Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
Oher · 22/12/2022 19:14

It would be like putting more water into a leaky bucket, unfortunately.

helford · 22/12/2022 19:01

HermioneWeasley · 22/12/2022 18:10

@helford private companies are spending their shareholders’ money so I don’t care what they do.

the NHS is probably the most diverse workforce in the Uk, I don’t think it’s an issue that take priority over clinical work if there is (as claimed) a shortage of money and people.

I agree but the issues with the NHS are not going to be solved by sacking off Diversity Managers, esp when one of their key roles is ensuring people don't leave.

The key issues are buildings, equipment and staff - the first two can be fixed with money,
Staff? the UK hasn't 110k people who are either trained or capable of being trained hanging around, there is no point taking them from other sectors and leaving them short.

Post brexit, there is a shortage of educated people, a nurses needs 2 A levels, an AHP 3, of foundation degrees - the NHS has to compete on wages and T&C's.

Its no longer attractive to EU staff so where do medics come from?

Dillydollydingdong · 22/12/2022 19:00

The nhs got £276 billion in 2021. Surely that's enough? So much money my brain can't grasp it.

PaperBagsAreUselessInRain · 22/12/2022 18:58

I think, in an ideal world, you would build non private old people's homes in every major area where they were required. A sort of step down from hospital where there would still be support but they could move in there from hospital before being discharged back home if possible.

You would need the money to build them but more importantly the money to staff them and to be able to find the staff.

That way you could clear out those in hospital who could be discharged if there was care.

You need to up nurse's pay and also stop the system of employing agency nurses by having enough supply because that costs a fortune.

We need to revolutionise primary care and make it everyone's first port of call unless it really is an emergency. I lived in another country prior to the UK and I'm surprised how people treat hospital emergency departments here. More minor injury units and GP appointments out of hours that are easily accessible would solve this. People now wait when they are ill because they believe they won't get to see the GP so you have an odd mix of people who present to hospital v late or people who present v early. Neither is ideal.

Staffing is more of an issue than money but of course staffing could be fixed by throwing money at it. None of these are short term fixes and will take years.

I think we will start having to pay - for all prescriptions, appointments etc. look at dental care now - most of us pay, we just simply ended up there.

NumberTheory · 22/12/2022 18:54

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 18:48

But no one's looking at cutting the money that goes to the NHS, just trying to make it more effective with the money it has, rather than always throwing more money at it.

Putting more money into the NHS wouldn’t be throwing it away. It would be meeting the increasing demand for care that we have because our population is much older, we don’t refuse them treatment the way we used to, and we can treat more problems now.

The NHS isn’t particularly inefficient, that isn’t why it’s struggling now, and a drive for efficiency is part of what has lead to the staffing crisis that’s causing a lot of our issues.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:54

@Fadedpicture

But no one's looking at cutting the money that goes to the NHS, just trying to make it more effective with the money it has, rather than always throwing more money at it.

Some not so subtle goalpost changing there....

You said that a 1% transfer from GPS to pharmacists would "save loads", and even quoted the saving in your next post when I challenged it!

If you'd said "it would make things more effective" - which is very different- I wouldn't have taken issue.

Athenen0ctua · 22/12/2022 18:53

I don't agree with taking those on low incomes anything extra at all, even £1 a month. People already not being able to afford adequate nutrition and heating to stay healthy will increase the burden on the NHS. I'd get rid of the regressive NI and roll it into income tax personally.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:49

@Fadedpicture

Having been involved with those who manage social care, which is in a similar predicament when it comes to staff, a HUGE amount of effort goes into retaining staff. It will be the same in the NHS... But if there's no extra money, and a buoyant job market with plenty of well paying and less stressful jobs, you're expecting something that's not just very hard, but virtually impossible without any understanding of reality.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 18:48

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:45

@Fadedpicture

Fewer GP appointments won't save money unless you actually reduce the number of GPs.

Given that GPs are overstretched, and people struggle to get appointments, a 1% transfer of appointments to pharmacies is hardly going to provide the capacity to reduce GP numbers!

But no one's looking at cutting the money that goes to the NHS, just trying to make it more effective with the money it has, rather than always throwing more money at it.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:45

@Fadedpicture

Fewer GP appointments won't save money unless you actually reduce the number of GPs.

Given that GPs are overstretched, and people struggle to get appointments, a 1% transfer of appointments to pharmacies is hardly going to provide the capacity to reduce GP numbers!

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 18:44

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:40

Reducing staff turnover and the use of agency staff would be a massive saving

No one is arguing that agency staff isn't cost efficient... but "reducing staff turnover"
can't be done with a magic wand whilst you're actually looking to cut costs in a over-heated system under pressure.

and prescribing paracetamol costs the NHS £80m pa which may be a drop in the ocean but it's quite a few nurses!

There's always going to be some waste in a very large organisation, and of course things can always be more efficient, but thinking "minding the pennies"'is a solution in itself is utterly deluded.

It was specifically said these aren't quick or easy fixes, but they are things someone should be looking at fixing.

Wibbly1008 · 22/12/2022 18:40

No amount of money will help the NHS. It’s a dead duck no longer fit for purpose.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:40

Reducing staff turnover and the use of agency staff would be a massive saving

No one is arguing that agency staff isn't cost efficient... but "reducing staff turnover"
can't be done with a magic wand whilst you're actually looking to cut costs in a over-heated system under pressure.

and prescribing paracetamol costs the NHS £80m pa which may be a drop in the ocean but it's quite a few nurses!

There's always going to be some waste in a very large organisation, and of course things can always be more efficient, but thinking "minding the pennies"'is a solution in itself is utterly deluded.

Aishah231 · 22/12/2022 18:40

They need to stop over medicating and ban ultra processed food. This would save huge amounts of money and lives. Not a lot of money to be made out of that policy though!

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 18:39

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:36

Of course they would. Swapping even 1% of GP appointments for a visit to a pharmacy would save loads.

How does that actually save cash?

Because you need 1% fewer GP appointments at a cost of c. £40 per appointment.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:36

Of course they would. Swapping even 1% of GP appointments for a visit to a pharmacy would save loads.

How does that actually save cash?

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 18:34

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:30

Apart from not prescribing paracetamol, which would save peanuts, none of those things actually save money...

Of course they would. Swapping even 1% of GP appointments for a visit to a pharmacy would save loads. Reducing staff turnover and the use of agency staff would be a massive saving and prescribing paracetamol costs the NHS £80m pa which may be a drop in the ocean but it's quite a few nurses!

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:33

Well, encouraging nurses to stay would, but how the heck are you meant to
do that when you're reducing NHS funding
as you suggest. "Please stay nurse - we really love you. We just can't give you an pay rise, let alone one that matches inflation, because we're cuts costs you see. Yes, there are loads of less stressful jobs out there that pay better, but have a sticker and round of applause and I'm sure you'll now want to stay!"

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:30

CakeCrumbs44 · 22/12/2022 14:44

They would be better off trying to reduce costs in the NHS rather than increase funding. Things like educating people about when they can go to a pharmacy rather than a doctor, or a minor injuries centre rather than calling an ambulance. Stop offering things like paracetamol for free on prescription when people could just buy it for 30p off the shelf. Encourage nurses to stay in the job so they don't have to employ agency nurses which cost 3x as much.
Obviously none of these things are simple fixes, but there must be so many places where the NHS is just haemorrhaging money. It needs rebuilding from the ground up.

Apart from not prescribing paracetamol, which would save peanuts, none of those things actually save money...

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:23

nancydroo · 22/12/2022 18:16

They'd piss it up the wall or give themselves yet another pay rise.

That's a pretty daft bit of very lazy analysis...

You don't give them a sufficient pay rise, you continue to lose staff, increasing the already eye watering vacancy rates... causing care to reduce further and requiring exorbitant agency workers to cover essential gaps.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:19

QueueEtwo · 22/12/2022 15:52

Didn't Johnson increase NIC to help fund the NHS initially & Social Care in the long-term but Truss put it back down again?

Can't remember wether Sunsk has put it back up or not - I'm passed following the incompetence of our current Govt! 🙄

The NI rise was reversed but the Government are continuing to invest that amount in social care, but doing so in a way that allows increased investment in social care provision, rather than using it to reduce contributions to care costs as was then original intention. This should allow NHS beds to be freed up more quickly, taking the pressure off NHS services somewhat. It's a more efficient investment that directly increasing NHS budgets.

Councils have had a very significant and very welcome increase in funding for social care as part of the Autumn Statement as a result... something that has had surprisingly little new airtime (though maybe not so surprising given that social care isn't sexy)

usethedata · 22/12/2022 18:19

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/12/2022 11:53

In Scotland we are already paying more tax for the NHS £100s to £1,000s and it's just as shit here.

It really really isn't as shit. It has a lot of issues yes, but having lived near London it is so so much better up here than it was down there

nancydroo · 22/12/2022 18:16

They'd piss it up the wall or give themselves yet another pay rise.

HermioneWeasley · 22/12/2022 18:10

@helford private companies are spending their shareholders’ money so I don’t care what they do.

the NHS is probably the most diverse workforce in the Uk, I don’t think it’s an issue that take priority over clinical work if there is (as claimed) a shortage of money and people.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:09

£1 per taxpayer per year would equivalent of 0.02% increase.

It would be the equivalent of giving someone on a £20,000 income an extra £4 per year, and expecting that to make a difference.