, i'd like to see us come up with a 25year plan, set in law, agreed by all main parties but as Lex as said, the Tories don't want a national health service, they see it as a socialist construct and much like the Republicans in the US they hate the very idea & fund it just to keep it ticking over but now even that has failed.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 17:17

@helford - the public health environment in the UK is very poor. It does encourage obesity.

There was once a Burger King in Charing Cross hospital. I hope they've got rid of it now.

I don't know why people are so credulous about government looking after them however. The Tory party hate the NHS, it's value, how it is funded, and they nibble at it all the time because they are well aware they cannot privatize it at strike. But then most British voters refuse to pay tax or support policies for social investment.

They go for a blond twit and a figure on the side of a bus and no delivery. I know my family understood the value of the NHS when it came. People are now learning what it looks like without it.

user1497207191 · 22/12/2022 17:11

helford · 22/12/2022 16:12

But it did work, we had a few 100 thousand on waiting lists, ambulances arrived within minutes and social care functions.

Then we had 10 years of Austerity, other countries had 5.

Many other countries have free at the point of use healthcare, they also had covid and ukraine, yet they have functioning healthcare.
They do not have 7.2m waiting for treatment and they attend stroke and accident patients, they do not have 20 or 30 ambulances waiting days to hand over patients at AE.

Why are we so badly affected?

Blair's trebling of the NHS didn't cure it of it's problems. Both my mother and FIL suffered awful treatment (or lack of treatment) in 2008 and 2010 respectively. Both would have lived longer had they received any modicum of decent care. Both died of cancer that could have been treated had it been treated earlier. The way the NHS ignored them repeatedly, with both languishing on wards for weeks/months waiting for life saving operations (that kept getting cancelled at last minute) and being randomly moved between hospitals for no obvious reason (presumably to reset the waiting time clock!) was absolutely criminal.

That was after FIL had suffered similar delays/incompetence a couple of years earlier with a different issue that likewise wasn't diagnosed properly for months during which time he went downhill under "supervised neglect" as a succession of doctors couldn't find the reason so ignored him hoping a different doctor the next day would have a better idea!

helford · 22/12/2022 17:08

@LexMitior Imho the nhs should not be set up to deal with things the govt of the day should be fixing.

Diet and food pricing is down to them, no or little exercise in schools, crappy school meals, low incomes, social deprivation, processed foods... how many fucking Macd's have we got? and host of similar.
They ve allowed a free for all of poor quality food.

On adult exercise, they don't encourage that either.

My point to Cinnamon was that people made poor choices pre NHS, its not a guarantee.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 16:54

Findwen · 22/12/2022 15:50

People who live healthy lives are a horrible drain on the NHS and social care. They live to 90 taking an ever increasing cocktail of absurdly expensive drugs, have an army of carers and draw their pensions for decades. End of life care is where all the money goes.

Really fat people die of a heart attack in their 50s, few drugs, no carers, no pension drawn.

Huge tax of fruit and veg needed, subsidise fat and sugar to make them essentially free.

I love it! 😆

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 16:51

Mind you we have food banks now so perhaps what's changed.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 16:48

@helford - we know why we have it but come on, it is not set up to deal with clinical obesity and the resultant diabetes. In the 20s and 30s people had problems getting enough to eat!

Hawkins001 · 22/12/2022 16:22

entropynow · 22/12/2022 12:00

Rubbish. We have low taxation compared to many countries with decent public services and welfare provision.
But what you actually mean is "I don't give a shit about my fellow citizens, just my money". Bet you use public services yourself though because that's different innit.

Actually Jamie diamon from jp Morgan and chase, recommends a balanced tax system.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 22/12/2022 16:21

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-48963215

I had no idea until I read that a few weeks back.

Xenia · 22/12/2022 16:19

No., Guessing there are about 30m tax payers that is £30m. It woudl be money down the drain. Gordon Brown put 1% on NI to fund the NHS for a generation -I remember it well. We are still paying the extra 1% and seem to have worse care then before. I would rather we could opt out of or abolish the NHS and reduce tax.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 16:17

Not sure that's correct about reducing dementia @CinnamonJellyBeans . Age is usually the primary cause. DMIL, who died last month at 93, lived pretty healthily all her life, but developed vascular dementia and was diagnosed at 87.

helford · 22/12/2022 16:17

CinnamonJellyBeans · 22/12/2022 16:03

It's not crap. It's entitled people, wilfully abusing the gift of good health, knowing they can go to hospital for gastric bypasses, new knees and medication. taking resources just because they can, leaving no money, equipment, beds or staffing for the people who cannot avoid ill-health through sheer bad luck or genetics.

If there was no NHS to pick up the bill, we'd all adopt a preventative attitude to our own health.

Ha ha Do you mean like we did pre NHS? Sick people unable to care for themselves ended up dead or in the workhouse.

My Gran would tell me that during the 20s and 30s, the beer would flow down the streets on a friday / Sat night when the men got paid & the women would also pay for it later that night.

Incredible that some people have no idea why they formed the NHS in the fist place.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 22/12/2022 16:13

...and I forgot to mention that we could reduce our risk of dementia by about 1/3 through healthier living.

helford · 22/12/2022 16:12

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 12:12

The NHS budget is 133 BILLION per year. An extra 2 billion will hardly touch the sides - it's only 1.5%!

Blair/Brown increased NIC twice "to save the nhs", but it clearly didn't work! Hence the recent further increase in NIC!

You'd need everyone to pay £5 per month extra, each year, i.e. £10 extra in year 2, and so on, ON TOP of normal increases in tax/nic on wage rises, etc.

Where does it stop? How many years do you want to pay an extra £5 per week on top of all the other extra £5 per week you've paid in previous years? After 10 years, that's £50 per week, after 20 years, it's £100 per week.

That's probably what's needed without radical reform, but is Joe Taxpayer happy to keep paying more and more and more for it?

But it did work, we had a few 100 thousand on waiting lists, ambulances arrived within minutes and social care functions.

Then we had 10 years of Austerity, other countries had 5.

Many other countries have free at the point of use healthcare, they also had covid and ukraine, yet they have functioning healthcare.
They do not have 7.2m waiting for treatment and they attend stroke and accident patients, they do not have 20 or 30 ambulances waiting days to hand over patients at AE.

Why are we so badly affected?

CinnamonJellyBeans · 22/12/2022 16:12

@Kendodd I cannot see your logic. Poor people in America qualify for medicaid, which is free.

If you are ironically implying that poor people in America are not slim and healthy? This would indeed tie into my logic that they don't need to maintain their personal health, as Medicaid will pick up the tab.

However, from a more informed perspective, I am aware that ill-health and poverty are actually causal. and there are many sociological and mental reasons for this.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 16:09

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 15:50

At 64 I was on no medication at all, took no drugs, didn't smoke, drank moderately and took exercise. A routine checkup led to me being diagnosed with blood cancer and the rest of my life on chemo drugs. Any suggestion about how I could have stopped my bone marrow DNA mutating with my lifestyle?
The NHS should treat everyone that requires professional healthcare and that certainly includes you.

The point is that people looked after themselves better, reduced alcohol consumption, cooked healthily most days, didn't fall to temptation every evenings in front of the TV and gave 1h 4 times a week to exercise, their chance of developing diabetes and other lifestyle conditions would reduce. We are not talking about people with health conditions that prevents them to do so, who put on weight due to medication etc...we are talking about common Jo who let themselves put in a stone every year, know they should do something about it, but opt for denial instead.

Would you like unicorns with that?

Swipe left for the next trending thread