Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
UthredofBattenberg · 22/12/2022 12:33

I think we need to pay more, but I also think we need to reassess what the NHS is used for. I think there needs to be some difficult conversations about what is essential NHS use and what isn't.

It's used for so much much more now than when it started, treatments are more expensive, people are living longer and expecting more to be covered.

I also think they need to put money into elderly care, something for those who are too ill to go home and too well to be in hospital. But also, as people are living longer, health becomes more complicated and multiple issues arise. I think thats the issue they need to address as a priority, is care of the elderly population.

neverbeenskiing · 22/12/2022 12:31

I would happily pay more tax if I had any faith that it would be spent on health, social care and other vital public services. I don't, unfortunately. Our Chancellor co-authored a book calling for the NHS to be dismantled and replaced with private health insurance. Any increase in taxation under this government will not be used to protect or improve a system many in government are ideologically opposed to and have never had to depend on. It will be used to feather the nests of the already rich and powerful and to fund callous, half-baked and discriminatory schemes like the Rwanda plan they've already sunk £140 million into.

AlcoholFear · 22/12/2022 12:29

I have no idea if it would be enough. Surely it would have to be on going? I don’t pay tax as I’m a student (will graduate as a vet in the summer providing I pass exams) but even now I’d be happy to pay something if it would make a difference

MolesOnPoles · 22/12/2022 12:29

I’ve just had the same blood test four times. The first three times it wasn’t processed because they wrote the name on the label wrong, then sent it to the wrong team, then left the top off the sample (!) for too long.

Each time they repeated it will have cost money.

The answer isn’t to throw more money into this shambles.

Lorrymum · 22/12/2022 12:28

It wouldn't make any difference, the NHS is a money pit. So much waste, both time and money.

SupernovaCharlotte · 22/12/2022 12:28

It wouldn’t solve it. There needs to be a massive review and overhaul. Opinions within need to shift so that we are not paying £50 for a lightbulb because it’s easier and requires no thought.

Last week I had a phone call to arrange an urgent appointment with a consultant, bringing another one forward. All agreed on the phone with the medical secretary. Today, after the appointment had taken place I received two letters, one cancelling the original appointment and another confirming the appointment that has already taken place. Those letters are a drop in the ocean but reflective of the massive inefficiencies on the system.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 22/12/2022 12:28

Nope.

Anyway the whole NHS needs an overhaul.

Both my son's have inherited a blood disorder and it doesn't manifest until around 7 or 8 yes old.
The child immunology dept want to see them both at least once a year and with some phone appointments in between.

This is totally not required! It's a complete waste of a consultants time.
If they are doing this for every child I can imagine the wasteage is monumental

XingMing · 22/12/2022 12:25

What health care and doctors could cure in 1947 was very limited. The NHS has increased life expectancy enormously, but not healthy life expectancy. A lot of that is in our own hands to turn around.

The day is coming when there will have to be a cross-party agreement as to whether the NHS in its present form can be preserved, and if not what is worth saving and how it should be re-designed and how it can be paid for. Difficult policy questions need answering.

GPs should be paid by the number of patient appointments they perform, not the number of patients registered with the practice. Patients, except children, should pay a fairly nominal sum for every appointment at the GP or A&E. Not every possible treatment should be available on the NHS.

HCPs should be trained in greater numbers, without fees and with bursaries, but in return should be required to serve the NHS for 1.5x their training duration.

Nap1983 · 22/12/2022 12:24

I’m an NHS nurse… there is nothing on this planet that could save it…

Augend23 · 22/12/2022 12:23

A single local hospital will have a budget of £400 million plus. So I don't think £32 million annually would make much of a debt honestly.

I also think that what we actually need to do is massively increase the number of people training - at the moment I just don't think money fixes the problem.

showmethedata · 22/12/2022 12:23

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 22/12/2022 11:56

No I doubt it. It costs 2,5 billion to run the NHS annually.

there are 32 million adults working in the uk,. So a pound is 32 million, doesn’t touch the sides.

£608,000,000,000 (£608 billion) allowed for the NHS in 2021.

If 32 million taxpayers each paid £1 that's £32,000,000. Sounds a lot but it's a drop in the bucket.

Every baby born will cost the NHS at least £7,000.
Hip replacement around £10,000.
I know someone who was badly brain-damaged in an accident and has already been looked after in a high-level care unit paid for by taxpayers for 12 years. He is only 47 now and they expect him to make it to 70+. He spent nearly a year on a high dependency ward before being transferred to a specialist care home. He's cost the NHS millions and has another 20 years to go.

Southwig22 · 22/12/2022 12:23

Unfortunately it would be a drop in the ocean.

We need reform of the NHS, funding arrangements and a new government and even then it'll be a hard slog.

Notreallyhappy · 22/12/2022 12:22

It bigger than that.. there's plenty of people.making money from.the nhs. It's not run as a business where in these tough times big decisions need to be made.
People I know work in the nhs on many sides..an ambulance comes in for a refit, so we'll dump the entire contents and buy new £40k...not sensible use of resources..
I expect some would rather pay less and go private maybe there should be an option in future

Lostinalibrary · 22/12/2022 12:21

Hereward1332 · 22/12/2022 12:13

How about incentivising people not to use the NHS - allow private health insurance to be tax-deductible. Annual cost in lost tax revenue for a family of 4 would be around £1000. While it's skewed, public spending on health services for a family of 4 is around £8000.

This is a good point. We have private health care as part of my husband’s work package. He pays tax on that on top of the ridiculous tax he pays already at 45%.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:18

Another unpopular view but we need to get away from the idea that people have the right to be fat/eat badly/do no exercise/smoke etc etc and expect the NHS to fix all the problems it causes.

There needs to be some sort of nudge campaign away from the idea that it's normal for a huge % of the population to be overweight/obese. People voted for Brexit for an extra £350m pe for the NHS (haha) but what would a population who took some responsibility for their own health save it?

Hereward1332 · 22/12/2022 12:13

How about incentivising people not to use the NHS - allow private health insurance to be tax-deductible. Annual cost in lost tax revenue for a family of 4 would be around £1000. While it's skewed, public spending on health services for a family of 4 is around £8000.

Lostinalibrary · 22/12/2022 12:12

entropynow · 22/12/2022 12:00

Rubbish. We have low taxation compared to many countries with decent public services and welfare provision.
But what you actually mean is "I don't give a shit about my fellow citizens, just my money". Bet you use public services yourself though because that's different innit.

We actually aren’t. Not when you consider higher bands, NI, VAT, council tax etc. It’s all designed to keep the headline rate low. We are a low pay, high tax country for very little return.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 12:12

keepaweatheredeye · 22/12/2022 12:05

£5 a month would give almost £2 billion.

I'd happily pay that. Happily. I'd pay double that if I knew it was going to front line services.

Maybe we should crowdfund!!

The NHS budget is 133 BILLION per year. An extra 2 billion will hardly touch the sides - it's only 1.5%!

Blair/Brown increased NIC twice "to save the nhs", but it clearly didn't work! Hence the recent further increase in NIC!

You'd need everyone to pay £5 per month extra, each year, i.e. £10 extra in year 2, and so on, ON TOP of normal increases in tax/nic on wage rises, etc.

Where does it stop? How many years do you want to pay an extra £5 per week on top of all the other extra £5 per week you've paid in previous years? After 10 years, that's £50 per week, after 20 years, it's £100 per week.

That's probably what's needed without radical reform, but is Joe Taxpayer happy to keep paying more and more and more for it?

Lostinalibrary · 22/12/2022 12:09

No because nearly half of the adults in this country don’t pay income tax and are economically inactive.

The elephant in the room is - those who’ve “paid in all their lives” didn’t pay in enough to sustain the state as is. Now the younger generations are paying more to subsidise and it will get worse. It’s all unsustainable.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 22/12/2022 12:07

I don't think it's lack of money that's killing the NHS.

The NHS can no longer cope with giving free care to people, as the care we expect and can be provided has changed so much: Elderly care, as we no longer look after our elderly parents and people live an extra decade, but that final decade is spent in poor health. Lots of lifestyle illnesses due to smoking, alcohol and sedentary lifestyles Research and technology has resulted in treatment for diseases that would have killed us back in the day, like type 1 diabetes, kidney disease and cancer.

I believe the main way we can ease the burden is by healthy people looking after our bodies as best we can and not getting complacent about the fact that abusing the gift of health will automatically get us new knees, livers, cancer treatments, metformin, BP tablets, mobility scooters, gastric bypasses. We take the NHS for granted. Everyone should receive a virtual bill when they leave, that lets them know how much their treatment would have cost if they had paid.

That way the NHS could spend its time and energy on the deserving people who have become unwell or were born unwell through no fault of their own.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:07

I also think we need to start looking at what, realistically the NHS can and can't do. There would have to be some unpopular choices but should things like fertility treatment, gender realignment, even maybe sporting injuries, be dealt with by the NHS? Perfect world, of course they should, but when resources will always be insufficient to do everything?

dementedma · 22/12/2022 12:05

I pay quite enough tax in Scotland thanks

keepaweatheredeye · 22/12/2022 12:05

£5 a month would give almost £2 billion.

I'd happily pay that. Happily. I'd pay double that if I knew it was going to front line services.

Maybe we should crowdfund!!

billyt · 22/12/2022 12:04

I was more than happy to pay the extra NI payment knowing it would be ring-fenced (supposedly)

When that was removed I was surprised.

But I do agree that it seems there are more managers who don't actual have the ability to help people get better, and just create yet another level of admin for users to wade through.

TreadLight · 22/12/2022 12:04

No matter how much money we throw at the NHS, it will never be fixed. With a free at the point of delivery health service, there will be infinite demand for services while the ability to service that demand is limited by the money available.

Rather than throwing ever more money at the NHS and the people working for it, we need to define when it has achieved its objectives. It could be an average life expectancy of, say, 83. It could be a limit on the number of sick days taken by the working population. It could be any number of things. Only when the NHS can be successful against a clear goal, can it spend money on the niceties.

Otherwise you will have one person having a spar experience while having a hip operation, while someone else just doesn't get their cataracts fixed.

But just giving the NHS more money without it having an achievable goal will simply make matters worse.