Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
KnittedCardi · 22/12/2022 13:17

The majority of GP appointments are for muscle/skeletal issues. There is very little a GP can do for you. So, back to personal responsibility. Take pain killers, move, exercise, lose weight, go a physio. Going direct to a physio costs about £40, same price as seeing a GP. Perhaps if we all had our own pot of health spend, we could use it more wisely.

kegofcoffee · 22/12/2022 13:17

Lostinalibrary · 22/12/2022 12:09

No because nearly half of the adults in this country don’t pay income tax and are economically inactive.

The elephant in the room is - those who’ve “paid in all their lives” didn’t pay in enough to sustain the state as is. Now the younger generations are paying more to subsidise and it will get worse. It’s all unsustainable.

Glad someone brought up the elephant in the room.

It's horrible to admit, but our aging population is only getting big, and medical ability are also getting more advance.

At some point difficult decisions need to be made about who and what the NHS can and can't treat. And how adult care is going to be funded.

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:16

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 13:10

They should make early retirees pay NI until state pension age

NI is payable until state pension age.

Not if you don't work even if your pension is as much as the average wage.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:15

The NHS would be better to start offering "private" style treatments so it could make profit from the people with access to money to spend, rather than the private providers profiteering. It needs to stop the political dogma of everyone receiving the same treatment!

Lots of ways it could raise funds from people able and willing to pay. Things like continue offering free hearing aids, but also offering better ones at a cost so that they get the profit rather than private hearing clinics. That kind of thing worked with dentistry of opticians for decades - i.e. you can have a basic filling on the NHS or a better one at a cost, likewise free glasses for some on the NHS or you can pay for better frames.

Take "upright" MRI scanners. None available in any of our local NHS trusts. My OH paid £1200 to a private firm to have one done. He'd have happily paid to have it done by the NHS if they'd have done it. But, no, the profit on his £1200 is now in a private firms' bank account instead of it being in the NHS.

Likewise private side rooms in wards. Could be made available (if not needed by others), for a daily charge. In fact, that's what was offered to me when I had my son in the maternity ward - we were told in the antenatal classes that private rooms may be available for a daily charge if they weren't needed for others. In reality, I had an emergency c-section so was allocated a private room for clinical reasons and didn't have to pay, but I'd have happily paid for the room if I'd had a normal birth and no one needed it.

Until the main political parties stop using the NHS as a political football, we can't have these kinds of discussions, and that's the real tragedy.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 13:15

Catapultaway · 22/12/2022 13:14

Totally agree. Fat people shouldn't get treatment at all. Or people injured playing sports, or whilst drinking, or whilst driving to fast (or just driving at all - lazy and fat). Or any accident that's their own fault and avoidable. And pregnant women, there's enough people in the world lets not treat them either, selfish people that they are.
You've solved it... Hardly anyone should get treatment, crisis over.

And this is our problem. You can't even broach the subject without these kinds of tantrums.

Taxistaxing · 22/12/2022 13:15

NHS has had so many 'extras' but unfortunately these seem to be swallowed up without making any tangible difference to the service (whether those funds reach the NHS who knows).
I would be in favour of paring back the service to a more physical need basis ie a 'core' service with a smaller remit and then addressing mental health/lifestyle as a separate service or more at a gp/community level but I am sure that this would have its flaws, but then again I don't think any service will fill the need of everyone, but what is on offer is a far cry from the original NHS offering.

crisscrosscringle · 22/12/2022 13:14

XingMing · 22/12/2022 13:10

Free prescriptions should not start until retirement age, instead of at 60. Pre-payment certificates are quite reasonable if people under retirement age need a lot of meds. Dental or sight tests aren't free for pensioners, as far as I know, but I am only a few months over 66, so they haven't come around yet.

Free prescriptions should only be free if you need them to be. Most pensioners I know are considerably better off than I am at 36 with a high income but childcare costs and a massive mortgage!

Catapultaway · 22/12/2022 13:14

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:18

Another unpopular view but we need to get away from the idea that people have the right to be fat/eat badly/do no exercise/smoke etc etc and expect the NHS to fix all the problems it causes.

There needs to be some sort of nudge campaign away from the idea that it's normal for a huge % of the population to be overweight/obese. People voted for Brexit for an extra £350m pe for the NHS (haha) but what would a population who took some responsibility for their own health save it?

Totally agree. Fat people shouldn't get treatment at all. Or people injured playing sports, or whilst drinking, or whilst driving to fast (or just driving at all - lazy and fat). Or any accident that's their own fault and avoidable. And pregnant women, there's enough people in the world lets not treat them either, selfish people that they are.
You've solved it... Hardly anyone should get treatment, crisis over.

crisscrosscringle · 22/12/2022 13:13

Prevention is sometimes the best cure. Making things like gym memberships, and private healthcare exempt from tax would see greater take up and ease the strain on the NHS.

The NHS is straining under the pressure of poor lifestyle choices and I believe there should be a limit of the free treatment of these issues. For example, my neighbour is morbidly obese, has a constant stream of just eat deliveries and yet is under consultant care for her knees as she believes she needs a replacement...

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 13:13

XingMing · 22/12/2022 13:10

Free prescriptions should not start until retirement age, instead of at 60. Pre-payment certificates are quite reasonable if people under retirement age need a lot of meds. Dental or sight tests aren't free for pensioners, as far as I know, but I am only a few months over 66, so they haven't come around yet.

Sight tests are free, my parents don't pay, but I think they do pay for dentistry?

JackieDaws · 22/12/2022 13:13

Delectable · 22/12/2022 13:02

The fact is the RF and more particularly Charles and William own the largest amount of land in this country. They not only don't need it as all their expenses are fully paid for for life; they don't pay any taxes. Yet the government not only keeps going after the commoner trying to make a living, they pitch us against eachother, distract us and program us using the media, asking for higher taxes. Tenants are fighting landlords, socialists want everyone on the same pay etc. We're all paying them and now they say Charles is refusing a slimmed down coronation. Ofcourse he is. This is a man who can't put toothpaste on his toothbrush nor move paper away from his desk. He has servants who dress him, drive him, cook, clean etc. Yet he needs more to be spent on him but we can't afford to pay nurses or heat our homes!

Stop lying. Most of them have to pay tax. Charles is legally exempt now he's king but is continuing to pay just as the Queen did.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/12/2022 13:12

Public health no longer sits with the nhs, it was taken out and put into local authorities. It made sense to a certain level because so much preventable health conditions are related to things like poverty, poor housing, obesity etc which fall more under the remit of local authorities. However, the money was not ring fenced and because local authority funding has been decimated, there is hardly any money to do any proper public health education or interventions.

the other thing of course is that prevention is really bloody complex. Take falls which cost the NHS and social care about 4.5 billion a year. The things that prevent falls primarily are 1. Keeping active - strength & balance 2. Reducing trip & slip hazards in the home and in the external environment 3. Ensuring people maintain good eye sight & have regular sight checks 4. Ensuring medications are regularly reviewed to ensure they’re not working against each other and causing dizziness 5. Adaptations in the home such a grab rails or aids ti help with walking such as frames

to tackle all of those requires GPs, local authority - social care, housing, the ppl who clear/ repair pavements, opticians, bus companies as falls often happen when an older person hasn’t sat down/got up too soon when bus is moving, pharmacists all to work together. And then for the older person to follow all the information and advice given. It’s enormously difficult and that’s just one small issue.

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 13:12

MolesOnPoles · 22/12/2022 12:29

I’ve just had the same blood test four times. The first three times it wasn’t processed because they wrote the name on the label wrong, then sent it to the wrong team, then left the top off the sample (!) for too long.

Each time they repeated it will have cost money.

The answer isn’t to throw more money into this shambles.

Obviously I can't speak for this specific occurence, but it may be that that's exactly what the answer is. Often mistakes like these happen because departments are under-funded and under-staffed. People end up scrambling to do extra things at the end of their shift that aren't really supposed to be part of their job; things get left undone when someone quits and hasn't been replaced yet etc.

All else being equal, an organisation (public or private) that is funded to a sufficient level to meet the expectations we have of it will do so with greater efficiency and reliability than one that is not funded nearly enough to do so. This shouldn't be a particularly controversial idea, yet it's remarkable how often people put everything backwards to justify what they're already determined to believe.

The Labour administration from 1997-2010 massively increased funding to the NHS, and outcomes massively improved. Since 2010 its funding has been cut in real terms (and even moreso when you consider the effect on demand from other cuts to social care, local authority funding etc.), and outcomes have plumetted.

This shouldn't be complicated to interpret. But apparently it's because it was always hopeless, the additional funding didn't actually help and we only thought it did because we were all hallucinating.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 13:12

NIC is a con because people assume that they have made contributions then somehow they are allocated a service. That may have been true when the NHS was founded but it is not true now and hasn't been for 40 years at least.

Since there no hypothecated tax in the UK it would be better dealt with a levy on transactions on assets or possibly income

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 13:10

They should make early retirees pay NI until state pension age

NI is payable until state pension age.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 13:10

Free prescriptions should not start until retirement age, instead of at 60. Pre-payment certificates are quite reasonable if people under retirement age need a lot of meds. Dental or sight tests aren't free for pensioners, as far as I know, but I am only a few months over 66, so they haven't come around yet.

YooniqueMe · 22/12/2022 13:09

I would pay it if it would work, but I don't believe it would work.

I asked a nurse recently if every job vacancy was filled and money was no issue, would everything be fine. They said no (although obviously would help) because of the lack of social care and the attitude/health of society in general (eg taking no responsibility for being obese, not completing courses of antibiotics so their problem reoccurs etc).

I would support a fee at point of contact. It's been shown that if a gym is free people value it less than if they have to pay even a nominal amount.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/12/2022 13:08

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 12:33

@CinnamonJellyBeans

I believe the main way we can ease the burden is by healthy people looking after our bodies as best we can and not getting complacent about the fact that abusing the gift of health will automatically get us new knees, livers, cancer treatments, metformin, BP tablets, mobility scooters, gastric bypasses. We take the NHS for granted. Everyone should receive a virtual bill when they leave, that lets them know how much their treatment would have cost if they had paid.

Yes, indeed, far too many people don't care about the damage they do their bodies and don't lead a healthy lifestyle at all. I don't think they intentionally do it because they expect the NHS to "cure" them, but they just don't think of the consequences. I really don't think many people will think "stuff it, I'm going to smoke like a chimney because the NHS will provide me with an oxygen mask". I think it's more that people just don't think of consequences any more, i.e. re health, dangerous sports, dangerous driving, etc. No sane person would intentionally damage themselves just because treatment was available.

As for a virtual bill, I'd be against that kind of thing as it just creates more layers of bureaucracy and there'll be doubts as to the reliability of the figures as there are different ways of working out costs, i.e. marginal costing, absorption costing, etc. We already have crazy figures for things like calling out a fire engine which aren't transparent as to what's included, and the old "lie" about raising a purchase order costing £40 when in reality the marginal cost is just a couple of pounds, but using absorbtion costing (inc the building, admin, management, equipment, etc it's much more). The general public can't understand the nuances of cost accounting.

If they started issuing virtual bills, they'd be using software used in, say the US, countries where there is no universal healthcare.

How long would it be after introducing billing software (which would also need a fully integrated universal computer system for all providers, which would make a private contractor an unfathomable amount of money at the prices they would charge for it) to introduce actually billing people? I'd give it a couple of years.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:08

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:05

They should make early retirees pay NI until state pension age. ( This would apply to me).
If you can afford to retire early you can afford NI.
Also free prescriptions should be means tested.
And eye tests.

Even better, just scrap NIC and raise income tax instead. That way, everyone will pay which is fairer, not just the "workers" shouldering the tax rises yet again. Lots of pensioners have incomes in excess of workers, yet don't pay NIC. Same with landlords, those living on investment portfolios, those living on foreign income etc. NIC is antiquated and needs scrapping. Just tax everyone on the same basis.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:06

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 12:58

No, I mention what I imagine are several million £1 letters every year. And it's just one example of one inefficiency. Plus, it's not £1, it's £1 plus the staff costs of sending them out.

But I have also said people taking responsibility for their own health is a bigger issue.

Indeed, millions of "small" inefficiencies add up to millions, if not billions of pounds. I appreciate that individual staff won't appreciate their part in the NHS waste scandal, as they'll just see the few pounds that they put into the bin each day, and won't really extrapolate that out among all the other staff too.

I've had a few ECGs over the years and have been amazed every time that they open a new pack of "connectors" - those clips with a sticky back they put on your chest. There's about 8 or 10 clips in the pack, and I've only ever had 4 or 5 attached to me, and the nurse just throws the others in the bin. Why not leave the pack and use the unused ones for the next patient? Even better, why don't they buy packs with only 4 or 5 in? Once the nurse attached me and threw away the unused in their pack, only for a couple of the sticky things to come loose, so she opened yet another pack to get two new ones and threw the rest of that pack away too! Yes, I know each pack won't cost too much, but if thousands of packs are being used across the NHS daily, that'll be thousands of pounds wasted on just one "consumable".

Unicorn34 · 22/12/2022 13:05

Kendodd · 22/12/2022 11:59

Might help if richer people paid the same rate of National insurance as poorer people.

www.gov.uk/national-insurance/how-much-you-pay

I didn't know that - WTF?

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:05

They should make early retirees pay NI until state pension age. ( This would apply to me).
If you can afford to retire early you can afford NI.
Also free prescriptions should be means tested.
And eye tests.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 13:04

Not sure you are on the right thread @Delectable .

LikeTearsInRain · 22/12/2022 13:03

Boris could have started by using that 350m per week ‘saved’ from the EU to increase the NHS budget…

oh wait…

Delectable · 22/12/2022 13:02

The fact is the RF and more particularly Charles and William own the largest amount of land in this country. They not only don't need it as all their expenses are fully paid for for life; they don't pay any taxes. Yet the government not only keeps going after the commoner trying to make a living, they pitch us against eachother, distract us and program us using the media, asking for higher taxes. Tenants are fighting landlords, socialists want everyone on the same pay etc. We're all paying them and now they say Charles is refusing a slimmed down coronation. Ofcourse he is. This is a man who can't put toothpaste on his toothbrush nor move paper away from his desk. He has servants who dress him, drive him, cook, clean etc. Yet he needs more to be spent on him but we can't afford to pay nurses or heat our homes!

Swipe left for the next trending thread