Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
AussiUnHomme · 28/12/2022 22:46

90% of people claim free prescriptions, including some people who have paracetamol or ibuprofen on prescription.

Maybe if more people paid for them, and didn't claim what are very cheap drugs, then that might be a start.

But tbh the whole system is a bureaucratic mess.

notimagain · 28/12/2022 22:29

@MarshaBradyo

Hi

If most is picked up by insurer would you say you’re paying in more overall than in U.K.? For similar income level (no need to disclose obvs)
Probably hard to compare.

I had seen your question, gave it some thought and you are right, it's hard to objectively compare so I might have to "pass"..sorry.

XingMing · 28/12/2022 20:27

Perhaps the private servicing companies are quicker and more responsive to requests for equipment. I realise that it's anathema to anyone under 40, but there were reasons that whole industries were privatised in the 80s and 90s. I see posters seeking the renationalisation of the railways, and I know they are under 35. British Rail managed demand for services by pricing demand off the railway. I was explicitly told this by a senior British Rail executive. I probably still have the taped recording.

helford · 28/12/2022 17:54

user1497207191 · 28/12/2022 15:10

@helford

Many complain about inefficiencies in the NHS, so we have a £xx charge for various services, then claim it back - how admin heavy (costly) is that?

Each NHS trust already has an army of pen pushers doing exactly that. It's the "internal market" where everything is "charged" for by the provider to the trust and the trust claims (or uses grants) from the Govt to pay them.

It's also exactly like that for dentists, pharmacists, opticians, etc., who charge the patient £x and the NHS £y for NHS services/items.

Our local NHS trust has an office block called the "business centre" where all this happens.

Extending it to patients paying for more things really shouldn't be much of an issue as the infrastructure etc is already in place and has been for decades now.

You'd just be basically extending the existing systems used by dentists, opticians and pharmacies to other areas of the NHS.

But we don't pay up front and then claim back do we?

On labour and the NHS, well Labour did form the NHS and they seem to genuinely value it, i ve yet to find books written by Labour MPs wanting to get rid of it.

The Cons on the other hand say they value it but do the opposite, as you say large parts are privatised via the internal market which seems to get bigger and bigger, even our local trust uses a privatised company to "sell" them medical aids such as wheelchairs and crutches.

SleeplessInEngland · 28/12/2022 15:15

user1497207191 · 28/12/2022 15:11

Cross party reform will never happen. Both main parties use the NHS for political purposes at every General Election, arguable Labour are worse, so Labour will never give up the NHS as an electioneering bargaining chip.

Labour aren't worse, whatever that means, they just recognise the NHS is popular and seems to strain under long tory governments. Of course it's political, how could it not be.

SleeplessInEngland · 28/12/2022 15:12

nomoneyno · 22/12/2022 11:55

If anything they should reduce tax. We are taxed far too much in this country

Compared to where? Not the rest of the continent we live on, that's for sure.

user1497207191 · 28/12/2022 15:11

Zebedee55 · 28/12/2022 13:51

The NHS needs reform. Endlessly chucking money at it never has improved much over many decades.

Ideally, a cross party reform.

Cross party reform will never happen. Both main parties use the NHS for political purposes at every General Election, arguable Labour are worse, so Labour will never give up the NHS as an electioneering bargaining chip.

user1497207191 · 28/12/2022 15:10

@helford

Many complain about inefficiencies in the NHS, so we have a £xx charge for various services, then claim it back - how admin heavy (costly) is that?

Each NHS trust already has an army of pen pushers doing exactly that. It's the "internal market" where everything is "charged" for by the provider to the trust and the trust claims (or uses grants) from the Govt to pay them.

It's also exactly like that for dentists, pharmacists, opticians, etc., who charge the patient £x and the NHS £y for NHS services/items.

Our local NHS trust has an office block called the "business centre" where all this happens.

Extending it to patients paying for more things really shouldn't be much of an issue as the infrastructure etc is already in place and has been for decades now.

You'd just be basically extending the existing systems used by dentists, opticians and pharmacies to other areas of the NHS.

helford · 28/12/2022 13:54

Many complain about inefficiencies in the NHS, so we have a £xx charge for various services, then claim it back - how admin heavy (costly) is that?
Or we operate an exemptions system but that hits people just above the cut offs.

We need a long term fully funded plan, on equipment buildings and staff - can't happen though because one party wants rid and the other doesn't.

But until we get this, we will be forever throwing money at firefighting short term fixes and Cons under funding when they are in and Labour trying to fix the issues when they get in.

Tories also need to own the mess the NHS is in, they have been in power for much of the last 75 years and gave us Brexit which has led directly to less care and health staff.

Zebedee55 · 28/12/2022 13:51

The NHS needs reform. Endlessly chucking money at it never has improved much over many decades.

Ideally, a cross party reform.

scaredoff · 28/12/2022 13:44

But we get what we vote for.
The people who voted for this can own it, 100% their fault, they 'knew what they voted for'.

But the problem appears to be, they can't.

"It's just as bad in other countries!" (not)

"It was just as bad under Labour!" (not)

"It can never work because it never has!" (not)

MarshaBradyo · 28/12/2022 13:15

On charges generally, I’m not sure. The points below make sense but other countries do have them.

Many posts praising other systems but often the thing they have in common is a charge.

maddening · 28/12/2022 12:55

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 22/12/2022 11:56

No I doubt it. It costs 2,5 billion to run the NHS annually.

there are 32 million adults working in the uk,. So a pound is 32 million, doesn’t touch the sides.

www.kingsfund.org.uk/audio-video/key-facts-figures-nhs

It costs 192 billion to run the nhs (and this is 2019 data so it is likely more now)

If this 2019 figure was split equally between the 32million tax payers then it would be £6000 a year each.

MarshaBradyo · 28/12/2022 12:52

notimagain · 26/12/2022 11:38

It depends on what service you are using. I’m not a “frequent flyer” anymore so most of the hospital stuff listed below is from memory and is indicative.

A GP’s appointment costs currently I think a flat fee of €25.

A Consultation at your local hospital might (depends on circumstances) cost in the region of €50.

Most other services (e.g. MRI/CT scans, lab test) will attract at least some sort of charge though it’s often a very notional amount (region of €50 ish or less for a “scan”).

In-patients hospital stay will see you charged a notional B&B fee of maybe €10-20 euro a night - that’s for a single room, cleaned top to bottom each day and good food…….

Good news most of the above can be claimed back of your insurer, there is a safety net for the low paid and for long term conditions such as cancer etc you may well be exempted from most of the charges - the State picks up the bill.

Ok thanks for breakdown

If most is picked up by insurer would you say you’re paying in more overall than in U.K.? For similar income level (no need to disclose obvs)

Probably hard to compare.

I’m wondering when people say French system is better wjo is paying more generally to make it so. I’m assuming those on higher income pay more than we do? Maybe middle income too.

It also might be possible to make changes to same fee level without structure change to insurance system etc

But people need to know fee changes. It’s a bit opaque - what would be required

user1497207191 · 28/12/2022 12:52

Kendodd · 28/12/2022 12:42

I'm against a pay per GP visit, reasons below -

Extra admin cost.
If it mirrors prescription charges, vast majority would be except anyway so minimal money raised.
The only people who would have to pay are NOT necessarily the poorest, plenty of people who needed a doctor, then couldn't afford to see one.
If A&E remained free, people would just go there.
Rich pensioners wouldn't pay.
The people who do have to pay are already the ones funding public services, if they are then the only people excluded form free access to those services, resentment builds.
Payment has worked out so well in dentistry (not).

Yep, fully agree with that chain of thought. It'd be just yet another "tax on workers". Like the suggestion of fines for missing GP appointments, with the add on throwaway comment of "of course certain groups would be exempt such as OAPs, those on certain benefits, etc". So what's the point?

I'd really, really, want to see some proper, audited, figures showing the numbers of appointments missed, broken down into age groups, workers, benefit claimants, and reasons for missed appointments, and then we could see exactly who is missing appointments and why, as a starting point before fines.

Exactly the same would apply to GP appointment charges. We need transparency as to who would pay, who'd be exempt, etc., before even thinking of going there. The last thing workers need is yet another tax on working. I'd be more keen on means testing based on total income/total savings rather than the lazy method of looking at wages only.

Kendodd · 28/12/2022 12:48

helford · 24/12/2022 07:58

But my point was in reply to some one who said the NHS can never work.
In 2019, whilst not brilliant, it did not take 3 days to get through AE or cat 2/3 calls not responded to in a timely manner.
Social Care was ok too.

All but one of your points have happened to other european countries and they seem to be coping?

However, and i ve argued this long and hard, point no3, Brexit, its the biggest difference & explains why we alone are suffering so much more in regard to health services across Europe.

I agree.
But we get what we vote for.
The people who voted for this can own it, 100% their fault, they 'knew what they voted for'.

Kendodd · 28/12/2022 12:42

I'm against a pay per GP visit, reasons below -

Extra admin cost.
If it mirrors prescription charges, vast majority would be except anyway so minimal money raised.
The only people who would have to pay are NOT necessarily the poorest, plenty of people who needed a doctor, then couldn't afford to see one.
If A&E remained free, people would just go there.
Rich pensioners wouldn't pay.
The people who do have to pay are already the ones funding public services, if they are then the only people excluded form free access to those services, resentment builds.
Payment has worked out so well in dentistry (not).

user1497207191 · 28/12/2022 12:32

XingMing · 28/12/2022 12:18

I read this morning that GPs in France are planning a strike to demand the consultation fee goes up to €50.

It's not unreasonable, but the availability and quality of appointments would have to improve. People aren't going to be happy to pay £50 to be fobbed off and then have to go back 2 or 3 more times before they get proper treatment.

I'd compare it to a recent consultation we had with a vet. She was absolutely hopeless, clearly didn't know anything about the pet we took to her and basically just prescribed a bottle of antibiotics (but she'd already said there were no signs of an infection). We complained to the manager and got an appointment with a different vet who had experience with our kind of animal and got a proper diagnosis and treatment plan. Then they tried to charge us for the second consultation too. Needless to say, we refused to pay twice when one consultation was useless. GPs need to be aware of the need to be able to provide "value for money" if they want to charge their patients directly, which I think will be quite a culture shock for many of them.

helford · 28/12/2022 12:30

XingMing · 28/12/2022 12:18

I read this morning that GPs in France are planning a strike to demand the consultation fee goes up to €50.

The GPs’ demands include:
A €30 payment per consultation, rather than the €25 paid today
A €60 payment for older people, or those who are suffering from a long-term condition
More doctors and resources to avoid time pressures and too many patients per doctor.

Though what that has to do on a thread about paying more into the NHS i don't know.

notimagain · 28/12/2022 12:30

XingMing · 28/12/2022 12:18

I read this morning that GPs in France are planning a strike to demand the consultation fee goes up to €50.

I think many already “en greve”, AFAIK ends next week.

There are multiple gripes, one of which is they reckon €25 per consultation often doesn’t cover associated costs…

poetryandwine · 28/12/2022 12:27

Interesting, @XingMing Hardly extortionate if those on low incomes continue to be protected, but more detail would be interesting. At the moment the French standard of care suggests to me that this could be worthwhile

XingMing · 28/12/2022 12:18

I read this morning that GPs in France are planning a strike to demand the consultation fee goes up to €50.

scaredoff · 26/12/2022 15:45

Libre55 · 26/12/2022 10:43

They would just waste it. My local hospital are paying an agency £28 an hour for temp cleaning staff. The cleaners get £12.50 an hour. Pay them £15 an hour so you can retain staff! But of course it would take a time study consultant £100k to look into that and make a recommendation.

If the hospital employs the cleaners directly, it will have to pay them sick pay, holiday pay, employers' NI contributions and God knows what else. It will also probably be subject to greater union involvement with implications for how staff are employed, what various staff can and can't do etc.

You can't simply compare an hourly rate when signing someone up to an in-house contract of employment, with an hourly rate paid to an agency for self-employed contractors. It's meaningless. If you want to talk about the waste involved in how capitalism syphons off profits generated by workers to a parasitic non-working elite then I'm all ears, but given that NHS trusts along with everyone else have to work within the capitalist system we have (and that most people here seem to be arguing for MORE of), they'll sometimes find that contracting out services is the most efficient way to do that.

Someone will have done the sums to compare the two solutions, taking into account all these factors and probably a hundred others I haven't thought of, and decided that it's financially better to contract out the service. But of course that person will be a "manager" (oooh . . . BAD!!!) and the NHS shouldn't have any of those. Just because it's the biggest employer in the country coordinating a mind-bogglingly complex set of processes with very serious consequences for failure, doesn't mean you actually need people who understand complex financial matters to run it.

Herein lies the NHS's problem: they waste all their budget employing people to make these calculations and decisions, when they should just ask the Armchair Accountants Of Mumsnet!

notimagain · 26/12/2022 11:38

anothergrievingsister · 24/12/2022 17:53

@MarshaBradyo My French friends make a modest payment ( I think this is what is called a co-pay in American terms) for using the health system. I think it is a flat fee, but if you fall below a certain income threshold you can apply to have it refunded. Or something like that. We need a French MumsNetter to share her experience

It depends on what service you are using. I’m not a “frequent flyer” anymore so most of the hospital stuff listed below is from memory and is indicative.

A GP’s appointment costs currently I think a flat fee of €25.

A Consultation at your local hospital might (depends on circumstances) cost in the region of €50.

Most other services (e.g. MRI/CT scans, lab test) will attract at least some sort of charge though it’s often a very notional amount (region of €50 ish or less for a “scan”).

In-patients hospital stay will see you charged a notional B&B fee of maybe €10-20 euro a night - that’s for a single room, cleaned top to bottom each day and good food…….

Good news most of the above can be claimed back of your insurer, there is a safety net for the low paid and for long term conditions such as cancer etc you may well be exempted from most of the charges - the State picks up the bill.

helford · 26/12/2022 11:08

Libre55 · 26/12/2022 10:43

They would just waste it. My local hospital are paying an agency £28 an hour for temp cleaning staff. The cleaners get £12.50 an hour. Pay them £15 an hour so you can retain staff! But of course it would take a time study consultant £100k to look into that and make a recommendation.

They would certainly waste it if they did what you suggest.

For starters, cleaners are rarely employed directly by the NHS and if they did employ directly with a hourly rate of £15 ph, they would earn more than most Nurses or Physios.

The NHS has been underfunded for decades (compared to EU health services) for many years and the monies it does get are used inefficiently, to fire fight and sticking plaster reforms that do not address underlying problems.

It needs a 15 or 25 y plan with guaranteed funding year on year.

Incidentally, where are the 40 new hospitals the Tories promised?