Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 23:48

@Theeyeballsinthesky

However, the money was not ring fenced and because local authority funding has been decimated, there is hardly any money to do any proper public health education or interventions.

You are incorrect on that. Public Heath Grant to local authorities most definitely remains ring-fenced.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 23:35

@user1497207191

I don't think the poster was referring to doctors - they tend to get more than £27k per annum!

paintitallover · 22/12/2022 23:35

I think an extra £1 would help, actually.

DepressingTimes · 22/12/2022 23:28

It’s expensive to run and eats money left right and centre. Only better management can save it. And leadership comes from top down. They need to do basic things like triage on door and not treat everyone no matter what. Get x-ray in one room, fast track elderly and pay out for public health campaigns so people with sick bugs don’t keep turning up!!

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 23:18

Fameinaframe · 22/12/2022 13:52

*That can't be right.

Your first grand or so a month should be subject to no tax as it's below the personal allowance. You're basically being taxed 50% on the remainder which should be basic rate*

Definitely how much my deductions are altogether!

PAYE can be a bit hit and miss when it comes to low incomes, because HMRC need to consider the whole picture of an individual's income before working out where the tax free allowance fits in, and they can only do that with the information they have. For example, for some years I had two part time jobs of which one earnt just under the allowance and the other over. It took some years of adjustments, estimates, rebates, communications and money back and forth before they finally sorted it, with the lower salary coming through untaxed.

They may be imposing a provisional tax code because they're waiting for confirmation you have no other source of income, for example, and you may be eligible for a rebate at the end of the year. Or something like that. Obviously I don't know your whole situation but the figures you say on face value don't sound right.

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 23:10

caringcarer · 22/12/2022 13:58

Over 500 managers earn over £100k each year.

So what?

Funny, when people want to extol the virtues of the free market, they usually reject criticism of how much fat cat CEOs and directors get paid because it's necessary to "attract the best people". So what makes you think something as large, complex and important as the NHS could function just as well with second rate managers? I've no idea how much a 100K NHS manager could earn in the private sector but presumably they wouldn't be offering that much if they didn't think it was necessary.

Or to put it another way: the existence of managers earning over 100K a year is supposed to be evidence that the NHS is wasteful, right? And therefore it should be replaced by some kind of private or semi-private system, right?

I wonder: How much do you think the managers in that private system will get paid? How much are the senior managers of large American health insurance firms paid? Less than 100GBP a year? I doubt it.

So will the existence of highly paid managers in private insurance firms equally be evidence that private health insurance is wasteful? And will people be coming on here sounding off about how terrible it is, that they have to pay inflated premiums for such indulgent business practices, and that clearly it all needs to be nationalised to get rid of such waste?

nolongersurprised · 22/12/2022 22:52

The Australian system has more than a basic public hospital system with inpatients, outpatients, therapists, investigations, emergency departments.

There is a private system working along side it, with overlaps. Some people will see consultant X for their endocrine problem publicly and consultant y for cardiology service.

The big misunderstanding about it is that you need private health insurance to access it, but you don’t. Private cover is largely for inpatient stays at private hospitals.

There’s a whole heap of private services - speech, OT, physio, psychology, medical specialists. You don’t need private cover to see them.

It works because the government pays each private provider a fee, then they charge on top. You pay the “gap”. My daughter saw a dermatologist privately, she cost $300ish and we were out of pocket 120. Follow ups are much cheaper.

If you have a low income or a chronic condition everything is cheaper. Private Therapy including psychology can be no cost, if you have a chronic medical condition/disorder and are on the National Disability Insurance Scheme. You don’t have to see a private consultant, ever, if you don’t want to. Some people without a lot of spare cash choose to see a specialist privately so they can see the same person every time.

GPs are private, although in most places you can find one who doesn’t charge beyond their government fee (bulk billed, no cost to patient). Most private lab tests are bulk billed (no cost), most basic radiology is. An MRI scan at our best local provider will have you out of pocket 150 dollars, if you choose to “go private” for this.

Without government funding this hybrid public/private service wouldn’t work, it would be crazily expensive.

I also don’t think it would work because culturally, people in the UK don’t want to pay anything at all.

Here, if you had a 7 year old child with ASD/aDHD and some delays you could see a paediatrician publicly (no cost), have fortnightly “private” speech, OT, physio, psychology through the government funded NDIS (no cost), see a bulk billing GP (no cost), have private bloods done to check for iron deficiency (no cost), private X-rays after a fall (no cost) and go to public ED for acute serious illnesses (no cost).

However, there is a cost to medications, the government subsidises medications and this subsidy is set irrespective of whether they are prescribed by the GP, private specialist of hospital. A child with a chronic condition or a low earning household will have meds cheaper; the cost of long acting stimulants
will be around $7/month.

A typical MN response to all of this is: “I can’t believe that I’d have to pay 2-3 pounds a month for this. I would have to go without food. I’ll stick with our wonderful NHS, thanks”.

I rhink it’s a cultural thing in the UK, most are not prepared to pay anything at all for health care.

user1497207191 · 22/12/2022 22:48

helford · 22/12/2022 22:16

Where are the students going to come from? and who will train them on placements?

You think there are all these unemployed people with 2 or 3 A levels waiting to go to Uni to work for 27k and a 50 hr week?

Medical schools are grossly oversubscribed. There’s no shortage of people with the right qualifications applying for far too few places.

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 22:30

@ScrappyMoggy

I have far too many letters, there are too many steps, and too many managers. there needs to be systems reform, and far better, focused spending at point of contact care.

How do you achieve that focus and efficiency, when you're removing the very people who would be needed to make that happen?

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 22:28

@ILoveeCakes

Well, if there are no suitable people at all, then it is what it is.After all, we are on an inverted population curve now - increasing olds and decreasing working age people. Add in increasing energy costs = everything gets harder, more scarce and more expensive.

There is a lack of suitable people due to pay, hours and conditions. Deal with those, and combine with training, and you begin to arrive at a solution.... but it's a solution that involves more money, which is what you recognise above...

ScrappyMoggy · 22/12/2022 22:26

The NHS doesn’t need extra money (although it would help), it needs better management. It needs to be worked as a business and wastage seriously reduced.

I have far too many letters, there are too many steps, and too many managers. there needs to be systems reform, and far better, focused spending at point of contact care. Scrap communications campaigns telling us to eat healthier etc. the NHS needs to be point of care service and there is little evidence those campaigns do anything other than make marketing agencies money.

Draw a line under some services. Not popular but cosmetic surgery, fertility treatments, gender surgery etc should carry a fee - not the cost of private but a fee to subsidise it.

Social care for the elderly needs a reform too.

ILoveeCakes · 22/12/2022 22:20

helford · 22/12/2022 22:16

Where are the students going to come from? and who will train them on placements?

You think there are all these unemployed people with 2 or 3 A levels waiting to go to Uni to work for 27k and a 50 hr week?

Well, if there are no suitable people at all, then it is what it is.

After all, we are on an inverted population curve now - increasing olds and decreasing working age people. Add in increasing energy costs = everything gets harder, more scarce and more expensive.

helford · 22/12/2022 22:16

ILoveeCakes · 22/12/2022 22:12

No. You have to increase training places. Just shovelling money in will just lead to more waste

Where are the students going to come from? and who will train them on placements?

You think there are all these unemployed people with 2 or 3 A levels waiting to go to Uni to work for 27k and a 50 hr week?

ILoveeCakes · 22/12/2022 22:12

No. You have to increase training places. Just shovelling money in will just lead to more waste

DdraigGoch · 22/12/2022 22:11

Kendodd · 22/12/2022 11:59

Might help if richer people paid the same rate of National insurance as poorer people.

www.gov.uk/national-insurance/how-much-you-pay

Given that income tax goes up by twice the drop in NI at the same point, it's hardly a discount.

Another76543 · 22/12/2022 22:06

Kendodd · 22/12/2022 11:59

Might help if richer people paid the same rate of National insurance as poorer people.

www.gov.uk/national-insurance/how-much-you-pay

Everyone pays the same NIC rate on the first part of their earnings. It only drops to a lower rate for that part of income over the 40% income tax band level. Those in the 40% tax band effectively pay 42% on the highest part of their earnings when the NIC is taken into account. The highest earners pay 47% (45% plus 2%). Bear in mind as well that higher earners don’t get the benefit of any personal allowance. Lower earners get over £12,500 entirely free of tax. Higher earners pay tax on every single penny they earn.

Kendodd · 22/12/2022 21:49

helford · 22/12/2022 21:40

UK has a massive shortage of Pharmacist's

Brexit cost the UK around 3000 dentists and similar number of pharmacists too.

More pressure on NHS & GPs.

To a large extent, we voted to make the NHS worse.

Mine and my children's lovely NHS dentist was one of them. I don't blame her for leaving. We now have to pay for dentistry and theres no dentist for 50 miles taking NHS patients.

Go us!

Exhausteddog · 22/12/2022 21:47

I think there are multiple issues (sorry if repeating haven't RTFT)
Firstly the NHS was set up for a smaller population with a much lower life expectancy.
With each advance in treating previously untreatable conditions that adds more people needing NHS treatment.
Babies surviving from a much more premature age and people living longer means more people relying on NHS treatment as above.
The longer someone lives the more health problems they are likely to acquire or need full time care.
The expectation and burden on the NHS is far greater than when it was first set up.
But there is also a lot of waste eg letters/paper trails where in any other situation an email or text would suffice

helford · 22/12/2022 21:42

Yes @Kendodd People go on about efficiency but they don't really know what they are talking about, any inefficiencies are made 100 x worse because of staff shortages.

helford · 22/12/2022 21:40

UK has a massive shortage of Pharmacist's

Brexit cost the UK around 3000 dentists and similar number of pharmacists too.

More pressure on NHS & GPs.

To a large extent, we voted to make the NHS worse.

Kendodd · 22/12/2022 21:36

Posters talk such bollocks about inefficiency in the NHS compared to other systems. The NHS is ranked as extreme efficient and excellent value for money compared to most others systems in the world. This isn't to say improvements couldn't always be made but the 'tear it down and start again' 'not fit for purpose' lot sound like Tory puppets, either that or just thick.

www.statista.com/statistics/1290426/health-care-system-administrative-efficiency-ranking-of-select-countries/

www.independent.co.uk/news/health/nhs-rank-rating-world-top-first-b1897008.html

healthcare-digital.com/hospitals/most-efficient-health-systems

www.bmj.com/content/343/bmj.d5143

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 21:32

EmmaDilemma5 · 22/12/2022 21:14

Are you arguing that poor lifestyle choices have little effect on care for older people? If so, that's crazy. And ignorant.

No but I work in elderly care, we are facing a massive boom in dementia rates. Obesity costs money yes but obese people are more likely to drop dead of heart attacks etc younger Vs living for 10 years in a care home until 100 bed bound doubly incontinent. It's good to live a healthy lifestyle but will it's not going protect you from a long protracted death in old age. I would rather die quickly I hope they have assisted dying when I reach that point.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 21:26

@AreOttersJustWetCats DH is a logistician/business/entrepreneurial type who won't second guess clinical judgements. The delivery process that enables doctors to deliver top notch medical care knowing the back office and support processes work smoothly behind the scenes would be the focus.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 22/12/2022 21:20

Tuilpmouse · 22/12/2022 21:02

Good points. It's clear that a lot of people posting with trite and simplistic solutions have never managed substantial resources.

There's also this notion that money spent on management is inherently wasteful, and that any extra money has to go to the front-line.... of course there'll be some waste in bureaucracy and management, but you need good bureaucracy and management to make things efficient! Who is doing the procuring and the planning if there's no one to manage?

Imagine an army with only infantry in the front line.... no officers, no logistics, no training, etc. It wouldn't last a week. And yet that's what people seem to expect the NHS to do. People should be demanding good management, and expect the costs that are required for that, rather than let's cut management because managers are useless and wasteful.

I agree, as a former NHS employee

XingMing · 22/12/2022 21:19

I am not paying compliments. Or even trying to @AreOttersJustWetCats

Swipe left for the next trending thread