Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
Tuilpmouse · 23/12/2022 14:21

@Badbadbunny

That's bad, and certainly hasn't been my experience since Spring of this year.

Xenia · 23/12/2022 14:16

I would rather just be allowed to opt out of the NHS and my income tax bill be 20% less.

Badbadbunny · 23/12/2022 13:11

helford · 23/12/2022 12:46

The OP said they were seen by a GP & 65 to 70% of appointments are F2F, maybe stop reading the 'Mail?

HCA's are not paid to make clinic diagnosis, they refer up and rightly so.

Neither myself nor OH have been able to see a GP face for face for the past two years. OH has cancer and numerous complications, but it's always phone consultations. Same with his haematologist who he's only seen once F2F in the past 3 years, all other "consultations" are by phone. He even had a video consultation with the orthopaedic surgeon re a broken bone in his foot and a video appointment re damage to the 3rd vertibrae in his neck. By the way, we don't read the Daily Mail. Being unable to see a doctor/consultant face to face around hear is the norm.

Fadedpicture · 23/12/2022 13:05

Fadedpicture · 23/12/2022 12:47

It was over the phone with GP. I'm not surprised the receptionist couldn't answer, but if it's something that happens fairly often surely the phlebotomist at the time could have said "sorry about that, it does happen sometimes, it could be sore with some numbness for 6-8 weeks, but don't worry, it will pass"?

She also didn't ask a single question that might have established if it was something else.

helford · 23/12/2022 13:04

Fadedpicture · 23/12/2022 12:47

It was over the phone with GP. I'm not surprised the receptionist couldn't answer, but if it's something that happens fairly often surely the phlebotomist at the time could have said "sorry about that, it does happen sometimes, it could be sore with some numbness for 6-8 weeks, but don't worry, it will pass"?

To be honest nicking a nerve drawing blood isn't common, bruising perhaps, didn't you feel something at the time? they are supposed to put the needle in a vein.

A 'phone conversation with a GP is hardly inefficient and its now on your med records, maybe next time they'll read that and be more careful?
Maybe the GP will speak to the person who did the blood test?

There some very real issues with the NHS, most of which are human error and or lack of staff.... things go very wrong in the private sector too and in other countries health systems.

I don't see how anyone can expect a problem free NHS.

TodayInahurry · 23/12/2022 12:49

The NHS is hideously inefficient, seen numerous posts on here from people who have worked there. There are huge numbers of highly paid none jobs, huge numbers of highly paid managers. They have followed every current fad, even if dangerous for patients, putting trans women in woman’s wards and denying there was a problem when a woman was raped. The Tavistock scandal which will probably end in them paying £millions.

Th NHS is not the envy of the world and has huge amounts of money thrown at it and does not improve. We need a German/French model in which people pay insurance.

Fadedpicture · 23/12/2022 12:47

helford · 23/12/2022 12:39

@Fadedpicture So how would have felt if you'd been told, over the phone "oh thats a pinched nerve, will go soon" but it turned out to be a clot and you then had a stoke?

Isn't it better someone sees you face to face by a Doctor or Consultant?

It was over the phone with GP. I'm not surprised the receptionist couldn't answer, but if it's something that happens fairly often surely the phlebotomist at the time could have said "sorry about that, it does happen sometimes, it could be sore with some numbness for 6-8 weeks, but don't worry, it will pass"?

helford · 23/12/2022 12:46

Badbadbunny · 23/12/2022 12:42

People aren't being seen face to face though, are they? GPs will only see you if they think there's a clinical need. So all the GP could say in this case was "wait and see" which is exactly what the HCA taking the blood should have said. Even better would have been for the HCA to tell the patient what warnings signs to look out for which may indicate a need to see a GP, i.e. it lasting longer than a few weeks, other side effects etc. The HCA explaining what may happen would have taken a few seconds and saved a GP consultation.

The OP said they were seen by a GP & 65 to 70% of appointments are F2F, maybe stop reading the 'Mail?

HCA's are not paid to make clinic diagnosis, they refer up and rightly so.

helford · 23/12/2022 12:43

Fifi00 · 23/12/2022 11:49

Pay their full degree including maintenance loan in exchange for a few years of service could work. Right now student nurses are effectively paying to go on placement and work for free. There's no incentive many don't feel they owe the NHS anything , paying for the degree has backfired on the government.

Do you seriously think that an A level student is going to chose NHS if they are stuck there for 5 or 10 years, unable to move jobs otherwise they will owe 50 or 60k?

Do it for all degrees and no one will go to Uni.

UK has the most expensive tiuton fees in the world & you pair think this will work?

Here's an idea, increase pay, improve working conditions and make the job attractive again?

So far its take take take by the employers and the public.

Badbadbunny · 23/12/2022 12:42

helford · 23/12/2022 12:39

@Fadedpicture So how would have felt if you'd been told, over the phone "oh thats a pinched nerve, will go soon" but it turned out to be a clot and you then had a stoke?

Isn't it better someone sees you face to face by a Doctor or Consultant?

People aren't being seen face to face though, are they? GPs will only see you if they think there's a clinical need. So all the GP could say in this case was "wait and see" which is exactly what the HCA taking the blood should have said. Even better would have been for the HCA to tell the patient what warnings signs to look out for which may indicate a need to see a GP, i.e. it lasting longer than a few weeks, other side effects etc. The HCA explaining what may happen would have taken a few seconds and saved a GP consultation.

helford · 23/12/2022 12:39

@Fadedpicture So how would have felt if you'd been told, over the phone "oh thats a pinched nerve, will go soon" but it turned out to be a clot and you then had a stoke?

Isn't it better someone sees you face to face by a Doctor or Consultant?

Fadedpicture · 23/12/2022 12:00

Another example of an easily solved inefficiency. I had a blood test, they caught a nerve. A week later I'm still in a lot of pain and have 2 numb fingers. I've no idea if this is normal, rang surgery to try and find out if I need to see someone. Can't help, you'll have to talk to the doctor.

So, I've just wasted a GP appointment to be told it happens sometimes, it will resolve in 6-8 weeks. So why couldn't the plebotomist have told me what to expect and save the surgery reception time, the congested telephone system and the GP appointment? Shouldn't it just be normal to explain what to expect when something relatively common happens?

Fifi00 · 23/12/2022 11:49

felulageller · 23/12/2022 10:41

To stop staff leaving to go private/ agency/ abroad we could make NHS degrees free and require those not working in the NHS to pay back their full fees (not just the £9k pa).

Pay their full degree including maintenance loan in exchange for a few years of service could work. Right now student nurses are effectively paying to go on placement and work for free. There's no incentive many don't feel they owe the NHS anything , paying for the degree has backfired on the government.

paintitallover · 23/12/2022 11:41

@NumberTheory I would be up for paying out an extra £50p a day, or say £35 a month, as long as those on the very highest incomes should contribute an equivalent percentage of income.

felulageller · 23/12/2022 10:41

To stop staff leaving to go private/ agency/ abroad we could make NHS degrees free and require those not working in the NHS to pay back their full fees (not just the £9k pa).

Fifi00 · 23/12/2022 09:52

Xenia · 23/12/2022 09:40

Loads of issues on this thread (not surprising). The NHS as someone said is cheaper than most alternatives. It is about 20% of people's income tax a year. So if as someone said above it costs each working person about £9500 a year in tax (£47, 500 income tax per person I suppose) some are paying just about nothing if they get a single person tax allowance (not everyone does these days) of about £12,500 and some are paying huge sums into it. I call me 2 NHS GP appointments in the last 15 years my £100k a time appointments given what I pay into an NHS I never need so far just about. I am very very lucky not to be ill (not all luck but mostly luck) and paying all that tax to help others is something I can accept as I would much rather be well than needing healthcare.

However it is getting very expensive and there are too many bells and whistles provided. We are moving as a nation from the richest best nation on earth down the pecking order which is fine but comes with many things being worse and we need to prepare for that.

I agree with those saying we do;'t need a single diversity manager in the NHS.

However I would look at where most of the money goes and try to cut from that. Eg we could legislate so no one can sue the NHS for negligence. "The overall cost of clinical negligence in England rose from £582 million in 2006 to 2007 to £2.2 billion in 2020 to 2021, representing a significant burden on the NHS. For all claims, legal costs have increased more than fourfold to £433 million since 2006 to 2007."

"In 2020/21 the Department for Health and Social Care spent £192 billion." "In 2019 the UK spent 10.2 per cent of GDP on health, which is in line with the average among comparable countries. The provisional estimate for 2020 is that this has risen to 12.8 per cent due to the increased funding allocated to tackling the Covid-19 pandemic."

"The NHS is one of the world’s largest employers with around 1.2 million full-time equivalent staff in England, as of June 2021. Consequently, the wage bill for the NHS makes up a substantial proportion of its budget. In 2019/20, the total cost of NHS staff was £56.1 billion which amounted to 46.6 per cent of the NHS budget. These statistics don’t include salaries for GPs or..." www.kingsfund.org.uk/audio-video/key-facts-figures-nhs

So about half is wages. If we are going into a massive recession with few jobs available due to the huge debts we took on because of furlough payments making changes like requiring all NHS staff to work full time only and no private work or other jobs ever and retirement at 67 for all and no employer provided pension other than auto enrolment and also no sick pay other than SSP I bet that would save an absolutely fortune.

NHS staff will just leave the only thing remotely attractive about it is the now reduced pension , sick pay , enhancements , annual leave and maternity leave. Private companies pay a lot more money . Also it's easy to get a job abroad with the qualifications other western countries who pay more are crying out for staff. You can't tell the staff not to take private work , they will be off as that's subsidising their NHS wages.

Xenia · 23/12/2022 09:40

Loads of issues on this thread (not surprising). The NHS as someone said is cheaper than most alternatives. It is about 20% of people's income tax a year. So if as someone said above it costs each working person about £9500 a year in tax (£47, 500 income tax per person I suppose) some are paying just about nothing if they get a single person tax allowance (not everyone does these days) of about £12,500 and some are paying huge sums into it. I call me 2 NHS GP appointments in the last 15 years my £100k a time appointments given what I pay into an NHS I never need so far just about. I am very very lucky not to be ill (not all luck but mostly luck) and paying all that tax to help others is something I can accept as I would much rather be well than needing healthcare.

However it is getting very expensive and there are too many bells and whistles provided. We are moving as a nation from the richest best nation on earth down the pecking order which is fine but comes with many things being worse and we need to prepare for that.

I agree with those saying we do;'t need a single diversity manager in the NHS.

However I would look at where most of the money goes and try to cut from that. Eg we could legislate so no one can sue the NHS for negligence. "The overall cost of clinical negligence in England rose from £582 million in 2006 to 2007 to £2.2 billion in 2020 to 2021, representing a significant burden on the NHS. For all claims, legal costs have increased more than fourfold to £433 million since 2006 to 2007."

"In 2020/21 the Department for Health and Social Care spent £192 billion." "In 2019 the UK spent 10.2 per cent of GDP on health, which is in line with the average among comparable countries. The provisional estimate for 2020 is that this has risen to 12.8 per cent due to the increased funding allocated to tackling the Covid-19 pandemic."

"The NHS is one of the world’s largest employers with around 1.2 million full-time equivalent staff in England, as of June 2021. Consequently, the wage bill for the NHS makes up a substantial proportion of its budget. In 2019/20, the total cost of NHS staff was £56.1 billion which amounted to 46.6 per cent of the NHS budget. These statistics don’t include salaries for GPs or..." www.kingsfund.org.uk/audio-video/key-facts-figures-nhs

So about half is wages. If we are going into a massive recession with few jobs available due to the huge debts we took on because of furlough payments making changes like requiring all NHS staff to work full time only and no private work or other jobs ever and retirement at 67 for all and no employer provided pension other than auto enrolment and also no sick pay other than SSP I bet that would save an absolutely fortune.

JudgeJ · 23/12/2022 08:12

upfucked · 22/12/2022 11:52

I don’t think it would be enough. One of the biggest issues facing the NHS is the lack of suitable social care rather than the NHS plus issues of poverty and deprivation puts more pressure on the NHS. It’s a whole society issue.

A number of problems here. The NHS is having to do far more than it was established to do, one only has to read comments here where someone is, in reality, a bit fed up but the suggestion is to 'see your doctor'. 'The provision os social care was never part of the NHS remit, nor was dealing with a multitude of addictions, things like being too lazy to keep one's house clean is now classed, conveniently, as an illness and is dumped on the NHS.
Taxing £1 will only be paid by those who pay tax, a lot of people will escape it.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 23/12/2022 07:46

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 22/12/2022 11:56

No I doubt it. It costs 2,5 billion to run the NHS annually.

there are 32 million adults working in the uk,. So a pound is 32 million, doesn’t touch the sides.

More like £122.5 billion!!

felulageller · 23/12/2022 07:38

For a start GPs are private businesses.

We need to end them being the gatekeepers of the NHS.

We need far more self referrals.

It would be far more efficient to have people going direct to specialists.

Why don't kids here have paediatricians?

Why don't women have an OBGYN?

I don't think GPs should be doing these pieces of work. It would free up their time if they didn't.

I was shocked when I went for physio (for severe mobility issues) and I was in an open ward type room where everyone else was being seen for sports type issues I think they should be paying for privately rather than using the NHS. I can't believe people in pain, who struggle with basic movement/ functioning have to wait in NHS queue for physio behind someone actually complaining about only being able to run a half marathon not a full one or only play 20 mins of tennis not two hours.

I don't think we should be paying for fertility treatment either, unless it's something exceptional like post cancer.

KTheGrey · 23/12/2022 07:17

@Setyoufree has it. There was money enough to throw at conservative party cronies for undelivered PPE, but the NHS is not properly funded.

That said, a mixture of reforms would help. France and Germany both have compulsory employer health insurance schemes in addition to state insurance, so nothing is "free" but everything is "covered". I think it's actually unhelpful to perceive the NHS as free; people need to understand that health care is expensive so they don't miss appointments or make them for frivolous things. We should be aware that time wasting or anti social behaviour in medical settings is stealing.

In addition, @CulturePigeon is right that we expect far too much. There has to be prioritisation. Cancer pathways are supposed to be only weeks long for a reason. NICE has imo some weird ideas about what it's reasonable to fund. Puberty blockers or opposite sex hormones for under 18s should never be a question; they simply compromise health too far.

And @Fadedpicture's point about social responsibility and @upfucked's about the impact of poverty are also important. It is not the NHS which is responsible for Aawab Ishak's death; it is a lack of accountability for health standards in housing. Traffic pollution, food poverty, lack of educational opportunity have an impact on health and cost the NHS.

And yes, it's also poorly organised and its inefficiencies are expensive.

helford · 23/12/2022 06:51

user1497207191 · 22/12/2022 22:48

Medical schools are grossly oversubscribed. There’s no shortage of people with the right qualifications applying for far too few places.

@user1497207191
Again, who will train them? you know why they don't train more, there simply isn't the space and staff in hospitals for their placements.
Where do these students who don't get in to med school go on to do? who will fill these jobs if we extend med school places?

What about all the nurses and AHPs the NHS is short of?

Then there is retention in both sectors.

what i see on this & on other NHS threads is simplistic solutions with no thought to the realities or the issues.

Beneficialchampion2 · 23/12/2022 06:23

"Your first grand or so a month should be subject to no tax as it's below the personal allowance. You're basically being taxed 50% on the remainder which should be basic rate"

it pains me to see how many people do not know the rate of taxation in this country, anything over your personal allowance as a basic rate tax payer is taxed at 20%. National insurance is 12%.

Ergo 32% and not 50%...

Beneficialchampion2 · 23/12/2022 06:19

You're all looking at this from the wrong angle. The problem with the NHS is the way it is managed and structured. Throwing money at it doesn't fix the issues, it papers the cracks.

The hierarchy of staff is completely broken, too many managers with no accountability.

Structure is top top heavy.

Also the NHS is abused for what it is, too many bellends taking themselves to a doctor or A and E with a sniffle.

NumberTheory · 23/12/2022 04:48

paintitallover · 22/12/2022 23:35

I think an extra £1 would help, actually.

£1 a day for every individual in the country would be close to the £25 billion mark and would make a good difference. £1 a year from income tax payers would raise something like £35 million and wouldn’t make a noticeable difference.

Swipe left for the next trending thread