Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
LexMitior · 22/12/2022 13:02

The other thing is the medicalisation of being old. Our bodies do fail. The NHS is not social care, and you can see the drift back to what used to happen, which is care of the old by the family except in cases of severe demantia.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:00

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 12:57

Personal responsibility is a huge aspect of NHS care. In other public health systems this is explicitly dealt with and you can expect to have to deal with lifestyle issues. That is the implicit deal.

My prediction is that lifestyle issues, relative to say, obesity, smoking, alcohol, drugs, sport, will increasingly be contracted out. You will be expected to deal with these issues yourself in terms of healthy eating, giving up vaping or smoking, receiving physio etc.

It is an obvious way to reduce the service without not providing critical or acute care.

I fully agree, especially in terms of telling people with lifestyle related health issues to do something about it themselves. Unfortunately, as we regularly see in the media, people complain when a doctor or nurse points out that they are overweight and suggests healthy lifestyle choices! So many healthcare professionals either don't mention the blindingly obvious or pussyfoot around skirting the issue. Some hard truths need to be told and if the patient doesn't like what they're being told, then tough!

EngTech · 22/12/2022 13:00

Any extra revenue raised would be lost into a general coffer plus admin charges would dilute any additional funding to the NHS 😔😳

LlynTegid · 22/12/2022 13:00

Start with windfall taxes at a proper level for oil companies, and then large tech companies paying a reasonable share of tax.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 13:00

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 12:59

This case is probably extreme, but how many excess hours are being paid because people fancy a bit of extra cash and how many are genuinely needed?
And again, what utter rubbish. Only staff band 7 and below get extra money for extra hours. They are not top managers! They usually only do so when their staff levels are low and the service is making a saving from the reduced staff level anyway!

I didn't say top managers....

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 12:59

This case is probably extreme, but how many excess hours are being paid because people fancy a bit of extra cash and how many are genuinely needed?
And again, what utter rubbish. Only staff band 7 and below get extra money for extra hours. They are not top managers! They usually only do so when their staff levels are low and the service is making a saving from the reduced staff level anyway!

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:58

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 12:52

DH had a long period of illness before his death, multiple hospital appointments, a letter sent to confirm each one, at a cost of what, £1 each for just the stationery and stamps, let alone the time. Now, people working in the system will tell me why it can't support any electronic communication, but it should
Posts like this make me laugh. It shows how the average person in this country has absolutely no clue how the NHS is run, the issues it faces, and the scale of these.

The biggest cost to the NHS is diabetes and associated health issues. We are talking about one billion pounds a year, close to half of the full costs of the NHS. And you mention a £1 letter!
To clarify, many efficiencies have been introduced such as reducing letters when appropriate except that this sadly leads to more appointments missed and a higher cost. This still is nothing compared to the savings the NHS made if we tackled the obesity crisis, something that the majority of people could manage themselves.

No, I mention what I imagine are several million £1 letters every year. And it's just one example of one inefficiency. Plus, it's not £1, it's £1 plus the staff costs of sending them out.

But I have also said people taking responsibility for their own health is a bigger issue.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 12:58

@vivainsomnia

The biggest cost to the NHS is diabetes and associated health issues. We are talking about one billion pounds a year, close to half of the full costs of the NHS.

Your figures are wrong. One billion pounds isn't anywhere near half the full costs of the NHS! A quick google suggests it costs 10 billion which is less than 10 percent of the costs of the NHS. Still a lot, but nothing like half!

strawberriesarenot · 22/12/2022 12:58

How do other countries with comparable economies manage? France, or Germany?
How do they deal with care of the very elderly, who can't manage independantly?

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 12:57

Personal responsibility is a huge aspect of NHS care. In other public health systems this is explicitly dealt with and you can expect to have to deal with lifestyle issues. That is the implicit deal.

My prediction is that lifestyle issues, relative to say, obesity, smoking, alcohol, drugs, sport, will increasingly be contracted out. You will be expected to deal with these issues yourself in terms of healthy eating, giving up vaping or smoking, receiving physio etc.

It is an obvious way to reduce the service without not providing critical or acute care.

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 12:57

The basic idea behind this is sound: that the government could, if it wanted to, increase the overall tax burden and spend it on fixing the NHS. However (1) as pp have pointed out, £1 per UK tax payer per year wouldn't raise nearly enough. (Personally I'd be willing to pay considerably more than that, but then you enter into a much more difficult political argument). And (2) given the huge and increasing inequality of UK society and the proximity of many lower paid people to the breadline already, there's no reason why such an increased burden should be a flat tax such as £1 per person. The money that has disappeared from public services over the last 12 years has gone somewhere - that is, there are sections of society that have gotten wealthier as everyone else has gotten poorer. I'd rather see the government reverse that process.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 12:56

DH was working as an external consultant with the NHS for years. He has recently pulled out as he can't cope any longer
At the same time, you do have consultants, who were let off from NHS roles for incompetence, who redesign themselves as consultants, demands massive amount of pay (one got close to 2 millions for less than 3 years), who come with made up ideas of how the organisation's can improved, things that had already been tested and failed, bully staff to change their ways in unfavourable ways, leading to chaos, at which point, they go and start again elsewhere whilst making a fortune. Not all, of course, but sadly too many who are in it just for the money.

Lostinalibrary · 22/12/2022 12:56

Also, procurement in the public sector is an absolute con. Procurement managers paid an absolute fortune to source basic components from “approved suppliers” which also cost a fortune. All that needs sorting first.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:54

I was talking to a friend who's a middle manager in the NHS. She works crazy hours, 12 hours days plus at least one day at the weekend. I'm all sympathetic thinking that's no way to live and no one should be working like that, but no, she does it by choice, for the money because she's saving to move house. She gets paid enhanced overtime rates for every hour she does and turns up regardless of whether there's an operational need or not.

Now, I'm not in favour of anyone doing unpaid work, but I don't know any manager in the private sector who gets overtime for additional hours and lower ranked staff who do get additional pay will only get those hours when there a genuine and pre approved need.

This case is probably extreme, but how many excess hours are being paid because people fancy a bit of extra cash and how many are genuinely needed?

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 12:52

DH had a long period of illness before his death, multiple hospital appointments, a letter sent to confirm each one, at a cost of what, £1 each for just the stationery and stamps, let alone the time. Now, people working in the system will tell me why it can't support any electronic communication, but it should
Posts like this make me laugh. It shows how the average person in this country has absolutely no clue how the NHS is run, the issues it faces, and the scale of these.

The biggest cost to the NHS is diabetes and associated health issues. We are talking about one billion pounds a year, close to half of the full costs of the NHS. And you mention a £1 letter!
To clarify, many efficiencies have been introduced such as reducing letters when appropriate except that this sadly leads to more appointments missed and a higher cost. This still is nothing compared to the savings the NHS made if we tackled the obesity crisis, something that the majority of people could manage themselves.

KnittedCardi · 22/12/2022 12:51

DH was working as an external consultant with the NHS for years. He has recently pulled out as he can't cope any longer. It is a behemoth. Creaking and stuck with a model no longer sustainable in the 21st century. What you have to remember is that "the NHS" really isn't a contiguous blob. Government set budgets, NHS England set frameworks, and trusts deliver the care. It is the trusts that actually make local decisions, as they should, it makes sense to respond to local needs. HOWEVER, some trusts are literally shit. They are run really badly, have terrible outcomes, some come to court, as we see often. DH can name and shame a handful of badly run trusts, and those are always the ones in the news. And yet, still, those Trust leaders are kept in post, or shuffled off somewhere else, to do the same in another trust. There is very little consequence for failure in the NHS. Jobs for life and all that.

Well run trusts, are just that, well run. Open to new ideas, new technology, new ways of running a modern system. It can be done.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 12:48

@XingMing

GPs should be paid by the number of patient appointments they perform, not the number of patients registered with the practice.

Absolutely. It's no wonder they don't make appointments available when they get paid anyway. They definitely need to be paid for what they do, not number of patients they may or may not see. It would also solve the problem of them claiming for people who've died, moved abroad, registered with more than one surgery, etc.

BMW6 · 22/12/2022 12:48

Nope, it's unsustainable in its present form, needs a complete and absolute reincarnation and run by people who know how to manage it efficiently financially and by medical need.

I agree with PP that the Public must have some accountability also. I think if you are taken to hospital because you are pissed you should be charged a sum for your treatment. Same if you smoke
No IVF, Obesity or gender reassignment surgery for free.

Some really tough decisions must be made and it won't be easy but is absolutely essential

ShimmeringShirts · 22/12/2022 12:47

Nope, I’m not willing to pay extra tax. The NHS needs completely scrapped and rebuilt from scratch.

Georgeskitchen · 22/12/2022 12:45

The NHS is not underfunded. It's just very badly managed. If they can pay 115 grand for a "director of lived experience " then I'm.sorry but they ain't anywhere on there arses!!

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:45

MardyMincepie · 22/12/2022 12:43

@Fadedpicture you are of course correct about personal responsibility but people get really irrational if it’s even mentioned.

I know, that's why I feel a nudge campaign is needed. It used to be OK to drink and drive and now the vast majority would see that as abhorrent. Anti smoking campaigns have made a big difference too. This needs to be the next one IMO, it is possible to bring change.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 12:44

@Fadedpicture

I also think too much is left until it's bad enough before the NHS will treat, which means expensive or long term treatment when they do. E.g DS had an infected ingrown toenail. NHS don't operate on in grown toenails, here's some antibiotics, but it will keep recurring. So I got it done privately, £40. Left to the NHS DS would have been having regular GP appointments and prescriptions indefinitely, all for the want of a £40 procedure.

Our DS finally got his ingrown toe nail treated by podiatry after 6 months of GP appointments. He kept getting told to do salt baths, prescribed creams, etc., and inevitably it got infected and he needed antibiotics. I've had ingrown toe nails (twice) myself and the only thing that worked was their removal, so I knew the GP surgery were just wasting time by not referring! We kept asking them to refer but just got excuse after excuse, the best being that "podiatry have a 12 month waiting list!" In reality, after referral, he had his consultation within 2 weeks and minor surgery the following week - they said they didn't even have a waiting list and were calling people for appointments the day the referral letter from the GP arrived!

MardyMincepie · 22/12/2022 12:43

@Fadedpicture you are of course correct about personal responsibility but people get really irrational if it’s even mentioned.

Purplechicken207 · 22/12/2022 12:37

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:03

I honestly don't think the problem with the NHS is money. It's definitely not the only problem. It's almost had too much money so there's been no need to develop efficiency.

For example. DH had a long period of illness before his death, multiple hospital appointments, a letter sent to confirm each one, at a cost of what, £1 each for just the stationery and stamps, let alone the time. Now, people working in the system will tell me why it can't support any electronic communication, but it should.

My GP surgery's telephone are constantly engaged. You have to ring to get blood test results which must be many calls everyday. I have suggested they just email them all routinely. A member of staff could do it in one batch, much more efficient then taking all those calls and it would take pressure of their phone system, but no it can't be done. Maybe the system as it is can't do it, but there must be a way, there's just no will to change or improve things

I also think too much is left until it's bad enough before the NHS will treat, which means expensive or long term treatment when they do. E.g DS had an infected ingrown toenail. NHS don't operate on in grown toenails, here's some antibiotics, but it will keep recurring. So I got it done privately, £40. Left to the NHS DS would have been having regular GP appointments and prescriptions indefinitely, all for the want of a £40 procedure.

It needs a complete overhaul, not more cash thrown at a broken system.

I recently had a letter requesting we go paperless, which I agreed to. I get text reminders (unless hospital appointment) and use the mychart system which pings all blood tests and medical letters to you - you get an email asking you to log in. I've also recently downloaded the NHS app and just waiting for the GP to link my childrens accounts and then I should have access to the 3 of us in there too. So it's certainly doable in some areas/with some demographics. But I know for a fact my grandma wouldn't/couldn't use the technology to allow for that. So it would need to be a hybrid system, but I totally agree there should be significantly fewer pieces of paper, and systems (like release of results) should be automated as much as possible. I've set up new systems like that in other industries in past jobs, it's a long hard process with much testing needed, and a lot of upfront expenditure, but over time pays for itself.
Tons more needed or course, but this is one of those areas that can remove a lot of tedium

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 12:33

@CinnamonJellyBeans

I believe the main way we can ease the burden is by healthy people looking after our bodies as best we can and not getting complacent about the fact that abusing the gift of health will automatically get us new knees, livers, cancer treatments, metformin, BP tablets, mobility scooters, gastric bypasses. We take the NHS for granted. Everyone should receive a virtual bill when they leave, that lets them know how much their treatment would have cost if they had paid.

Yes, indeed, far too many people don't care about the damage they do their bodies and don't lead a healthy lifestyle at all. I don't think they intentionally do it because they expect the NHS to "cure" them, but they just don't think of the consequences. I really don't think many people will think "stuff it, I'm going to smoke like a chimney because the NHS will provide me with an oxygen mask". I think it's more that people just don't think of consequences any more, i.e. re health, dangerous sports, dangerous driving, etc. No sane person would intentionally damage themselves just because treatment was available.

As for a virtual bill, I'd be against that kind of thing as it just creates more layers of bureaucracy and there'll be doubts as to the reliability of the figures as there are different ways of working out costs, i.e. marginal costing, absorption costing, etc. We already have crazy figures for things like calling out a fire engine which aren't transparent as to what's included, and the old "lie" about raising a purchase order costing £40 when in reality the marginal cost is just a couple of pounds, but using absorbtion costing (inc the building, admin, management, equipment, etc it's much more). The general public can't understand the nuances of cost accounting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread