Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
AreOttersJustWetCats · 22/12/2022 21:18

XingMing · 22/12/2022 21:14

Unpopular with the top brass, because DH will not mince words or tiptoe around egos. He's trained to deliver, and to train people to deliver, and he doesn't like waffle.

I don't think what you're saying is the compliment you clearly think it is!

XingMing · 22/12/2022 21:17

@EmmaDilemma5 the NHS is already crippled if you're approaching middle age, when health issues emerge.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 22/12/2022 21:16

The tax take would be around £60m (£1 × no. of adults in the UK), which is the square root of bugger all in the context of NHS funding requirements.

EmmaDilemma5 · 22/12/2022 21:14

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 20:39

Not true many people develop dementia and it's not because they live unhealthy lives it's because of aging. Care home ratios women outnumber men because we are less likely to die of heart attacks etc. You can live for 10-15 years with it because pneumonia for example which previously killed can be treated with antibiotics. Stopping eating can be treated with special drinks/thickened fluids. Many elderly people are ill because they are old not because of lifestyle choices and we can extend their physical lives with treatment sadly it doesn't work very well on the mind. You can live healthy your entire life and still develop dementia and have a long drawn out death. Your body starts to fail as you get older.

Are you arguing that poor lifestyle choices have little effect on care for older people? If so, that's crazy. And ignorant.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 21:14

Unpopular with the top brass, because DH will not mince words or tiptoe around egos. He's trained to deliver, and to train people to deliver, and he doesn't like waffle.

EmmaDilemma5 · 22/12/2022 21:11

upfucked · 22/12/2022 11:52

I don’t think it would be enough. One of the biggest issues facing the NHS is the lack of suitable social care rather than the NHS plus issues of poverty and deprivation puts more pressure on the NHS. It’s a whole society issue.

Plus the cost of increasing chronic illnesses like diabetes. There are a lot of people receiving a lot of medication and appointments for lifestyle based illnesses. Unless we do anything about this, the NHS will be crippled.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 21:10

DH is rather looking forward to retiring and volunteering with the NHS. He's been a patient and a supplier/contractor. They will either make use of his skills to save money or shunt him off. But he won't be the one directing traffic and giving directions. I fear he will become very very unpopular.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 21:09

@Blocked & @billyt

I was more than happy to pay the extra NI payment knowing it would be ring-fenced (supposedly)When that was removed I was surprised.

The NI rise was principally to fund charging reform, to reduce the amount people would have to contribute for their social care. It was not (at least in large part) to support existing social care services.

However... despite the removal of NI, the funding earmarked for social care has remained and the charging reform has been postponed.... with the result that all the extra money (and it's many billions) is now available to actually support social care, and help facilitate hospital discharges.

Council budgets will increase significantly next year as a result.... And yet this is something that has largely gone unnoticed!

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 21:02

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 14:27

Thrown out walking frames after being used once? Bank staff paid twice or three times the amount of regular nurses? The waste is eye watering
No it isn't. You are talking peanuts. Not even .001% of the while funding.

It's as stupid a statement as someone saying they are crap at money and easing their income because they use two sheets of toilet paper when they could use one. Probably true, but I don't that would explain why a family is £10000s in debts.

The public really need to educate themselves about the scale of money we are talking about, and focusing on very minimal issues solely whilst ignoring the issue that costs half the NHS IS bad management.

Good points. It's clear that a lot of people posting with trite and simplistic solutions have never managed substantial resources.

There's also this notion that money spent on management is inherently wasteful, and that any extra money has to go to the front-line.... of course there'll be some waste in bureaucracy and management, but you need good bureaucracy and management to make things efficient! Who is doing the procuring and the planning if there's no one to manage?

Imagine an army with only infantry in the front line.... no officers, no logistics, no training, etc. It wouldn't last a week. And yet that's what people seem to expect the NHS to do. People should be demanding good management, and expect the costs that are required for that, rather than let's cut management because managers are useless and wasteful.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 20:56

Women outnumber men by at least 3-1 in care homes, often much more. Women are simply more robust than most men, so grow old in larger numbers. I do sometimes wonder whether antibiotics should be prescribed at all for people over 80. I think I would rather fade out with pneumonia than be kept afloat on a raft of drugs just so a small child can say bye bye to granny.

It's been a priority for me this autumn as DMIL was hospitalised. When DSIL visited, she wanted her children and GC to say farewell, but DMIL was not well enough to enjoy seeing them, definitely not well enough to engage with LOs, or even to make it worthwhile for a much loved grand daughter to plan a flight home from Europe. As soon as the hospital discharged her as medically well, she died six hours later. I do think the hospital were being slightly cynical about getting her to die off their premises.

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 20:39

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 20:21

The biggest expenditure is on over 65s. Not because they’re obese or have unrealistic expectations, or are sitting under £50 lightbulbs but because we’ve put our money into learning how to stop people dying, and it’s worked
No, the issue is not people living longer but living unhealthily longer. I can't remember the exact figures and can't be bothered to look, but a large scale research showed that on average, women live with a long term condition for over 20 years or something like that, men even more. Then you had those who lived fewer years but with 3 or more long term conditions. That's the biggest costs. My MIL is 95 but has been really healthy and needed very little care. Zero from social services. She is less costly than her sister who passed away in her 70s but had an unhealthy lifestyle and was diabetic, suffered from high cholesterol, and had emphysema from years of smoking and needed a lot of care for more than 20 years.

Not true many people develop dementia and it's not because they live unhealthy lives it's because of aging. Care home ratios women outnumber men because we are less likely to die of heart attacks etc. You can live for 10-15 years with it because pneumonia for example which previously killed can be treated with antibiotics. Stopping eating can be treated with special drinks/thickened fluids. Many elderly people are ill because they are old not because of lifestyle choices and we can extend their physical lives with treatment sadly it doesn't work very well on the mind. You can live healthy your entire life and still develop dementia and have a long drawn out death. Your body starts to fail as you get older.

CakeCrumbs44 · 22/12/2022 20:36

Totally agree with you @Blocked. There are probably ways the NHS could save money. I definitely don't think that if everyone went to the pharmacy instead of GP it would solve the crises of the NHS. The government are pretty hopeless and nobody wants to be "the party who raised taxes" so just stick a plaster over the problem until it's someone else's problem.

Blocked · 22/12/2022 20:34

CakeCrumbs44 · 22/12/2022 20:27

If more people used the appropriate service such as pharmacy or minor injuries clinic, rather than GP then there would be more GP appointments available.

Currently a lot of people aren't able to get a GP appointment so they go to A&E, or use an out of hours service or some even call for an ambulance which all cost the NHS more than a GP appointment. More GP appointments available would save money and reduce strain on other services.

A lot of people don't seem to realise that pharmacies are a healthcare service not just a shop, it probably doesn't help that they're usually inside Boots or Superdrug and the actual trained pharmacist is out of sight.

It really isn't the fault of people. People have always acted the same way. The problem isn't the number of NHS managers either.

The problem is we have had for some time a steadily increasing population, an ageing population, and the elderly often have very significant health needs but as social care is so underfunded they aren't getting the care they need at home, they aren't getting residential places either, so they're stuck in hospital.

There is also the issue of training staff, now that bursaries have been all but done away with, and retaining staff when working conditions are so much better elsewhere.

These problems have been evident for decades, but governments rarely create a long term plan - they plan to do what they can to achieve their goals, until the next election.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 20:31

@LexMitior which is why I have been banging on about the HMO element in US healthcare, which does work efficiently and effectively, quietly where it exists. It is a robust model that serves the population well, without promising unicorns. Doubt it covers gender reassignment or more than minimal IVF, but cancer, heart disease, diabetes and orthopaedic surgery are all well within the remit, plus childbirth and paediatric medicine. However, you need to be employed by an organisation that subscribes to a socialised medicine model -- like a university.

Blocked · 22/12/2022 20:29

billyt · 22/12/2022 12:04

I was more than happy to pay the extra NI payment knowing it would be ring-fenced (supposedly)

When that was removed I was surprised.

But I do agree that it seems there are more managers who don't actual have the ability to help people get better, and just create yet another level of admin for users to wade through.

Me too, I'm on a low income and the amount I paid was negligible to them but quite a lot for me - but I still think they should bring it back.

CakeCrumbs44 · 22/12/2022 20:27

If more people used the appropriate service such as pharmacy or minor injuries clinic, rather than GP then there would be more GP appointments available.

Currently a lot of people aren't able to get a GP appointment so they go to A&E, or use an out of hours service or some even call for an ambulance which all cost the NHS more than a GP appointment. More GP appointments available would save money and reduce strain on other services.

A lot of people don't seem to realise that pharmacies are a healthcare service not just a shop, it probably doesn't help that they're usually inside Boots or Superdrug and the actual trained pharmacist is out of sight.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 20:21

The biggest expenditure is on over 65s. Not because they’re obese or have unrealistic expectations, or are sitting under £50 lightbulbs but because we’ve put our money into learning how to stop people dying, and it’s worked
No, the issue is not people living longer but living unhealthily longer. I can't remember the exact figures and can't be bothered to look, but a large scale research showed that on average, women live with a long term condition for over 20 years or something like that, men even more. Then you had those who lived fewer years but with 3 or more long term conditions. That's the biggest costs. My MIL is 95 but has been really healthy and needed very little care. Zero from social services. She is less costly than her sister who passed away in her 70s but had an unhealthy lifestyle and was diabetic, suffered from high cholesterol, and had emphysema from years of smoking and needed a lot of care for more than 20 years.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 19:56

Insurance is okay if you are young, fit, healthy and well off.

If you are not these things, it is very expensive. I wonder how many on this thread who say not a penny more tax etc have looked at the scope of a private medical insurance policy for themselves, and how much it would cost?

For a lot of people on an average salary, with genetic disease, family history of cancers, heart disease, chronic conditions, the old, the NHS is far better than that.

Capri3 · 22/12/2022 19:54

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:45

@Fadedpicture

Fewer GP appointments won't save money unless you actually reduce the number of GPs.

Given that GPs are overstretched, and people struggle to get appointments, a 1% transfer of appointments to pharmacies is hardly going to provide the capacity to reduce GP numbers!

I agree that it would help. Currently, the lack of gp appointments means that many patients are told by the gp receptionist to call the OOH service (which is 111). 111 will either tell you to go to A&E or book you an OOH appointment (usually several hours later at 1 am or some other ridiculous time). If more gp appointments were available, it would mean less patients at A&E.

user1497207191 · 22/12/2022 19:54

Based on £276bn, it costs everyone in the UK £4,600 per year. If you divide it by number of "workers" (roughly half), that's £9,200 per worker per year. Another pound or two per person wouldn't touch the sides.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 19:49

Dillydollydingdong · 22/12/2022 19:00

The nhs got £276 billion in 2021. Surely that's enough? So much money my brain can't grasp it.

Using your logic, why not £27 billion, ten times less but still a massive sum of money that we struggle to comprehend?

Massive savings all around for the taxpayer and the NHS still gets multi-billions (which surely must be enough - looks at all the number of zeros!). Win-win!

Athenen0ctua · 22/12/2022 19:47

Hawaii4 · 22/12/2022 19:22

Yabu. It needs to be ended, it's unsustainable and not fit for purpose. Move to the American style of insurance. Taxpayers pay too much already, at least then we'd save tax, pay insurance and get a better service.

Those who don't want to pay don't need to either, freedom of choice, so win-win really.

What about those who can't pay?

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 19:45

@user1497207191

You'd reduce GP appointments so need fewer GPs to pay, and/or the GPs would have more time to treat people who really needed GP help rather than them using A&E or their conditions getting worse and costing the NHS more to treat more progressed disease.

The crisis in the NHS js largely down to acute staff shortages, and you're suggesting cutting GPs as a solution?!? 😖

But I agree your point that more targeted GP work through more appropriate self-referral to pharmacies could help disease to be treated earlier, which would benefit health and save money (or at least allow resources to be better targeted) in primary care.

Hawaii4 · 22/12/2022 19:22

Yabu. It needs to be ended, it's unsustainable and not fit for purpose. Move to the American style of insurance. Taxpayers pay too much already, at least then we'd save tax, pay insurance and get a better service.

Those who don't want to pay don't need to either, freedom of choice, so win-win really.

user1497207191 · 22/12/2022 19:15

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 18:36

Of course they would. Swapping even 1% of GP appointments for a visit to a pharmacy would save loads.

How does that actually save cash?

You'd reduce GP appointments so need fewer GPs to pay, and/or the GPs would have more time to treat people who really needed GP help rather than them using A&E or their conditions getting worse and costing the NHS more to treat more progressed disease.