Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
Libre55 · 26/12/2022 10:43

They would just waste it. My local hospital are paying an agency £28 an hour for temp cleaning staff. The cleaners get £12.50 an hour. Pay them £15 an hour so you can retain staff! But of course it would take a time study consultant £100k to look into that and make a recommendation.

paintitallover · 26/12/2022 10:29

Like hell you'd take the risk, Xenia. It's just an I'm all right Jack approach.

felulageller · 26/12/2022 09:42

Pay their full degree including maintenance loan in exchange for a few years of service could work. Right now student nurses are effectively paying to go on placement and work for free. There's no incentive many don't feel they owe the NHS anything , paying for the degree has backfired on the government

Yes it's scandalous that students are paying to work on placements (with no employment rights!)

Verbena17 · 25/12/2022 01:10

The amount of money isn’t the problem.
It’s the often poor management allowing inconsistencies and wastage and generally not being great at managing.

The NHS has been being sold off bit by bit for decades - so many fingers in pies and Big Pharma fund universities where research takes place so there’s bribery, people on the make and all sorts.

Nothing is straight forward and not everyone involved is doing the right thing.
Obviously there many, many great people working for the NHS but sadly, it doesn’t seem that everyone is on the same page and until they are, nothing will change.

nationallampoons · 25/12/2022 01:04

An extra pound might be nothing to a lot of you, but to some it's a lot.

We're taxed enough, well the working poor are and the middles classes

anothergrievingsister · 24/12/2022 17:53

@MarshaBradyo My French friends make a modest payment ( I think this is what is called a co-pay in American terms) for using the health system. I think it is a flat fee, but if you fall below a certain income threshold you can apply to have it refunded. Or something like that. We need a French MumsNetter to share her experience

Athenen0ctua · 24/12/2022 14:41

paintitallover · 23/12/2022 11:41

@NumberTheory I would be up for paying out an extra £50p a day, or say £35 a month, as long as those on the very highest incomes should contribute an equivalent percentage of income.

I couldn't afford that. I'd be up for 1% of gross income, as long as everyone was paying 1%. Though, I think there is a lot of waste that could be cut first.

Fadedpicture · 24/12/2022 14:38

helford · 23/12/2022 13:04

To be honest nicking a nerve drawing blood isn't common, bruising perhaps, didn't you feel something at the time? they are supposed to put the needle in a vein.

A 'phone conversation with a GP is hardly inefficient and its now on your med records, maybe next time they'll read that and be more careful?
Maybe the GP will speak to the person who did the blood test?

There some very real issues with the NHS, most of which are human error and or lack of staff.... things go very wrong in the private sector too and in other countries health systems.

I don't see how anyone can expect a problem free NHS.

Yes, I did feel it at the time. The HCP was well aware of what happened, the "electric shock" made me literally jump out of the chair. She apologised and said it sometimes happens, but didn't tell me what to expect in the coming days. It ses like it should be a basic part of their training to me and would have avoided the GP telephone appointment.

GP just listened to me telling them what had happened and told me all would be fine in 6-8 weeks. Didn't ask any other questions at all. I'm sure any HCP could have done that and it would ake sense to me that the "system" and their training had them do it at the time.

mummywithtwokidsplusdog · 24/12/2022 14:24

I live in Scotland and therefore pay more tax plus NHS gets more £… the situation is just a dire here despite more money so more money isn’t the answer, in my opinion.

LexMitior · 24/12/2022 14:20

It sounds good that you could adopt a more French or German system. But, and it is a big issue, you have voters who already say that they cannot give any more. One of the reasons the NHS has such a grip on the public is the fact it is free or appears so.

If you ask British voters, at election, to make these changes, I can quite see a lot of people for whom money is not a big issue, might well accept it. For those who cannot afford more they would certainly vote to keep the situation as it is. An issue as divisive as Brexit, I think.

Tuilpmouse · 24/12/2022 13:27

@helford

Fair points... I agree, Brexit was a catastrophically stupid and expensive mistake.

Xenia · 24/12/2022 10:55

Those who do a tax return get a calculatoin showing what percentage or the income tax and NI they pay goes on the NHS. It is about 20% of your income tax/NI bill. So 20% off if we could opt out is right on that basis but the person above raises a good point as I also pay through insurance premium tax, VAT, car tax, airline duties etc into the NHS via that means, council tax perhaps even and all the rest it is may be that we should also get 20% reductoin on those other taxes too if we could opt out of the NHS.

I agree I would have to take a rsik on death from accident unless there were other arrangements in place - the UK already does treat foreigners over here either to give birh to qunituplets on the NHS - health tourism or who are simply lll wqhilst here but asks for insurance details or payment up front in many cases so we would simply extend that to those of us who opted out.

Also for that massive tax saving I would be prepared to take the risk of death as I would have duringcovid when I accepted that if the state decided those like I am who are unvaccinated would be left to die [the state did not decide that of course} and in fact at height of covid where I lived most people could not even get ambulances unless they could not say more than 2 words - 4 words and you were denied one so I am not so sure there is that much NHS care available anyway. I have also had to pay a small fortune for just about every health thing my sons have had in the last 10 years as there was no NHS cover. Pity I cannot set all those thousands against my huget tax bills.

MarshaBradyo · 24/12/2022 08:00

anothergrievingsister · 23/12/2022 18:50

@MarshaBradyo the French system is means tested and the private component is modest

Thanks. What’s the main difference to here - is it just that higher incomes pay more?

Plus a nominal fee - which could be useful but not enough imo would vote for it

helford · 24/12/2022 07:58

Tuilpmouse · 23/12/2022 22:42

@helford

But it worked relatively well for many years. What has changed? just a few years ago, social care packages could be obtained within days, now its 6 to 8 weeks.

What's changed? Quite a lot....

  1. An aging population - fewer working age adults per pensioner
  2. The ill health legacy of Covid
  3. Brexit, with the associated departure of large numbers of health and social care workers
  4. Our success in developing medical treatments that improve and save lives, but are very expensive!..... all coupled with the fact
  5. a weak economy meaning there's less tax to support health and social care

But my point was in reply to some one who said the NHS can never work.
In 2019, whilst not brilliant, it did not take 3 days to get through AE or cat 2/3 calls not responded to in a timely manner.
Social Care was ok too.

All but one of your points have happened to other european countries and they seem to be coping?

However, and i ve argued this long and hard, point no3, Brexit, its the biggest difference & explains why we alone are suffering so much more in regard to health services across Europe.

kittymu9397 · 23/12/2022 23:59

Setyoufree · 22/12/2022 11:53

Nope, they'd fritter it on waste and corruption like they do with the rest of my tax.

THIS!!!

Tuilpmouse · 23/12/2022 22:42

@helford

But it worked relatively well for many years. What has changed? just a few years ago, social care packages could be obtained within days, now its 6 to 8 weeks.

What's changed? Quite a lot....

  1. An aging population - fewer working age adults per pensioner
  2. The ill health legacy of Covid
  3. Brexit, with the associated departure of large numbers of health and social care workers
  4. Our success in developing medical treatments that improve and save lives, but are very expensive!..... all coupled with the fact
  5. a weak economy meaning there's less tax to support health and social care
helford · 23/12/2022 21:36

Isitsixoclockalready · 23/12/2022 19:33

This is by no means a dig at the OP's suggestion - more money is part of it but I think sometimes there is a tendency to look at one solution to a problem whereas it's definitely not an issue that can be solved using one method. The idea of free medical care for all, regardless of means is one that I would never want to see disappear but the health service doesn't seem fit for the challenges of today and neither does social care.

But it worked relatively well for many years.

What has changed? just a few years ago, social care packages could be obtained within days, now its 6 to 8 weeks.

helford · 23/12/2022 21:33

Haven’t rtft but one thing that other systems do is have nominal charges. It’d probably change behaviour so you have to check what impact - too many waiting longer, or more valuing what they get and not wasting time - but I don’t think any party could get voted in with it in the manifesto

When people say they want French / German do they envisage they’ll be paying more in or someone else will?

We were in France in the summer, chatting to our host and she explained the range of charges for medical services, though it is largely refunded, which does seem a waste of time and money = inefficiency.

There are also caps on what can and cannot be done, this can be quite proscriptive, her partner lost his leg, he could not get the latest prosthetics unless he paid '000s of euros - how did he lose his leg? hospital acquired infection, after a routine op - things are not always as pink n rosy as we might believe.

Isitsixoclockalready · 23/12/2022 19:33

This is by no means a dig at the OP's suggestion - more money is part of it but I think sometimes there is a tendency to look at one solution to a problem whereas it's definitely not an issue that can be solved using one method. The idea of free medical care for all, regardless of means is one that I would never want to see disappear but the health service doesn't seem fit for the challenges of today and neither does social care.

anothergrievingsister · 23/12/2022 18:50

@MarshaBradyo the French system is means tested and the private component is modest

NumberTheory · 23/12/2022 16:23

Xenia · 23/12/2022 14:16

I would rather just be allowed to opt out of the NHS and my income tax bill be 20% less.

That does rather presume the NHS is funded solely out of income tax. Which it isn’t.

Income tax is only about 20-25% of government receipts.

NumberTheory · 23/12/2022 16:22

user1497207191 · 23/12/2022 16:03

For a start, I've always thought the NHS should bill the car insurance company for the medical costs resulting from an accident. Yes, it'll increase premiums, but that's just a cost of owning/driving a vehicle. If they did that, I'm sure the private sector would start building A&E units in the bigger towns and cities where demand would warrant it.

They do.

MarshaBradyo · 23/12/2022 16:05

Haven’t rtft but one thing that other systems do is have nominal charges. It’d probably change behaviour so you have to check what impact - too many waiting longer, or more valuing what they get and not wasting time - but I don’t think any party could get voted in with it in the manifesto.

When people say they want French / German do they envisage they’ll be paying more in or someone else will?

Not sure if it’s linked to level of care or just income. I assume just income? Although private insurance here is linked to usage

user1497207191 · 23/12/2022 16:03

Augend23 · 23/12/2022 15:49

I didn't think you could get emergency care from private hospitals in the UK? They would usually transfer you to an NHS hospital if anything went wrong I thought, so I am not sure how this would work - what would happen if you were in a car crash?

For a start, I've always thought the NHS should bill the car insurance company for the medical costs resulting from an accident. Yes, it'll increase premiums, but that's just a cost of owning/driving a vehicle. If they did that, I'm sure the private sector would start building A&E units in the bigger towns and cities where demand would warrant it.

Augend23 · 23/12/2022 15:49

Xenia · 23/12/2022 14:16

I would rather just be allowed to opt out of the NHS and my income tax bill be 20% less.

I didn't think you could get emergency care from private hospitals in the UK? They would usually transfer you to an NHS hospital if anything went wrong I thought, so I am not sure how this would work - what would happen if you were in a car crash?