Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:33

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 13:32

That can't be right.

Your first grand or so a month should be subject to no tax as it's below the personal allowance. You're basically being taxed 50% on the remainder which should be basic rate.

Employees NIC, student loan deductions, workplace pension deductions, etc. It's not just basic rate tax which is deducted!

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:32

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:30

After tax and NI someone on 100k takes home £6k a month before private pension deductions. They're doing fine.

You're missing the point. Because "they're doing fine", they don't need to do more, and may feel that they can afford to work less. Hence leading to shortages of dentists and doctors who reduce their hours or take early retirement.

People need to be incentivised to work more, not punished. UK PLC is worse off overall if people who can work more decide to work less - the Treasury get less tax and employers like the NHS end up with staff shortages.

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 13:32

Fameinaframe · 22/12/2022 13:22

I already pay a ridiculous amount of tax and National insurance thanks!

£700 totally deductions a month 😪
My take home after this is 1,700 so not loads either!

That can't be right.

Your first grand or so a month should be subject to no tax as it's below the personal allowance. You're basically being taxed 50% on the remainder which should be basic rate.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 13:30

Fameinaframe · 22/12/2022 13:22

I already pay a ridiculous amount of tax and National insurance thanks!

£700 totally deductions a month 😪
My take home after this is 1,700 so not loads either!

It's not enough though is it? Surely you can see that £700 pm is unlikely to be sufficient to cover the cost of the schools, roads, policing and health care you make use of and set something aside for your pension, even if you are a low user of these services. The vast majority are not net contributors.

poetryandwine · 22/12/2022 13:30

Something to think about:

America has the reputation for over the top medical care. But when I taught at uni there, most employees and our families received medical care through kind of a mini NHS organised by the university medical centre, with associated GP surgeries in the local communities. I think my family paid about USD 80-100/month as a standing fee.

Care was superb, of a much higher standard than the NHS. However, there was a small copay - about USD 15 over 10 years ago - for every visit. (Vaccinations and such were free. There were essentially no further fees for hospitalisation, and the norm was a private or semi-private room.) For those who can afford it, I agree with@XingMing that this is reasonable but I think that, as in France, it should be means tested.

Also, and this is tricky, IVF and gender reassignment were not covered expenses. The medical centre had experts, but you had to go private. Probably the NHS currently covers other things that this system did not. I really don’t know what I think of this, given our current crisis with people dying for lack of basic health provision. (Yes, I know it is complicated)

It’s hard. I would like to see studies on the plusses and minuses of copays within the NHS given that France, other successful European health systems and America all use them successfully and have better health outcomes than we do. People say dismissively that copays cost more than they are worth, but no one has given me a source.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:30

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:23

In France tax is based on family income so if one parent is part time or doesn't work the other parent gets the benefit of the tax allowance.
Much fairer imo.

Indeed. The tax system needs to change before the NHS funding/model is reformed. Unfortunately, neither party has either the guts nor the competence to deal with the big issues. So both continue to tinker around the edges, making ruinously expensive minor changes that simply don't work, because they're incapable of making the big changes needed.

Our tax system is a shambles. Far too many anomalies. And as you say, a fairer system would be based on household income rather than independent taxation. Of course, that was another political bodge. Women wanting to be taxed independently, so that's what they were given, far too simple though, as we lost the long standing idea of a husband/wife having joint taxation, which did have advantages. Competent politicians would have found a way of keeping household taxation, but with more power to the woman, as previously it was always the man with the "power" when it came to tax. As often the case, throwing the baby out with the bathwater because they weren't capable of coming up with a modern system!

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:30

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:24

62% tax/nic on earnings between £100-£125k is already plenty don't you think?

Tax people too much and you end up worse off. Look at how the pension tax has affected doctors and dentists who are reducing their working hours or taking early retirement to avoid punitive high taxation charges. Or the damage done by enforcing IR35 rules onto the NHS locums etc (meaning it's not worth them working extra shifts because of the punitive tax & nic they have to pay).

After tax and NI someone on 100k takes home £6k a month before private pension deductions. They're doing fine.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 13:30

@Badbadbunny - it sounds good but for political reasons I think it will never happen.

The dream of private medicine is disease that the patient makes for themselves and is back seeing a doctor every week. So much money!!!

The inverse is true. This is the nightmare for public medicine.

EddyF · 22/12/2022 13:29

NoodleDoodleDo · 22/12/2022 11:53

£1 how often? A week/month/year?

Monthly salary.

OP posts:
crisscrosscringle · 22/12/2022 13:28

MollyQueenOfSocks · 22/12/2022 13:20

No, but if the rich and super rich were taxed proportionally it would make a humongous difference.

Taxing the ultra rich isn't the answer. They will just move their money elsewhere and continue to fund their own private healthcare without paying into the system at all.

As a PP points out - all the 80+ olds who retired at 60 haven't paid in enough to cover the costs. If the NHS was a Pension scheme there would be a three yearly actuarial valuation to establish how much we should be paying in... I suspect we'd never be able to retire.

I am in very a fortunate position of being a 36year old high earner with a good (local government) pension but honestly I am at a point where I begrudge paying any more into a broken system. At the risk of sounding like Jeremy Clarkson Everyone my age feels the same way... (well not everyone but certainly a lot of friends in our social circle)

Elphame · 22/12/2022 13:28

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:23

In France tax is based on family income so if one parent is part time or doesn't work the other parent gets the benefit of the tax allowance.
Much fairer imo.

There is a similar scheme in the UK already whereby a spouse can transfer £1260 of their unused allowances to the other spouse provided that they are not subject to tax greater than at the basic rate,.

You need to know about it though and claim it

BMW6 · 22/12/2022 13:27

LlynTegid · 22/12/2022 13:00

Start with windfall taxes at a proper level for oil companies, and then large tech companies paying a reasonable share of tax.

Nope. Just throwing good money after bad.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:26

@LexMitior

Medical devices on the NHS are nowhere near as good as privately available hearing aids, mobility scooters, dental treatment, glasses, Physio, therapy, recouperation.

Exactly why the NHS should start to offer "better" options at a price, so that the NHS gets the profit instead of private providers. But political dogma of equality won't let that happen. Instead everyone has to be given the same (often substandard) service/products.

Housepricerocket · 22/12/2022 13:25

Setyoufree · 22/12/2022 11:53

Nope, they'd fritter it on waste and corruption like they do with the rest of my tax.

This. It’s always been a black hole.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:24

MollyQueenOfSocks · 22/12/2022 13:20

No, but if the rich and super rich were taxed proportionally it would make a humongous difference.

62% tax/nic on earnings between £100-£125k is already plenty don't you think?

Tax people too much and you end up worse off. Look at how the pension tax has affected doctors and dentists who are reducing their working hours or taking early retirement to avoid punitive high taxation charges. Or the damage done by enforcing IR35 rules onto the NHS locums etc (meaning it's not worth them working extra shifts because of the punitive tax & nic they have to pay).

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 13:23

The reality is that lifestyle based disease is going to be subtly privatised.

And even that would suit both parties politically. The Tories want those services because it is good money. Excellent money because lifestyle disease can last years and years. For Labour, it would be a return to the original purpose of the NHS, acute care and management of chronic medical need.

You can already see it. Medical devices on the NHS are nowhere near as good as privately available hearing aids, mobility scooters, dental treatment, glasses, Physio, therapy, recouperation.

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:23

In France tax is based on family income so if one parent is part time or doesn't work the other parent gets the benefit of the tax allowance.
Much fairer imo.

Fameinaframe · 22/12/2022 13:22

I already pay a ridiculous amount of tax and National insurance thanks!

£700 totally deductions a month 😪
My take home after this is 1,700 so not loads either!

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 13:22

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:00

I fully agree, especially in terms of telling people with lifestyle related health issues to do something about it themselves. Unfortunately, as we regularly see in the media, people complain when a doctor or nurse points out that they are overweight and suggests healthy lifestyle choices! So many healthcare professionals either don't mention the blindingly obvious or pussyfoot around skirting the issue. Some hard truths need to be told and if the patient doesn't like what they're being told, then tough!

Have "lifestyle related health issues" gotten worse in the period the NHS has existed? Genuine question - I'm not sure. On one hand I suppose obesity is probably worse. On the other, far fewer people smoke now.

I also wonder how many health issues are NOT in some way lifestyle-related, and where you draw the line. Healthy lifestyles are also easier for the economically comfortable to maintain than for the poorest, for a variety of reasons.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:21

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:19

And how poor have you got to be to pay no income tax.
It's a disgrace that 25% earn so little.

They don't pay income tax because the personal tax allowance has more than doubled in the last few years. That's a GOOD thing, not a bad thing. It's not a matter of earning too little, it's a matter of increasing the threshold at which people pay tax by far more than inflation or average pay rises over several years.

MollyQueenOfSocks · 22/12/2022 13:20

No, but if the rich and super rich were taxed proportionally it would make a humongous difference.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:20

crisscrosscringle · 22/12/2022 13:13

Prevention is sometimes the best cure. Making things like gym memberships, and private healthcare exempt from tax would see greater take up and ease the strain on the NHS.

The NHS is straining under the pressure of poor lifestyle choices and I believe there should be a limit of the free treatment of these issues. For example, my neighbour is morbidly obese, has a constant stream of just eat deliveries and yet is under consultant care for her knees as she believes she needs a replacement...

I agree, in fact I think you should get tax relief on gym memberships and private healthcare, not be taxed on them. It's another kind of the political dogma, i.e. people who can afford them should be taxed on them because it's "unfair" they can afford it when others can't. Dogma like that prevents sensible discussion as it always comes back to it being unfair that "the rich" can afford things that "the poor" can't, so they need to be punished!

I'd far prefer to encourage "richer" people to make their own arrangements, whether it's health, education, or whatever, leaving the state funded alternatives with fewer people to look after.

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:19

EileenAdler · 22/12/2022 13:18

25% of the working population pays no income tax at all, ZERO ! , so you need to start comparing eggs for eggs.

And how poor have you got to be to pay no income tax.
It's a disgrace that 25% earn so little.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 13:18

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:16

Not if you don't work even if your pension is as much as the average wage.

Yes this is why the NI increase was such a bad idea. Paying more towards the NHS is fine(ish) but doing it through NI means anyone whose income comes from anything other than a salary pay nothing

EileenAdler · 22/12/2022 13:18

Kendodd · 22/12/2022 11:59

Might help if richer people paid the same rate of National insurance as poorer people.

www.gov.uk/national-insurance/how-much-you-pay

25% of the working population pays no income tax at all, ZERO ! , so you need to start comparing eggs for eggs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread